Nitrogen-enriched discharges from a highly managed watershed intensify red tide (Karenia brevis) blooms in southwest Florida

Karenia brevis blooms on Florida's Gulf Coast severely affect regional ecosystems, coastal economies, and public health, and formulating effective management and policy strategies to address these blooms requires an advanced understanding of the processes driving them. Recent research suggests that natural processes explain offshore bloom initiation and shoreward transport, while anthropogenic nutrient inputs may intensify blooms upon arrival along the coast. However, past correlation studies have failed to detect compelling evidence linking coastal blooms to watershed covariates indicative of anthropogenic inputs. We explain why correlation is neither necessary nor sufficient to demonstrate a causal relationship-i.e., a persistent pattern of interaction governed by deterministic rules-and pursue an empirical investigation leveraging the fact that systematic temporal patterns may reveal systematic cause-and-effect relationships. Using time series derived from in-situ sample data, we applied singular spectrum analysis-a non-parametric spectral decomposition method-to recover deterministic signals in the dynamics of K. brevis blooms and upstream water quality and discharge covariates in the Charlotte Harbor region between 2012 and 2021. Next, we applied causal analysis methods based on chaos theory-i.e., convergent cross-mapping and S-mapping-to detect and quantify persistent, state-dependent interaction regimes between coastal blooms and watershed covariates. We discovered that nitrogen-enriched Caloosahatchee River discharges have consistently intensified K. brevis blooms to varying degrees over time. River discharge was typically most influential at the earliest stages of blooms, while total nitrogen concentrations exerted the strongest influence during blooms' growth/maintenance stages. These results indicate that discharges and nitrogen inputs influence blooms through distinct yet synergistic causal mechanisms. Additionally, we traced this anthropogenic influence upstream to Lake Okeechobee (which discharges to the Caloosahatchee River) and the Kissimmee River basin (which drains into Lake Okeechobee), suggesting that watershed-scale nutrient management and modifications to Lake Okeechobee discharge protocols will likely be necessary to mitigate coastal blooms.

Automated summary

Karenia brevis blooms have severe impacts on Florida's Gulf Coast ecosystems, coastal economies, and public health. Research shows that river discharge and nitrogen inputs influence the blooms through different causal mechanisms, suggesting the need for watershed-scale nutrient management and modifications to discharge protocols to mitigate the blooms.