4.2 Article

Evaluating the Impact of Systematic Error on the Estimation Performance of a Length-Based Spawning Potential Ratio

期刊

MARINE AND COASTAL FISHERIES
卷 13, 期 6, 页码 665-678

出版社

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/mcf2.10185

关键词

-

资金

  1. National Key R&D Programs of China [2019YFD0901404, 2019YFD0901401]
  2. National Natural Science Foundation of China [NSFC 31902372]
  3. China Scholarship Council [202008967001]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

This study conducted simulation-estimation analysis to evaluate the performance of a length-based data-limited method for LBSPR and found that the estimation performance was sensitive to observation error, life history types, and selectivities. It emphasizes the need to carefully evaluate the effectiveness of length-based data-limited stock assessment on a species-by-species basis when observation error is present.
During recent years, there has been growing efforts in methodological development for length-based approaches to meet an increasing demand for science-based management of data-limited fisheries. Numerous simulation-estimation analyses have been conducted to evaluate and compare the performance of length-based data-limited methods under various conditions, but none of them have evaluated the impact of observation error on the estimation performance. In this study, a simulation-estimation analysis was conducted to evaluate the performance of a length-based data-limited method for length-based spawning potential ratio (LBSPR) across a variety of cases in relation to systematic observation errors, life history types, and selectivities. The results showed that the estimation performance of LBSPR was sensitive to all types of the cases above. In particular, a disproportionately high frequency of small fish in the length composition could cause larger deviations in estimates of stock status compared with cases in which large fish are overrepresented. Partial dependence plots from the general linear model show how factors such as systematic changes in bias in length composition data affect the estimation of LBSPR. Our study suggests that the effectiveness of length-based data-limited stock assessment should be carefully evaluated on a species-by-species basis when observation error, such as systematic error in length-frequency data, is present.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.2
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Ecology

Feeding habits and trophic niche of rainbow runner Elagatis bipinnulata in the western and central Pacific Ocean

Shaoqin Wang, Xuefang Wang, Liuxiong Xu, Siquan Tian

Summary: Possible changes in feeding habits and trophic niche width of rainbow runner were investigated using stomach content analysis and stable isotope analysis. The results indicated that different size classes of rainbow runner may have different feeding ecology and prey preferences.

ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGY OF FISHES (2022)

Article Fisheries

Quantifying bycatch risk factors for the Chinese distant water fishery

Meng Xia, Tom Carruthers, Richard Kindong, Libin Dai, Zhe Geng, Xiaojie Dai, Feng Wu

Summary: Mitigating bycatch of non-target fish species is important in fisheries management. This study analyzed Chinese tuna longline fishery data to build models for assessing bycatch rates and ratios. Results showed that the Pacific Ocean had lower bycatch rates and ratios compared to the Indian and Atlantic Oceans. Fishing in open oceans also reduced the risk of high bycatch ratios. Specific fishing grounds were recommended for different tuna species. Setting fishing gear deeper than 500m was found to lower bycatch rates and ratios.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Fisheries

Diagnosis of the Senegalese Marine Fisheries Profile during the Last Two Decades: A Perspective toward Fisheries Management

Ousmane Sarr, Richard Kindong, Siquan Tian, Fambaye Ngom Sow, Momar Ka, Ousmane Niang Seye

Summary: The coasts of Senegal have abundant fishery resources due to the frequent occurrence of intense upwelling systems. Fishing is a vital activity for Senegal, playing an important role in the country's socioeconomic plans and food security. This review provides an update on the Senegalese marine fisheries from 1999 to 2018, discussing the political environment and management measures taken to protect exploited species. The study reveals the dynamic and significant contribution of the Senegalese fishing sectors to the country's economic growth. However, it also highlights increasing catches, economic value, and illegal fishing practices in the marine fisheries sector. The review identifies the main challenges faced by the fisheries sector and suggests recommendations to address them, including the application of new assessment methods suitable for data-poor fisheries.

REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

How Well Do 'Catch-Only' Assessment Models Capture Catch Time Series Start Years and Default Life History Prior Values? A Preliminary Stock Assessment of the South Atlantic Ocean Blue Shark Using a Catch-Based Model

Richard Kindong, Feng Wu, Siquan Tian, Ousmane Sarr

Summary: Blue shark species have been declining due to overfishing, and their stock status was evaluated using a new assessment model (CMSY++) in the South Atlantic. The results indicate that the blue shark stock may be witnessing overfishing and is being overfished. The use of different catch time series and priors had varying effects on the output results of the model.

ANIMALS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Occurrence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the seafood from an important fishing area in the East China Sea and a comparison between seafood from different origins

Wang Qian, Lu Dequan, Xiong Yiran, Peng Fei, Li Juan-ying, Wu Feng, Chu Yanping, Sun Ruihua, Tian Siquan

Summary: This study analyzed the levels of PAHs in various coastal marine seafood in the Wentai fishing area and identified the sources of these PAHs. The results showed that the PAHs in the seafood were mainly derived from fossil fuel sources. The study also assessed the behavior of PAHs in the food chain and their association with dietary risk. It was found that the area had a relatively short food chain and higher trophic magnification factors. The highest carcinogenic risk was associated with consuming yellow croaker. Therefore, it is necessary to control the unintentional use of fossil fuels and optimize the energy structure in the nearby terrestrial area to reduce dietary risk.

ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND ASSESSMENT (2022)

Article Fisheries

Performance evaluation of catch-only methods when catch data are misreported

Libin Dai, Cameron T. Hodgdon, Luoliang Xu, Jiaqi Wang, Siquan Tian, Yong Chen

Summary: Catch-only methods (COMs) based on catch histories are commonly used in fisheries management, but they tend to bias the estimates of stock status due to potential catch errors. This study evaluated the performance of two types of COMs, Catch-MSY and catch-only boosted regression trees, and found that both methods were influenced by catch errors and showed poor performance in correctly identifying stock biomass status. The study suggests that improving catch quality would not improve the estimation of COMs and does not recommend their application in fisheries management.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

Standardized catch per unit effort and size compositions of Atlantic bonito, Sarda sarda (Bloch, 1793), harvested by artisanal fisheries in the Senegalese Exclusive Economic Zone (SEEZ)

Ousmane Sarr, Richard Kindong, Fambaye Ngom Sow, Siquan Tian

Summary: Atlantic bonito, a valuable small tuna species, is heavily exploited in the Senegalese Exclusive Economic Zone by artisanal fisheries. The commonly used gears include gillnets, purse seines, longlines, and sleeping nets. However, limited information is available on the catch per unit effort (CPUE) and size selectivity of Atlantic bonito in the region.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

Identification of Keystone Species in Ecological Communities in the East China Sea

Yin Wang, Richard Kindong, Chunxia Gao, Jiaqi Wang

Summary: Keystone species play a crucial role in maintaining community stability and species diversity. Identifying and studying these species helps prioritize important species and enhance the understanding of community stability mechanisms. This study aimed to identify major keystone species in an important ecosystem in the East China Sea. Data from fisheries surveys conducted between 2016 and 2021 were analyzed, and Muraenesox cinereus, Leptochela gracilis, and Trichiurus lepturus were identified as keystone species based on principal component analysis. Removal analysis suggested that the loss of keystone species could negatively impact the complexity and stability of the food web in the East China Sea. Therefore, prioritizing keystone species in marine ecosystems is crucial.

FISHES (2023)

Article Engineering, Marine

Characterizing the Sound-Scattering Layer and Its Environmental Drivers in the North Equatorial Current of the Central and Western Pacific Ocean

Tianji Gao, Jianfeng Tong, Minghua Xue, Zhenhong Zhu, Yue Qiu, Richard Kindong, Qiuyun Ma, Jun Li

Summary: In this study, acoustic survey data collected by the Songhang research vessel in 2022 were used to analyze the spatiotemporal factors and environmental influences on the sound-scattering layer (SSL) in the North Equatorial Current (NEC) warm pool region of the Central and Western Pacific Ocean. It was found that the SSL in this region is primarily distributed in shallow waters above 100 m and consists of micronekton and zooplankton with diel vertical migration behavior. Factors such as temperature, current velocity, turbidity, solar altitude angle, longitude, and latitude were identified as important in influencing the SSL distribution. The results of this study have implications for long-term studies on ecological changes and their impact on micronekton and zooplankton distribution.

JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Fisheries

Stock Assessment of Chub Mackerel (Scomber japonicus) in the Northwest Pacific Using a Multi-Model Approach

Kai Cai, Richard Kindong, Qiuyun Ma, Siquan Tian

Summary: This study aims to provide a wider choice of potential models for the stock assessment of Chub mackerel in the Northwest Pacific. The results indicate that the Chub mackerel stock may be slightly overfished, but could also be healthy. Further projection is required for specific catch limit setting. Management efforts should focus on maintaining or slightly reducing fishing effort and accurately estimating input parameters.

FISHES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Length-Based Assessment Methods for the Conservation of a Pelagic Shark, Carcharhinus falciformis from the Tropical Pacific Ocean

Richard Kindong, Ousmane Sarr, Feng Wu, Siquan Tian

Summary: The silky shark is heavily exploited in tuna fisheries worldwide, but little is known about its life history and population status. This study used length-based data-limited methods to estimate the status of the tropical Pacific silky shark population, indicating a potential risk of further decline and overfishing. Immediate intensification of monitoring programs is necessary for the development of efficient management and conservation plans in the Pacific Ocean.

FISHES (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Life history of wahoo, Acanthocybium solandri, in the Tropical Eastern Atlantic Ocean - the importance of applying a suite of methods for fisheries assessment in data-limited situations

Richard Kindong, Feng Wu, Ousmane Sarr, Libin Dai, Siquan Tian, Xiaojie Dai

Summary: Unassessed fisheries, especially non-targeted fisheries, play a critical role in food security in developing countries, but the lack of reliable data makes it difficult to assess their stocks, leading to overfishing and declining yield. This study proposes a framework for determining the life history and management of unassessed fisheries, using wahoo as a case study. It provides a comprehensive methodological approach to estimate life history parameters, evaluate biological reference points, and assess stock status.

OCEANOLOGICAL AND HYDROBIOLOGICAL STUDIES (2022)

Article Fisheries

Assessment of Coilia mystus and C. nasus in the Yangtze River Estuary, China, Using a Length-Based Approach

Lu Zhai, Zengguang Li, Yongbin Hu, Chengwei Huang, Siquan Tian, Rong Wan, Daniel Pauly

Summary: This study assessed the stock status and historical changes of Coilia mystus and C. nasus in the Yangtze River Estuary, China, and found that both species are overfished. The maximum lengths and relative biomasses have declined due to increasing fishing pressure.

FISHES (2022)

暂无数据