Ci 2022-06-24

2022.4.12 Submitted to this journal
2022.4.15 First revision
2022.4.30 Revised and resubmitted
2022.5.15 Received minor revision comments, reviewer was very friendly
2022.5.30 Decision letter sent
2022.6.5 Accepted
2022.6.15 Online
Thank you, editor, for making my first submission go so smoothly.

希望顺意 2022-06-23

It has been 9 days, and I have been continuously submitting to the journal. Why is it taking so long? How long is the estimated time?

FFFFFFD 2022-06-23

Hey Xiao Xiu, have you accepted it or not?

xlustb 2022-06-21

Jun 20, 2022 With Editor

xlustb 2022-06-19

Jun 18, 2022 With Editor

Sonia421 2022-06-18

I have transferred here for a whole month already, but the submission still hasn't reached the editor's hands. The speed is really frustrating.

asdfdcv 2022-06-15

The editor said that the format of the document is incorrect. Does anyone have a template to share?

xlustb 2022-06-13

Jun 13, 2022 Submitted to Journal -> June 13, 2022, Submitted to Journal.

xfly 2022-06-13

It's been almost two weeks, and I'm still stuck in the "transferred submission received" status. It's way too slow.

Accepted, Sir！ 2022-06-10

2022.1.27 Submitted
2022.2.4 With Editor
2022.3.9 Under Review
2022.5.20 Revise
2022.5.30 Revision Submitted to Journal
2022.6.1 With Editor
2022.6.2 Under Review
2022.6.10 Accept
The editor is Professor Guillaume Miquelard-Garnier from France, with three reviewers, two minor revisions and one major revision. The three reviewers are indeed very knowledgeable and should be industry experts. The review process is very careful, strict, and rigorous. They raised crucial questions, and I made serious revisions, not daring to be careless. I wrote a response of nearly 20 pages. After revising, the paper was sent to the three reviewers again, and two of them agreed to accept it. The editor informed me directly via email about the acceptance. Overall, this journal requires sufficient research effort, especially the data must fully support the conclusions, otherwise, the reviewers will definitely point it out. Although it took nearly 5 months for this submission, the journal editor was quite meticulous and responsible. I wish the journal continued success! Now, I'm just waiting for the proof and online publication. Good luck to everyone! (I always write in detail, hoping to help everyone, haha)

xlustb 2022-06-10

Jun 04, 2022 Transferred Submission Received

Translation: Jun 04, 2022 Transferred Submission Received

ggod 2022-06-09

After submission, the status changes to: Revise without peer review-editorial review.
There are several options in Action:
- View Submission
- File Inventory
- Revise Submission
- Decline to Revise
- Send E-mail

Which option should be selected for modification in Action? Where can the revision comments be viewed? Is it good or bad to have this status?

ggod 2022-06-09

After submission, the status changes to: Revise without peer review-editorial review
Action:
View Submission
File Inventory
Revise Submission
Decline to Revise
Send E-mail
Which option should be chosen in the Action? Is it good or bad to have this status?

吴江第一深情 2022-05-31

I am also like this, required reviews have been completed for a long time. May I ask what is the situation? How are you doing afterwards?

seastar12 2022-05-06

2021.11.20 submitted;
2022.02.08 sent to Xiaoxiu;
2022.03.25 returned for repair (There was no email in between, so the clean version for repair was not uploaded, causing a delay of one month.);
2022.05.05 received.

yrg 2022-05-01

The speed is indeed a bit slow. Please wait patiently.
On January 18th, I submitted a repair request and received feedback on March 28th. They said it required major repairs and gave a two-month timeframe. On April 10th, I sent it back for repairs, thinking there might be a need for a second repair. It was an unexpected surprise when it was finally returned on April 30th.

Accepted, Sir！ 2022-04-23

Apr 22, 2022 - Under Review

三缺一啦 2022-04-18

Transfer to MTC, submitted for one week, with editor for one month (using Elsevier's proprietary conflict of interest statement), under review for half a month, two reviewers, 16 comments-major revisions, modified for one month, half a month for revising (clear version required), accepted. A conscientious journal. Overall speed is decent, hoping everyone's submission goes smoothly as well.

Accepted, Sir！ 2022-04-13

Jan 18, 2022 Submitted
Jan 27, 2022 Submitted
Feb 4, 2022 With Editor
Mar 7, 2022 With Editor
Mar 9, 2022 Under Review
Mar 16, 2022 Under Review
Mar 25, 2022 Under Review
Apr 4, 2022 Under Review
Apr 13, 2022 Under Review
...
The date keeps changing every ten days, as expected. The cycle is torturous, and the updates continue.
Will the next date be Apr 22/23, 2022? We wait with anticipation.

皮卡丘& 2022-04-12

With the editor, it takes about one month, slightly slower, but the review speed is incredibly fast. The first review takes 30 days and only requires minor revisions. The second review takes 20 days. After that, it is directly accepted and published online within three days. Overall, except for being a little slower with the editor, the rest of the process is very fast.

坐在街头看文献 2022-04-08

2022.1.18 submitted
2022.1.27 submitted
2022.2.4 with editor
2022.3.7 with editor
2022.3.6 under review
2022.3.16 under review
2022.3.25 under review
2022.4.4 under review
······
It has been two and a half months since submission, and I don't know what the situation is. Let's wait patiently.

hyg901221 2022-04-08

Posted on January 17, 2022. Sent for review on February 6. Received feedback on March 7. The editor gave two months for revisions, but it only took one week to make the changes. Returned on March 30. Accepted on April 8.

The speed is still quite fast. The editor regularly handles manuscripts. The main reason for slow review is finding reviewers and waiting for their feedback. Editors process manuscripts based on the timeline.

坐在街头看文献 2022-03-26

The time for the review has changed again. Looking at the comments, everyone's review status has changed multiple times within a week, but then it remains unchanged. Why is it that my review status only changes once every ten days or so? I don't know if I can accept it before graduation.

yrg 2022-03-19

My submission was sent for review on 2.15. During the process, the corresponding time for the "under review" status changed twice. It did not change on noon of 2.27, and until now, it is still under review. It has been 60 days since I submitted it.

坐在街头看文献 2022-03-17

Mar 9, 2022 Under Review
Mar 16, 2022 Under Review
The date changed after submission for review. What could be the reason? Did a reviewer decline the review and had to invite another reviewer, or did one of the reviewer's comments come back? I don't understand...

夏季清风 2022-03-15

After my state became like this, all the states disappeared. What is this situation?

坐在街头看文献 2022-03-14

3-7-2-0-6-7-3-1-6，交流投稿经验。哈哈

3-7-2-0-6-7-3-1-6, Exchange and share submission experience. Haha.

yrg 2022-03-14

Mine is also too slow. It has been two months since I submitted it, and it is still under review.

坐在街头看文献 2022-03-13

My manuscript has been in the hands of the editor for over a month, and it was just submitted for review a few days ago. The current status is unknown. Interestingly, the time with the editor changed once before the review. It is likely due to the internal process of the journal, where the previous editor finished reviewing and passed it to another editor, who then reviewed and submitted it within two days. I just hope that the peer review process can be faster, and I am looking forward to a smooth review.

#89757 2022-03-07

Please, let me graduate soon, I'm in a hurry.