4.4 Article

Constructive Alignment of Interdisciplinary Graduate Curriculum in Engineering and Science: An Analysis of Successful IGERT Proposals

期刊

JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING EDUCATION
卷 99, 期 4, 页码 355-369

出版社

AMER SOC ENGINEERING EDUCATION
DOI: 10.1002/j.2168-9830.2010.tb01068.x

关键词

curriculum design; graduate education; interdisciplinary

资金

  1. U.S. National Science Foundation [EEC-0643107]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

BACKGROUND Interdisciplinary approaches are critical to solving the most pressing technological challenges. Despite the proliferation of graduate programs to fill this need, there is little archival literature identifying learning outcomes, learning experiences, or benchmarks for evaluating interdisciplinary graduate student learning. PURPOSE (HYPOTHESIS) The purpose of this study is to understand how engineering and science academics conceptualize interdisciplinary graduate education in order to identify common practices and recommend improvements. Questions generated by an instructional design framework guided the analysis: what desired outcomes, evidence, and learning experiences are currently associated with interdisciplinary graduate education? To what extent are these components constructively aligned with each other? DESIGN/METHOD Content analysis was performed on 130 funded proposals from the U. S. National Science Foundation's Integrative Graduate Education and Research Traineeship (IGERT) program. RESULTS Four desired student learning outcomes were identified: contributions to the technical area, broad perspective, teamwork, and interdisciplinary communication skills. Student requirements (educational plans) addressed these outcomes to some extent, but assessment/evidence sections generally targeted program level goals-as opposed to student learning. This lack of constructive alignment between components is a major weakness of graduate curriculum. CONCLUSIONS Current practices are promising. Further clarification of interdisciplinary learning outcomes, coupled with closer alignment of outcomes, evidence, and learning experiences will continue to improve interdisciplinary graduate education in engineering and science. Specific recommendations for engineering and science faculty members are: define clear learning objectives, enlist assessment/evaluation expertise, and constructively align all aspects of the curriculum.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.4
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Education & Educational Research

Systematic Literature Reviews in Engineering Education and Other Developing Interdisciplinary Fields

Maura Borrego, Margaret J. Foster, Jeffrey E. Froyd

JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING EDUCATION (2014)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Professional Aspects of Engineering: Improving Prediction of Undergraduates' Engineering Identity

Nathan H. Choe, Luis L. Martins, Maura Borrego, Meagan R. Kendall

JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ISSUES IN ENGINEERING EDUCATION AND PRACTICE (2019)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Factors Influencing Engineering Identity Development of Latinx Students

Meagan R. Kendall, Maya Denton, Nathan Hyungsok Choe, Luis M. Procter, Maura Borrego

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EDUCATION (2019)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Prediction of Engineering Identity in Engineering Graduate Students

Nathan Hyungsok Choe, Maura Borrego

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EDUCATION (2019)

Review Education & Educational Research

Community cultural wealth in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education: A systematic review

Maya Denton, Maura Borrego, Audrey Boklage

JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING EDUCATION (2020)

Article Education & Educational Research

Engineering students' attitudinal beliefs by gender and student division: a methodological comparison of changes over time

Madison E. Andrews, Anita D. Patrick, Maura Borrego

Summary: The study highlighted discrepancies between cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses of the same dataset. Cross-sectional analyses showed significant differences in engineering utility value and interest by student division, but no significant gender differences for any variable. Longitudinal analyses revealed significant decreases in engineering utility value, self-efficacy, and interest for lower division students, as well as a decrease in engineering attainment value for upper division students over a one-year period. Moreover, there was a gender gap in engineering self-efficacy for upper division students, with men reporting higher means than women.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STEM EDUCATION (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

STEM doctoral students' skill development: does funding mechanism matter?

