xxxsssJH 2023-08-07

Brother, will AE and EIC be displayed in the middle?

kathiy 2023-08-06

Excuse me, is there a result now?

kathiy 2023-07-29

Capitalized Under Review

kathiy 2023-07-29

The text translates to: "Submitted two weeks ago, the current status is Under Review. When can I generally expect to receive the review comments?"

xxxsssJH 2023-07-25

It feels careless to only display the name ADM under review. I thought at least the names AE and EIC would be shown, indicating that it has been sent for external review.

reznov 2023-07-25

This journal only has "under review" and "decision" statuses, and all other states in between will not change.

xxxsssJH 2023-07-25

Brother, is there a process for reviewing manuscripts with "Under Review" and results? When I just submitted, only the name "ADM" was displayed. Will it later show AE/EIC?

xxxsssJH 2023-07-21

Brother, I want to ask, does this publication's submission system have no intermediate status? Does it go directly from "Under Review" to the final result?

reznov 2023-07-21

It should be the main file uploaded without annotations, and then upload another file with annotations.

hxw 2023-07-20

Hello, I would like to ask, the system requires that the submitted text not be highlighted or colored. Is it really not allowed to mark it?

lynnre 2023-07-15

Learned a lot from the forum, and today my paper was accepted. I am here to give back:

2022-12-01: Submitted manuscript
2023-03-07: Received major revision
2023-04-06: Submitted revision
2023-05-29: Received minor revision
2023-06-07: Submitted revision
2023-07-14: Accepted

BruceQian 2023-07-14

Mar-2022 Submit - Submit in March 2022
Dec-2022 Revise and Resubmit as New - Revise and resubmit as new in December 2022
Apr-2023 Resubmit - Resubmit in April 2023
至今 Under Review - Under review until now

My review speed has been a bit slow...

reznov 2023-07-12

Is there any news on the older brother's reapplication? For my reapplication, there should only be one reviewer left with comments, but the review time is longer than the second review. Can I add you as a friend to chat?

reznov 2023-05-30

No change of personnel, he said you have resolved my doubts but I still have some questions, blabla. Overall, it gives a confusing feeling.

lotya 2023-05-29

Why does it feel like you've changed the third reviewer... This translation is so amateurish if you ask me.

qqxyf 2023-05-29

Shouldn't the status of TMM审稿 be "In Peer Review"? Not "Under review", right?

qqxyf 2023-05-29

May I ask: After you send a reminder email, ADM said that the opinions have all returned, and we are waiting for the editor's decision. At this time, is the system status in peer review or awaiting AE decision?

靶心 2023-05-24

Why does it feel like this review is so confusing? Both the AE and the reviewer are quite confusing.

reznov 2023-05-23

Update: The second review will take one month.
The first expert in the field has agreed to undertake major revisions.
The second novice in the field has rejected the manuscript and suggested minor revisions.
The third novice (the one who raised 20 formatting issues in the first review) has raised a few new questions, reducing the number of issues from 20 to 3, with two of them being previously raised by someone else in the first review. However, the major revisions have been rejected, which is quite interesting.
The editor has asked for revised modifications to be resubmitted.

lotya 2023-05-19

Update, will return after major repairs in mid-March. In mid-May, I sent an email to ask about the status again (I am so brave to urge for the manuscript in just two months). ADM said that all the feedback has been received and they are waiting for the editor's decision. The second review is quite fast. Last time, the results were sent out within eleven to twelve days after I urged. It should be fast this time too.

靶心 2023-05-15

I'm not sure, this journal only shows "under review." It has been almost four months since I revised and resubmitted, but I haven't received any updates.

vawjyi 2023-05-15

I am really speechless. It has been almost a year, I sent an email to ask the admin, and the admin forwarded it to the AE. The AE replied that one of the three reviewers has disappeared, but considering that the opinions given by the other two reviewers were not good either, if you want to withdraw the manuscript now, you can go ahead and withdraw it. I am so frustrated. Why didn't you just reject it directly? Withdraw this damn manuscript. Let's see if I will complain about you to the end. Stupid journal and stupid AE.

reznov 2023-05-13

@靶心: Brother, may I ask if modifying and resubmitting the paper will assign it to a new reviewer?

reznov 2023-05-06

Do any seniors know how long the second review process for this publication takes? Is the probability of major revisions being rejected high?

hxw 2023-04-28

Some articles with a 23-year term are published online and have a DOI in 2021. It is estimated that there are too many articles, sigh.

vawjyi 2023-04-26

Update, it has been 11 months already, and it is still under review. I have followed up twice in the meantime, but it seems to be of no use. It looks like I will have to wait until they call me grandchild and send me the review comments.

hxw 2023-04-07

The text "under review" is displayed above with the names of the ADM and executive editor. I would like to ask how long it takes to receive a result saying "revise and resubmit"?

靶心 2023-04-06

I am revise and resubmit, just a little bit away from rejection...

reznov 2023-04-04

Brother, may I ask if you are resubmitting after rejection or doing a major revision?

靶心 2023-03-31

Do you actually have the authority to execute edits? When I return for repairs and resubmissions in January, I only have "Under Review" (with capital letters).