4.8 Article

Ethical, legal, and social issues in the Earth BioGenome Project

出版社

NATL ACAD SCIENCES
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2115859119

关键词

genomics; ELSI; EBP; ethics; biodiversity

向作者/读者索取更多资源

The Earth BioGenome Project (EBP) aims to obtain whole-genome sequences of all eukaryotic species on Earth. This paper, from the EBP's Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues (ELSI) Committee, highlights the legal, ethical, and social concerns faced by the project, including issues related to sample collection, international treaties, intellectual property, and biosecurity. The paper also discusses the ethical implications of sampling from indigenous territories, protecting endangered species, and cross-border collections. The authors conclude by providing a starting point for addressing these issues and considering ethical frameworks for future projects.
The Earth BioGenome Project (EBP) is an audacious endeavor to obtain whole-genome sequences of representatives from all eukaryotic species on Earth. In addition to the project's technical and organizational challenges, it also faces complicated ethical, legal, and social issues. This paper, from members of the EBP's Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues (ELSI) Committee, catalogs these ELSI concerns arising from EBP. These include legal issues, such as sample collection and permitting; the applicability of international treaties, such as the Convention on Biological Diversity and the Nagoya Protocol; intellectual property; sample accessioning; and biosecurity and ethical issues, such as sampling from the territories of Indigenous peoples and local communities, the protection of endangered species, and cross-border collections, among several others. We also comment on the intersection of digital sequence information and data rights. More broadly, this list of ethical, legal, and social issues for large-scale genomic sequencing projects may be useful in the consideration of ethical frameworks for future projects. While we do not-and cannot-provide simple, overarching solutions for all the issues raised here, we conclude our perspective by beginning to chart a path forward for EBP's work.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.8
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Patients' Reactions to Letters Communicating Collateral Findings of Pragmatic Clinical Trials: a National Web-Based Survey

Kevin P. Weinfurt, Juli M. Bollinger, Elizabeth May, Gail Geller, Debra J. H. Mathews, Stephanie R. Morain, Lorrie Schmid, Diane L. Bloom, Jeremy Sugarman

Summary: This study investigated the reactions of respondents to a letter communicating background collateral findings. The results indicated that the signatory and level of detail about the findings did not significantly impact people's intentions to contact their doctor. The decision of whether to include a description of the pragmatic clinical trial involves a trade-off between transparency and complexity of understanding.

JOURNAL OF GENERAL INTERNAL MEDICINE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Multilateral benefit-sharing from digital sequence information will support both science and biodiversity conservation

Amber Hartman Scholz, Jens Freitag, Christopher H. C. Lyal, Rodrigo Sara, Martha Lucia Cepeda, Ibon Cancio, Scarlett Sett, Andrew Lee Hufton, Yemisrach Abebaw, Kailash Bansal, Halima Benbouza, Hamadi Iddi Boga, Sylvain Brisse, Michael W. Bruford, Hayley Clissold, Guy Cochrane, Jonathan A. Coddington, Anne-Caroline Deletoille, Felipe Garcia-Cardona, Michelle Hamer, Raquel Hurtado-Ortiz, Douglas W. Miano, David Nicholson, Guilherme Oliveira, Carlos Ospina Bravo, Fabian Rohden, Ole Seberg, Gernot Segelbacher, Yogesh Shouche, Alejandra Sierra, Ilene Karsch-Mizrachi, Jessica da Silva, Desiree M. Hautea, Manuela da Silva, Mutsuaki Suzuki, Kassahun Tesfaye, Christian Keambou Tiambo, Krystal A. Tolley, Rajeev Varshney, Maria Mercedes Zambrano, Joerg Overmann

Summary: Open access to sequence data is crucial for biology and biodiversity research, but it has caused tension under the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). Finding a practical solution to ensure international benefit-sharing without jeopardising open sharing is a major challenge for the CBD and other UN negotiations.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Editorial Material Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Introduction

R. Michael Roberts, Harris A. Lewin

ANNUAL REVIEW OF ANIMAL BIOSCIENCES (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Voluntary workplace genomic testing: wellness benefit or Pandora's box?

Kunal Sanghavi, Betty Cohn, Anya E. R. Prince, W. Gregory Feero, Kerry A. Ryan, Kayte Spector-Bagdady, Wendy R. Uhlmann, Charles Lee, J. Scott Roberts, Debra J. H. Mathews

Summary: Consumer interest in genetic and genomic testing is growing, leading commercial vendors to expand their customer base by selling genetic testing services to employers for workplace wellness programs. The ethical, legal, and social implications of workplace genetic testing are being addressed, and it is important to develop governance based on data.

