胸口碎大石 2022-02-11

12 Sep 2021 Submit
4 Jan 2022 Major revision
17 Jan 2022 Article revised
9 Feb 2022 Article accepted

Translation:
12th September 2021: Submission
4th January 2022: Major revision
17th January 2022: Article revised
9th February 2022: Article accepted

酥苏苏 2022-02-08

2021.09.07 Submission
2021.12.03 Major revision, two reviewers, one positive and one negative. They mentioned lack of innovation and mostly provided negative comments.
2021.12.13 Resubmission for review
2021.12.21 Editorial decision
2021.12.30 Under review again, probably with a third reviewer assigned by the editor
2022.01.17 Response to comments, both reviewers provided positive feedback. The reviewer who previously had a positive opinion got into an argument with the reviewer who had negative opinions, which was quite amusing. I responded to the comments the same day after making minor revisions.
2022.01.22 Acceptance
It took over four months in total. This was my first research paper, and honestly, I feel like I didn't write it very well. I initially submitted it to JMMM but it got rejected. Following my advisor's advice, I resubmitted it to Ceramics International and surprisingly it got accepted, in the third quartile rather than the second. I didn't expect that. By the way, I want to complain about JMMM. My second paper got rejected by them as well, and it really frustrated me. I won't be submitting to JMMM anymore.

楚非以 2022-02-08

2021.11 23 Submission
2021.12.16 Received review comments
2022.1.13 Accepted

abcdd 2022-02-06

May I ask if the moderator rejected it after the modification?

JinHong G 2022-02-02

January 29th, major revision. The deputy editor suggests language polishing, is it necessary to use the one they love to surround?

wanfengchui 2022-02-02

2022.01.13 Majer revise - Majer revises (the document) on January 13, 2022.
2022.01.25 Resubmit With editor - Resubmit (the document) with editor on January 25, 2022.
2022.01.27 Under review - Currently under review on January 27, 2022.

angus9676 2022-01-29

Have you received any feedback from houxinmei, the editor, yet?

sanrepian 2022-01-27

Dec 19, 2021 - submitted to journal
Dec 19, 2021 - with editor
Dec 22, 2021 - under review
Dec 27, 2021 - revise
Dec 19, 2021 - submitted
Jan 26, 2022 - accept
Editor-in-chief Pietro Vincenzini handled it quickly, thank you.

YUANRUITIAN 2022-01-26

May I ask if it is not allowed to submit a PDF version when submitting the manuscript for Guo Tao?

@silent 2022-01-26

I would like to ask how we can check the status of reviewer requirements and the allocation of editors. I haven't been able to find where to do that.

硅酸盐 Ceramics 2022-01-25

2021.11.16 Post assigned to editorial assistant: Hu Xiao.
2021.11.26 Under review, this process is slower compared to other editors.
2021.11.19 Review completed.
2021.12.23 Received review comments, requiring major revisions and language editing by the editorial assistant, along with an editing certificate.
2022.01.05 Submitted revised manuscript.
2022.01.09 Under review.
2022.01.19 Review completed.
2022.01.23 Accepted without any comments.

angus9676 2022-01-25

I also went to Hou Xin Mei, and as of today, there has been no movement on the required reviews completed on January 18th.

JinHong G 2022-01-21

12.29 under review translates to "December 29th is currently being reviewed."
1.20 Required Reviews Completed translates to "January 20th, all required reviews have been completed."

猩 2022-01-20

2021.12.3 submitted to journal
2021.12.6 under review
2021.12.28 major revise
2022.1.17 submitted
Waiting for notification.

Mr. Cao 2022-01-15

Thank you Editor-in-Chief Pietro Vincenzini!

要起飞的的旺仔 2022-01-10

2021.9.30 submitted to journal
2021.10.6 under review
2021.11.11 major revise
2021.12.5 submitted
2021.12.21 revise
2021.12.27 submitted
2021.12.29 accept
Two reviewers, overall the process was quite fast.

wanweii 2022-01-04

2021.12.3 submitted to journal - Submitted to the journal on December 3, 2021.
2021.12.7 under review - Under review since December 7, 2021.
2020.01.03 required reviews completed - Required reviews were completed on January 3, 2020.

wanfengchui 2022-01-03

2021.12.06 submitted to journal
2021.12.06 with editor
2021.12.13 under review
2021.12.21 under review
2021.12.31 required reviews completed
2022.01.03 under review

Translation:
2021.12.06 submitted to journal
2021.12.06 with editor
2021.12.13 under review
2021.12.21 under review
2021.12.31 required reviews completed
2022.01.03 under review

fengming 2021-12-30

Hello, during the process of revising your comments in GuoTao, the "under review" status has changed 3 times. May I ask if this is due to changing three reviewers?

fengming 2021-12-29

Is Christmas also a working day?

Zh1993 2021-12-28

Dec 24 with editor translates to "December 24th with editor" in English.
Dec 28 with editor translates to "December 28th with editor" in English.

GuoYongYong 2021-12-27

Where is the article sent to the deputy editor Hou Xinmei? Does anyone have an article with her?

猩 2021-12-26

It has been 23 days under review, just in time for Christmas. I don't know how much longer it will take.

Daive Hu 2021-12-25

It is the editor, not Xiaohu.

Daive Hu 2021-12-25

2021.11.24 Submission
2021.12.25 Morning Revision
2021.12.25 Afternoon Acceptance

Leo 2021-12-23

The given revision should be between minor revision and major revision, I suppose.

fengming 2021-12-22

Should we do a major repair or a minor repair?

Leo 2021-12-20

11.29: Submission of repair suggestions, one reviewer, two comments.
12.5: Under review.
12.16: Under review.
Why does "under review" change the time in the middle? Does it mean a change of reviewer? Feeling a little anxious. ???

wanfengchui 2021-12-10

Hello, may I ask if there are any results for your submission now? Mine has been with the editor for a week already, and there is still no news. How do I know which editor my article was sent to? I guess mine was sent to Xiaohu. It's too slow.

Rocky 2021-12-10

Received at Editorial Office: 11th September 2021
Article revised: 22nd November 2021 (two reviewers)
Article accepted for publication: 9th December 2021