4.7 Article

Exploring uncertainty and model predictive performance concepts via a modular snowmelt-runoff modeling framework

期刊

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE
卷 25, 期 6, 页码 691-701

出版社

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsoft.2009.11.010

关键词

Modeling framework; Model comparison; Bayesian inference; Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation; Calibration; Uncertainty analysis; Snowmelt; Predictive performance

资金

  1. Montana Water Center
  2. U.S. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Model selection is an extremely important aspect of many hydrologic modeling studies because of the complexity, variability, and uncertainty that surrounds the current understanding of watershed-scale systems. However, development and implementation of a complete precipitation-runoff modeling framework, from model selection to calibration and uncertainty analysis, are rarely confronted. This paper introduces a modular precipitation-runoff modeling framework that has been developed and applied to a research site in Central Montana, USA. The case study focuses on an approach to hydrologic modeling that considers model development, selection, calibration, uncertainty analysis, and overall assessment. The results of this case study suggest that a modular framework is useful in identifying the interactions between and among different process representations and their resultant predictions of stream discharge. Such an approach can strengthen model building and address an oft ignored aspect of predictive uncertainty; namely, model structural uncertainty. (C) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Engineering, Civil

Identifying the Influence of Systematic Errors in Potential Evapotranspiration on Rainfall-Runoff Models

Dilhani Jayathilake, Tyler Smith

Summary: This study investigates the sensitivity of a widely used conceptual rainfall-runoff model to systematic errors in potential evapotranspiration (PET) inputs for 57 US catchments. The results show that energy-limited catchments are more sensitive to PET errors, and the PET error threshold decreases along the water- to energy-limited continuum. Additionally, negatively biased PET data can cause catchments to shift towards energy limitation, resulting in higher model sensitivity.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGIC ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Bayesian Model Calibration Using Surrogate Streamflow in Ungauged Catchments

Hae Na Yoon, Lucy Marshall, Ashish Sharma, Seokhyeon Kim

Summary: This study presents a novel approach for modeling streamflow in ungauged catchments using remotely sensed data. The approach utilizes the satellite-derived calibration ratio-measurement (C/M ratio) as a direct measurement of streamflow. The study demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach for three Australian Hydrologic Reference Stations and suggests significant improvements over traditional approaches.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Water Resources

Coevolution of machine learning and process-based modelling to revolutionize Earth and environmental sciences: A perspective

Saman Razavi, David M. Hannah, Amin Elshorbagy, Sujay Kumar, Lucy Marshall, Dimitri P. Solomatine, Amin Dezfuli, Mojtaba Sadegh, James Famiglietti

Summary: Machine learning applications in Earth and environmental sciences have evolved separately from traditional process-based modeling paradigms. Overcoming cultural barriers and exploring the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches are essential for developing a coevolutionary approach to model building.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Water Resources

A conceptual model for simulating streamflow in a changing snow-covered catchment: application to the data-sparse upper Brahmaputra River basin

Ahmad Hasan Nury, Ashish Sharma, Lucy Marshall, Ian Cordery

Summary: Understanding the hydrological processes in the Tibetan Plateau is crucial due to the demand for freshwater downstream. However, the limited information makes it challenging to develop a hydrological model that characterizes future streamflow. This study proposes a flexible conceptual hydrological model based on remote sensing data, which can simulate dynamically varying snow cover fraction, snow water equivalent, and streamflow.

HYDROLOGICAL SCIENCES JOURNAL (2022)

Article Meteorology & Atmospheric Sciences

Projected Changes in the Tibetan Plateau Snowpack Resulting From Rising Global Temperatures

Ahmad Hasan Nury, Ashish Sharma, Raj Mehrotra, Lucy Marshall, Ian Cordery

Summary: This study examines the impact of climate change on snowpack change over the Tibetan Plateau. The results show that the region will experience longer periods without snow and a decrease in the proportion of snowy days in the future. Additionally, there will be a decrease in snow water equivalent due to warming temperatures and changes in precipitation.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Improving probabilistic monthly water quantity and quality predictions using a simplified residual-based modeling approach

