Newly graduated nurses' stress, coping, professional identity and work locus of control: Results of a cross-sectional study in Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taipei

Aim The study aimed to explore and compare stress, coping, professional identity and work locus of control of new graduate nurses among Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taipei. Background The transition from a student to a staff nurse role is recognized as a stressful experience and can be a rough journey. Many newly graduated nurses find it challenging to cope with their new roles in their first few months. Methods A cross-sectional research was used in the study. This study was completed in Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taipei with newly graduated nurses working in hospitals. A total of 591 graduate nurses who had worked within 1 year in hospitals were recruited using convenient sampling. Data were collected using a structured questionnaire, including demographics, the occupational stress scale, the Chinese trait coping style questionnaire, the nurse professional identity scale and the work locus of control scale (Chinese version). Results The newly graduated nurses in Shanghai had significantly lower (p < 0.05) work stress score (2.65 +/- 0.67) compared with their counterparts in Hong Kong (2.99 +/- 0.69) and Taipei (2.94 +/- 0.60). Newly graduated nurses in Shanghai tended to choose positive coping to deal with stressful situations, whereas those in Hong Kong would be more likely to adopt negative attitudes (p < 0.05). The newly graduated nurses in Taipei had the lowest level of professional identity (3.25 +/- 0.55, p < 0.05), and their work control tended to be external (46.13 +/- 6.20). In contrast, those in Shanghai (52.75 +/- 6.04) and Hong Kong (59.41 +/- 7.29) tended to be controlled internally. Conclusions The study findings revealed the differences among newly graduated nurses in Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taipei with their level of stress, coping, professional identity and work locus of control. Proper leadership, mentoring for newly graduated nurses, and emphasis on first aid nursing training, emotional management and management of stress in newly graduated nurse transition programmes were suggested. Implications for Nursing Management By comparing the results in the three regions, we recommend that nursing managers promote the right leadership style. In addition to coaching, nursing managers can assign additional mentors to newly graduated nurses to help them supplement their clinical knowledge and skills with psychological support. These mentors can come from senior nurses or nursing managers working on less demanding tasks. In addition to the existing post transfer training programmes, new graduate nurses should also focus on emergency nursing training, emotional management training and stress management training.

Automated summary

This study aimed to explore and compare stress, coping, professional identity, and work locus of control among new graduate nurses in Shanghai, Hong Kong, and Taipei. The results showed that newly graduated nurses in Shanghai had lower work stress and tended to choose positive coping strategies. In contrast, those in Hong Kong were more likely to adopt negative attitudes, and those in Taipei had the lowest level of professional identity and tended to have external work control.