4.5 Article

Simple procedures of choice in multicriteria problems without precise information about the alternatives' values

期刊

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH
卷 37, 期 12, 页码 2239-2247

出版社

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.cor.2010.03.014

关键词

Multi-criteria decision analysis; MAUT/MAVT; Imprecise/incomplete/partial information; Ordinal information; Simulation

资金

  1. FCT [SFRH/BD/29178/2006]
  2. Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia [POCI/EGE/58371/2004, SFRH/BD/29178/2006] Funding Source: FCT

向作者/读者索取更多资源

The additive model of multiattribute value theory is widely used in multicriteria choice problems. But often it is not easy to obtain precise values for the scaling weights or the alternatives' value in each function. Several decision rules which require weaker information, such as ordinal information, have been proposed to select an alternative under these circumstances. We propose new decision rules and test them using Monte-Carlo simulation, considering that there is ordinal information both on the scaling weights and on the alternatives' values. Results show the new rules constitute a good approximation. We provide guidelines about how to use these rules in a context of selecting a subset of the most promising alternatives, considering the contradictory objectives of keeping a low number of alternatives yet not excluding the best one. (C) 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.5
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Operations Research & Management Science

Integrating life-cycle assessment and multi-criteria decision analysis to compare alternative biodiesel chains

Luis C. Dias, Carolina Passeira, Joao Malca, Fausto Freire

Summary: This article compares the environmental impacts of four different Rapeseed Methyl Ester biodiesel production chains from different feedstock origins. The study applies a combination of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) to evaluate the various impact categories. Two different MCDA methods are used to address the weighting issue in the LCA research and studies. The proposed LCIA-MCDA approach aims to assess robust conclusions without specific weightings.

ANNALS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Management

Learning target-based preferences through additive models: An application in radiotherapy treatment planning

Luis C. Dias, Joana Dias, Tiago Ventura, Humberto Rocha, Brigida Ferreira, Leila Khouri, Maria do Carmo Lopes

Summary: This article presents a new multi-criteria decision aiding preference disaggregation method based on an asymmetric target-based model. The method penalizes solutions that do not meet the target, representing the preferences of a radiation oncologist effectively in choosing radiotherapy treatment plans.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Management

Performance evaluation of emergency department physicians using robust value-based additive efficiency model

Anna Labijak-Kowalska, Milosz Kadzinski, Inga Spychala, Luis C. Dias, Javier Fiallos, Jonathan Patrick, Wojtek Michalowski, Ken Farion

Summary: This study proposes a novel variant of the value-based additive data envelopment analysis model and conducts a comprehensive robustness analysis of physicians' performance using mathematical programming and the Monte Carlo simulation. The results indicate a strong dependence of physicians' performances on the selected weight vectors, and provide a basis for identifying overall good performers, developing improvement plans, and recognizing challenging patients' complaints.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Multicriteria Decision Analysis Addressing Marine and Terrestrial Plastic Waste Management: A Review

Murilo R. Santos, Luis C. Dias, Maria C. Cunha, Joao R. Marques

Summary: This paper provides a systematic review of studies that utilized multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) to address plastic waste management. The review included 20 relevant papers published from 2008 to 2021, covering case studies in three continents. The findings suggest that alternative solutions were identified for almost all types of plastic disposal methods. The most commonly used method was AHP, followed by TOPSIS and outranking methods.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Management

Project portfolio management considering the commitment of agents: A bi-objective model applied to administrative services

Jorge Noro, Luis C. Dias

Summary: This article presents a new bi-objective optimization model for project portfolio management, aiming to improve team performance by maximizing the economic gains of the project portfolio and the skills development of the allocated agents. The model selects project implementers and considers the workload and distribution of work's impact on employment commitment.

JOURNAL OF THE OPERATIONAL RESEARCH SOCIETY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A Delphi Based Approach to the Assessment of New Marine Litter Reduction and Processing Technologies

Maria C. Cunha, Joao Marques, Luis C. Dias, Ignacio Rada Cotera, George Triantaphyllidis

Summary: This paper explores the important factors for assessing new marine litter reduction and processing technologies through the Delphi method. The study highlights the relevant technology features and gathers valuable data in areas lacking information. By involving recognized experts and stakeholders, the study determines the consensus and perception of the importance for each aspect. The findings provide a list of factors to consider in different decision-making contexts, taking into account technical, environmental, socio-economic, and political issues.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Management

Two-party Bargaining Processes Based on Subjective Expectations: A Model and a Simulation Study

Luis C. Dias, Rudolf Vetschera

Summary: This article presents a model for a two-party bargaining process that involves multiple offers with a risk of breakdown. By considering confidence as a factor, the study offers a new perspective on the bargaining process. Analytical results show that under certain assumptions, the bargaining process converges to the nonsymmetric Nash bargaining solution.