Tian Guo, Yaoze Liu, Gang Shao, Bernard A. Engel, Ashish Sharma, Lucy A. Marshall, Dennis C. Flanagan, Raj Cibin, Carlington W. Wallace, Kaiguang Zhao, Dongyang Ren, Johann Vera Mercado, Mohamed A. Aboelnour

Summary: This study generated and evaluated probabilistic hydrologic and water quality predictions at 18 locations in the U.S., and found the best predictive uncertainties using a residual-based modeling approach. The ensemble average of hydrologic and water quality simulations better represented the predictive uncertainty compared to a single realization of simulations, especially for large watersheds. The study recommends various methods to improve the robustness and uncertainty of hydrologic and water quality predictions.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2022)

Article Water Resources

Modelling daily transmission losses in basin-scale river system models under changing hydrological regimes

Shaun S. H. Kim, Justin D. Hughes, Lucy A. Marshall, Cuan Petheram, Ashish Sharma, Jai Vaze, Russell S. Crosbie

Summary: A new river loss model was developed to better represent the exchange of water between rivers and groundwater. The model performed better than a benchmark model in a case study in Cooper Creek, Australia, and provides river state and flux terms that are not typically available in basin-scale models. This model has the potential to be valuable for calibration and validation using alternative observed data types.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Which Rainfall Errors Can Hydrologic Models Handle? Implications for Using Satellite-Derived Products in Sparsely Gauged Catchments

C. M. Stephens, H. T. Pham, L. A. Marshall, F. M. Johnson

Summary: There is interest in using satellite-derived rainfall products for water management in areas with limited data. This study found that a flexible hydrologic model (GR4J) was able to filter errors in rainfall magnitude and variance, making it a useful alternative when bias correction data is unavailable. However, the model had difficulty compensating for errors in rainfall occurrence. Increasing the spatial and temporal resolution of satellite observations could enhance satellite-derived precipitation for hydrologic modeling.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Quantifying the Effects of Sea Level Rise on Estuarine Drainage Systems

K. Waddington, D. Khojasteh, L. Marshall, D. Rayner, W. Glamore

Summary: The development of low elevation coastal zones often involves reclamation and drainage systems. However, sea level rise and tidal changes can affect drainage and necessitate changes to existing land uses.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Water Resources

International capacity building to achieve SDG6: insights from longitudinal analysis of five water operator partnerships

Clare M. Stephens, Michelle Ho, Susanne Schmeidl, Hung T. Pham, Andrew P. Dansie, Gregory L. Leslie, Lucy A. Marshall

Summary: Water operator partnerships (WOPs) have gained popularity in pursuit of SDG 6. This study found that communication and relationship-building are key success factors for achieving desired outcomes, while broader institutional learning becomes increasingly important as participants gain experience. Expanding partnerships to involve governance and policy organizations and collaboratively implementing upgrades could enhance future programmes.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatial Variation in Catchment Response to Climate Change Depends on Lateral Moisture Transport and Nutrient Dynamics

C. M. Stephens, L. A. Marshall, F. M. Johnson, H. Ajami, L. Lin, L. E. Band

Summary: Future shifts in rainfall, temperature and carbon dioxide will have varying impacts on hydrologic and ecosystem behavior, with spatial heterogeneity and important differences in riparian zones. Models need to consider spatial heterogeneity, key ecosystem-driving dynamics and lateral transport to accurately predict ecohydrologic changes in catchments.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Cyclone trajectory and intensity prediction with uncertainty quantification using variational recurrent neural networks

Arpit Kapoor, Anshul Negi, Lucy Marshall, Rohitash Chandra

Summary: Cyclone track forecasting is a critical climate science problem, and machine learning methods, especially recurrent neural networks (RNNs), have shown promise in this field. However, these methods often lack uncertainty quantification. This paper proposes variational RNNs, which approximate the posterior distribution of parameters by minimizing the KL-divergence loss, for cyclone track and intensity prediction. The results demonstrate that variational RNNs provide a good approximation with uncertainty quantification while maintaining prediction accuracy.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Verifying model performance using validation of Pareto solutions

