4.7 Article

The impact of the objective function in multi-site and multi-variable calibration of the SWAT model

期刊

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE
卷 93, 期 -, 页码 255-267

出版社

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.03.018

关键词

Catchment model; Objective function; Multi-site calibration; Nutrients; SWAT; Calibration scheme

资金

  1. Danish Strategic Research Council [09067259]
  2. 7th EU Framework Programme, Theme 6 (Environment including Climate Change) [603378]
  3. Ramon Areces Foundation

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Automatic calibration of complex hydro-ecological models is an increasingly important issue which involves making decisions. One of the most relevant is the choice of the objective function, but its effects have been scarcely studied in complex models. We have used the SWAT model to assess the impact of the objective function for a multi-site (4 stations) and multi-variable (OrgP, OrgN, NO3-, PO43-) calibration of the Odense catchment (Denmark). Six calibration schemes were tested, varying the objective function and the nutrient fractions targeted. The best performance metrics (R2, NSE, PBIAS) were obtained when using NSE as objective function and targeting N-fractions and P-fractions separately. The scheme was validated in another SWAT set-up in northern Denmark. Although NSE is often questioned, we found it as an adequate objective function when addressing a multi-site and multi-variable calibration. Our findings may serve as guideline for hydro-ecological modellers, being useful to achieve watershed management goals. (C) 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Ecology

Targeted regulation of nitrogen loads: A national, cross-sectoral analysis

Maria Theresia Konrad, Line Block Hansen, Gregor Levin, Gitte Blicher-Mathiesen, Hans Estrup Andersen, Louise Martinsen, Berit Hasler

Summary: Eutrophication in coastal areas of Denmark is a major challenge in meeting the requirements of the European Water Framework Directive. Excessive nitrogen loads from agricultural production are the main cause, and implementing abatement measures is crucial. Spatial heterogeneity of costs and effects significantly impacts the cost-effectiveness of land use policies, and it is important to reconsider abatement measures in sectors beyond agriculture due to increased marginal costs.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Impacts of land use, climate change and hydrological model structure on nitrate fluxes: Magnitudes and uncertainties

Ida Karlsson Seidenfaden, Torben Obel Sonnenborg, Christen Duus Borgesen, Dennis Trolle, Jorgen Eivind Olesen, Jens Christian Refsgaard

Summary: Nitrate pollution and eutrophication are becoming increasingly concerning in agriculturally dominated regions. With projected climate changes in the future, these issues are expected to worsen. Changes in land use and management have the potential to mitigate these concerns, but the extent of their interaction and associated uncertainty is unknown.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Simulating shifting ecological states in a restored, shallow lake with multiple single-model ensembles: Lake Arreskov, Denmark

Tobias Kuhlmann Andersen, Anders Nielsen, Erik Jeppesen, Karsten Bolding, Liselotte S. Johansson, Martin Sondergaard, Dennis Trolle

Summary: This study investigates the performance of the lake model GOTM-WET in reproducing the dynamics and shifts between turbid and clear water states in Lake Arreskov. The results show that the model is capable of simulating cyanobacteria blooms and zooplankton dynamics, but has limitations in reproducing the timing of shifts between phytoplankton and submerged macrophytes dominance following fish removal.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Temporarily and frequently occurring summer stratification and its effects on nutrient dynamics, greenhouse gas emission and fish habitat use: case study from Lake Ormstrup (Denmark)

Martin Sondergaard, Anders Nielsen, Christian Skov, Henrik Baktoft, Kasper Reitzel, Theis Kragh, Thomas Alexander Davidson

Summary: Temporary summer stratification is a common but easily overlooked phenomenon in shallow lakes. In this study, we used high frequency measurements and monitoring to investigate the dynamics of temporary stratification in Lake Ormstrup, Denmark. The results showed that temporary stratification occurred multiple times each summer, but its duration varied between years.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

How on Earth did that get there? Natural and human vectors of aquatic macrophyte global distribution

