4.7 Article

Benefits and and limitations of the ecosystem services concept in environmental policy and decision making: Some stakeholder perspectives

期刊

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY
卷 25, 期 -, 页码 13-21

出版社

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2012.08.001

关键词

Ecosystem services; Environmental policy; Valuation; Participation; Stakeholder preferences; Trade-offs and synergies

向作者/读者索取更多资源

The concept of ecosystem services (ES) is increasingly being used in environmental policy and decision making. We report here on the empirical results which emerged from stakeholder discussions within the PRESS (PEER Research on EcoSystem Services) project on certain unresolved challenges related to the use of the ES concept in decision making. The results show that the occurrence of synergies and trade-offs between different ES and their relevance for decision making depends significantly on the scale involved (in particular regarding the levels of policy formulation and policy implementation respectively) and on the specific ways in which ecosystems are managed (e.g. different practices in forestry and agriculture). We conclude that using the concept of ecosystem services, would enable a comprehensive evaluation of policy impacts. Such an evaluation would contribute to an increased congruence between policies by uncovering and discussing trade-offs and realize synergies. Crucial to this, however, is a sound assessment that incorporates the diversity of stakeholder perceptions, knowledge and preferences at the different scales. (C) 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Environmental Sciences

Scrutinizing the Great Acceleration: The Anthropocene and its analytic challenges for social-ecological transformations

Christoph Goerg, Christina Plank, Dominik Wiedenhofer, Andreas Mayer, Melanie Pichler, Anke Schaffartzik, Fridolin Krausmann

ANTHROPOCENE REVIEW (2020)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Agroforestry governance for operationalising the landscape approach: connecting conservation and farming actors

Yves Zinngrebe, Elena Borasino, Brian Chiputwa, Philip Dobie, Edwin Garcia, Anja Gassner, Phillip Kihumuro, Heru Komarudin, Nining Liswanti, Permutia Makui, Tobias Plieninger, Etti Winter, Jennifer Hauck

SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE (2020)

Review Environmental Sciences

Lessons Learnt From Linking Global Recommendations With Localized Marine Restoration Schemes and Policy Options by Using Mixed Methods

Gesche Krause, Christine Wolf, Anne-Kathrin Happe, Jennifer Hauck, Pier Luigi Buttigieg, Nike Fuchs, Jan Scheve, Claudia Koenig, Heidi Wittmer, Kristina Raab

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2020)

Article Ecology

Global socio-economic impacts of changes in natural capital and ecosystem services: State of play and new modeling approaches

Onil Banerjee, Neville Crossman, Renato Vargas, Luke Brander, Peter Verburg, Martin Cicowiez, Jennifer Hauck, Emily McKenzie

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2020)

Article Ecology

Doing more with less: Provisioning systems and the transformation of the stock-flow-service nexus

Christina Plank, Stefan Liehr, Diana Hummel, Dominik Wiedenhofer, Helmut Haberl, Christoph Gorg

Summary: The relationship between stocks, resource flows and services is crucial for social-ecological transformations. Introducing the concept of provisioning systems helps analyze the relationship between resources and actors, understanding the construction and transformation of stock-flow-service nexus. This understanding can help define options for the transformation of the stock-flow-service nexus in a transdisciplinary process.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2021)

Article Ecology

Managing spatial sustainability trade-offs: The case of wind power

Paul Lehmann, Kathrin Ammermann, Erik Gawel, Charlotte Geiger, Jennifer Hauck, Jorg Heilmann, Jan-Niklas Meier, Jens Ponitka, Sven Schicketanz, Boris Stemmer, Philip Tafarte, Daniela Thraen, Elisabeth Wolfram

Summary: The study shows that stakeholders have different opinions on the ranking of sustainability criteria in the spatial allocation of wind power generation capacity, not only in terms of weights, but also in terms of definition and measurement. Concerns about interregional equity are important in allocating generation capacity, but stakeholders have different concepts and approaches towards it.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2021)

Correction History & Philosophy Of Science

Organismic positions in early German-speaking ecology and its (almost) forgotten dissidents (vol 42, 44, 2020)

Kurt Jax

HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF THE LIFE SCIENCES (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Management plans as resources in conservation conflicts

