HESS.C 2023-02-12

Always been With Editor

豆腐 2023-02-06

It seems like this is the case for everyone. I submitted in December with an editor, and it doesn't feel normal.

发Sci发到手抽筋 2023-02-05

I submitted my work in mid-November 2022, and it is still "with editor" now. I sent a reminder letter a month ago, but it was still ineffective.

豆腐 2023-02-05

Is there anything recently submitted? Why does it always say "with editor"?

vicat 2023-02-02

2022.10.18 submitted
2022.11.13 major revision
2022.12.01 revision submitted
2022.12.04 Resubmitted with modified version due to missing line numbers
2022.12.30 Reviewer1 has no comments, Reviewer2 couldn't find the download link for supporting documents
2023.01.01 Resubmit
2023.01.30 Decision in process
2023.01.31 Accepted
Overall, it feels good. The speed is fast, worth it!

JW.Shen.FM 2023-02-02

It's very normal, mine has three reviewers.

dikesen 2023-02-01

2.1 with editor:

坡以 2023-01-30

Submission experience:
2022.10.24 submitted
2022.12.01 major revision
2023.1.03 minor revision
2023.1.10 major revision
2023.1.30 accepted

First time experiencing three rounds of revisions, not sure if it's bad luck or if the reviewers are too strict.

宛飞丞 2023-01-30

Immediately after sending the body, the link was sent to the corresponding author's email.

阿巴......阿巴 2023-01-29

Submitted the second article to this journal. The first one was reviewed quickly, but this time the editor might be on leave for the Lunar New Year.
01.19 submission
01.29 with editor

无怨 2023-01-29

"1.28 under review"

LICHUYI 2023-01-28

At that time, I didn't actually rush for the manuscript. After the completion of the required reviews, the feedback from the external review came back.

无怨 2023-01-28

My card is stuck under review.

dikesen 2023-01-28

In January, they have been in a stuck state. I don't know if they also went for the New Year.

dikesen 2023-01-28

12.31 submission - This refers to the deadline for submitting something.
1.5 with editor - This means that something will be reviewed or edited by an editor on January 5th.
1.28 with editor - This means that something will be reviewed or edited by an editor on January 28th.

无怨 2023-01-28

January 27 under review

无怨 2023-01-20

1.19 under review.

无怨 2023-01-18

Is your track link sent during the first review?

无怨 2023-01-15

We both invested about the same amount of time.

无怨 2023-01-15

Do you know what's going on?

12.12 submission
12.14-16 with editor
12.20 under review
12.26 under review
1.3 under review
1.11 under review

Sisen 2023-01-12

2022.08.30 submitted - Submitted on August 30, 2022.
2022.11.09 major revision - Major revision on November 9, 2022.
2022.11.29 R1 submitted - Revised version 1 submitted on November 29, 2022.
2023.01.04 minor revision - Minor revision on January 4, 2023.
2023.01.04 R2 submitted - Revised version 2 submitted on January 4, 2023.
2023.01.09 accepted - Accepted on January 9, 2023.

Overall, the process was relatively fast, but the submission system was not user-friendly (possibly my own issue). When uploading for the initial review, the Nomenclature did not compile successfully (using LaTeX), and it took a lot of time to debug it repeatedly.

ML_1 2023-01-04

Submit by the end of June.
Receive revision comments on November 20th, provided by two experts, who gave very good suggestions. Editor provided major revisions, return on December 19th.
Accepted on January 3rd.

紫露可可 2023-01-04

August 17, 2021 Submission
October 26, 2021 Major Revision 1
December 9, 2021 Minor Revision 2
December 20, 2021 Accepted, searchable online
Took four months, first SCI publication.

OABLO 2023-01-02

May I ask who has the JES manuscript file that I can take a look at? I want to submit it to the journal. Thank you.

OABLO 2023-01-02

Can I see the manuscript file? I also want to submit to this journal.

坡以 2022-12-30

"You are too hardworking."

JW.Shen.FM 2022-12-22

2022.12.7 Submitted to Journal - This document was submitted to the journal on December 7, 2022.
2011.12.10 With Editor - This document is currently with the editor as of December 10, 2011.
2011.12.21 Under Review - This document is currently under review as of December 21, 2011.

蓝蓝蓝洛 2022-12-20

2022-3-10 Submission
2022-5-10 Major Repair
2022-6-4 R1
2022-9-8 Major Repair
2022-9-10 R2
2022-10-24 Major Repair
2022-11-10 R3
2022-12-10 Minor Repair
2022-12-12 R4
2022-12-20 Accept
The process is too arduous, I hope everyone can have a smooth journey...

上善若水 2022-12-20

7.27 Submission
10.2 Review
11.2 Major revision
11.20 Revised
12.11 Minor revision
12.18 Revised
12.20 Accepted for publication

科研的小马 2022-12-18

I wonder if the editor in charge of me is watching the World Cup... It has been 13 days since I received the second review comments, but he hasn't replied yet. I hope to receive a positive response soon.