Aromatic amines: mechanisms of carcinogenesis and implications for risk assessment

Carcinogenic aromatic amines are widespread and need to be regulated. Genotoxic and non-genotoxic effects are both necessary for tumor development. The common mode of action includes metabolic activation, the reaction of metabolites with nucleic acids and cellular macromolecules as well as toxic effects. The dose-response relationship of irreversible DNA damage is linear down to background concentrations and a no-effect level (NEL) cannot be defined. The dose-response relationships of reversible toxic effects are often non-linear and have been used to derive no-observed adverse effect levels (NOAEL). However, this procedure does not account for background exposure, the activity of structurally related, and those structurally unrelated chemicals which compete for the same biochemical systems. Fixed limit values for acceptable risk are therefore unacceptably uncertain. The perspective should change from risk to the contribution to risk. The ALARA principle is part of such an approach. It does not say how much exposure is acceptable. Scientific risk assessment and risk management should be kept distinct and the input of scientific data and expert judgement documented.