Tatiana Lobato-de Magalhaes, Kevin Murphy, Andrey Efremov, Thomas A. Davidson, Eugenio Molina-Navarro, Kevin A. Wood, Julissa Tapia-Grimaldo, Deborah Hofstra, Hui Fu, Ileana Ortegon-Aznar

Summary: This study examined the distributional drivers of 3,499 macrophyte species on a global scale. It found that most species are endemic to a single ecozone and lack adaptations for long-distance dispersal. Natural factors such as climate and migratory birds influence native species, while introduced species are influenced by climate and longitude. Ancient vicariance events and recent climate change also affect a few species.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Assessing the effectiveness of potential best management practices for science-informed decision support at the watershed scale: The case of the Mar Menor coastal lagoon, Spain

Adrian Lopez-Ballesteros, Dennis Trolle, Raghavan Srinivasan, Javier Senent-Aparicio

Summary: Coastal lagoons, such as the Mar Menor in Spain, are highly vulnerable to pollution from human activities. This study used the SWAT model to analyze potential solutions for the environmental degradation of the Mar Menor lagoon. The combination of best management practices, including vegetative filter strips and contour farming, showed the most effective results in reducing nutrient and sediment loads.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Manure Acidification and Air Cleaners for Ammonia Abatement: A Holistic Assessment of the Costs and Effects on Terrestrial, Freshwater and Marine Ecosystems

Camilla Geels, Steen Gyldenkaerne, Tavs Nyord, Hans Estrup Andersen, Eugenio Molina-Navarro, Dennis Trolle, Hans Thodsen, Jesper L. Bak, Maria Theresia Konrad, Berit Hasler, Kaj M. Hansen, Jesper H. Christensen, Karen Timmermann

Summary: Manure acidification is introduced to reduce NH3 emissions and protect environments, but if fertilizer application rate is not adjusted, it may lead to nitrogen leaching and harm to ecosystems.

AGRONOMY-BASEL (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Modelling the impact of the Nordic Bioeconomy Pathways and climate change on water quantity and quality in a Danish River Basin

M. V. Carstensen, E. Molina-Navarro, F. Hashemi, B. Kronvang, K. Bieger

Summary: A societal transformation towards bio-economy in Nordic countries will have extensive implications for land use. The study used the Nordic Bio-economic Pathways (NBPs) and the SWAT model to simulate the effect of different scenarios on land use and water quality. The results showed that only the sustainability-first pathway could achieve the reduction target for total nitrogen loads in the River Odense catchment, while other pathways had varying impacts on nitrogen loads.

CATENA (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A century of nitrogen dynamics in agricultural watersheds of Denmark

Benoit Dessirier, Gitte Blicher-Mathiesen, Hans Estrup Andersen, Bo Gustafsson, Baerbel Muller-Karulis, Kimberly Van Meter, Nandita B. Basu, Christoph Humborg

Summary: Intensive agriculture is associated with increased nitrogen loads and negative effects on aquatic ecosystems. This study used detailed land use and agricultural statistics to examine nitrogen surpluses in three agriculture-dominated watersheds in Denmark. The findings suggest that reducing agricultural surpluses can have a significant positive impact on water quality.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

EUSEDcollab: a network of data from European catchments to monitor net soil erosion by water

Francis Matthews, Gert Verstraeten, Pasquale Borrelli, Matthias Vanmaercke, Jean Poesen, An Steegen, Aurore Degre, Belen Carceles Rodriguez, Charles Bielders, Christine Franke, Claire Alary, David Zumr, Edouard Patault, Estela Nadal-Romero, Ewa Smolska, Feliciana Licciardello, Gilles Swerts, Hans Thodsen, Javier Casali, Javier Eslava, Jean-Baptiste Richet, Jean-Francois Ouvry, Joaquim Farguell, Jolanta Swiechowicz, Joao Pedro Nunes, Lai Ting Pak, Leonidas Liakos, Miguel A. Campo-Bescos, Miroslaw Zelazny, Morgan Delaporte, Nathalie Pineux, Nathan Henin, Nejc Bezak, Noemi Lana-Renault, Ourania Tzoraki, Rafael Gimenez, Tailin Li, Victor Hugo Duran Zuazo, Vincenzo Bagarello, Vincenzo Pampalone, Vito Ferro, Xavier Ubeda, Panos Panagos

