4.5 Article

Waiting list may be a nocebo condition in psychotherapy trials: a contribution from network meta-analysis

期刊

ACTA PSYCHIATRICA SCANDINAVICA
卷 130, 期 3, 页码 181-192

出版社

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/acps.12275

关键词

waiting lists; placebo; control groups; cognitive therapy; clinical trials

资金

  1. Asahi Kasei
  2. Eli Lilly
  3. GlaxoSmithKline
  4. Mochida
  5. MSD
  6. Otsuka
  7. Pfizer
  8. Shionogi
  9. Tanabe-Mitsubishi
  10. Japanese Ministry of Education, Science, and Technology
  11. Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare
  12. Japan Foundation for Neuroscience and Mental Health
  13. Medical Research Council, UK
  14. MRC [MR/K023233/1, G0902118] Funding Source: UKRI
  15. Medical Research Council [MR/K023233/1, G0902118] Funding Source: researchfish
  16. Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research [26670314] Funding Source: KAKEN

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Objective: Various control conditions have been employed in psychotherapy trials, but there is growing suspicion that they may lead to different effect size estimates. The present study aims to examine the differences among control conditions including waiting list (WL), no treatment (NT) and psychological placebo (PP). Method: We comprehensively searched for all randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing cognitive-behaviour therapies (CBT) against various control conditions in the acute phase treatment of depression, and applied network meta-analysis (NMA) to combine all direct and indirect comparisons among the treatment and control arms. Results: We identified 49 RCTs (2730 participants) comparing WL, NT, PP and CBT. This network of evidence was consistent, and the effect size estimates for CBT were substantively different depending on the control condition. The odds ratio of response for NT over WL was statistically significant at 2.9 (95% CI: 1.3-5.7). However, the quality of evidence, including publication bias, was less than ideal and none of the preplanned sensitivity analyses limiting to high-quality studies could be conducted, while findings of significant differences did not persist in post hoc sensitivity analyses trying to adjust for publication bias. Conclusion: There may be important differences in control conditions currently used in psychotherapy trials.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.5
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Review Substance Abuse

Practitioner and digitally delivered interventions for reducing hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption in people not seeking alcohol treatment: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Fiona R. Beyer, Ryan P. W. Kenny, Eugenie Johnson, Deborah M. Caldwell, Claire Garnett, Stephen Rice, Julija Simpson, Colin Angus, Dawn Craig, Matt Hickman, Susan Michie, Eileen F. S. Kaner

Summary: This study compares the effectiveness of practitioner versus digitally delivered interventions for reducing hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption. The findings suggest that practitioner delivered interventions are more effective in reducing consumption up to 6 months, but there is no evidence of a difference at 12 months.

ADDICTION (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Prognostic factors and effect modifiers for personalisation of internet-based cognitive behavioural therapy among university students with subthreshold depression: A secondary analysis of a factorial trial

Rie Toyomoto, Masatsugu Sakata, Kazufumi Yoshida, Yan Luo, Yukako Nakagami, Teruhisa Uwatoko, Tomonari Shimamoto, Ethan Sahker, Aran Tajika, Hidemichi Suga, Hiroshi Ito, Michihisa Sumi, Takashi Muto, Masataka Itoi, Hiroshi Ichikawaj, Masaya Ikegawaj, Nao Shiraishi, Takafumi Watanabe, Edward R. Watkins, Hisashi Noma, Masaru Horikoshi, Taku Iwami, Toshi A. Furukawa

Summary: This study explored the prognostic factors and effect modifiers for five common components of internet-cognitive behavioural therapy (iCBT) for depression. The study found that baseline depressive symptoms and exercise habits are factors influencing the effectiveness of the self-monitoring component.

JOURNAL OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS (2023)

Letter Health Care Sciences & Services

Meta-epidemiological studyis a study in which the unit of analysis is a study, not a patient; response to Puljak et al.

Yuki Kataoka, Masahiro Banno, Yasushi Tsujimoto, Toshi A. Furukawa

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY (2023)

Review Immunology

A systematic review of communication interventions for countering vaccine misinformation

Hannah S. Whitehead, Clare E. French, Deborah M. Caldwell, Louise Letley, Sandra Mounier-Jack

Summary: Misinformation and disinformation around vaccines have become more prominent, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic. This systematic review examines communication-based strategies to combat vaccine misinformation and assesses their effectiveness. The review identifies nine intervention approaches, focusing on the content and delivery of the intervention or message. Some strategies, such as scare tactics, were found to be ineffective, while others, such as communicating the weight-of-evidence and incorporating warnings, showed promise. Further evaluation is needed to measure the impact on vaccine uptake.

