4.7 Article

Domestic politics and the diffusion of international policy innovations: How does accommodation happen?

出版社

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2014.04.001

关键词

Clean air policy; Domestic accommodation; Nitrogen oxide emissions; Policy change; Policy diffusion; Policy innovations

资金

  1. EU-funded collaborative research project CONSENSUS [217239]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

What happens to policy innovations after they have been adopted? What factors account for subsequent changes to these policies? These are the research questions guiding this study on the spread of and subsequent changes to limit values for nitrogen oxide emissions from large combustion plants. By comparing the processes of diffusion and follow-up policy changes, we assess whether and how policy innovations translate into policy making. In so doing, we build on the literature on the determinants of policy diffusion and transfer. We employ original data on instances of policy adoption and policy change in 24 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries over a period of thirty years (1976-2005). The data are analysed using semi-parametric event-history models. Our empirical findings show that both international and domestic factors account for the observed variation in our data regarding both first-time adoptions and post-adoption modifications. The results reveal that the subsequent tightening of emission standards faces greater obstacles than their mere diffusion (i.e., policy adoption). While international factors and supranational integration appear to impede the subsequent tightening of existing policies, international peer pressure is a strong predictor of an on-going regulatory commitment. Overall, adoption and accommodation processes seem to follow distinctive patterns, suggesting that a promising strategy in policy innovation research would involve differentiation between the first-time adoption and subsequent modification of policies. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Attaining policy integration through the integration of new policy instruments: The case of the Farm to Fork Strategy

Giulia Bazzan, Carsten Daugbjerg, Jale Tosun

Summary: This article argues that the challenge of implementing the Farm to Fork Strategy lies in achieving cross-sectoral policy integration. While the EU has successfully integrated policies in the environmental sector, the scope of the F2F extends beyond that, requiring the integration of climate-related concerns into sectoral policies. Therefore, an innovative approach to policymaking is necessary.

APPLIED ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES AND POLICY (2023)

Article Political Science

The Significance of Leadership in the Evolution of Policy Styles: Reconciling Policy-Making in the Short and Long Term

Jale Tosun, Maria Tullia Galanti, Michael Howlett

Summary: Can relatively short-term political leadership affect long-term national policy styles, and if so, how? We examine these questions in order to explain the temporal dynamics in national policy styles observed in several recent studies whose findings have challenged the traditional view that policy styles lend continuity and stability to policy-making. In its original formulation, the concept of policy styles refers to the extent to which governments are committed to anticipatory or reactive policy-making, as well as to whether they seek to reach consensus with societal groups over policies or simply impose decisions on them. Following these definitions, we contend that political leaders can alter a long-held policy style and often do so due to strategic considerations, either in an attempt to improve their policy performance or in response to an exogenous shock, such as an economic crisis. We illustrate this argument by using longitudinal records of changes in country-level governance indicators which include data on dimensions of policy styles. Specifically we examine how two of the Sustainable Governance Indicators compiled by the Bertelsmann Foundation changed for Ireland, Italy, Malta, and Poland between 2014 and 2020. As the cases show, government leaders sought to alter long-standing processes and the arrangements of governance and policy-making. Our empirical findings support the overarching argument that the study of national policy styles should be combined with that of political leadership.

POLITISCHE VIERTELJAHRESSCHRIFT (2022)

Article Social Sciences, Interdisciplinary

Determinants of Job-Finding Intentions Among Young Adults from 11 European Countries

Francisco Simoes, Jale Tosun, Antonella Rocca

Summary: This study investigates the impact of individual, parental, and social factors on young adults' job-finding intentions. The findings show that individual factors are the most decisive, while social factors and country-level factors also play a role. The study reflects on the importance of education as a means of improving professional aspirations and providing adequate services to help young people through the school-to-work transition.

SOCIAL INDICATORS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Who takes the lead? A disaggregate analysis of the EU's engagement in the Clean Energy Ministerial and Mission Innovation

Jale Tosun, Christin Heinz-Fischer, Rui Luo

Summary: Global cooperation is needed among major emitting economies to achieve net-zero carbon dioxide emissions. The study focuses on the EU Commission's leadership in the Clean Energy Ministerial (CEM) and Mission Innovation (MI) initiatives. The EU Commission has shown greater leadership in MI compared to the CEM, surpassing even the United States. Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, the Netherlands, and Denmark stand out as particularly active in these initiatives.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Public Administration

Presidents and intermediaries: insights from clean energy policy processes in Mexico

Israel Solorio, Jale Tosun

Summary: This study aims to assess whether different presidents have different styles of involving intermediaries in the policy process and found that the different presidents had different policy styles and therefore varied in how they included climate intermediaries. This finding has important implications for research on policy styles as well as climate intermediation.

POLICY STUDIES (2023)

Article Political Science

The enactment of public participation in rulemaking: A comparative analysis

Fabrizio De Francesco, Jale Tosun

Summary: This study analyzes the implementation of public participation in rulemaking in the European Union and the Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development countries. It finds that countries with a highly independent judiciary are less likely to enact comprehensive provisions for public participation, highlighting a paradox.

SWISS POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW (2023)

Article Social Issues

Adapted to Climate Change? Issue Portfolios of Environmental Nongovernmental Organizations in the Americas

Jale Tosun, Emiliano Levario Saad

Summary: This study used an original dataset of 293 ENGOs to explore the extent to which they tackle climate change issues and the factors influencing this variation. It was found that generalist ENGOs are more likely to prioritize and address climate change issues. Additionally, the specific issue areas and alignment with climate action of specialist ENGOs explain the differences among ENGOs in different countries.