GROUP DECISION AND NEGOTIATION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

A multi-criteria assessment of policies to achieve the objectives of the EU marine litter strategy

Luis C. Dias, Maria C. Cunha, Emma Watkins, George Triantaphyllidis

Summary: This study evaluated policy options for the EU marine litter strategy using a multi-criteria decision analysis method. The results showed that revising the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive, setting legislative targets on marine litter, and funding proven clean-up technologies are the most potentially impactful policies, while others can also play an important complementary role.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2022)

Article Operations Research & Management Science

A stochastic method for exploiting outranking relations in multicriteria choice problems

Luis C. Dias, Humberto Rocha

Summary: This study proposes a stochastic method based on Markov solution for selecting the most preferred alternative. It can be used to exploit different types of outranking relations and guarantees important properties with minimal computation effort.

ANNALS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Efficiency benchmarking of wastewater service providers: An analysis based on the Portuguese case

A. Luis Amaral, Rita Martins, Luis C. Dias

Summary: This study characterizes and benchmarks the wastewater treatment sector in Portugal and identifies the best practices in resource efficiency. The analysis reveals the positive impact of service providers' size and certifications on efficiency, while underuse of treatment plants negatively affects efficiency. These findings provide valuable insights for strategic policies in the water sector and can be applied to identify role models in other countries.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Management

Low cited articles in operations research/management science

Luis C. Dias, Benjamin Lev, James B. Anderson

OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Drivers of water utilities? operational performance-An analysis from the Portuguese case

Antonio L. Amaral, Rita Martins, Luis C. Dias

Summary: Identifying the main drivers of performance is essential for enhancing the sustainability of water utilities. This study aims to identify the relevant drivers associated with sustainability-related operational indicators in both drinking water supply and wastewater treatment. Various data analysis methods, including cross correlations analysis, clustering analysis, and principal components analysis, were employed to investigate the interrelationships between variables and capture important information. The results emphasize the importance of service provider size, personnel allocation, water losses, and certification policies in influencing operational indicators. Policy recommendations include promoting the aggregation of smaller service providers, controlling water losses and personnel allocation, and implementing certification practices.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Management

Confidence in bargaining processes and outcomes: Empirical tests of a conceptual model

Rudolf Vetschera, Luis C. Dias

Summary: In this study, the researchers examined the compatibility between a dynamic bargaining model and observations from negotiation experiments. They found that the model was largely compatible with the observed bargaining processes, but actual agreements tended to be more balanced than predicted by the model. Additionally, they discovered a strong relationship between negotiator confidence and their independently ascertained aspiration levels, providing further evidence for the model's external validity.

EURO JOURNAL ON DECISION PROCESSES (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A multi-criteria framework for the ecodesign of bio-based materials at early development stages

Jade Muller-Carneiro, Carla Rodrigues, Luis C. Dias, Carlos Henggeler Antunes, Adriano L. A. Mattos, Fausto Freire

Summary: This article proposes a framework combining ex-ante life cycle assessment (LCA) with multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) for the evaluation of novel bio-based materials. The framework is applied to starch films for food packaging and compares them with commercial polymers based on cost, environmental, and technical criteria. The results show that the commercial polymers outperform the novel films in terms of technical performance, but the starch films have potential for rigid applications.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Proceedings Paper Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

DRIVERS OF ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN THE PORTUGUESE WATER INDUSTRY

Antonio L. Amaral, Rita Martins, Luis C. Dias

Summary: To improve the sustainability of the water sector, it is crucial to identify top-performing service providers and understand the factors driving their performance.

TECHNOLOGIES, MARKETS AND POLICIES: BRINGING TOGETHER ECONOMICS AND ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A unified exact approach for a broad class of vehicle routing problems with simultaneous pickup and delivery

Rafael Praxedes, Teobaldo Bulhoes, Anand Subramanian, Eduardo Uchoa

Summary: The Vehicle Routing Problem with Simultaneous Pickup and Delivery is a classical optimization problem that aims to determine the least-cost routes while meeting pickup and delivery demands and vehicle capacity constraints. In this study, a unified algorithm is proposed to solve multiple variants of the problem, and extensive computational experiments are conducted to evaluate the algorithm's performance.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

An asynchronous parallel benders decomposition method for stochastic network design problems

Ragheb Rahmaniani, Teodor Gabriel Crainic, Michel Gendreau, Walter Rei

Summary: Benders decomposition (BD) is a popular solution algorithm for stochastic integer programs. However, existing parallelization methods often suffer from inefficiencies. This paper proposes an asynchronous parallel BD method and demonstrates its effectiveness through numerical studies and performance enhancement strategies.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Exact algorithms for a parallel machine scheduling problem with workforce and contiguity constraints

Giulia Caselli, Maxence Delorme, Manuel Iori, Carlo Alberto Magni

Summary: This study addresses a real-world scheduling problem and proposes four exact methods to solve it. The methods are evaluated through computational experiments on different types of instances and show competitive advantages on specific subsets. The study also demonstrates the generalizability of the algorithms to related scheduling problems with contiguity constraints.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

An iteratively doubling binary search for the two-dimensional irregular multiple-size bin packing problem raised in the steel industry

