Transplant center variability in utilizing nonstandard donors and its impact on the transplantation of patients with lower MELD scores

There is a subset of patients with lower MELD scores who are at substantial risk of waitlist mortality. In order to transplant such patients, transplant centers must utilize nonstandard donors (eg, living donors, donation after circulatory death), which are traditionally offered to those patients who are not at the top of the waitlist. We used Organ Procurement and Transplantation data to evaluate center-level and region-level variability in the utilization of nonstandard donors and its impact on MELD at transplant among adult liver-alone non-status 1 patients transplanted from April 1, 2020, to September 30, 2022. The center-level variability in the utilization of nonstandard donors was 4-fold greater than the center-level variability in waitlisting practices (waitlistings with a MELD score of <20). While there was a moderate correlation between center-level waitlisting and transplantation of patients with a MELD score of <20 (p = 0.58), there was a strong correlation between center-level utilization of nonstandard donors and center-level transplantation of patients with a MELD score of <20 (p = 0.75). This strong correlation between center-level utilization of non-standard donors and center-level transplantation of patients with a MELD score of <20 was limited to regions 2, 4, 5, 9, and 11. Transplant centers that utilize more nonstandard donors are more likely to successfully transplant patients at lower MELD scores. Public reporting of these data could benefit patients, caregivers, and referring providers, and be used to help maximize organ utilization.

Automated summary

There is a subset of patients with lower MELD scores who are at risk of waitlist mortality. The utilization of nonstandard donors varies among transplant centers, and centers that use more nonstandard donors are more likely to successfully transplant patients with lower MELD scores. This information can be used to improve organ utilization and benefit patients, caregivers, and referring providers.