N. Harvey, L. Marshall, R. W. Vervoort

Summary: Calibrating a hydrological model using multiple independent data sets can improve parameter estimation, but often leads to indistinguishable performance among parameter sets. This study investigates the performance of Pareto optimal solutions during model validation and the tradeoffs between objective functions during calibration. The ecohydrological model used focuses on a forested Australian catchment and simulates leaf area index, evapotranspiration, and streamflow. The results show that the performance deteriorated between calibration and validation, with no clear optimal parameter set identified from the Pareto set.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD) Spatial Prioritisation through Global Sensitivity Analysis for Effective Urban Pluvial Flood Mitigation

Wenhui Wu, Behzad Jamali, Kefeng Zhang, Lucy Marshall, Ana Deletic

Summary: In this study, a new Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD) spatial prioritisation framework was developed using global sensitivity analysis (GSA) to identify priority subcatchments for effective flood mitigation. The framework combines the Urban Biophysical Environments and Technologies Simulator (UrbanBEATS) and the U.S. EPA Storm Water Management Model (SWMM) to simulate flooding in an urbanised catchment. The GSA was used to vary the effective imperviousness of subcatchments and prioritize their influence on catchment flooding. The effectiveness of the framework was validated by comparing different WSUD spatial distribution scenarios in a Sydney catchment. The results showed that implementing WSUD in high priority subcatchments achieved the largest flood volume reduction, followed by medium priority subcatchments and catchmentwide implementation.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Water Resources

Incorporating multiple observational uncertainties in water quality model calibration

Xia Wu, Lucy Marshall, Ashish Sharma

Summary: This study introduces the BEAR method for handling multiple sources of observational errors in water quality models to accurately estimate model parameters, which has been shown to successfully quantify sources of observational errors. Considering observational errors in both model inputs and outputs, rather than just inputs or outputs, can improve parameter calibration and error characterization.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Incorporating physically-based water temperature predictions into the National water model framework

Jeffrey Wade, Christa Kelleher, Barret L. Kurylyk

Summary: This study developed a physically-based water temperature model coupled with the National Water Model (NWM) to assess the potential for water temperature prediction to be incorporated into the NWM at the continental scale. By evaluating different model configurations of increasing complexity, the study successfully simulated hourly water temperatures in the forested headwaters of H.J. Andrews Experimental Forest in Oregon, USA, providing a basis for integrating water temperature simulation with predictions from the NWM.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Improving the statistical reliability of river model predictions via simple state adjustments

Shaun SH. Kim, Lucy A. Marshall, Justin D. Hughes, Lynn Seo, Julien Lerat, Ashish Sharma, Jai Vaze

Summary: A major challenge in hydrologic modelling is producing reliable uncertainty estimates outside of calibration periods. This research addresses the challenge by improving model structures and error models to more reliably estimate uncertainty. The combination of the RBS model and SPUE produces statistically reliable predictions and shows better matching performance in tests.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Class3Dp: A supervised classifier of vegetation species from point clouds

Juan Pedro Carbonell-Rivera, Javier Estornell, Luis Angel Ruiz, Pablo Crespo-Peremarch, Jaime Almonacid-Caballer

Summary: This study presents Class3Dp, a software for classifying vegetation species in colored point clouds. The software utilizes geometric, spectral, and neighborhood features along with machine learning methods to classify the point cloud, allowing for the recognition of species composition in an ecosystem.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A comparison of numerical schemes for the GPU-accelerated simulation of variably-saturated groundwater flow

