君君发sci 2022-08-05

Yes, there are quite a few Indians.

旺仔 2022-08-05

There is also a reviewer who seems to be of Indian nationality, quite disgusting, insisting on adding three almost unrelated articles as references. The quality of the articles is very low and they are not even SCI papers. However, under the pressure of submission, I added them, but I deleted them during the proofreading after acceptance. Haha, I guess the reviewer will be furious when they see the published article in the future.

旺仔 2022-08-05

Other top journals recommended transferring to JECE. After looking at similar articles inside, I think the level is pretty good. I don't want to look for others anymore and will transfer at the same time.
6.4 submitted to the journal
6.5 with editor
6.7 under review
6.13 required reviewers completed
6.20 major revision (should have found more than 7 reviewers, received feedback from three reviewers, one highly approved, the other two provided some suggestions, a few of which were difficult to answer)
7.22 revised with the editor, answered each question seriously and in detail, made all the requested additions or modifications, ensuring no omissions in the response. Although no additional experiments were required, it still took over a month for the revisions.
7.24 under review
7.25 required reviewers completed
7.30 completed-accept (all three reviewers agreed to accept)
8.2-8.3 notified and completed proofreading
8.4 already notified online via email, PDF can be downloaded
Overall, I think this journal is very fast and efficient. The peer review process may be strict, but I have high expectations for this journal.

ciaojing 2022-08-03

Hello, may I ask how to change the submitted order? Thank you!

ciaojing 2022-08-03

Hello, may I ask how to change the order of the submissions during the repair process? Thank you!

ciaojing 2022-08-03

Hello, may I ask how to make changes to the order that has been submitted?

花火夜空 2022-08-02

Finally, there was news on July 27th, allowing for major revisions and providing a month's time. Reviewer 1 had 4 comments, and Reviewer 3 had 3 review comments. It is estimated that the delay was due to the lack of results from Reviewer 2's review.

Wilson411424 2022-08-01

First submission to this journal, just keeping a record and hoping for some good luck. Seeking advice.

Submitted on July 31, 2022.
With Editor on August 3, 2022, Decision in Process. Most likely going to be rejected.
Rejected on August 5, 2022. Suggested to submit to Chemical Engineering and Processing - Process Intensification, Chemical Engineering Research and Design.

zhs874381 2022-07-30

Help! Why is it that after one to two months of publication, some articles in JECE can be searched, while others cannot be found as a whole?

Lucky1024 2022-07-29

Did you submit it for review later? How long does it take to reach the next stage?

Lucky1024 2022-07-29

Did the article get reviewed later? How long does it take to get the results?

Lucky1024 2022-07-29

Did you submit it for approval later?

123456hua 2022-07-26

Two days after submission, it was assigned to an editor. Three days later, without external review, it turned into "decision in process." Generally, when it goes directly to this status, it means rejection. Another day passed, and I received a rejection email. It took one week from submission to rejection for this journal, as it was my first submission to this journal.

俗闺女J 2022-07-25

2022-05-12 Submitted to Journal, With Editor, Under Review
2022-06-07 Major Revision (two reviewers, 13 questions)
2022-06-28 Revised with Editor
2022-07-02 Under Review
2022-07-24 Completed - Accept

huagonggou 2022-07-20

First master's thesis, make sure to record the submission process.
Submitted on April 13, 2022.
Language revision requested on April 22, 2022, with a one-month deadline for revisions.
Official website language polishing from April 23, 2022, to May 7, 2022, costing 2100RMB.
Language revised and submitted on May 9, 2022, with two reviewers assigned.
First review comments received on June 4, 2022, requiring moderate revisions and a one-month deadline.
Revised version returned on June 16, 2022, for a second review (with two reviewers).
Accepted on July 8, 2022.
Initially submitted to Separation and Purification Technology, faced rejections after three to four months of efforts. Subsequent submissions to ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, Hazardous Journal, and other journals were directly rejected by the editors, with none sent for review. Finally, submitted to JECE, and it was accepted. I am grateful for the editor's and reviewers' recognition and hope that the journal continues to thrive. I wish Separation and Purification Technology would soon be included in the prestigious D Journal at Chuan University (please accept my request).

江江江1007 2022-07-18

This magazine IF is still very popular, haha. I feel like it will reach the top 10 next year, but I'm not sure if it can break into the first district.

早晚要还的 2022-07-16

2022.7.6 Submitted
2022.7.7 With Editor
2022.712 With Editor
Still With Editor until now, anxious...

yan 2022-07-15

Yes, this website is really not that great. At least they should allow us to delete our own comments. I had my manuscript reviewed three times. The second review had only two people and they were very fast. The first review, however, was delayed by the third person for over a month. The second review only took three days to yield results. Next time, I still want to submit to this journal, haha.

A...L 2022-07-14

Does anyone know if there are any young friends who have submitted to the journal? From July 6th until now, it is still "with editor" on July 11th. What's going on?

江江江1007 2022-07-14

Oh my goodness, what is going on? I clearly replied under my own post, how did another thread open up? The worst part is that I can't even delete it.

江江江1007 2022-07-14

Replying to "yan": Mine is okay, with only two reviewers and their comments are not difficult to address. The review process of this journal is still quite fast, but the final decision may take some time. Perhaps the editors are busy.

江江江1007 2022-07-14

Reply to "Mr. Hulawawa": There is an RRC in the second review, and it took several days to receive it. This magazine shouldn't be that strict, so as long as you modify it properly, there shouldn't be any major issues. Good luck to you~

XWE 2022-07-13

Excuse me, classmates, how long did it take to receive it in the end?

君君发sci 2022-07-05

The translation of "转投的这个期刊" into English is "The journal that has been transferred to."

yan 2022-07-04

My reviewer also delayed the review for a long time, so I wrote a letter asking him to change to another reviewer.

yan 2022-07-04

Thank you, I see that you said you were rejected and then re-applied, can I also re-apply?

yan 2022-07-04

Thank you, I thought you had said you were rejected and then re-applied, can you re-apply?

葫芦娃先生 2022-07-04

May I ask if there is an RRC in the second review status? The "Under review" status has changed several times.

君君发sci 2022-06-28

For everyone's reference:
2022.4.1 Submitted to Journal
2022.4.2 With Editor
2022.4.9 With Editor
2022.4.11 Under Review
2022.4.27 Required Reviews Completed
2022.5.10 Major revisions received, one month
2022.6.8 Major revisions resubmitted, With Editor
2022.6.11 Under Review
2022.6.15 Required Reviews Completed
2022.6.16 Minor Revision, revised on the same day, With Editor
2022.6.18 With Editor
2022.6.19 Under Review
2022.6.25 Required Reviews Complete
2022.6.28 Completed-Accepted.

张叔叔 2022-06-26

2022-1-14 submitted to journal
2022-1-16 with editor
2022-1-18 under review
2022-2-26 major revisions
2022-3-23 submitted to journal
2022-3-23 with editor
2022-3-24 under review
2022-3-28 completed - accept

Translated:
2022-1-14 submitted to journal
2022-1-16 with editor
2022-1-18 under review
2022-2-26 major revisions
2022-3-23 submitted to journal
2022-3-23 with editor
2022-3-24 under review
2022-3-28 completed - accept