mangoyang 2021-12-07

I have been waiting for 60 days, it has been under review all this time. Could it be that it has reached Xiaohu?

Law Fakeerut 2021-12-07

10.13 submitted
10.13 with editor
10.14 under review
11.05 required reviews completed
11.05 major revise
11.26 submitted
11.26 with editor
11.26 under review
11.30 required reviews completed
12.05 accept

Translation:
10.13 submitted
10.13 with editor
10.14 under review
11.05 required reviews completed
11.05 major revise
11.26 submitted
11.26 with editor
11.26 under review
11.30 required reviews completed
12.05 accept

刘小兜 2021-12-06

Submit to the journal on November 15th.
Receive five minor revisions within five days during the evening external review.
Submit the revised manuscript three days later for another external review.
Article accepted on December 5th.
Total time taken: 20 days.
Thank you, Editor P.V, for being really fast!

Joean 2021-12-04

May I ask if you have received an email from editor Xiaohu stating "waiting for more reviewers' comments as they still have some questions" about one week after the completion of the required reviews after your two major revisions?

YJZ369 2021-12-01

Did you submit your manuscript for review? My situation is similar to yours as well.

YJZ369 2021-12-01

Did you submit your manuscript for review? Mine is in the same situation as yours.

做完实验打boss 2021-12-01

September 30th Submission
October 1st Editor-in-Chief Pietro Vincenzini and Deputy Editor Zhaoju Yu acknowledge receipt of the manuscript under review.
October 18th Feedback received - major revision required, two reviewers.
November 8th Revised manuscript returned under review.
November 30th Acceptance.
Thanks to Editor-in-Chief Pietro Vincenzini and Deputy Editor Zhaoju Yu for handling the manuscript promptly. Let's continue to work hard to achieve our end-of-year KPIs.

YJZ369 2021-11-28

Which editor made a mistake?

EBC-APS 2021-11-26

The chief editor, Pietro Vincenzini, processed it quickly and assigned it to the assistant editor, Xiaohu. It was submitted on August 8th and had only one reviewer. The review process took around 100 days, and there were no scientific issues raised, only three formatting issues. Although the speed was slow, it was still accepted.

YJZ369 2021-11-25

May I ask how to find out which reviewer has received my article?

FYXZ 2021-11-25

8.08 Submission, on the same day the General Editor replied for language revision.
8.09 Revised submission (R1), assigned to an editor on the same day.
8.27 Review completed, two reviewers. Reviewer 1 provided sharp comments mainly on the novelty, suggesting major revisions or rejection; Reviewer 2 provided minor revisions.
9.23 Revised (R2), assigned to an editor the next day.
11.05 Review completed, Reviewer 1 still unsatisfied, emphasizing the novelty and suggesting rejection; Reviewer 2 raised two minor issues.
11.05 Revised submission returned (R3) on the same day.
11.15 Status changed to "required reviews completed."
11.25 Acceptance.
Summary: From submission to final acceptance, it took approximately 3.5 months. The journal assigned an editor quickly, with the initial assignment being the General Editor (Pietro Vincenzini), later transferred to the Assistant Scientific Editor (Xiao Hu) for this submission. The editors promptly sent the manuscript for review, and the review process was also relatively fast (the journal gave reviewers a deadline of 2 weeks). However, it may take some time to summarize and address the reviewers' comments and make a decision, thus resulting in a longer duration for "required reviews completed."

东南小明王 2021-11-24

If you are also Xiao Hu editor, you may be a little busy editing recently. We can only wait patiently.

vivo 2021-11-24

It has been 16 days, and still no results. I hope for good luck.

初心是苏呀 2021-11-24

Thank you to the chief editor P. Vincenzini and the deputy editor M. Ferrari.

初心是苏呀 2021-11-24

The text "11.23 accept" is already in English.

东南小明王 2021-11-24

Hello, may I ask if there are any results yet? Mine has also been "required reviews completed" for 15 days, edited by Xiao Hu.

Strive 2021-11-22

p. vincenzini does not have a specific meaning in English. It appears to be a name or abbreviation without context.

vivo 2021-11-21

Excuse me, is the editor Xiaohu?

Strive 2021-11-21

9.27 submitted
9.28 with editor
10.5 under review
10.13 required reviews completed
10.18 under review
10.18 required reviews completed
10.25 under review
10.28 required reviews completed
10.29 decision in process
10.29 major revision
11.9 submitted
11.10 with editor - changed editor
11.11 under review
11.19 required reviews completed
11.19 accept

大鱼 2021-11-21

10-2 Submission,
11-4 Major revision,
Half a month for revisions, revised manuscript submitted,
Under review on the same day,
11-20 Acceptance.

Thank you to Editor-in-Chief P. Vincenzini and the assistant editor for their efficient and diligent work.

vivo 2021-11-20

The time has changed, but the matter still hasn't been dealt with. It has been 13 days.

Tsolmon 2021-11-20

The editor is very nice. There were two reviewers in total, one recommended a major revision and the other rejected it. The editor chose the major revision. In the second review, one recommended a major revision and the other rejected it again, but the editor still chose the major revision. In the third review, both were accepted. Thank you again to the editor for giving me multiple opportunities to make revisions.

边疆大兵 2021-11-19

Assistant Editor Xiao Hu is too slow. It has been more than ten days and it is still "with editor". I am truly speechless.

vivo 2021-11-19

10 days later, the "required reviews completed" status remains unchanged, only the date has changed. How many reviewers have been assigned?

大鱼 2021-11-19

Hello, have you received the acceptance results yet? I also uploaded the revised manuscript on the 15th and haven't received any results so far. The journal's homepage indicates that it takes 10 days.

gui li 2021-11-18

My package has arrived in Xiaohu's hands. It's been almost four months, too frustrating.

AM123 2021-11-18

The submission made on November 3rd underwent major revisions today. In reality, there were only four minor issues that I discovered. I noticed that, apart from XiaoHu, all the other editors of this journal work very efficiently.

vivo 2021-11-18

It has been 10 days since the required reviews were completed, sigh.

Huspring 2021-11-18

Mine also arrived at Hu Xiao's place, why is it so slow! I hope it doesn't get rejected.

初心是苏呀 2021-11-17

8.28 submitted
8.28 reject
9.14 resubmitted after modifications
9.14 with editor
9.14 revise
9.15 submitted
9.15 with editor
9.15 transferred to associate editor, under review
10.4 required reviews completed
10.4 major revise
10.26 returned with editor, subsequently under review
11.9 revise
11.16 resubmitted for revisions, under review