笑对人生 2023-06-21

The top journal for materials is truly well-deserved of its reputation. The external review process is strict. In the first review, there were four reviewers, and it took a month for major revisions. In the second review, there were four reviewers again, and the reviewers for the first and second reviews were of high quality and not repeated. After going through countless obstacles and difficulties, it was finally accepted.

网志 2023-06-21

I was rejected for my poor performance, which I got criticized for every two months.

左家陇科研弱鸡 2023-06-20

2023.4.21 Submission
2023.5.9 Under review
2023.5.29 Feedback received, 8 reviewers, 7 minor revisions and 1 major revision
2023.6.5 Revisions requested
2023.6.19 Accepted

ccccl 2023-06-20

The fact proves that being fast is not a good thing. Out of 6 submissions, only 3 were accepted for review. The feedback was just one sentence without any innovation, and I suspect that the reviewer didn't even read it... It didn't even take a month, so it didn't waste my time.
Submitted on May 5th.
Under review on May 10th.
Under review on May 15th.
Under review on May 19th.
Under review on May 22nd.
Under review on May 31st.
Rejected on June 2nd.

L.H. 2023-06-19

After the reminder, the status changed to "Decision in Process" on June 17th. Does this mean it's over?!

奥德修斯 2023-06-19

6.5 Second Revision Submission
6.7 with editor
6.19 with editor

day day upupup 2023-06-19

There is a new update, let's share it.
2023.02.25 Submission
2023.03.14 Under review
2023.03.21 RRC (Reviewers' Comments)
2023.03.26 RRC
2023.03.27 RRC
2023.03.28 RRC
2023.03.30 Major revision with 5 reviewers, 4 accepted and 1 rejected
2023.04.20 Delay letter until 4.30
2023.04.30 Submission
2023.05.02 Under review
2023.05.07 RRC
2023.05.10 RRC
2023.05.16 RRC
2023.05.19 Major revision, still 4 accepted and 1 rejected
2023.06.04 Submission (Delayed by 3 days without a delay letter)
2023.06.09 Under review
2023.06.18 RRC
The feedback has been continuously improved, hoping for acceptance!

lgy11 2023-06-17

Submitted 2023.4.6 - Submitted on April 6th, 2023.
Under Review 4.12 - Under review on April 12th.
RRC 4.18 - Referred to Reviewers Committee on April 18th.
Major Revised 4.28 (4 reviewers, extensive revisions took 21 days) - Major revisions completed on April 28th, with input from 4 reviewers and it took 21 days.
Submitted Revision Manuscript 5.17 - Submitted revised manuscript on May 17th.
With Editor 5.18 - Being reviewed by the editor on May 18th.
Under Review 5.18 - Under review on May 18th.
RRC 5.19 - Referred to Reviewers Committee on May 19th.
RRC 5.21 - Referred to Reviewers Committee again on May 21st.
RRC 5.31 - Referred to Reviewers Committee once more on May 31st.
Major Revised 6.2. (4 reviewers, 3 accepted, 1 suggested more discussion, extensive revisions took 14 days) - Major revisions completed on June 2nd, with input from 4 reviewers, 3 of which accepted the manuscript and 1 recommended more discussion, and it took 14 days.
Submitted Revision Manuscript 6.11 - Submitted revised manuscript on June 11th.
Accept 6.13 - Accepted on June 13th.

静儿 2023-06-16

2022.10 October 18th - Initial submission
2022.12 December 30th - Reception

keyanren01 2023-06-16

Has your paper been submitted for review?

如此彻底 2023-06-16

Maybe it's because we have different perspectives.

keyanren01 2023-06-16

Did you submit it for review?

keyanren01 2023-06-16

I have had mine for 20 days, still with the editor.

如此彻底 2023-06-15

23.6.15 Under review translates to "23rd June 2015 Under review" in English.

Wenwen2529 2023-06-15

The review was submitted a few days later than the original poster. After a month, only one of the three reviewers provided feedback. A new reviewer was then sought, and now it has been almost two months and the review is still not complete.

WangLei NXU 2023-06-15

2023
6.2 submit to journal
6.6 with editor
6.13 with editor

zz晨光熹微 2023-06-15

Hello, may I ask if you would like to submit it again after you make modifications?

L.H. 2023-06-15

I asked customer service, and they said the editor is already aware of the situation and is either looking for a new reviewer or making a decision. It's really frustrating to have a third reviewer and still not receive any review!

科研乐 2023-06-14

There is not enough context provided to accurately translate the text "6.14 RRC" into English. Please provide more information or clarify the meaning of the text you would like to translate.

科研乐 2023-06-14

Hello, did you submit your summary directly or did you write a letter first?

scupanda123 2023-06-14

2023.5.25 submit
2023.5.27 with editor
2023.5.30 under review
2023.6.12 rrc
2023.6.13 rrc
2023.6.14 rrc

A review on photocatalysis was submitted, hoping for a favorable outcome.

Qiangting 2023-06-14

Your situation is similar. On the 10th, with the editor, it is still with the editor. Please, please submit it for review.

接accept啊啊啊啊 2023-06-14

How is it going? Mine has also been in the editor's hands for a few days. I don't know if it's good or bad.

接accept啊啊啊啊 2023-06-14

May I ask how it's going? Mine has been with the editor for a few days. I don't know if it's good or bad. I'm worried.

接accept啊啊啊啊 2023-06-14

May I ask how it's going? Mine has been in the hands of the editor for a few days. I don't know if it's good or bad. Anxious.

keyanren01 2023-06-14

Have you submitted it for review?

晴天Y 2023-06-14

Accepted, thank you!

zz晨光熹微 2023-06-14

23.5.14 - submitted
23.5.16 - with editor
23.5.19 - under review
23.6.11 - required reviews complete
23.6.12 - required reviews complete
23.6.13 - decision in process

keyanren01 2023-06-13

Refused several times, regardless of how long the time was.

Qiangting 2023-06-13

The longer the time, the better it is. Usually, it will be submitted for review.