Dustin Grote, Anita Patrick, Chelsea Lyles, David Knight, Maura Borrego, Abdulrahman Alsharif

Summary: The research found significant differences in the development of career-relevant skills among STEM doctoral students in the U.S., with students funded through research assistantships performing better in research and teamwork skills, while those with teaching assistantships excelling in peer training and mentoring skills. Students supported by external fellowships showed lower skill development in all four career-relevant skills compared to those primarily funded by research assistantships.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STEM EDUCATION (2021)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

LGBTQ plus in ECE: Culture and (Non)Visibility

Jerry A. Yang, Max K. Sherard, Christine Julien, Maura Borrego

Summary: This study confirms the continued marginalization of undergraduate LGBTQ+ electrical and computer engineering students in the engineering field, facing noninclusive environments and marginalizing experiences due to their intersectional identities, leading to lower sense of belonging and greater mental stress.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EDUCATION (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

US postdoctoral careers in life sciences, physical sciences and engineering: Government, industry, and academia

Maya Denton, Maura Borrego, David B. Knight

Summary: This article examines the employment implications for postdoctoral researchers in the fields of physical sciences and engineering, as well as life sciences. It finds that there is considerable movement between employment sectors within the first six years post-PhD, with postdocs in physical sciences and engineering having shorter durations, higher salaries, and more nonacademic sector positions.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

The fallacy of there are no candidates: Institutional pathways of Black/African American and Hispanic/Latino doctorate earners

Gabriella Coloyan Fleming, Anita D. Patrick, Dustin Grote, Maya Denton, David Knight, Walter Lee, Maura Borrego, Homero Murzi

Summary: This study focuses on the academic pathways of Black/African American and Hispanic/Latino engineering PhD graduates and finds that the majority of them did not graduate from top-tier institutions. Instead, they earned their degrees from non-top-tier, non-US, and minority-serving institutions. The results also indicate that recruiting students and faculty solely from a few top-tier institutions is unlikely to increase diversity among racially minoritized individuals in engineering.

JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The relations between students' belongingness, self-efficacy, and response to active learning in science, math, and engineering classes

Matthew C. C. Graham, Katie Jacobson, Jenefer Husman, Michael Prince, Cynthia Finelli, Madison E. E. Andrews, Maura Borrego

Summary: This study surveyed 579 students from 25 Science, Engineering, and Computer Science courses across 14 universities to examine the influence of students' belongingness and self-efficacy on their response to active learning, as well as the moderating effect of gender identity. The findings showed that belongingness and self-efficacy independently predicted students' affective and behavioral response to active learning. Additionally, belongingness predicted students' behavioral participation in active learning. Furthermore, despite differences in value, positivity, and distraction, gender did not affect the strength of relations between variables.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENCE EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Capacity Building Workshop for Two-Year Colleges Seeking U.S. National Science Foundation Funding

Marialice Mastronardi, David R. Brown, Maura Borrego, John Krupzak

Summary: In this paper, the authors describe and evaluate an annual workshop that aims to facilitate submissions to the NSF S-STEM program from 2-year colleges. The workshop received positive feedback and resulted in an increased success rate for funded proposals. The paper discusses specific challenges faced by 2-year college teams and presents suggestions for better support.

COMMUNITY COLLEGE JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

STEM doctoral student agency regarding funding

Maura Borrego, Nathan Hyungsok Choe, Kevin Nguyen, David B. Knight

Summary: The study found that funding instability and unavailability of desired funding types can limit some STEM doctoral students' agency. Advisors can encourage students to pursue opportunities to gain skills or networking connections through different types of funding. Students were unable to articulate specific ways that assistantships prepared them for nonacademic positions, pointing to a direction for future research.

STUDIES IN HIGHER EDUCATION (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

A Competitive System: Graduate Student Recruitment in STEM and Why Money May Not be the Answer

Whitney E. Wall Bortz, David B. Knight, Chelsea H. Lyles, Timothy Kinoshita, Nathan H. Choe, Maya Denton, Maura Borrego

JOURNAL OF HIGHER EDUCATION (2020)

Article Education & Educational Research

Understanding retention in US graduate programs by student nationality

Erin Crede, Maura Borrego

STUDIES IN HIGHER EDUCATION (2014)

暂无数据