会翻身的咸鱼干 2022-09-21

8.1 revise - Four reviewers, one rejection, indicating a lack of innovation, three minor revisions.
8.15 revision submitted.
8.17 under review.
8.19 required reviewers complete.
9.1 accept.

市民7 2022-09-20

The first experimental and simulated article initially only involved MD simulation. However, upon the recommendation of the reviewers, additional experiments were included. Due to lack of experimental experience, an extension of two months was requested for revisions. Fortunately, it was eventually accepted. When I was pursuing my master's degree, I had always wanted to have both MD and ASS. Now, I have finally achieved one of them. I am grateful to the editor and the two reviewers! Below is the timeline:

Submitted: April 10, 2022
With Editor: April 13, 2022
Under Review: April 26, 2022
Under Review: June 21, 2022
Required Reviews Completed: June 26, 2022
Major Revision: June 27, 2022
Revision Submitted to Journal: September 8, 2022
With Editor: September 8, 2022
Under Review: September 8, 2022
Accept: September 19, 2022

文章顺利 2022-09-06

Excuse me, do you have any results yet? Good luck to you! Mine has been in the "required review completed" state for a month and a half now, with no updates. I'm a little frustrated.

KYJX 2022-08-20

After reading your comments on various journals, it is clear that you are just a piece of trash. If your submission is not accepted, you resort to defaming the journal. I remember when you supported domestic journals and submitted your best work to NML. But when it was rejected, you called it a garbage journal, claiming that only big shots can get published there. I really look down upon someone like you who criticizes others' journals just because your own work is not up to standard.

润成 2022-08-06

Such a trashy journal is actually in Zone 1, the classification system of the Chinese Academy of Sciences is really rubbish to the extreme.

会翻身的咸鱼干 2022-07-29

4.15 submitted to journal
4.21 with editor
4.27 under review
7.13 required reviews complete
It's really slow. I have urged once during the under review stage, and now I am waiting again. Helpless.

lsweet 2022-07-14

Hello, I would like to ask if all authors need to click on the link in the email to confirm after submitting their contribution. Thank you.

lsweet 2022-07-14

Hello, I would like to ask if all authors need to click on the link in the email to confirm after submitting the manuscript. Thank you!

edcee30000 2022-06-25

Hello, may I ask if all the co-authors have clicked on the confirmation link after you submitted the manuscript? Do you need to click on the confirmation link?

edcee30000 2022-06-25

Hello, may I ask if all co-authors have clicked on the confirmation link after you submitted your contribution? Is it necessary to click on it?

edcee30000 2022-06-25

Hello, may I ask if all co-authors have confirmed the link after you submitted the manuscript? Is confirmation required?

冲冲冲 2022-06-23

2022.6.18 Submitted to Journal
Now there is still no update on the status, does anyone know what's going on?

科研民工 2022-06-22

20220422-submitted
20220424-under review
20220525-revise
Three reviewers, a total of 27 comments, the first one gave minor revisions, the second one gave major revisions, and the third one did not have a clear attitude, but supplemented some experiments. Detailed responses and explanations were provided for all the issues.
20220608-revision submitted
20220611-under review
20220622-accept

不醒人士 2022-06-20

The school requires Zone 1, so I tried submitting to MD. It feels quite fast, but I don't know how the result will be. Submitted on May 24th, reviewed within three days. They provided a tracking link, so I can see clearly how many people have taken it. Maybe there are fewer people in this direction. After a week, one person took over the review, and there were changes every three days until June 15th, when the second person took over. Currently, there have been no changes for 6 days. I saw someone earlier saying there are only two reviewers, so it might be relatively stable. I have been worried that no one will review it and it will be rejected...

deletep 2022-06-16

May I ask if it has been submitted for review in the end? The editing process is so slow.