VACCINE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Effect of climatic environment on immunological features of rheumatoid arthritis

Yuya Kondo, Saori Abe, Hirofumi Toko, Tomoya Hirota, Hiroyuki Takahashi, Masaru Shimizu, Hisashi Noma, Hiroto Tsuboi, Isao Matsumoto, Toshiro Inaba, Takayuki Sumida

Summary: The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of climatic environment on the immunological features of rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Blood samples were collected from RA patients and healthy controls residing in two different locations with varying altitude, average air temperature, and atmospheric pressure. The analysis revealed significant differences in T and B cell subpopulations between the two sites. These findings suggest that climatic environment may influence immune cell proportions and functions, potentially contributing to the pathogenesis of RA.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

An extension minimal important difference credibility item addressing construct is a reliable alternative to the correlation item

Yuting Wang, Tahir Devji, Alonso Carrasco-Labra, Anila Qasim, Qiukui Hao, Elena Kum, Niveditha Devasenapathy, Madeleine T. King, Berend Terluin, Caroline B. Terwee, Michae Walsh, Toshi A. Furukawa, Yasushi Tsujimoto, Gordon H. Guyatt

Summary: The minimal important difference (MID) is the smallest change or difference that patients perceive as important to interpret patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) scores. A credibility instrument for anchor-based MID assessment typically includes a core item evaluating the correlation between the PROM and the anchor. However, many MID studies do not report this correlation. To address this, we developed an alternative construct proximity item to assess credibility when the correlation is lacking.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Electronic Health Record-Nested Reminders for Serum Lithium Level Monitoring in Patients With Mood Disorder: Randomized Controlled Trial

Tomotsugu Seki, Morio Aki, Toshi A. Furukawa, Hirotsugu Kawashima, Tomotaka Miki, Yujin Sawaki, Takaaki Ando, Kentaro Katsuragi, Takahiko Kawashima, Senkei Ueno, Takashi Miyagi, Shun'ichi Noma, Shiro Tanaka, Koji Kawakami

Summary: This study aimed to examine whether an electronic health record (EHR)-nested reminder system can help patients achieve therapeutically appropriate serum lithium levels. The study found insufficient evidence for the reminder system to increase the achievement of therapeutic serum lithium concentrations, but it did increase the number of monitoring. The EHR-based reminders may be useful for improving the quality of care for patients on lithium maintenance therapy.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Depressive rumination and trait anxiety mediate the effects of childhood victimization on adulthood depressive symptoms in adult volunteers

Jiro Masuya, Chihiro Morishita, Motoki Higashiyama, Ayaka Deguchi, Yoshitaka Ishii, Miki Ono, Mina Honyashiki, Yoshio Iwata, Takeshi Inoue

Summary: This study found that childhood victimization directly influences adult trait anxiety, depressive rumination, and depressive symptom severity, and indirectly worsens depressive symptoms through trait anxiety and depressive rumination as mediators. These results highlight the importance of preventing and addressing childhood victimization to reduce the risk of clinical depression in adulthood.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Optimal duration of antibiotic treatment for community-acquired pneumonia in adults: a systematic review and duration-effect meta-analysis

Yuki Furukawa, Yan Luo, Satoshi Funada, Akira Onishi, Edoardo Ostinelli, Tasnim Hamza, Toshi A. Furukawa, Yuki Kataoka

Summary: This study aimed to identify the optimal treatment duration with antibiotics for adults with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) through a systematic review and duration-effect meta-analysis. The findings suggest that a shorter treatment duration (3-5 days) may provide the best balance between efficacy and treatment burden for treating CAP in adults who have achieved clinical stability. However, the limited number of included studies and the overall moderate-to-high risk of bias may affect the certainty of the results, highlighting the need for further research.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Four 2x2 factorial trials of smartphone CBT to reduce subthreshold depression and to prevent new depressive episodes among adults in the community-RESiLIENT trial (Resilience Enhancement with Smartphone in LIving ENvironmenTs): a master protocol

Toshi A. Furukawa, Aran Tajika, Masatsugu Sakata, Yan Luo, Rie Toyomoto, Masaru Horikoshi, Tatsuo Akechi, Norito Kawakami, Takeo Nakayama, Naoki Kondo, Shingo Fukuma, Hisashi Noma, Helen Christensen, Ronald C. Kessler, Pim Cuijpers, James M. S. Wason

