吃鱼 2023-03-10

Hello, congratulations on the acceptance! I would like to ask how long does it usually take for the "under review" process? It has been twelve days and the current status is "with editor". I am not sure if they are still looking for reviewers or if the editor has not reviewed it yet.

小卢，我想吃鱼了 2023-03-10

3.7 reception, the speed of the first review is very slow, contacting the editor said they had been searching for a reviewer for a long time.

小卢，我想吃鱼了 2023-03-10

2022.04.07 Submission
2022.11.24 First revision, to be submitted one week later
2023.01.11 Second revision, to be submitted one week later
2023.03.23 Accepted

吃鱼 2023-03-09

2023.02.27 Submission
2023.02.28 Status changed to "with editor"
2023.03.01 The status date changed once, but it is still "with editor"
2023.03.09 Still "with editor"
Is this speed normal? Is there hope for external review?

Translation:

Is this speed normal? Is there a chance for external review?

a cat 2023-03-07

May I ask where can I find the comments from the external reviewer? I have also been rejected, but I don't know where to find the comments from the external reviewer.

爱祖国 2023-03-01

10-21 submitted to journal
10-25 with editor
10-27 with editor
11-24 under review
12-30 major revise
23-2-1 under review

Translation:
10-21: Submitted to journal
10-25: With editor
10-27: With editor
11-24: Under review
12-30: Major revision
23-2-1: Under review

佛系小赵 2023-01-31

2023.1.31 Required Reviews Completed

爱祖国 2023-01-23

Okay, thank you.

佛系小赵 2023-01-16

2023.1.14 under review

chenhao112 2023-01-13

Two reviewers, have been rejected.

冬阳1109 2023-01-11

When submitting to this journal, there is no need to choose whether it is open access. It can be selected after acceptance.

xiaiphu 2023-01-08

8.17 Submission
12.28 Rejection
Submission for four months, two reviewers, rejection.

佛系小赵 2023-01-01

12.26 submit - This means that something needs to be submitted on December 26th.
12.29 with editor - This means that something will be reviewed or worked on by an editor on December 29th.

梦途mtu 2022-12-28

In March, make the investment; in September, undergo a two-month major overhaul; in December, receive.

爱祖国 2022-12-16

under review

chenhao112 2022-12-16

Has it been reviewed?

爱祖国 2022-11-23

Still with editor

chenhao112 2022-11-23

11-19 submitted to journal
11-19 with editor
11-23 with editor
12-09 under review
01-13 reject

Translation:
11-19 submitted to journal
11-19 with editor
11-23 with editor
12-09 under review
01-13 reject

chenhao112 2022-11-23

Are you still with the editor?

爱祖国 2022-11-07

The text "10-21 submitted to journal" means that something was submitted to a journal on October 21st.

The text "10-25 with editor" means that something is currently with the editor as of October 25th.

The text "10-27 with editor" means that something is still with the editor as of October 27th.

谜的果 2022-10-27

08-05 submitted to journal - This means that the document or article was sent to a journal for consideration or publication on August 5th.

08-06 with editor - On August 6th, the document or article was being reviewed or examined by an editor.

08-10 under review - Starting from August 10th, the document or article was being assessed or evaluated by reviewers.

09-16 major revision - On September 16th, it was determined that significant changes or modifications needed to be made to the document or article.

10-24 revised to journal - On October 24th, the revised version of the document or article was resubmitted to the journal.

10-26 accept - On October 26th, it was confirmed that the document or article was approved or accepted for publication.

MuTuDu 2022-10-25

05-28 ~ 05-29: Submitted to Journal (1 day)
05-29 ~ 06-09: With Editor (11 days)
06-09 ~ 07-18: Under Review (39 days)
07-18 ~ 09-14: Major Revision (58 days)
09-14 ~ 09-15: With Editor (1 day)
Accept
Total Time: 110 days

Faerie1 2022-10-24

Could I ask the original poster how long it took to find a reviewer after "under review"? It has been two months since submission without anyone accepting the review. Should a reminder email be sent to request the review?

爱祖国 2022-10-21

Excuse me, the original poster, is it normal for this journal to not specify the publishing method as open access or subscription when submitting articles?

冬瓜排骨 2022-09-13

2021.9.16 submitted to the journal - Submitted to the journal on September 16th, 2021.
2021.11.10 major revision - Major revision made on November 10th, 2021.
2022.1.21 accepted - Accepted on January 21st, 2022.

冬阳1109 2022-07-30

22-03-19 Posting;
22-05-04 Major renovation;
22-07-24 Submitting revised edition;
22-07-25 Receiving.

柚子123 2022-07-17

Research on flood risk of disasters.

Submitted in late November 2021, accepted in mid-July 2022, and stayed with the editor for more than four months. There were four reminders sent back and forth, but it didn't make much difference. The overall speed is still normal.

Snail 2022-06-19

Submitted on June 10th, 2022, rejected on June 16th, 2022, a total of 10 days, the rejection was relatively fast.

The research direction is seismic resistance in lifeline engineering and water supply systems.

The rejection feedback received stated that the proposed framework method did not provide new advancements or indirectly contribute, in other words, it lacked innovation. Hopefully, next time it will be accepted.

柚子123 2022-06-18

The longest stage since November 2021 in the submission process has been "with editor," which has already lasted for over 4 months combined, which is quite slow.

梦途mtu 2022-05-30

How are you, my friend? I have been under review for over two months.