Verified Reviews - Chemical Engineering Journal
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

华工国际软体机器人 2023-05-08

It has been 55 days and it is still under review, so slow.

cerius 2023-05-08

3.19 submitted to journal
3.23 with editor
4.09 under review
4.21 rrc
5.06 rrc
5.07 accept

Translation:

3.19: Submitted to the journal
3.23: Under the editor's review
4.09: Under review
4.21: RRC (possibly refers to a specific process or decision)
5.06: RRC (possibly refers to a specific process or decision)
5.07: Accepted

大耳朵图图 2023-05-07

It has been almost exactly one month since you and I...

XYZ 2023-05-07

How are things going now? Any news?

幽草沐晚晴 2023-05-06

CEJ's impact factor is really soaring, but the articles in the materials field are indeed a bit shallow.

day day upupup 2023-05-06

2023.02.25 Submission
2023.03.14 Under review
2023.03.21 RRC (Reviewers' Comments)
2023.03.26 RRC
2023.03.27 RRC
2023.03.28 RRC
RRC changed four times in four days
2023.03.30 Major revision, 5 reviewers, 4 accepted, 1 rejected
2023.04.20 Delay letter until 4.30
2023.04.30 Submit
2023.05.02 Under review
Hope there won't be a second review and it will be accepted directly.

falconry 2023-05-06

11.18 - Submitted to journal
11.25 - With editor
12.08 - Under review
2.21 - Major revision
3.5 - Revision submitted
3.12 - With editor
3.28 - Under review
4.11 - Minor revision
5.4 - Accept

大大伟俊 2023-05-06

I submitted it on April 7th and it's still with the editor now. It's really ridiculous.

西安王斌的知识产权圈 2023-05-06

After the Chinese New Year, I submitted a paper, and I have already finished revising it. It is about the research on the thermal and physical properties of nanofluids. It is about to be accepted. I am willing to offer the first authorship. I wonder if anyone is interested.

VALAK 2023-05-06

Just ask about the contact in the "about" section according to the process. It is like an online customer service. After the conversation is over, the entire dialogue will be sent to your reserved email.

Sun678 2023-05-05

Does it have something to do with the direction? Look downstairs, there are fast delivery options.

ycyycy 2023-05-05

It took 35 days for my editing to be reviewed, very slow!!!

蛞蝓· 2023-05-05

Is there any news? Mine is the same, no movement with the editor for half a month.

吃井不忘人挖水 2023-05-05

When inquiring about the review process, may I contact customer service directly via email?

Sun678 2023-05-05

5.5 submitted translates to "5.5 is submitted" in English.

RWsrwS 2023-05-05

4.17 submitted
4.19 with editor
4.22 with editor
Until now, still being with the editor is quite unreasonable.

F.D 2023-05-04

It's been so long, has there been any change now?

大耳朵图图 2023-05-04

I am also, 4.13 with the editor, until now.

VALAK 2023-05-04

Thank you to the reviewer for providing the opportunity for a major revision.

VALAK 2023-05-04

Thank you to the reviewer for giving me the opportunity for a major revision.

Cappuccino_HHH 2023-05-03

3.18 submitted to journal
3.18 with editor
3.20 under review
4.13 major revision
4.30 revision submitted
5.2 with editor
5.2 accept

Translation:
3.18 - Submitted to journal
3.18 - With editor
3.20 - Under review
4.13 - Major revision
4.30 - Revision submitted
5.2 - With editor
5.2 - Accepted

wyx2010 2023-04-30

Submission experience:
3.22 submitted to journal
3.24 with editor
3.26 with editor (date changed)
4.6 under review (2+)
4.14 required Reviews Completed
4.17 major revision
4.23 revision submitted
4.25 with editor
4.26 under review
4.27 required Reviews Completed
4.30 accept

VALAK 2023-04-28

Today I discovered that I can go to the "contact" section of the submission page and inquire about the specific number of reviewers at Elsevier. There is still one reviewer who hasn't provided any feedback yet, so I hope to be given an opportunity for major revisions.

VALAK 2023-04-28

4.28 Required Reviews Completed translates to "4.28 reviews that were required have been completed."

华工国际软体机器人 2023-04-28

It has been 45 days since the manuscript was reviewed and still no news. It's a bit slow, sigh.

蕴山海 2023-04-28

18 Apr 2023 Submitted
21 Apr 2023 with editor
23 Apr 2023 with editor

Translation:

18th April 2023 Submitted
21st April 2023 with editor
23rd April 2023 with editor

动物世界 2023-04-26

Need to confirm

动物世界 2023-04-26

When does it start?

无语-1 2023-04-26

4.1 Submitted
4.6 With Editor
4.26 With Editor
Why has it taken so long? On 4.23, a reminder letter was sent and it was still with the editor. Is there a similar timeframe?
5.22 Major Revision
6.7 Article Revised
6.8 With Editor
6.21 Accept

黄小雨 2023-04-25

Wow, I envy you. Your first paper can be published in a Q1 journal with a score of 16. My first paper was still in Frontiers, hahaha.

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started