Taru Peltola, Isabelle Arpin, Johanna Leino, Lasse Peltonen, Outi Ratamaki, Pekka Salmi

Summary: This article explores the ability of management plans to address conflicts in conservation planning and management. It discusses how these plans influence planning situations and the conflicts that arise, even if conflict resolution is not their primary goal. By analyzing the effects of four management plans dealing with wildlife and land-use conflicts, the article identifies features that increase the sensitivity of management plans to power imbalances. It suggests that considering power effects is a step towards "uncomfortable planning," which involves including peripheral voices and experiences that are often overlooked and contribute to conflicts. Embracing uncomfortable planning can enhance the efficacy of management plans in contentious conservation planning situations.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY AND GOVERNANCE (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Transformative Change Needs Direction

Sander Jacobs, Fernando Santos-Martin, Eeva Primmer, Fanny Boeraeve, Alejandra Moran-Ordonez, Vania Proenca, Martin Schlaepfer, Lluis Brotons, Robert Dunford, Sandra Lavorel, Antoine Guisan, Joachim Claudet, Zuzana Harmackova, Inge Liekens, Jennifer Hauck, Kasper Kok, Yves Zinngrebe, Simona Pedde, Balint Czucz, Cosimo Solidoro, Matthew Cantele, Christian Rixen, Anna Heck, Jomme Desair, Tobias Plieninger, Paula A. Harrison

Summary: This study compares the impacts of six future scenarios on sustainable development goals and biodiversity targets in Europe and Central Asia. The findings emphasize the importance of transformative change and provide insights into preferred directions for political transformation. The study also highlights the potential to avoid significant societal losses and generate multiple benefits.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Improving governance outcomes for water quality: Insights from participatory social network analysis for chalk stream catchments in England

Jennifer Ball, Jennifer Hauck, Robert A. Holland, Amy Lovegrove, Jake Snaddon, Gail Taylor, Kelvin S-H Peh

Summary: Globally important chalk streams in England are facing poor ecological health due to inadequate water quality. Understanding the governance systems surrounding water quality is crucial in addressing this issue. Through participatory social network analysis, the social networks of River Test and River Itchen in Hampshire, United Kingdom were mapped and analyzed to identify actors and their roles. The results revealed a well-connected network of actors from the state, private sector, and civil society, but decision-making remains centralized. Lack of trust in central state actors and private actors hinders collaboration and coordination. Devolving authority to local actors, building trust in the networks, and improving connections to important actors could enhance governance outcomes for water quality.

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

'Societal Relationships with Nature': A framework for understanding nature-related conflicts and multiple values

Uta Berghoefer, Julian Rode, Kurt Jax, Johannes Foerster, Augustin Berghoefer, Heidi Wittmer

Summary: This paper operationalizes the concept of Societal Relationships with Nature (SRN) as a framework for understanding nature-related conflicts and multiple values. Using case studies, the SRN framework is shown to reveal and structure the complexity of human-nature relationships. Four requirements for analyzing nature-related conflicts and stakeholders' attribution of importance to nature are derived from conceptual advances and academic debates on multiple values of nature. The paper discusses whether and how the SRN framework meets these requirements and presents it to the academic community working at the interface with policy and practice on multiple values of nature and nature-related conflicts.

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Climate policy integration viewed through the stakeholders' eyes: A co-production of knowledge in social-ecological transformation research

Christina Plank, Willi Haas, Anna Schreuer, Jenan Irshaid, Daniel Barben, Christoph Goerg

Summary: The paper examines stakeholder expectations towards Climate Policy Integration (CPI) in Austria's energy and land use sectors, emphasizing obstacles, contested policy integration, the need for alternative visions to economic growth, improved communication with policy-makers, and the central role of reflexive learning for successful CPI. It highlights the importance of inclusive knowledge co-production, while facing challenges in maintaining transformative capacities. There is a call for a shift from a narrow focus on policy-making to consider enabling structural conditions for interaction between a wide variety of stakeholders, aimed at achieving normative climate targets.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY AND GOVERNANCE (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Developing multiscale and integrative nature-people scenarios using the Nature Futures Framework

