The Antagonists But Not Partial Agonists of Glucocorticoid Receptor Ligands Show Substantial Side Effect Dissociation

A synthetic glucocorticoid receptor (GR) ligand with the efficacy of a glucocorticoid, but without the accompanying side effects, would meet an unmet medical need for the treatment of inflammatory diseases. It was hypothesized that a GR ligand that shifted helix 12 in a manner distinct from an agonist and an antagonist would confer a distinct GR conformation, resulting in differential gene expression and, ultimately, dissociation of antiinflammatory activity from side effects. A structural feature expected to interfere with helix 12 was incorporated into a nonsteroidal, tricyclic scaffold to create novel, high-affinity, and selective GR ligands that manifested a dual function in cellular assays, partial but robust agonist activity for inflammatory cytokine inhibition, and full antagonist activity for reporter gene activation. In contrast, analogs not likely to hinder helix 12 exhibited partial agonist activity for reporter gene activation. The requirement of full antagonist activity for substantial side effect dissociation was demonstrated in primary human preadipocytes, hepatocytes, and osteoblasts in which effects on adipogenesis, key genes involved in gluconeogenesis, and genes important for bone formation were examined, respectively. The dissociated GR ligands, despite lacking significant reporter gene activation, weakly recruit a limited number of coactivators such as peroxisomal proliferator-activated receptor-gamma coactivator 1 alpha. Transcriptional activation was sensitive to both peroxisomal proliferator-activated receptor-gamma coactivator 1 alpha and GR levels, providing a basis for cell-selective modulation of gene expression. The antiinflammatory activity of the dissociated ligands was further demonstrated in mouse models of inflammation. Together these results suggest that these ligands are promising candidates with robust antiinflammatory activity and likely dissociation against glucocorticoid-induced side effects. (Endocrinology 152: 3123-3134, 2011)