风我渡 2022-06-06

Hello, may I ask if after submitting the MD, does each author need to confirm before it is sent for review?

humprotoss 2022-05-17

20220224 Submitted to Journal
20220303 With Editor
20220303 Under Review-1
20220304 Under Review-2
20220307 Under Review-3
20220309 Under Review-4
20220324 Under Review-5
20220326 Under Review-6
20220328 Under Review-7
20220330 Under Review-8
20220401 Under Review-9
20220404 Under Review-10
20220407 Under Review-11
20220413 Revise
20220504 With Editor
20220504 Under Review
20220506 Required Reviews Completed
20220506 Accept
20220511 Available online

Thank you Xu Song, DPhil for your dedication and effort. Wishing the journal continued success.

never reject 2022-05-12

After submitting to the final step, click "Generate PDF". Then, please indicate your publishing options. Click "Publishing Options". There is only "Publish as a subscription article" available, but it cannot be selected. The option below, "Close", is freely selectable, but it cannot proceed to the next step. It seems to be stuck in a loop. Can anyone please help urgently?

刻晴老公 2022-04-12

Agreed. Nowadays, using OA (Online Application) is basically a trend, and I don't think there is much to criticize about it since the acceptance rate is objectively determined. Besides, after all, the submission fee is not paid by ourselves. If the boss has a problem with a few thousand dollars, it's better to criticize the boss by dissing them.

ysulxi 2022-04-11

Posted on December 22, 2021;
Repaired and reviewed on March 20, 2022 (repaired twice, minor repairs);
Hired on April 8, 2022.

科研小虫666 2022-03-06

There are many criticisms in the comments about this journal. Don't look down on it just because it is open-source, and don't judge it based on its low acceptance rate. Don't say grapes are sour just because you can't taste them. This year, the expected impact factor is 8.9, surpassing Acta Materialia's estimated 8.3. It's just a matter of time before it happens.

我就看个评论 2021-12-23

Five months, two major repairs, and finally rejected, the dust finally settles.

阿浩的小跟班 2021-12-21

2021.10.2 submitted to j - Submitted to journal on October 2, 2021.
2021.10.3 with editor - Under review by the editor on October 3, 2021.
2021.10.5 under review - Under review by reviewers on October 5, 2021.
2021.10.29 revised - Revised on October 29, 2021.
2021.11.18 resubmitted - Resubmitted on November 18, 2021.
2021.11.18 with editor/under review - Under review by the editor and reviewers on November 18, 2021.
2021.12.04 accept - Accepted on December 4, 2021.

一审两个审稿人20条意见，补了实验，句句中肯，提高了文章水平！！！ - First review with 20 comments from two reviewers, conducted additional experiments, every comment was pertinent, improved the quality of the paper!!!

另外本期刊在贵网站有个同名旧ISSN:0261-3069,望及时删除，以免误导作者！！！ - Furthermore, this journal has an old ISSN: 0261-3069 on your website. Please remove it promptly to avoid misleading authors!!!

carpenter 2021-12-20

Although the impact factor is not high, only 7.991, the 2020/2021 upgraded version of the Chinese Academy of Sciences is in the top tier of materials science.
==
There are many editorial requirements, such as graphic abstract, highlights, and cited references.
Submitted on July 28, 2021.
With editor on August 2, 2021.
Under review on August 5, 2021 (this status has changed 8 times).
Required reviews completed on October 9, 2021.
Revision requested on October 15, 2021 (4 reviewers and 1 editor provided revision suggestions).
Revision 1 submitted with editor on November 19, 2021.
With editor on November 19, 2021.
Under review on November 21, 2021.
Required reviews completed on November 25, 2021.
Minor revision on November 30, 2021.
Revision 2 submitted with editor on November 30, 2021.
With editor on December 4, 2021.
Accepted on December 6, 2021.

Angela＆Yoga 2021-12-15

Similarly, the second trial has been reviewed for a month, and the status has changed three times.

朴小嘻嘻 2021-12-13

It has been over a month since now, and I am still in the submission status. I don't know the reason. Does anyone know?

我就看个评论 2021-11-29

The date for "under review" has been changed twice, and there are still no results...

丘大猫 2021-11-27

Is this how you respond when you get rejected?

yuanyuan@ 2021-11-26

November 8th submitted,
November 9th with editor,
November 10th under review,
November 22nd under review changed to a different date,
November 25th still under review but date changed again.
I want to ask, what does it mean when "under review" keeps changing during the submission process? I am waiting anxiously as I need it for job hunting after graduation.

溺 2021-11-02

Yesterday I submitted, today it was rejected. The speed was quite fast. I wish your DY would be warned soon.