Laura M. Pereira, Kathryn K. Davies, Eefje den Belder, Simon Ferrier, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen, HyeJin Kim, Jan J. Kuiper, Sana Okayasu, Maria G. Palomo, Henrique M. Pereira, Garry Peterson, Jyothis Sathyapalan, Machteld Schoolenberg, Rob Alkemade, Sonia Carvalho Ribeiro, Alison Greenaway, Jennifer Hauck, Nicholas King, Tanya Lazarova, Federica Ravera, Nakul Chettri, William W. L. Cheung, Rob J. J. Hendriks, Grigoriy Kolomytsev, Paul Leadley, Jean-Paul Metzger, Karachepone N. Ninan, Ramon Pichs, Alexander Popp, Carlo Rondinini, Isabel Rosa, Detlef van Vuuren, Carolyn J. Lundquist

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

The double materiality of democracy in capitalist societies: challenges for social-ecological transformations

Melanie Pichler, Ulrich Brand, Christoph Goerg

ENVIRONMENTAL POLITICS (2020)

Article International Relations

Overcoming neoliberal globalization: social-ecological transformation from a Polanyian perspective and beyond

Ulrich Brand, Christoph Goerg, Markus Wissen

GLOBALIZATIONS (2020)

Article Environmental Sciences

Defining successful climate services for adaptation with experts

Eva Boon, Jurian Vincent Meijering, Robbert Biesbroek, Fulco Ludwig

Summary: This article introduces a global Delphi study, which presents a widely supported definition for successful climate services. The definition emphasizes the importance of user satisfaction and highlights the need for climate service developers to consider climate change uncertainties, build trust and capacity with users, and tailor interactions based on user needs.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Common pool resource governance in strong-government context: A case study of caterpillar fungus (Ophiocordyceps sinensis) on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

Zhiqi Zhang, Xiangyu Jia, Zeren Gongbu, Dingling He, Wenjun Li

Summary: This study conducted research in two villages on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau of China and found that the village with interactive and supportive government involvement achieved better outcomes compared to the village with forceful government intervention. This highlights the importance of congruence between government actions and community demands in developing self-governance institutions for natural resource management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

The role of iconic places, collective efficacy, and negative emotions in climate change communication

Yolanda L. Waters, Kerrie A. Wilson, Angela J. Dean

Summary: This study found that climate messages centered around the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) are more effective in strengthening intentions to adopt energy reduction behaviors. However, they are limited in motivating more impactful civic and social behaviors, including those seeking to influence climate policy support. Messages emphasizing collective efficacy can enhance message effect and influence the uptake of a broader range of behaviors. Emotions related to distress played a significant role in this effect. This research offers an alternative for expanding beyond traditional climate communication strategies.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Investigating the barriers and pathways to implementing satellite data into air quality monitoring, regulation and policy design in the United Kingdom

Daniel A. Potts, Emma J. S. Ferranti, Joshua D. Vande Hey

Summary: This study investigates the barriers to integrating satellite data into air quality management and proposes the creation of a network of experts to facilitate collaboration and knowledge exchange between scientific research and air quality management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Imagining reef futures after mass coral bleaching events

Amber W. Datta, Carina Wyborn, Brian C. Chaffin, Michele L. Barnes

Summary: Extreme climate events are changing social-ecological systems and challenging environmental governance paradigms. This study explores governance actors' perspectives on the future of reef management after a crisis and finds that multiple and conflicting visions are shaping the trajectory of coral reef governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate change resiliency response from and within cross-cultural children activities

Ranjan Datta, Prarthona Datta

Summary: This paper discusses the importance of learning climate change solutions from the activities of cross-cultural children, and introduces reflective learning, Indigenous Elders land-based teaching, music and arts learning, and positive interactions with cross-cultural children in a cross-cultural community garden.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Comparing biogenic blue mussel (Mytilus edulis) reef definitions in Northern Europe: Implications for management and conservation

Julie Lydia Stounberg, Karen Timmerman, Karsten Dahl, Maurizio Pinna, Jon C. Svendsen

Summary: To combat biodiversity loss, the European Union established the Natura 2000 network. However, some sites are still not mapped, and habitats remain undefined. This study compared the definitions of blue mussel reefs in different EU member states and identified significant variations in parameters and limits used for reef identification. The study also highlighted the need for compatible and justified habitat definitions to ensure a consistent level of protection.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Farmers perspectives on options for and barriers to implementing climate resilient agriculture and implications for climate adaptation policy