Summary: As a network of researchers, we have released an open-access database called EUSEDcollab, which contains time series records of water discharge and suspended sediment yield collected from small to medium sized catchments in Europe. EUSEDcollab was compiled to address the lack of open-access data at relevant scales for research on runoff, soil erosion, and sediment delivery. The database includes data from multiple sources that have been harmonized into a common time series and metadata structure. It covers over 1600 catchment years of data from 245 catchments across ten European countries, with temporal resolutions of event, daily, and monthly. The database focuses on small to medium sized catchment drainage areas and is applicable for soil erosion research. We have released this database with the aim of fostering collaboration and knowledge exchange through the European Union Soil Observatory (EUSO).

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Water Resources

SWAT soil moisture assessment under Mediterranean conditions: An intercomparison analysis in the Henares basin (Spain)

Jose Martinez-Fernandez, Eugenio Molina-Navarro, Angel Gonzalez-Zamora, Alejandro Sanchez-Gomez, Laura Almendra-Martin

Summary: This study assessed the SWAT soil moisture in the Henares River Basin under Mediterranean conditions for the first time. Modeling and remote sensing products were used as references, and the evaluation results showed satisfactory performances. The findings indicate that producing reliable SWAT soil moisture databases can increase the availability of suitable soil moisture series worldwide.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY-REGIONAL STUDIES (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Streamflow components and climate change: Lessons learnt and energy implications after hydrological modeling experiences in catchments with a Mediterranean climate

Alejandro Sanchez-Gomez, Silvia Martinez-Perez, Sylvain Leduc, Antonio Sastre-Merlin, Eugenio Molina-Navarro

Summary: Sustainable water management needs to consider the impact of climate change on water resources. This study used hydrological modeling to assess the climate change effects on three basins in Mediterranean climate regions and discussed the potential implications for energy production. The results show that streamflow reduction is expected by the end of the century, with significant decreases in groundwater contribution, posing challenges for water resource management and energy planning.

ENERGY REPORTS (2023)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Incorporating physically-based water temperature predictions into the National water model framework

Jeffrey Wade, Christa Kelleher, Barret L. Kurylyk

Summary: This study developed a physically-based water temperature model coupled with the National Water Model (NWM) to assess the potential for water temperature prediction to be incorporated into the NWM at the continental scale. By evaluating different model configurations of increasing complexity, the study successfully simulated hourly water temperatures in the forested headwaters of H.J. Andrews Experimental Forest in Oregon, USA, providing a basis for integrating water temperature simulation with predictions from the NWM.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Improving the statistical reliability of river model predictions via simple state adjustments

Shaun SH. Kim, Lucy A. Marshall, Justin D. Hughes, Lynn Seo, Julien Lerat, Ashish Sharma, Jai Vaze

Summary: A major challenge in hydrologic modelling is producing reliable uncertainty estimates outside of calibration periods. This research addresses the challenge by improving model structures and error models to more reliably estimate uncertainty. The combination of the RBS model and SPUE produces statistically reliable predictions and shows better matching performance in tests.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Class3Dp: A supervised classifier of vegetation species from point clouds

Juan Pedro Carbonell-Rivera, Javier Estornell, Luis Angel Ruiz, Pablo Crespo-Peremarch, Jaime Almonacid-Caballer

Summary: This study presents Class3Dp, a software for classifying vegetation species in colored point clouds. The software utilizes geometric, spectral, and neighborhood features along with machine learning methods to classify the point cloud, allowing for the recognition of species composition in an ecosystem.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A comparison of numerical schemes for the GPU-accelerated simulation of variably-saturated groundwater flow

