4.7 Article

Benchmarking eleven biodiversity indicators based on environmental DNA surveys: More diverse functional traits and evolutionary lineages inside marine reserves

期刊

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY
卷 59, 期 11, 页码 2803-2813

出版社

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2664.14276

关键词

bioindicator; crypto-benthic fish; elasmobranch; environmental DNA metabarcoding; marine protected areas; Mediterranean Sea; monitoring

资金

  1. ANR LabCom DiagADNe [ANR-20-LCV1-0008]
  2. Office de l'Environnement de la Corse
  3. Agence de l'Eau RMC
  4. Region Occitanie
  5. Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR) [ANR-20-LCV1-0008] Funding Source: Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR)

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Marine-protected areas (MPAs) have emerged as powerful conservation tools, but their impact on biodiversity is still uncertain. A study in the Mediterranean Sea found that MPAs have a positive effect on functional and phylogenic diversity, as well as the ratio between demerso-pelagic and benthic species richness. However, total fish richness responded negatively to protection.
To mitigate the ongoing threats to coastal ecosystems, and the biodiversity erosion they are causing, marine-protected areas (MPAs) have emerged as powerful and widespread conservation tools. Strictly no-take MPAs, also called marine reserves, undeniably promote fish biomass and density, but it remains unclear how biodiversity responds to protection. Identifying which facets of biodiversity respond to protection is critical for the management of MPAs and the development of relevant conservation strategies towards the achievement of biodiversity targets. We collected 99 environmental DNA (eDNA) samples inside and outside nine marine reserves in the Mediterranean Sea to assess the effect of protection on 11 biodiversity indicators based on fish traits, phylogeny and vulnerability to fishing. We controlled for the effect of environmental heterogeneity (habitat, bathymetry, productivity, temperature and accessibility) using a principal component analysis, and for spatial autocorrelation due to potential unmeasured factors. We found a positive and significant effect of protection on only 3 out of 11 indicators: functional and phylogenic diversity but also the ratio between demerso-pelagic and benthic species richness. Rather, total fish richness responded significantly and negatively to protection. We did not detect any significant effect of protection on threatened and elasmobranch species richness, probably due to their large home range compared to the size of Mediterranean marine reserves. Synthesis and applications: Our findings highlight the importance of looking beyond the mere number of species to fully depict and understand the effect of marine reserves on biodiversity and evaluate the effectiveness of conservation measures. Rather, we propose a dashboard of three eDNA-based indicators that can provide an early signal of ecosystem deterioration or recovery. eDNA metabarcoding offers a powerful tool to supply site-specific and standardized taxonomic-, phylogenetic- and trait-based biodiversity assessments, in complement to other classical techniques, such as visual censuses or video surveys, able to estimate species abundance but also individual life-stage and size.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Similar trait structure and vulnerability in pelagic fish faunas on two remote island systems

Madeline Steinberg, Jean-Baptiste Juhel, Virginie Marques, Clara Peron, Regis Hocde, Andrea Polanco Fernandez, Loic Pellissier, Sebastien Villeger, David Mouillot, Tom B. Letessier

Summary: This study explores the relationship between pelagic fish species diversity and functional diversity in two oceanic island systems. The results show that although there are differences in species composition, the communities in both locations share a similar functional structure and resilience potential.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Extent of introgressive hybridization in the Hermann's tortoise (Testudo hermanni hermanni) from the south of France

N. Bech, D. Nivelle, S. Caron, J. M. Ballouard, V Arnal, D. Arsovski, A. Golubovic, X. Bonnet, C. Montgelard

Summary: The Western subspecies of Hermann's tortoise is under threat from various factors including habitat loss, wildfires, and illegal harvesting. Furthermore, there is a risk of hybridization with an introduced subspecies from Eastern Europe. Genetic analysis revealed that around 18% of tortoises in the Var district of France are hybrids between the two subspecies. While hybridization can increase genetic diversity, it also poses a threat to the integrity of the Western subspecies. Conservation efforts should focus on communication and education to limit further hybridization, and accurate genetic identification is crucial for translocation programs. The impact of hybridization on populations facing rapid global changes and depressed genetic diversity needs further investigation.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF WILDLIFE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Biology

Cross-ocean patterns and processes in fish biodiversity on coral reefs through the lens of eDNA metabarcoding

Laetitia Mathon, Virginie Marques, David Mouillot, Camille Albouy, Marco Andrello, Florian Baletaud, Giomar H. Borrero-Perez, Tony Dejean, Graham J. Edgar, Jonathan Grondin, Pierre-Edouard Guerin, Regis Hocde, Jean-Baptiste Juhel, Eva Kadarusman, Eva Maire, Gael Mariani, Matthew McLean, Andrea Polanco F., Laurent D. Pouyaud, Rick Stuart-Smith, Hagi Yulia Sugeha, Alice Valentini, Laurent B. Vigliola, Indra Vimono, Loic Pellissier

Summary: Using environmental DNA metabarcoding, researchers have found that coral reefs have higher fish biodiversity than previously thought. This method also revealed hidden patterns and provided a fresh perspective on the assembly rules of fish communities on reefs.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Estimating the extended and hidden species diversity from environmental DNA in hyper-diverse regions

Jean-Baptiste Juhel, Virginie Marques, Rizkie Satriya Utama, Indra Bayu Vimono, Hagi Yulia Sugeha, Kadarusman Kadarusman, Christophe Cochet, Tony Dejean, Andrew Hoey, David Mouillot, Regis Hocde, Laurent Pouyaud

Summary: Species inventories are crucial for assessing biodiversity patterns and human impact. However, traditional visual-based inventories are often incomplete, which can be addressed by using environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding. In this study, a new framework combining eDNA surveys and sampling-theory methods was proposed to estimate species richness in under-sampled and hyper-diverse regions. The framework was applied to coastal fish diversity in the coral triangle, where eDNA metabarcoding recorded numerous species that were not detected by visual surveys. The findings highlight the potential of eDNA to expand regional inventories and guide conservation strategies.

ECOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Ecological indicators based on quantitative eDNA metabarcoding: the case of marine reserves

Loic Sanchez, Emilie Boulanger, Veronique Arnal, Pierre Boissery, Alicia Dalongeville, Tony Dejean, Julie Deter, Nacim Guellati, Florian Holon, Jean-Baptiste Juhel, Philippe Lenfant, Fabien Leprieur, Alice Valentini, Stephanie Manel, David Mouillot

Summary: In the context of marine biodiversity erosion, this study proposes a combination of metabarcoding and quantitative polymerase chain reaction to measure the quantity of eDNA molecules per species and develop a new ecological indicator. The study demonstrates that the proposed indicator, known as DeBRa, can reliably reflect human pressure on fish species and is not affected by habitat or environmental variations.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2022)

Article Ecology

Ecological indices from environmental DNA to contrast coastal reefs under different anthropogenic pressures

Andrea Polanco F, Conor Waldock, Thomas Keggin, Virginie Marques, Romane Rozanski, Alice Valentini, Tony Dejean, Stephanie Manel, Mark Vermeij, Camille Albouy, Loic Pellissier

Summary: Human activities can have negative impacts on the quality of coral reefs, resulting in a decline in fish species richness and functional diversity, as well as erosion of ecosystem services. Environmental DNA metabarcoding is a rapid method for assessing marine biodiversity, which can meet the demand for ecosystem health indices in management. By combining taxonomic information from sequenced eDNA with functional traits and phylogenetic positions, various ecological indices describing ecosystem functioning can be generated. Through studying two contrasting coastal areas in Curaçao, we found that despite no marked difference in species richness, the area near the city had higher phylogenetic diversity, while the more isolated reef had higher functional diversity.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Review Ecology

The global depth range of marine fishes and their genetic coverage for environmental DNA metabarcoding

Agnes Duhamet, Camille Albouy, Virginie Marques, Stephanie Manel, David Mouillot

Summary: The study examines the genetic coverage and distribution of deep-sea fish species using environmental DNA metabarcoding. The results show that there is a need for more data collection on deep-endemic species. This method shows promise for better understanding and conserving marine biodiversity in the deep-sea.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Ecology

Delimiting species in the taxonomically challenging orchid section Pseudophrys: Bayesian analyses of genetic and phenotypic data

Nina Joffard, Bruno Buatois, Veronique Arnal, Errol Vela, Claudine Montgelard, Bertrand Schatz

Summary: Accurate species delimitation is crucial for biodiversity conservation. This study utilized an integrative taxonomic approach to investigate species boundaries within a group of Pseudophrys taxa from France, using genetic, morphometric, and chemical data. The integration of genetic and phenotypic data significantly improved the accuracy of species delimitation, highlighting the potential of this approach for taxonomic revisions in other orchid groups.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

An environmental DNA assay for the detection of Critically Endangered angel sharks (Squatina spp.)

Nadia Faure, Stephanie Manel, Bastien Mace, Veronique Arnal, Nacim Guellati, Florian Holon, Adele Barroil, Franck Pichot, Jean-Jacques Riutort, Gianni Insacco, Bruno Zava, David Mouillot, Julie Deter

Summary: The three sympatric angel shark species in the Mediterranean are all listed as Critically Endangered. This study introduces an eDNA assay that can detect and distinguish these species. The presence of Squatina squatina in north-western Corsica was confirmed using this assay. The results can help with angel shark conservation and future population identification, but further validation is needed for the other two species.

AQUATIC CONSERVATION-MARINE AND FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Ecology

The distribution of coastal fish eDNA sequences in the Anthropocene

Laetitia Mathon, Virginie Marques, Stephanie Manel, Camille Albouy, Marco Andrello, Emilie Boulanger, Julie Deter, Regis Hocde, Fabien Leprieur, Tom B. Letessier, Nicolas Loiseau, Eva Maire, Alice Valentini, Laurent Vigliola, Florian Baletaud, Sandra Bessudo, Tony Dejean, Nadia Faure, Pierre-Edouard Guerin, Meret Jucker, Jean-Baptiste Juhel, Kadarusman, Andrea F. Polanco, Laurent Pouyaud, Dario Schworer, Kirsten F. Thompson, Marc Troussellier, Hagi Yulia Sugeha, Laure Velez, Xiaowei Zhang, Wenjun Zhong, Loic Pellissier, David Mouillot

Summary: In this study, environmental DNA analysis was used to investigate the relationship between fish biodiversity and environmental as well as socio-economic factors. The results showed a strong correlation between coastal fish biodiversity and environmental factors worldwide, while also revealing a negative correlation with human dependence on marine ecosystems. Additionally, the study found that a diversity index based on DNA sequences could reliably assess phylogenetic and functional diversity.

GLOBAL ECOLOGY AND BIOGEOGRAPHY (2023)

Meeting Abstract Pharmacology & Pharmacy

The role of RNA modification m1A in Alzheimers Disease

M. Joerg, C. Lietz, M. Kristen, F. Pichot, N. Kreim, N. Ruffini, S. Gerber, Y. Motorin, M. Helm, K. Friedland

NAUNYN-SCHMIEDEBERGS ARCHIVES OF PHARMACOLOGY (2023)

暂无数据