Shilpi Kundu, Edward A. Morgan, James C. R. Smart

Summary: Climate change impacts in low lying coastal areas, like Bangladesh, are negatively affecting food and livelihood security, necessitating adaptation measures to build resilience. However, the effective implementation of these measures is hindered by a lack of local-level knowledge.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Social equity and pluralism in Nature-based Solutions: Practitioners' perspectives on implementation

Theodore Tallent, Aiora Zabala

Summary: This study explores how pluralism and social equity are incorporated into the governance of Nature-based Solutions (NbS) in the field of conservation. Using a conceptual framework of social equity, the researchers analyze five exemplary cases to understand how practitioners assimilate these principles into their practices and governance processes. The findings highlight a strong commitment to participation and involvement of local communities, along with practices that aim to foster actor participation, build local capacity, and strengthen ownership. The study emphasizes the importance of considering diverse voices, perspectives, and forms of knowledge in conservation governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Lessons from a plain language analysis: US Clean Air Act Title V public notices as barriers to environmental justice

Natalie Sampson, Carmel Price, Melanie Sampson, Mary Bradshaw, Bianca Freeman

Summary: The Title V program of the Clean Air Act provides opportunities for public participation in permit-related decisionmaking, but there is a lack of substantive changes prioritizing environmental justice in overburdened communities. Increasing the use of plain language can improve public participation by enhancing access, transparency, and accountability. Analysis of public notices revealed poor writing quality and a lack of attention to writing strategies for improved understanding and addressing environmental health and justice. Suggestions for improving public notices are provided, emphasizing the need for plain language and environmental health literacy.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Building adaptive capacity to address coastal flooding: The case of a small Texas City

Karabi Bezboruah, Amruta Sakalker, Michelle Hummel, Oswald Jenewein, Kathryn Masten, Yonghe Liu

Summary: This study examines the role of a rural, community-based nonprofit organization in addressing coastal flooding. Through an analysis of the Ingleside on the Bay Coastal Watch Association (IOBCWA) in Texas, the study finds that the organization has improved the community's adaptive capacity through activities such as community organizing, advocacy, data collection, resident capacity building, and regional communication networks. However, more policies, partnerships, and inclusion of socially vulnerable groups are needed.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Knowledge co-production around the cormorant-fishing conflict using a joint fact-finding approach

Heli Saarikoski, Suvi Vikstrom, Lasse Peltonen

Summary: This paper examines the cormorant conflict in Finland, highlighting the frame conflict resulting from different scales of analysis. The study finds that knowledge co-production processes have the potential to address environmental conflicts and generate practical and contextually appropriate knowledge. Key factors include participants' control over information and third-party facilitation of dialogue.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Inviting a decolonial praxis for future imaginaries of nature: Introducing the Entangled Time Tree

Naomi Terry, Azucena Castro, Bwalya Chibwe, Geci Karuri-Sebina, Codruta Savu, Laura Pereira

Summary: The practice of envisioning the future has deep roots in African traditions, but is not widely used in conventional futuring methodologies. To achieve a decolonial approach to futuring, it is important to consider diverse pasts and storytelling forms. Stories can serve as mechanisms of power, healing, and diversification, leading to more just and ecologically sustainable futures.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Weather information, farm-level climate adaptation and farmers' adaptive capacity: Examining the role of information and communication technologies

Priya Chetri, Upasna Sharma, P. Vigneswara Ilavarasan

Summary: Previous studies have overlooked the role of information in farmers' capacity to adapt to weather and climate variability. This paper examines the relationship between farmers' access to weather information and the uptake of farm-level adaptation strategies, and highlights the potential of information in improving farmers' adaptive capacity. The paper also emphasizes the moderating effect of farmers' social ecosystem on this relationship.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Resource nexus perspectives in the Blue Economy of India: The case of sand mining in Kerala

Baker Matovu, Floor Brouwer, Raimund Bleischwitz, Firas Aljanabi, Meltem Alkoyak-Yildiz

Summary: This paper proposes a novel framework for sustainable sand mining based on Ecosystem Service Assessment. It analyzes the case of Kerala, India to demonstrate the impacts of sand mining on local ecosystems and livelihoods. The article also highlights seven key steps that can guide sustainable sand mining and promote integrated governance systems.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)