Verified Reviews - Science China-Materials
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

sumer1 2022-11-12

Hello, may I ask if this journal is a paid one? If it is, how much is the page fee?

yiyiyiyiyiyiyi 2022-10-28

Hello, I would like to ask how the pictures are provided? How can I provide PPT vector graphics? Thank you.

Adam James 2022-10-26

10.26 accepted translates to "10.26 has been accepted" in English.

Adam James 2022-09-22

9.21 in attesa dei punteggi dei revisori (Italian)

Translation: 9.21 awaiting reviewer scores.

Adam James 2022-09-20

9.19 waiting for the reviewer to be selected.

nana 2022-09-18

I am also in the same situation. May I ask what was the final outcome for you?

nana 2022-09-18

After EA made the decision, I also submitted it for review. What's the situation? Are the opinions of the reviewers conflicting?

nana 2022-09-18

After AE made the decision, it was sent for review again. Does anyone know what the situation is?

Adam James 2022-09-16

9.15 submitted, EO Pick and Assign Manuscript.

卫斯理a 2022-08-15

Hello, when submitting a manuscript, you are requested to upload the Copyright. Should I write it myself or upload a transfer agreement?

watermelon粑 2022-07-25

5.31 submit
6.2 awaiting ED process
6.2 awaiting reviewer selection
6.7 awaiting reviewer assigning
6.7 awaiting reviewer scores
6.16 awaiting AE make decision
6.18 awaiting editor final processing
6.20 major revision (Three reviewers, all positive evaluations, additional experiments required, editor provided 1 month)
7.11 revision submit
7.11 awaiting reviewer invitation
7.13 awaiting reviewer scores
7.21 awaiting AE make decision
7.21 awaiting editor final processing
7.21 Editor provided 1-3 days, requesting language polishing, format modification, and providing editable image files
7.23 email
7.25 accept

化工陈 2022-07-12

July 11 eproof

化工陈 2022-06-11

Your application should have been rejected and returned, right?

你的小可爱 2022-06-11

The following text translates to: "The submission has been waiting for ED processing for three days, and today it suddenly changed to Draft. I want to know what happened. T T"

CDC 2022-05-31

EO: Wang Guilin, rejected before review, rejection reason is a cliché, the speed is quite fast.

小文 2022-05-31

Oh, it was rejected without being reviewed.
The editor is Yadong Li.
Sad.

12344 2022-05-20

I have been waiting for this week. A few days ago, it changed to awaiting ED process, and now 3 days have passed.

化工陈 2022-04-27

March 26 submitted
March 29 awaiting ED processing
March 29 awaiting reviewer selection
March 30 awaiting reviewer assignment
March 31 awaiting reviewer scores
April 14 awaiting AE make decision
April 15 minor revision
April 18 revision submitted
April 20 format modification before acceptance
April 27 accepted

Jason Lee 2022-04-12

In the field of photoelectrochemistry, progress is quite fast. The submission was made on February 8th, and the reviewers' comments were received on March 1st. There were two reviewers, and their comments were very fair and professional. It was not very convenient to conduct supplementary experiments during the pandemic, and I was reminded once because it exceeded two weeks. The revised version was submitted on March 19th in the morning. It was accepted on April 8th. Currently, I am waiting for publication.

123t 2022-04-06

The speed is quite fast. After submission, it takes 3 days to find a reviewer and 7 days for review. Major revisions take about a month, and after the revisions are sent back, it takes 10 days to accept. Domestic journals may need time to establish themselves, but many journals are progressing quickly. Now in China, there is a desire to support domestic magazines, so they are expected to improve. Especially with the strong rise of Nano Micro Letter and Science Bulletin, it seems that once a domestic journal's impact factor exceeds 10, its quality will instantly rise.

chem-2022 2022-03-30

Supplement
One month for review
Two months just accept

zhaixu 2022-03-30

The overall speed is quite fast, with two reviewers who provide professional and objective opinions. I hope IF can reach 10 as soon as possible.

zhaixu 2022-03-30

The journal is good, and the quality of the published articles is also very good. I wish you all the best in your future endeavors, and hope that the impact factor will exceed 10 soon.

lchs 2022-03-17

Hello editor, I would like to ask about the rejection rate after entering the editing process in this publication (including major and minor revisions).

lchs 2022-03-17

In order to submit an article for the first district, I hope for a good outcome.

sunsky633 2022-02-15

Hello editor, the revised manuscript was returned to the reviewer the next day. On the third day, the status changed to "awaiting AE (Associate Editor) decision". After the editor's processing, the status changed again to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment". Does this mean that a new reviewer has been selected again? Or does it mean that the previous reviewer rejected it during the first round of review?

sunsky633 2022-02-14

The modified manuscript was returned to the reviewer the next day. One day later, the status changed to "awaiting AE (Associate Editor) make decision". Then, the status changed again to "awaiting reviewer assigned". Does this mean that a new reviewer is being selected again? Or does it imply that the first round of reviewers rejected it?

sunsky633 2022-02-14

It's time for review. The review process is exceptionally fast, and I will receive it back in just two weeks.

Dr. HF 2022-02-14

Excuse me, OP, does "Awaiting Reviewer selection" mean that it is awaiting review after submitting? Did you have this status when you submitted it?

小哲000 2021-12-22

Did your brain get waterlogged? You are a beneficiary of domestic journals. Do you think the quality of papers can compare to Small, JMCA, Carbon, and Chemistry of Materials? The categorization of domestic journals is a joke. You are just a slave to domestic journals.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started