让我发个大子刊吧 2022-11-07

9.18 submission
9.19 under evaluation
9.21 editor invited
9.23 under evaluation
10.1 under evaluation
10.5 under evaluation
10.05 to review
10.07 to review
10.08 to review
10.11 to review
10.12 to review
10.18 to review
10.19 to review
10.20 to review
10.25 under evaluation
11.02 under evaluation
11.04 under evaluation
No news until now, it has been half a month under evaluation, not looking very optimistic.

jinqing wang 2022-11-04

10.12 submission received
10.14 under evaluation
11.04 under evaluation
11.04 Updated the date, probably changed the editor, it's a bit slow.

让我发顶刊吧，谢谢！ 2022-11-03

The journal itself is quite authoritative, and the review process is relatively quick. It takes less than 2 months from submission to receiving the results.

9.2: Submission received
9.3: Under evaluation
9.6: Editor invited
9.9: Editor invited
9.14: To review
9.16: To review
9.20: To review
9.21: To review
9.27: To review
9.30: To review
10.04: To review
10.07: To review
10.15: To review
10.17: To review (From review)
10.22: To review (From review)
10.27: Reject

Among them, the time for "To Review" changed multiple times, possibly assigned to different reviewers. However, only one reviewer's opinion came back in the end. They provided some direct and crucial suggestions, indicating that they are an expert in the field. Overall, there was still some gain.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-11-01

Okay, thank you all for sharing, let's wait a little longer.

Joney Joney 2022-11-01

Translation: "The status of the garden is 'Editor Evaluation Completed.' It usually takes 1 to 2 days to receive the review comments."

Joney Joney 2022-11-01

My always displays Status: Editor Evaluation Completed.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-11-01

10.25 under evaluation, until now there has been no change in status, no feedback received.

Joney Joney 2022-11-01

"Let me publish a big magazine issue."
May I ask how long it takes to receive a round of feedback for an increase? Mine has been in this state for 5 days as well.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-29

Yours is the fastest I have ever seen. How long did it take to submit for review? It's so excellent.

milan23002 2022-10-29

22-Sep-2022 Under evaluation/Reviewer invited
23-Sep-2022 To review
25-Sep-2022 To review
26-Sep-2022 To review / From review
03-Oct-2022 To review / From review
05-Oct-2022 To review / From review
06-Oct-2022 To Revision
25-Oct-2022 From Revision
27-Oct-2022 Under evaluation / Editor evaluation completed
28-Oct-2022 Accept-technical hold

Translation:
22-Sep-2022 Under evaluation/Reviewer invited
23-Sep-2022 To review
25-Sep-2022 To review
26-Sep-2022 To review / From review
03-Oct-2022 To review / From review
05-Oct-2022 To review / From review
06-Oct-2022 To Revision
25-Oct-2022 From Revision
27-Oct-2022 Under evaluation / Editor evaluation completed
28-Oct-2022 Accept-technical hold

milan23002 2022-10-29

24-Mar-2022 Submitted
25-Mar-2022 Under evaluation
30-Mar-2022 Editor invited/Under evaluation/Reviewer invited/To review
02-Apr-2022 To review
06-Apr-2022 To review
07-Apr-2022 To review / From review
08-Apr-2022 To review / From review
12-Apr-2022 To review / From review
14-Apr-2022 To review / From review
19-Apr-2022 To review / From review
21-Apr-2022 To revision
07-Sep-2022 From revision
20-Sep-2022 From revision/Fill COI and License Agreement

Translated text:
24-Mar-2022 Submitted
25-Mar-2022 Under evaluation
30-Mar-2022 Editor invited/Under evaluation/Reviewer invited/To review
02-Apr-2022 To review
06-Apr-2022 To review
07-Apr-2022 To review / From review
08-Apr-2022 To review / From review
12-Apr-2022 To review / From review
14-Apr-2022 To review / From review
19-Apr-2022 To review / From review
21-Apr-2022 To revision
07-Sep-2022 From revision
20-Sep-2022 From revision/Fill COI and License Agreement

milan23002 2022-10-28

After the review comments are changed to "To Revision" status, you can click on the manuscript number of the article to download. It should be in the attachment section of the second option page after entering. The file name is "abqXXXX_Blinded Review Report_seq1_v1", and there are also several other checklists. The corresponding author will also receive an email notification.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-28

I haven't received it yet. It has been in this state for 3 days, under evaluation.

mll0805 2022-10-27

Hello, where can I find your review comments? The website currently shows "to revision," and the email asked me to complete the COI and license form, but I cannot see the review comments.

mll0805 2022-10-27

Where did you see the comments from the reviewers? The website currently shows "to revision," and the email asks for the completion of COI and license forms, but I cannot see the comments from the reviewers.

yiyi0101 2022-10-25

Did you receive the email?

yiyi0101 2022-10-25

Did you receive the review comments on the 26th?

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-25

10.20 to review - editor
10.25 under evaluation - editor

Under evaluation again, not sure if a decision will be made to accept or reject it, feeling nervous...

Joney Joney 2022-10-25

Is it true that the approval rate is 20%?

ww-geo 2022-10-21

My submission also went under review. The status has changed four times, and I don't know if this journal reviews quickly. Praying.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-20

I don't know. I've seen some take nearly 2 months for review. It's my first time submitting for review, so I'm praying and trembling.

yiyi0101 2022-10-19

It looks like you should be receiving the review comments soon.

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-19

What is the current status now?

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-10-19

An article written in 2022
9.18 submission
9.19 under evaluation by editor
9.21 editor invited
9.23 under evaluation by editor
10.1 under evaluation by editor
10.5 under evaluation by editor
10.5 to review by editor
10.7 to review by editor
10.8 to review by editor
10.11 to review by editor
10.12 to review by editor
10.18 to review by editor
10.19 to review by editor
(Updating in progress)

JiawLee 2022-10-13

When I went back for minor repairs twice, I was stuck on "from revision" for a long time, a couple of months. Recently, it seems to be slow, so I can only patiently wait.

JiawLee 2022-10-13

Went to the wrong floor, 0 0.

JiawLee 2022-10-13

When I went back for the second minor repair, I also got stuck at "from revision" for a long time, for about a couple of months. Lately, it seems to be very slow, so I can only wait patiently.

Suede 2022-10-11

Hello, may I ask how long the status of "from revision" will last when it is sent back for the second time? I have been in the "from revision" status for one month now, and the due date has changed four or five times during this period.

JiawLee 2022-10-10

2021.12.23 initial submission - December 23, 2021, initial submission
2022.03.02 major revision - March 2, 2022, major revision
2022.03.23 major revision submission from the author - March 23, 2022, major revision submission from the author
2022.05.21 minor revision - May 21, 2022, minor revision
2022.05.28 minor revision submission from author - May 28, 2022, minor revision submission from the author
2022.06.23 minor revision about the request in DMA statement - June 23, 2022, minor revision about the request in DMA statement
2022.06.27 submission with revision about updated data - June 27, 2022, submission with revision about updated data
2022.08.26 second minor revision - August 26, 2022, second minor revision
2022.08.28 second minor revision submission from the author - August 28, 2022, second minor revision submission from the author
2022.10.06 accept-technical hold - October 6, 2022, accept-technical hold
It took a total of 10 months, with slightly longer waiting times for the two minor revisions, causing some anxiety, but in the end, good news was received.

Joney Joney 2022-09-29

The slowness is outrageous, it has been over a month and the submission has not been reviewed yet.