NONPROFIT AND VOLUNTARY SECTOR QUARTERLY (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Reducing pesticides without organic certification? Potentials and limits of an intermediate form of agricultural production

Marcus A. Koch, Jale Tosun, Laura Kellermann, Charlene Marek, Markus Kiefer, Mike Thiv

Summary: A growing number of farmers' cooperatives cultivate crops without chemical pesticides, but also without organic certification. This intermediate form of agriculture between conventional and organic production can contribute to a successful transition towards more sustainable agricultural systems. The research findings from the AgroBioDiv project on the farmers' cooperative KraichgauKorn in Germany suggest that while the biodiversity on KGK cereal fields is higher than conventional fields, it is lower than organic fields. This model also shows a higher presence of endangered wild species on KGK fields compared to conventional fields.

COGENT FOOD & AGRICULTURE (2023)

Article Political Science

Europeans' Attitudes Toward the Goals of Agricultural Policy: A Case of Rural-Urban Divide?

Jale Tosun, Simon Schaub, Charlene Marek

Summary: Is there a rural-urban divide in citizens' views on European Union agricultural policy? We analyze data from a Special Eurobarometer survey and find that the place of residence significantly predicts attitudes towards agricultural policy. Rural populations are less likely to prioritize environmental and climate action, and sustainable food production, but prioritize rural job growth and fair living standards for farmers. This rural-urban divide highlights the need for policymakers to address differing perspectives.

POLITICAL STUDIES REVIEW (2023)

Article Public Administration

European climate pact citizen volunteers: strategies for deepening engagement and impact

Jale Tosun, Jan Pollex, Laurence Crumbie

Summary: The European Climate Pact is part of the European Green Deal, aiming to achieve climate neutrality in the EU by 2050. It is a volunteer-based initiative that appoints European Climate Pact Ambassadors to inform and inspire their communities about climate change. Each ambassador has a dedicated webpage hosted by the EU Commission, allowing for personalized engagement. This paper offers guidance to non-policy professionals in navigating their ambassadorship and encourages them to personalize their roles and activities within the program's overarching goals and principles.

POLICY DESIGN AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Country-Specific Participation Patterns in Transnational Governance Initiatives on Sustainability: Preliminary Insights and Research Agenda

Jale Tosun, Emiliano Levario Saad, Johannes Gluckler, Alejandra Irigoyen Rios, Rosa Lehmann

Summary: Transnational public-private governance initiatives (TGIs) have become important elements in global governance, especially in the governance of sustainability. Research has focused on why TGIs emerge and their impacts on political outcomes and legitimacy. This study explores the domestic-level patterns of participation in TGIs and national factors that determine the types of organizations involved. The study finds cross-country variation in the composition patterns of 29 sustainability TGIs in Latin American countries, suggesting that national conditions matter for organizational participation in TGIs. By improving knowledge of national conditions, a more comprehensive analysis of participation and effectiveness of TGIs in global sustainability governance can be provided. An agenda for future research on this topic is developed.

GLOBAL CHALLENGES (2023)

Article Economics

The European Union's Climate and Environmental Policy in Times of Geopolitical Crisis

Jale Tosun

JCMS-JOURNAL OF COMMON MARKET STUDIES (2023)

Article Public Administration

Intermediating climate change: conclusions and new research directions

Jale Tosun, Paul Tobin, Fay Madeleine Farstad

Summary: The urgency and threats of climate change have raised the issue's profile in the policy process, leading to increased focus on climate politics and climate change governance. However, the role of intermediating actors in climate politics, known as climate intermediaries, has been largely overlooked in conceptualization and analysis, except for certain contexts. This Special Issue aims to bridge this research gap by analyzing the strategies, interactions, and impacts of these go-betweens in the policy process across three continents. The concluding article summarizes the insights provided by the individual contributions, addresses the research questions guiding the Special Issue, and suggests future research avenues.

POLICY STUDIES (2023)

Article Public Administration

Intermediating climate change: the evolving strategies, interactions and impacts of neglected climate intermediaries

Paul Tobin, Fay Madeleine Farstad, Jale Tosun

Summary: Climate change governance systems involve various actors, including climate intermediaries who connect different actors and levels of governance. This Special Issue explores two under-researched forms of climate intermediaries: those that are unrelated to climate change and new or uncommon forms. In this Introduction, the conceptual framework is presented, existing research on intermediaries is summarized, and an overview of the contributions included in the issue is provided.

POLICY STUDIES (2023)

Article Law

For Young and Future Generations? Insights from the Web Profiles of European Climate Pact Ambassadors

Jale Tosun, Lucas Geese, Irene Lorenzoni

Summary: The study analyzed the web profiles of European Climate Pact Ambassadors (PAs) as of January 2023 to explore their commitment to young and future generations. It found that older generations, parents, and grandparents are more likely to justify their engagement based on the interests of young and future generations. While young people do target other young people as PAs, educators are also more likely to focus on young people as their target audience.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF RISK REGULATION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Private provisioning of public adaptation: Integration of cognitive-behavioral, adaptive capacity, and institutional approaches

Hallie Eakin, Nadine Methner, Gina Ziervogel

Summary: There is a growing need to involve private actors in public adaptation in urban systems. Urban administrators have limited control over urban dynamics, and the actions of private actors have a significant influence. A conceptual framework combining cognitive and behavioral theory, institutional analysis, adaptive capacity, and research on urban adaptation governance is used to understand the potential for private provisioning. The case of Cape Town's response to drought illustrates the complex interactions that shape private actors' willingness to engage in public-oriented adaptation.

GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE-HUMAN AND POLICY DIMENSIONS (2024)