王默默 2022-11-10

My revised draft also does not have line numbers. Best wishes.

蓝蓝蓝洛 2022-11-09

Then I can only borrow your auspicious words.

王默默 2022-11-09

I would like to ask, for the second submission, do I still need line numbers?

王默默 2022-11-09

Posted at 8:30, first review on October 26th, with around 10 questions given to the major for modifications after the first review, and it has been completed with the editor.

Olaf 2022-11-06

There is nothing wrong with Sanxiu. I feel that as long as I give it a try, the probability of acceptance is as high as 90%.

Olaf 2022-11-06

Translation: The editing is random, you can only rely on luck.

huangdi0916 2022-11-03

Does the original poster have any recommended editors? Graduation is approaching, and I'm worried about not being able to find one.

蓝蓝蓝洛 2022-11-02

I have to say, I really like this journal, rrc. I already have six reviewers now, and three just returned... Everyone in the same field says that not refusing is good news, but my heart has been hanging... Hahaha.

上善若水 2022-11-02

Today I received the review comments. There were a total of three reviewers, and they raised 20 questions in total. The review period was given for 20 days, and each question was crucial.

Huijie Ren 2022-11-01

Reply to Little Horse on scientific research: No, I didn't. But my senior sister previously marked the revised manuscript she submitted to another journal, so please check the requirements of the journal. Good luck to you!

Huijie Ren 2022-11-01

Reply to Wang Mo Mo: My RRC time has been updated, there are a total of four reviewers. Usually, RRC is displayed after the first two reviewers have reviewed the manuscript. However, if their opinions differ significantly, the third or even the fourth reviewer may be consulted. After the opinions of the subsequent reviewers are available, the RRC status may not change, but the time will be updated. Therefore, the final decision will be made after the last RRC. I hope this is clear. Good luck with your studies!

Huijie Ren 2022-11-01

Update:
Submitted the manuscript on September 5th
Received reviewer comments on September 27th (two major revisions, two minor revisions)
Submitted revised manuscript on October 6th
Accepted on October 31st
The whole process took less than two months.
Without going into details, the overall feeling is that it was not delayed. The editor quickly found reviewers, and the reviewers reviewed the manuscript promptly. (It may also be related to the field of expertise, as I am in the field of electrochemistry). I am very happy with my first SCI paper!!!

liumaodegangbeng 2022-10-31

Which editor is more reliable?

ZhiyuRen 2022-10-31

The first revision had four reviewers, who provided 26 comments; the second revision had three reviewers, and another one provided four additional comments; the third revision had the last reviewer who brought up language issues; surprisingly, the fourth revision required me to reduce the weight; for the fifth revision, it was resubmitted and directly accepted.

Olaf 2022-10-29

This system is very strange. If it automatically generates line numbers, there is no need to add them. If it doesn't generate them, then you have to add them yourself.

科研的小马 2022-10-28

Hello, excuse me, but have you marked the line numbers in your revised draft?

大雨小雨 2022-10-28

Eight months, ah ah ah.

Olaf 2022-10-27

One trial, two reviewers, the questions raised were relatively simple, and after the second trial, the paper was directly accepted two weeks later. The processing speed of this journal is related to the editor. Reliable editors are still very fast. It only took three hours from receiving the second review comments to acceptance.

Olaf 2022-10-27

Jul 24, Submitted to Journal
Jul 25, With Editor
Jul 27, With Editor
Aug 11, Under Review
Aug 20, Under Review
Sep 8, Under Review
Sep 21, Required Reviews Completed
Sep 21, Under Review
Oct 01, Major revision
Oct 11, "with Editor"
Oct 12, With Editor
Oct 13, Under Review
Oct 26, Required Reviews Completed
Oct 26, Accept

Translated:

Jul 24, Submitted to Journal
Jul 25, With Editor
Jul 27, With Editor
Aug 11, Under Review
Aug 20, Under Review
Sep 8, Under Review
Sep 21, Required Reviews Completed
Sep 21, Under Review
Oct 01, Major revision
Oct 11, "with Editor"
Oct 12, With Editor
Oct 13, Under Review
Oct 26, Required Reviews Completed
Oct 26, Accept

科研的小马 2022-10-26

Hello, does your revised manuscript for the Journal of Energy Storage have any marked lines?

王默默 2022-10-26

Is decision after RRC?

王默默 2022-10-26

The submission and review process took two months, and today the status has changed to RRC. I don't know what the outcome will be. Wishing for good luck.

上善若水 2022-10-25

Yes, send email.

Yuuni 2022-10-24

Hello, may I ask where to send reminder emails for the Journal of Energy Storage? I couldn't find the "send email" option on the official website, but there is a "send email" function in the submission system.

changlijun0814@163.com 2022-10-22

It has been four months and it still hasn't been reviewed. I don't know if it's just bad luck or something else, it's really confusing.

ZHTTJU 2022-10-22

09.20 Submission
10.09 under review
Unknown outcome

Liuton ward 2022-10-18

Thank you for your kind words. The results have already been produced. For the minor revision, there were 2 reviewers with a total of 18 comments, one suggesting major revisions and the other suggesting minor revisions. Ironically, the reviewer suggesting minor revisions provided 14 comments, while the one suggesting major revisions provided 4 comments.

Huijie Ren 2022-10-17

Reply to Liuton: I submitted the revised paper to the teacher on October 14th, and the teacher made some formatting changes. On the 16th, the paper was uploaded. The current tracking status is "with Editor". I asked senior students before, and they said that the rrc time is not related to acceptance. It would be a good thing if the process doesn't drag on for too long. Let's be patient and hope for a good outcome.

Liuton ward 2022-10-15

How are you doing, brother? My RRC took place on October 12th and lasted for 2 days before turning into a decision. It is said online that the longer the RRC lasts, the better the outcome. I'm really nervous now.

sidom 2022-10-14

A pleasant submission experience~ Just received the acceptance notice yesterday.
Submitted on 7.15, first revision on 8.15 (two reviewers), then two more revisions due to some unexpected circumstances, finally notified of acceptance on 10.13.
It took a total of 3 months from submission to acceptance.