Shaowen Yao, Chao Tang, Hao Zhang, Songhuan Wu, Lijun Wei, Qiang Liu

Summary: This paper examines the problem of two-dimensional irregular multiple-size bin packing and proposes a solution that utilizes an iteratively doubling binary search algorithm to find the optimal bin combination, and further optimizes the result through an overlap minimization approach.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Drop-and-pull container drayage with flexible assignment of work break for vehicle drivers

Decheng Wang, Ruiyou Zhang, Bin Qiu, Wenpeng Chen, Xiaolan Xie

Summary: Consideration of driver-related constraints, such as mandatory work break, in vehicle scheduling and routing is crucial for safety driving and protecting the interests of drivers. This paper addresses the drop-and-pull container drayage problem with flexible assignment of work break, proposing a mixed-integer programming model and an algorithm for solving realistic-sized instances. Experimental results show the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm in handling vehicle scheduling and routing with work break assignment.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Manipulating hidden-Markov-model inferences by corrupting batch data

William N. Caballero, Jose Manuel Camacho, Tahir Ekin, Roi Naveiro

Summary: This research provides a novel probabilistic perspective on the manipulation of hidden Markov model inferences through corrupted data, highlighting the weaknesses of such models under adversarial activity and emphasizing the need for robustification techniques to ensure their security.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Evolutionary multi-objective design of autoencoders for compact representation of histopathology whole slide images

Davood Zaman Farsa, Shahryar Rahnamayan, Azam Asilian Bidgoli, H. R. Tizhoosh

Summary: This paper proposes a multi-objective evolutionary framework for compressing feature vectors using deep autoencoders. The framework achieves high classification accuracy and efficient image representation through a bi-level optimization scheme. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed framework in image processing tasks.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Verifying new instances of the multidemand multidimensional knapsack problem with instance space analysis

Matthew E. Scherer, Raymond R. Hill, Brian J. Lunday, Bruce A. Cox, Edward D. White

Summary: This paper discusses instance generation methods for the multidemand multidimensional knapsack problem and introduces a primal problem instance generator (PPIG) to address feasibility issues in current instance generation methods.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Efficient iterative optimization to real-time train regulation in urban rail transit networks combined with Benders decomposition method

Yin Yuan, Shukai Li, Lixing Yang, Ziyou Gao

Summary: This paper investigates the design of real-time train regulation strategies for urban rail networks to reduce train deviations and passenger waiting times. A mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) model is used and an efficient iterative optimization (IO) approach is proposed to address the complexity. The generalized Benders decomposition (GBD) technique is also incorporated. Numerical experiments show the effectiveness and computational efficiency of the proposed method.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Unmanned surface vehicles (USVs) scheduling method by a bi-level mission planning and path control

Xinghai Guo, Netirith Narthsirinth, Weidan Zhang, Yuzhen Hu

Summary: This study proposes a bi-level scheduling method that utilizes unmanned surface vehicles for container transportation. By formulating mission decision and path control models, efficient container transshipment and path planning are achieved. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach in guiding unmanned surface vehicles to complete container transshipment tasks.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Review Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Metaheuristics for bilevel optimization: A comprehensive review

Jose-Fernando Camacho-Vallejo, Carlos Corpus, Juan G. Villegas

Summary: This study aims to review the published papers on implementing metaheuristics for solving bilevel problems and performs a bibliometric analysis to track the evolution of this topic. The study provides a detailed description of the components of the proposed metaheuristics and analyzes the common combinations of these components. Additionally, the study provides a detailed classification of how crucial bilevel aspects of the problem are handled in the metaheuristics, along with a discussion of interesting findings.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Electric vehicle-based express service network design with recharging management: A branch-and-price approach

Xudong Diao, Meng Qiu, Gangyan Xu

Summary: In this study, an optimization model for the design of an electric vehicle-based express service network is proposed, considering limited recharging resources and power management. The proposed method is validated through computational experiments on realistic instances.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Bilevel optimization for the deployment of refuelling stations for electric vehicles on road networks

Ramon Piedra-de-la-Cuadra, Francisco A. Ortega

Summary: This study proposes a procedure to select candidate sites optimally for ensuring energy autonomy and reinforced service coverage for electric vehicles, while considering demand and budget restrictions.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Cutting Plane Approaches for the Robust Kidney Exchange Problem

Danny Blom, Christopher Hojny, Bart Smeulders

Summary: This paper focuses on a robust variant of the kidney exchange program problem with recourse, and proposes a cutting plane method for solving the attacker-defender subproblem. The results show a significant improvement in running time compared to the state-of-the-art, and the method can solve previously unsolved instances. Additionally, a new practical policy for recourse is proposed and its tractability for small to mid-size kidney exchange programs is demonstrated.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Generating linear programming instances with controllable rank and condition number

Anqi Li, Congying Han, Tiande Guo, Bonan Li

Summary: This study proposes a general framework for designing linear programming instances based on the preset optimal solution, and validates the effectiveness of the framework through experiments.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2024)