Zhi Li, Daniel Caviedes-Voullieme, Ilhan Oezgen-Xian, Simin Jiang, Na Zheng

Summary: The optimal strategy for solving the Richards equation numerically depends on the specific problem, particularly when using GPUs. This study investigates the parallel performance of four numerical schemes on both CPUs and GPUs. The results show that the scaling of Richards solvers on GPUs is influenced by various factors. Compared to CPUs, parallel simulations on GPUs exhibit significant variation in scaling across different code sections, with poorly-scaled components potentially impacting overall performance. Nonetheless, using GPUs can greatly enhance computational speed, especially for large-scale problems.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

ANDROMEDE - A software platform for optical surface velocity measurements

Ludovic Cassan, Leo Pujol, Paul Lonca, Romain Guibert, Helene Roux, Olivier Mercier, Dominique Courret, Sylvain Richard, Pierre Horgue

Summary: Methods and algorithms for measuring stream surface velocities have been continuously developed over the past five years to adapt to specific flow typologies. The free software ANDROMEDE allows easy use and comparison of these methods with image processing capabilities designed for measurements in natural environments and with unmanned aerial vehicles. The validation of the integrated algorithms is presented on three case studies that represent the targeted applications: the study of currents for eco-hydraulics, the measurement of low water flows and the diagnosis of hydraulic structures. The field measurements are in very good agreement with the optical measurements and demonstrate the usefulness of the tool for rapid flow diagnosis for all the intended applications.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Uncovering heterogeneous effects in computational models for sustainable decision-making

Mariia Kozlova, Robert J. Moss, Julian Scott Yeomans, Jef Caers

Summary: This paper introduces a framework for quantitative sensitivity analysis using the SimDec visualization method, and tests its effectiveness on decision-making problems. The framework captures critical information in the presence of heterogeneous effects, and enhances its practicality by introducing a formal definition and classification of heterogeneous effects.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Inclusive simulation game development to enhance Florida research and management: Cedar Key oyster fishery

Chad R. Palmer, Denis Valle, Edward V. Camp, Wendy-Lin Bartels, Martha C. Monroe

Summary: Simulation games have been used in natural resource management for education and communication purposes, but not for data collection. This research introduces a new design process which involves stakeholders and emphasizes usability, relevance, and credibility testing criteria. The result is a finalized simulation game for future research.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Numerical analysis of the abiotic formation and distribution of the iron curtain in subterranean estuaries

Tao Wang, Chenming Zhang, Ye Ma, Harald Hofmann, Congrui Li, Zicheng Zhao

Summary: This study used numerical modeling to investigate the formation process of iron curtains under different freshwater and seawater conditions. It was found that Fe(OH)3 accumulates on the freshwater side, while the precipitation is inhibited on the seaward side due to high H+ concentrations. These findings enhance our understanding of iron transformation and distribution in subterranean estuaries.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Wildland fire mid-story: A generative modeling approach for representative fuels

Grant Hutchings, James Gattiker, Braden Scherting, Rodman R. Linn

Summary: Computational models for understanding and predicting fire in wildland and managed lands are becoming increasingly impactful. This paper addresses the characterization and population of mid-story fuels, which are not easily observable through traditional survey or remote sensing. The authors present a methodology to populate the mid-story using a generative model for fuel placement, which can be calibrated based on limited observation datasets or expert guidance. The connection of terrestrial LiDAR as the observations used to calibrate the generative model is emphasized. Code for the methods in this paper is provided.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

IMDLIB: An open-source library for retrieval, processing and spatiotemporal exploratory assessments of gridded meteorological observation datasets over India

Saswata Nandi, Pratiman Patel, Sabyasachi Swain

Summary: IMDLIB is an open-source Python library that simplifies the retrieval and processing of gridded meteorological data from IMD, enhancing data accessibility and facilitating hydro-climatic research and analysis.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Multiple equidistant belt technique for width function estimation through a two-segmented-distance strategy

Pengfei Wu, Jintao Liu, Meiyan Feng, Hu Liu

Summary: In this paper, a new flow distance algorithm called D infinity-TLI is proposed, which accurately estimates flow distance and width function using a two-segment-distance strategy and triangulation with linear interpolation method. The evaluation results show that D infinity-TLI outperforms existing algorithms and has a low mean absolute relative error.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2024)