Ykkkkk123 2023-06-20

I submitted it on April 19th, and it is still under review. Moreover, there is only one reviewer, and it has not been reviewed yet. I am really frustrated. May I ask who is your editor?

小小苏苏 2023-06-20

2023.4.24 submitted to journal
2023.4.25 with editor
2023.4.30 under review
2023.5.2 under review
2023.5.10 under review
2023.6.15 rrc
Still under rrc till now.

只高不冷 2023-06-14

On June 13th, after dipping and then accepting, the difficulty of submitting articles in the Guotao Sheng District has noticeably increased, and the editing process has also slowed down.

zzzcsupm006 2023-06-13

Today's dip, the editor is Xiao Hu, please, editor big brother, give me a chance to make changes.

QQ努力努力努力 2023-06-13

Is it possible that not all the review comments have been returned?

只高不冷 2023-06-13

Is the handling editor Pietro Vincenzini? I feel like he has disappeared. My first review for RRC lasted 47 days, and now it has been 29 days since the second review on May 29th. I had a previous article that was accepted directly after a two-month second review for RRC.

zzzcsupm006 2023-06-12

How long does it take for the boss to process the RRC in the first review?

zzzcsupm006 2023-06-12

2023.05.09 submitted to journal
2023.05.10 with editor
2023.05.15 under review
2023.05.30 rrc

It is still under rrc until now. It has been half a month and the editor has not processed it yet. Does anyone know how long it usually takes for rrc? I hope the editor can give me an opportunity to make revisions.

SCUCY 2023-06-12

I don't know if it's because I criticized Guo Tao here, but it was submitted for review in the afternoon (no mention of duplication rate and polishing issues).
2023.5.31 Submitted to journal
2023.6.1 With Editor
2023.6.2 With Editor
2023.6.12 Under Review

小小苏苏 2023-06-12

It may be because it has now been upgraded to Zone 1. Since the end of April until now, the review manuscripts are currently slow.

SCUCY 2023-06-12

The national ceramics journal has been floating and drifting for two weeks now, and it is still with the editor until June 12, 2023. The processing speed has slowed down a lot. Is this related to the editor's handling, or is the entire journal's processing speed like this...

许兴旺 2023-06-12

I am planning to invest in Guotao recently and would like to know how much is the required repetition rate. Currently, my repetition rate is 12%.

仙lv 2023-06-09

The first article on national ceramics, without any polishing, the editor did a great job, finally fulfilling a long-held dream of national ceramics.

仙lv 2023-06-09

3.30 submit - Submitted on March 30th
5.6 major revise - Major revisions required on May 6th
5.26 revised submit - Revised submission on May 26th
5.27 with editor and under review - Under review by the editor since May 27th
6.2 rrc - Re-review completed on June 2nd
6.5 under review - Under review since June 5th
6.8 decision in process and accept - Decision is currently being processed and acceptance is likely on June 8th

月光倾城 2023-06-08

Posted on March 29th, reviewed by the editor on the same day, submitted for review one day later, received feedback on April 26th from three reviewers, all suggesting minor revisions. The associate editor requested further language polishing.

After making revisions on May 18th, the article was resubmitted and sent for review on the 22nd. Until now, only one reviewer has accepted and completed the reevaluation. The other two reviewers have encountered issues: one has disappeared, and the other has accepted the invitation but has yet to submit their feedback. Currently, the article is still under review.

Overall, the efficiency of the Guo Tao editor is extremely high. The progress of the manuscript mainly depends on the reviewers. The current situation is that there are many irresponsible reviewers who procrastinate. Some even surpass the deadline and continue to delay, despite the editor's reminder emails. Unfortunately, there is no solution to this issue.

只高不冷 2023-06-07

I used to invest in Guotao, and the processing was particularly fast. But now that it has been upgraded to a higher level, it has completely gone downhill. I might as well invest in Energy.

小小苏苏 2023-06-07

How long does the reviewer take to review? It has been almost 2 months for me, and I haven't received any feedback yet.

SCUCY 2023-06-07

2023.6.7 Continue with editor
Everyone seems to be quite fast in the comments. I remember Guo Tao being quite fast too, why has it become slower...

Distance1008 2023-06-07

My RRC is also 29th after repair, and it has not been processed until now. What's going on with Guo Tao recently?

萤火1 2023-06-07

Have you received any updates since May 29th rrc?

只高不冷 2023-06-05

Posted on February 15th
RRC on March 17th, RRC lasted for 47 days
Major revision on May 2nd
Returned for revision on May 22nd
RRC ongoing since May 29th
The editor is Pietro Vincenzini. I don't know why RRC has been unresponsive and it shows only two reviewers. All comments have been received, but they are not being processed. Last time, there was also an article that took two months for RRC and was directly accepted. I want to know why the processing by the national ceramic society is currently so slow.

Meidong Yu 2023-06-03

Keep going, there will be good results!

QQ努力努力努力 2023-06-03

Haha, the submission time is the same, and the status is the same.

SCUCY 2023-06-03

Has your article been submitted for review? Is there a higher chance of being reviewed after passing the review by the chief editor?

SCUCY 2023-06-03

How is your article doing now? Is there a high possibility of passing the review after going through the chief editor?

SCUCY 2023-06-03

2023.5.31 submitted to journal
2023.6.1 with editor (Chief Editor)
2023.6.2 with editor
Has the date change with the editor passed the Chief Editor's review? Is there a greater chance of being sent for review after passing the Chief Editor's review?

levi258 2023-06-02

Of course not, I am also in this situation. I have urged the editor and the reply said it needs at least two reviewers.

Ykkkkk123 2023-06-02

The editor invited 2+ reviewers, but only one agreed to review. It has been almost two months now. Can one reviewer make revisions and accept? Or will more reviewers be added? Adding more reviewers will slow down the process.

小小苏苏 2023-06-01

It has been nearly two months since submission, and there are still no comments.

QQ努力努力努力 2023-06-01

May I ask how slow it is?