Summary: This study aims to develop an iCBT platform that can adapt to the evolving internet technologies and examine the short-term and long-term efficacy of different CBT skills for depression. The study will recruit 3520 participants with subthreshold depression and approximately 1700 participants without subthreshold depression to evaluate the short-term efficacy for reducing depressive symptoms and the long-term efficacy for preventing depression in the total sample.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Trait anxiety and depressive rumination mediate the effect of perceived childhood rearing on adulthood presenteeism

Akifumi Shimasaki, Ayaka Deguchi, Yoshitaka Ishii, Tomoteru Seki, Yoshio Iwata, Yu Tamada, Mina Honyashiki, Yota Fujimura, Takeshi Inoue, Jiro Masuya

Summary: In this study, the effects of perceived childhood rearing on presenteeism in adult workers were analyzed, and the mediating effects of trait anxiety and depressive rumination were examined. The results showed that the low perceived quality of childhood rearing indirectly worsened presenteeism through trait anxiety and depressive rumination. Therefore, assessing the quality of childhood rearing, trait anxiety, and depressive rumination may help to understand and effectively manage presenteeism in the workplace.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Optimal Physical Activity Is Associated with the Reduction of Depressive Symptoms via Neuroticism and Resilience

Kazuki Nakajima, Akiyoshi Shimura, Masayuki Kikkawa, Shunichiro Ito, Mina Honyashiki, Yu Tamada, Shinji Higashi, Masahiko Ichiki, Takeshi Inoue, Jiro Masuya

Summary: This study investigated the mediating effects of neuroticism and resilience between physical activity duration and depressive symptoms. The results showed that an optimal physical activity duration can reduce depressive symptoms, and a greater difference from the optimal duration increases depressive symptoms through neuroticism and resilience.

HEALTHCARE (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

When does the placebo effect have an impact on network meta-analysis results?

Adriani Nikolakopoulou, Anna Chaimani, Toshi A. Furukawa, Theodoros Papakonstantinou, Gerta Ruecker, Guido Schwarzer

Summary: The placebo effect is the result of a participant's belief or expectation in the effectiveness of a treatment. It can play a significant role in certain conditions, particularly those with subjective symptoms. Factors such as informed consent, number of arms in a study, occurrence of adverse events, and quality of blinding can influence placebo response and introduce bias in randomized controlled trials.

BMJ EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE (2023)

Article Psychiatry

New living evidence resource of human and non-human studies for early intervention and research prioritisation in anxiety, depression and psychosis

Andrea Cipriani, Soraya Seedat, Lea Milligan, Georgia Salanti, Malcolm Macleod, Janna Hastings, James Thomas, Susan Michie, Toshi A. Furukawa, David Gilbert, Karla Soares-Weiser, Carmen Moreno, Stefan Leucht, Matthias Egger, Parisa Mansoori, James M. Barker, Spyridon Siafis, Edoardo Giuseppe Ostinelli, Robert McCutcheon, Simonne Wright, Matilda Simpson, Olufisayo Elugbadebo, Virginia Chiocchia, Thomy Tonia, Rania Elgarf, Ayse Kurtulmus, Emily Sena, Ouma Simple, Niall Boyce, Sophie Chung, Anjuli Sharma, Miranda Wolpert, Jennifer Potts, Julian H. Elliott

Summary: Progress in developing novel therapies for anxiety, depression, and psychosis has been slow, and predicting effective treatments for individuals remains challenging. Understanding the mechanisms of mental health conditions, developing targeted interventions, and improving diagnosis and prediction are crucial. Living systematic reviews can enhance efficiency and reduce waste in research. The Global Alliance for Living Evidence on aNxiety, depressiOn and pSychosis (GALENOS) aims to catalog and evaluate relevant scientific research, involving both human and preclinical studies, to advance mental health science. GALENOS will also facilitate collaboration and identify key research questions, accelerating the translation of discovery science into effective interventions.

BMJ MENTAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Guided versus unguided chatbot-delivered cognitive behavioral intervention for individuals with moderate-risk and problem gambling: A randomized controlled trial (GAMBOT2 study)

Ryuhei So, Naoki Emura, Kozue Okazaki, Sakiko Takeda, Takashi Sunami, Kohei Kitagawa, Yoshitake Takebayashi, Toshi A. Furukawa

Summary: This study compared the effects of therapist-guided internet interventions with unguided ones on gambling behavior, cognition, and stage of change. The results showed that there were no significant differences between the guided and unguided groups in terms of improvement in gambling symptoms, behavior, and stage of change.

ADDICTIVE BEHAVIORS (2024)

暂无数据