4.2 Editorial Material

Can dissonance engineering improve risk analysis of human-machine systems?

期刊

COGNITION TECHNOLOGY & WORK
卷 19, 期 1, 页码 1-12

出版社

SPRINGER LONDON LTD
DOI: 10.1007/s10111-017-0405-7

关键词

Dissonance engineering; Risk analysis; Conflict evaluation; Behavioural conflict; Knowledge evolution

资金

  1. International Research Group on Human-Machine Systems in Transportation and Industry

向作者/读者索取更多资源

The paper discusses dissonance engineering and its application to risk analysis of human-machine systems. Dissonance engineering relates to sciences and technologies relevant to dissonances, defined as conflicts between knowledge. The richness of the concept of dissonance is illustrated by a taxonomy that covers a variety of cognitive and organisational dissonances based on different conflict modes and baselines of their analysis. Knowledge control is discussed and related to strategies for accepting or rejecting dissonances. This acceptability process can be justified by a risk analysis of dissonances which takes into account their positive and negative impacts and several assessment criteria. A risk analysis method is presented and discussed along with practical examples of application. The paper then provides key points to motivate the development of risk analysis methods dedicated to dissonances in order to identify the balance between the positive and negative impacts and to improve the design and use of future human-machine system by reinforcing knowledge.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.2
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Engineering, Civil

Predicting Compliance with Speed Limits using Speed Limit Credibility Perception and Risk Perception Data

Yao Yao, Oliver Carsten, Daryl Hibberd

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD (2020)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Transitions Between Highly Automated and Longitudinally Assisted Driving: The Role of the Initiator in the Fight for Authority

Davide Maggi, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten

Summary: Drivers' behaviors during transitions between highly automated driving and longitudinally assisted driving depend on their initial role, with initiating drivers being more engaged in the driving task. Handover strategies that retain a larger authority share are more effective when the automation initiates the transition.

HUMAN FACTORS (2022)

Article Transportation

Impact of lane keeping assist system camera misalignment on driver behavior

Richard Romano, Davide Maggi, Toshiya Hirose, Zara Broadhead, Oliver Carsten

JOURNAL OF INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS (2020)

Article Engineering, Industrial

User-centred design evaluation of symbols for adaptive cruise control (ACC) and lane-keeping assistance (LKA)

Mickael Jean Remy Perrier, Tyron Linton Louw, Oliver Carsten

Summary: Advanced driving assistance systems (ADAS) encompass various systems relieving drivers of different aspects of control responsibility. Standard symbols for ACC and LKA may not be the most suitable, especially when compared to manufacturer-specific symbols. Drivers without prior knowledge of ADAS have difficulties interpreting symbols, particularly in the realm of lane-keeping assistance and lane centring control.

COGNITION TECHNOLOGY & WORK (2021)

Review Orthopedics

Doctor when can I drive? Braking response after knee arthroplasty: A systematic review & meta-analysis of brake reaction time

Vasileios Giannoudis, Stephen Guy, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten, Hemant Pandit, Bernard van Duren

Summary: Limited evidence is available on the return to driving for patients undergoing knee arthroplasty (KA), with studies showing no significant difference in total brake reaction time up to 3 months postoperatively, while reaction time improved significantly. In contrast, movement time significantly decreased post KA and may represent a more reliable measure of braking performance. Surgeons should consider these findings and patient factors when advising on safe return to driving.
Article Transportation

Evaluating the effectiveness of a smartphone speed limit advisory application: An on-road study in Port-Harcourt, Nigeria

Anderson Etika, Natasha Merat, Oliver Carsten

Summary: The study found that the use of the ISA application significantly improved compliance with speed limits, especially in the 60 km/h and 80 km/h zones. No negative effects on driver speeding behavior were observed from the use of the system.

