dj wu 2022-12-14

I have been under review for a month for the second round, and it seems like it has been sent. In the first round, there were two reviewers, one rejected the manuscript and the other directly declined it.

19002000 2022-12-14

Classmate, how long did it take you to go from RRC to accept in the second review?

科研小睿 2022-12-14

Waited for more than two months, finally Under Review on December 13th, hoping everything goes smoothly.

王默默 2022-12-13

11.20 under review
11.25 under review
12.11 accept

The feeling is okay, it took a little over 3 months in total, and the magazine processing speed is acceptable.

宛飞丞 2022-12-10

22.6.29 submitted
22.7.04 under review, no reviewers available during this period
22.9.19 author query, editor urged for reviewers and two were quickly assigned
22.11.01 major revision, one major and one minor issue, major revisions were difficult and requested additional case studies (3 weeks)
22.11.18 revision due date extension, due to tight experimental schedule and dormitory quarantine, requested a 2-week extension
22.12.1 submit the revised manuscript
22.12.6 under review
22.12.7 reviews completed (can be viewed in the track link), both reviewers completed the reviews overnight, estimated to be good news
22.12.10 decision in the afternoon
22.12.10 9:00 PM acceptance

Overall, for my first SCI journal publication, I found the Elsevier system and editor to be very nice. The track link received positive feedback and was user-friendly. Although reviewers were not found in the first two months, they were promptly assigned after requesting. The reviewers' comments were insightful and significantly improved the quality of the paper. Additionally, the reviewers were very fast in their responses. Many thanks to the two reviewers!

王默默 2022-12-09

I submitted it on the 16th of last month, and it is still under review for the second round. I guess our situations are similar. I hope everyone gets good results.

科研的小马 2022-12-09

According to what I saw in the link he provided, there were opinions returned inside, but I am speechless that the status is still "under review". I guess the editor hasn't seen it yet. It's probably the final moment, and I hope to be selected.

超超 2022-12-09

Just wait a moment, I will need almost three months for the external review.

ZHTTJU 2022-12-08

decision in process means that a decision is currently being made or considered.

ZHTTJU 2022-12-08

How long does it usually take for a decision to be made?

科研的小马 2022-12-08

I did not ask them all to confirm, so it should not be necessary for all of them to confirm, right?

菜狗 2022-12-07

Hello, may I ask if it is necessary for all authors to confirm now?

科研的小马 2022-12-07

I haven't received the final result yet. Currently, I have received all the feedback and opinions. The outcome is about to be revealed, hoping for a positive outcome.

19002000 2022-12-06

Classmate, have you got any results yet?

科研的小马 2022-12-02

After major revision, the paper has been under review since the 15th, hoping to be accepted as soon as possible.

dj wu 2022-12-01

I have two reviewers, one agrees to accept, and the other rejects. The editor has given me a major revision, and it has been two weeks since I submitted the revised manuscript. It is still under review.

达达小达达 2022-11-29

Submitted Sep 28, 2022
With Editor Sep 30, 2022
With Editor Oct 3, 2022

What is this! It's been two months with the editor. On September 30th, it was "with editor," and after updating the date on October 3rd, there has been no further communication. Everyone, don't submit to this journal. It's too unreliable.

梁建海 2022-11-28

It's been almost two months for me, may I ask if you have updated your status now?

NicVicky 2022-11-27

how great!! my second one has been accepted.
Submit-16 May
Accept-26 Nov
Thanks for that!!

yaping2319 2022-11-24

My paper was directly rejected after submission, but the editor said I can resubmit it after major revisions. I need to write a modification explanation. I would like to ask everyone if this is the case for this journal, do they allow all authors to resubmit their papers for a second time? Do I need to resubmit it again? Thank you.

123lyh 2022-11-23

I have been abstaining for more than 2 months.

123lyh 2022-11-23

Same, I don't know the reason.

科研小睿 2022-11-21

Until now, it has been almost two months and it is still in the "with editor" status. I have reminded them once about the manuscript, but it seems to have had no effect. This is just too slow...

19002000 2022-11-20

11.19大修正 translates to "11.19 major revision" in English.

Gavin9 2022-11-19

How long does it usually take with an editor?

19002000 2022-11-17

11.17 decision in process translates to "The decision is currently being processed."

19002000 2022-11-17

11.07 decision in process translates to "11th of July, decision being processed" in English.

19002000 2022-11-16

9.28 submitted to journal
10.3 with editor
10.26 under review
10.27 under review
11.15 required reviews completed

Translation:
9.28 submitted to journal
10.3 with editor
10.26 under review
10.27 under review
11.15 required reviews completed

科研的小马 2022-11-14

After the major repair, it has already been returned for rework. It has been over ten days now with the editor, and the speed is a bit slow.

Yuuni 2022-11-11

It has been over two months with the editor, but urging for the manuscript hasn't been effective.