lavinia 2022-04-06

May I ask if you have made a decision?

Tisen 2022-04-05

I am also in the same situation. Since the decision in process on 3.22, there has been no movement at all.

jayzzzz 2022-04-05

2022.1.27 submit - Submitted on January 27, 2022.
2022.1.29 under review - Under review since January 29, 2022.
2022.2.8 required review completed - Required review completed on February 8, 2022.
2022.2.12 under review - Under review since February 12, 2022.
2022.2.16 required review completed - Required review completed on February 16, 2022.
2022.2.24 decision in process - Decision is being processed since February 24, 2022.
2022.2.28 major revision - Major revision requested on February 28, 2022.
2022.3.15 submit major revision - Submitted major revision on March 15, 2022.
2022.3.17 with editor - With the editor since March 17, 2022.
2022.3.18 under review - Under review since March 18, 2022.
2022.3.20 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed on March 20, 2022.
2022.3.24 decision in process - Decision is being processed since March 24, 2022.

The review process is quite fast, but I'm not sure why the "decision in process" is taking a long time this time. I noticed that two other colleagues in the comments section have also been waiting for a long time for the decision. Does anyone know why? It has been two weeks since the decision was made.

艳橙 2022-04-05

Now the speed of the journal is a bit slow.

稻荷化狐 2022-04-05

Personal experience shows that the longer the review process of this journal, the worse it is. The longer the time with the editor and decision-making, the greater the likelihood of rejection. At least, that's how it was when I submitted.

稻荷化狐 2022-04-05

This is the third time I have submitted my personal experience. The longer the review time of this journal with the editor and decision, the less favorable it is. The longer the time, the more likely it is to be rejected, at least.

稻荷化狐 2022-04-05

More than one week with the editor.

牛122 2022-04-02

I've been with the editor for a long time. Is everyone also like this when submitting contributions? I'm anxious to graduate...

hezy 2022-04-01

It has been almost half a month with the editor, what is the situation?

烟雨惹尘 2022-04-01

What is the status of your paper? Mine has been with the editor for over a month now.

levinzhao 2022-04-01

Another week has passed, still no news...

x305491759 2022-03-30

I also entered the decision stage on the 19th after minor revisions, and the results have not been released yet.

lavinia 2022-03-30

After the major repair, it has been 8 days since the decision is in progress, and I am still waiting. I wish for a good outcome for everyone~

kaykay 2022-03-29

Has the status date changed during the under review period for this journal?

kaykay 2022-03-29

Brother, has the status date of your paper changed during the under review period?

levinzhao 2022-03-29

Posted on 2021.12.07, it has been about a month since the major revision was submitted. After the revision, it took 20 days to receive feedback. Two reviewers agreed to accept it, but one reviewer's comments seemed to indicate rejection. The editor requested minor revisions.
On 2022.3.1, the minor revisions were submitted. It has been 10 days now with the status "decision in process". Is it likely to be rejected?

稻荷化狐 2022-03-28

The homepage of this journal is marked with "Your paper your way," which means that only a neat manuscript formatting is required.

果壳栗子 2022-03-13

2022.1.5 submitted
2022.1.6 with editor
2022.1.7 under review
2022.2.3 Required reviews completed
2022.2.5 Major revision
2022.2.24 with editor
2022.2.26 under review
2022.3.11 required reviews completed
2022.3.13 accept

Translation:
2022.1.5 submitted
2022.1.6 with editor
2022.1.7 under review
2022.2.3 Required reviews completed
2022.2.5 Major revision
2022.2.24 with editor
2022.2.26 under review
2022.3.11 required reviews completed
2022.3.13 accept

lllate 2022-03-10

After one month with the editor, it directly turned into "decision in process," which most likely means it's not looking good.

lllate 2022-03-09

It has been nearly a month since I submitted it, and it is still in the "with editor" status. Should I follow up on this?

MuChenZhou 2022-03-08

I envy your speed. I have been waiting for the decision for over ten days.

lavinia 2022-03-08

3.2 Submit Major Revision With Editor
3.4 Editor Sends for External Review
3.8 Still in Under Review status temporarily

MuChenZhou 2022-03-04

After 20 days, the required reviews have been completed and it has changed to "decision in progress". The decision in progress has been ongoing for one week till now. I don't know if it's good or bad.

糖包是只猫 2022-03-01

Hello, may I ask if the reviewers for the first and second review have been changed, or if the handling editor for the documents has changed?

糖包是只猫 2022-03-01

Hello, may I ask if there is a specific template for submitting to this journal? I couldn't find the LaTeX template on the official website's "Guide for Article" section. Can you please tell me which template the others have used to submit their articles?

lllate 2022-03-01

Hello, I also want to ask you how long it took for your submission to be rejected with the editor? I have been in this state for a long time.

DuXY 2022-03-01

Hello, how long does it take for you to be notified of rejection when your paper is in the "under editor" status? Thank you.

MuChenZhou 2022-02-28

Hello, may I ask how many days your decision in process status has lasted?

投的都中 2022-02-28

Hello, may I ask if there are no major problems with the review comments? The editor rejected it, saying it is not suitable for this journal. What could be the reason for this? Is it necessary to make revisions and submit it to this journal again?

lllate 2022-02-26

Hello, I would like to ask how long after you submit the paper does it become "under review"? Mine has been in the "with editor" status for over ten days.