IATSS RESEARCH (2021)

Article Psychology, Applied

Handing control back to drivers: Exploring the effects of handover procedure during transitions from Highly Automated Driving

Davide Maggi, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten

Summary: Lane Keeping Assist can help drivers keep the vehicle in the center of the lane when control is handed back to them. However, assistance at an operational level does not improve their ability to handle more complex tasks. Task-specific assistance, such as Blind-spot assist, is more effective for tackling tactical decisions.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART F-TRAFFIC PSYCHOLOGY AND BEHAVIOUR (2022)

Article Ergonomics

The effect of inconsistent steering guidance during transitions from Highly Automated Driving

Davide Maggi, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten

Summary: The study found that drivers' steering engagement is more influenced by the transition initiation rather than the quality of guidance. In user-initiated transitions, drivers exert stronger steering inputs, allowing them to maintain larger TTLC values with fewer corrections.

ACCIDENT ANALYSIS AND PREVENTION (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

When terminology hinders research: the colloquialisms of transitions of control in automated driving

Davide Maggi, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten, Joost C. F. De Winter

Summary: Technological advancement and economic interests have fueled research on automated driving and its impact on drivers' behavior. However, imprecise and colloquial use of terms has created confusion. This survey aims to compare different taxonomies and standardize the use of terms to enhance future research.

COGNITION TECHNOLOGY & WORK (2022)

Correction Engineering, Industrial

When terminology hinders research: the colloquialisms of transitions of control in automated driving (Jun, 10.1007/s10111-022-00705-3, 2022)

Davide Maggi, Richard Romano, Oliver Carsten, Joost C. F. De Winter

COGNITION TECHNOLOGY & WORK (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Usability testing of three visual HMIs for assisted driving: How design impacts driver distraction and mental models

Mickael J. R. Perrier, Tyron L. Louw, Oliver M. J. Carsten

Summary: This study used a user-centered design approach to compare the usability of three different HMI designs for ACC systems. The results provided design recommendations for indicating set target speed, set time gap between vehicles, and system mode in a more efficient way.

ERGONOMICS (2023)

Review Economics

Implications of automated vehicles for physical road environment: A comprehensive review

Oguz Tengilimoglu, Oliver Carsten, Zia Wadud

Summary: Automated vehicles (AVs) have attracted significant attention in recent years, posing new challenges and opportunities for transportation networks and built environments. Understanding the impact of AVs on road infrastructure is crucial for assessing network readiness and planning for future roads. This paper conducts a comprehensive literature review to investigate the implications of AVs for road infrastructure, identifying thirteen key topics that need consideration during deployment or transition to full automation. The paper discusses potential changes and challenges and provides recommendations for future research directions to ensure safe and efficient operation.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART E-LOGISTICS AND TRANSPORTATION REVIEW (2023)

Article Economics

Infrastructure requirements for the safe operation of automated vehicles: Opinions from experts and stakeholders

Oguz Tengilimoglu, Oliver Carsten, Zia Wadud

Summary: The need to future-proof road transport networks for the safe operation of automated vehicles (AVs) is urgent, but limited literature exists on the infrastructure requirements of AVs. This study surveyed experts and stakeholders from 29 countries to understand the necessary road infrastructure elements for Level 4 automated driving. The findings suggest that stakeholders have similar views on early considerations for implementing AVs, but differing opinions exist regarding constraints on road networks.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Infrastructure-related challenges in implementing connected and automated vehicles on urban roads: Insights from experts and stakeholders

Oguz Tengilimoglu, Oliver Carsten, Zia Wadud

Summary: The introduction of connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) has the potential to bring numerous advantages to urban mobility, but there are many challenges for road infrastructure that need to be overcome. This study conducted a comprehensive survey with 168 experts from different sectors and regions around the world to address the implications of CAV deployment for road infrastructure. The research shows that there is still no consensus among stakeholders on maximizing CAV benefits, indicating the necessity for cooperation to ensure safe and efficient operation. Overall, this study provides valuable insights for decision-makers and transport planners to shape policies and guidelines for the future implementation of CAVs on roads before commercialization.

IET INTELLIGENT TRANSPORT SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Psychology, Applied

Do drivers differ in their attitudes on speed limit compliance between work and private settings? Results from a group of Nigerian drivers

Anderson A. Etika, Natasha Merat, Oliver Carsten

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART F-TRAFFIC PSYCHOLOGY AND BEHAVIOUR (2020)

暂无数据