Zhi Li, Daniel Caviedes-Voullieme, Ilhan Oezgen-Xian, Simin Jiang, Na Zheng

Summary: The optimal strategy for solving the Richards equation numerically depends on the specific problem, particularly when using GPUs. This study investigates the parallel performance of four numerical schemes on both CPUs and GPUs. The results show that the scaling of Richards solvers on GPUs is influenced by various factors. Compared to CPUs, parallel simulations on GPUs exhibit significant variation in scaling across different code sections, with poorly-scaled components potentially impacting overall performance. Nonetheless, using GPUs can greatly enhance computational speed, especially for large-scale problems.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

ANDROMEDE - A software platform for optical surface velocity measurements

Ludovic Cassan, Leo Pujol, Paul Lonca, Romain Guibert, Helene Roux, Olivier Mercier, Dominique Courret, Sylvain Richard, Pierre Horgue

Summary: Methods and algorithms for measuring stream surface velocities have been continuously developed over the past five years to adapt to specific flow typologies. The free software ANDROMEDE allows easy use and comparison of these methods with image processing capabilities designed for measurements in natural environments and with unmanned aerial vehicles. The validation of the integrated algorithms is presented on three case studies that represent the targeted applications: the study of currents for eco-hydraulics, the measurement of low water flows and the diagnosis of hydraulic structures. The field measurements are in very good agreement with the optical measurements and demonstrate the usefulness of the tool for rapid flow diagnosis for all the intended applications.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Uncovering heterogeneous effects in computational models for sustainable decision-making

Mariia Kozlova, Robert J. Moss, Julian Scott Yeomans, Jef Caers

Summary: This paper introduces a framework for quantitative sensitivity analysis using the SimDec visualization method, and tests its effectiveness on decision-making problems. The framework captures critical information in the presence of heterogeneous effects, and enhances its practicality by introducing a formal definition and classification of heterogeneous effects.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Inclusive simulation game development to enhance Florida research and management: Cedar Key oyster fishery

Chad R. Palmer, Denis Valle, Edward V. Camp, Wendy-Lin Bartels, Martha C. Monroe

Summary: Simulation games have been used in natural resource management for education and communication purposes, but not for data collection. This research introduces a new design process which involves stakeholders and emphasizes usability, relevance, and credibility testing criteria. The result is a finalized simulation game for future research.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Numerical analysis of the abiotic formation and distribution of the iron curtain in subterranean estuaries

Tao Wang, Chenming Zhang, Ye Ma, Harald Hofmann, Congrui Li, Zicheng Zhao

Summary: This study used numerical modeling to investigate the formation process of iron curtains under different freshwater and seawater conditions. It was found that Fe(OH)3 accumulates on the freshwater side, while the precipitation is inhibited on the seaward side due to high H+ concentrations. These findings enhance our understanding of iron transformation and distribution in subterranean estuaries.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Wildland fire mid-story: A generative modeling approach for representative fuels

Grant Hutchings, James Gattiker, Braden Scherting, Rodman R. Linn

Summary: Computational models for understanding and predicting fire in wildland and managed lands are becoming increasingly impactful. This paper addresses the characterization and population of mid-story fuels, which are not easily observable through traditional survey or remote sensing. The authors present a methodology to populate the mid-story using a generative model for fuel placement, which can be calibrated based on limited observation datasets or expert guidance. The connection of terrestrial LiDAR as the observations used to calibrate the generative model is emphasized. Code for the methods in this paper is provided.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

IMDLIB: An open-source library for retrieval, processing and spatiotemporal exploratory assessments of gridded meteorological observation datasets over India

Saswata Nandi, Pratiman Patel, Sabyasachi Swain

Summary: IMDLIB is an open-source Python library that simplifies the retrieval and processing of gridded meteorological data from IMD, enhancing data accessibility and facilitating hydro-climatic research and analysis.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Multiple equidistant belt technique for width function estimation through a two-segmented-distance strategy

Pengfei Wu, Jintao Liu, Meiyan Feng, Hu Liu

Summary: In this paper, a new flow distance algorithm called D infinity-TLI is proposed, which accurately estimates flow distance and width function using a two-segment-distance strategy and triangulation with linear interpolation method. The evaluation results show that D infinity-TLI outperforms existing algorithms and has a low mean absolute relative error.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)