NPJ GENOMIC MEDICINE (2022)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Africa: sequence 100,000 species to safeguard biodiversity

ThankGod Echezona Ebenezer, Anne W. T. Muigai, Simplice Nouala, Bouabid Badaoui, Mark Blaxter, Alan G. Buddie, Erich D. Jarvis, Jonas Korlach, Josiah O. Kuja, Harris A. Lewin, Roksana Majewska, Ntanganedzeni Mapholi, Suresh Maslamoney, Michele Mbo'o-Tchouawou, Julian O. Osuji, Ole Seehausen, Oluwaseyi Shorinola, Christian Keambou Tiambo, Nicola Mulder, Cathrine Ziyomo, Appolinaire Djikeng

NATURE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Conservation of chromatin conformation in carnivores

Marco Corbo, Joana Damas, Madeline G. Bursell, Harris A. Lewin

Summary: This study used high throughput chromatin conformation capture (Hi-C) to investigate the evolutionary stability of chromatin conformation at the chromosomal level in 11 species from three carnivore families. The results showed that chromatin conformation is conserved during carnivore evolution and can be accurately identified through Hi-C contact maps analysis. The study also discovered significant differences in chromatin conformation for the X chromosome and the red fox genome.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2022)

Article Ecology

Evolutionary history constrains heat tolerance of native and exotic tropical Zingiberales

Georgia G. Hernandez, Timothy M. Perez, Oscar M. Vargas, W. John Kress, Ramon Molina-Bravo, Roberto A. Cordero, Jeffrey R. Seemann, Carlos Garcia-Robledo

Summary: Tropical wet forest plants usually experience stable temperatures, but tropical forests consist of various habitats with different temperatures. When exotic species are introduced to new communities, their previous adaptation to high temperatures may give them a competitive advantage, and increasing temperatures can be an environmental filter affecting community assembly. This study examines heat tolerance in Zingiberales species and finds that heat tolerance is influenced by evolutionary history and habitat, and exotic species have slightly higher heat tolerance than native species.

FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Establishment of Cryptococcus neoformans and C. gattii as certified reference materials according to the requirements of ISO 17034:2016

Aline da Silva Soares Souto, Carlos Roberto Sobrinho do Nascimento, Carla de Oliveira Rosas, Marilia Martins Nishikawa, Maria Helena Simoes Villas Boas, Manuela da Silva

Summary: The objective of this study was to establish Cryptococcus neoformans and Cryptococcus gattii as certified reference materials (CRMs) for the diagnosis of cryptococcosis. The CRMs were found to be stable and homogeneous, and their quantitative and qualitative characterization was conducted. The assigned property values and uncertainties for each CRM were determined.

ACCREDITATION AND QUALITY ASSURANCE (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

YaHS: yet another Hi-C scaffolding tool

Chenxi Zhou, Shane A. McCarthy, Richard Durbin

Summary: YaHS is a user-friendly command-line tool that constructs chromosome-scale scaffolds from Hi-C data. It requires minimal input from users (an assembly file and an alignment file), can be run with a single-line command, and provides assembly results in multiple formats, enabling rapid and accurate construction of high-quality genome assemblies.

BIOINFORMATICS (2023)

Editorial Material Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

How legislations affect new taxonomic descriptions

Manuela da Silva, Philippe Desmeth, Stephanus N. Venter, Yogesh Shouche, Andrey Yurkov

Summary: Restrictions imposed by countries like India, South Africa, or Brazil on the distribution of biological material prevent the use of strains as type material for validating or publishing prokaryotic species names. This issue extends beyond prokaryotic taxonomy and has implications for other areas of biological research.

TRENDS IN MICROBIOLOGY (2023)

Article Ethics

Policy options to facilitate cancer genomic variant data sharing: outcomes of a modified policy Delphi

Jill O. Robinson, Amira Daoud, Janis Geary, Vasiliki Rahimzadeh, Juli Bollinger, Christi J. Guerrini, Robert Cook-Deegan, Amy L. McGuire, Mary A. Majumder

Summary: Sharing cancer gene variant data and addressing issues of financial sustainability, equity, incentives, privacy/security, and data quality are crucial to advance cancer genomics. Evidence-based policy options, especially stable funding for trusted entities, can facilitate data sharing and interpretation of cancer-associated genomic variants. Expert stakeholders favored policy options focused on action by funders and were skeptical of options involving legislative actors and data resources. These findings provide valuable inputs for policymakers to enable sharing of cancer gene variant data and improve health outcomes.

JOURNAL OF LAW AND THE BIOSCIENCES (2023)

Article Ethics

Payer reimbursement practices and incentives for improving interpretation of germline genetic testing

Patricia Deverka, Janis Geary, Charles Mathews, Matan Cohen, Gillian Hooker, Mary Majumder, Zuzana Skvarkova, Robert Cook-Deegan

Summary: Germline genetic testing has shifted to multi-gene panel tests, which detect more pathogenic variants but also more variants of uncertain significance (VUSs). Data sharing among laboratories is critical to addressing the VUS problem, but barriers and lack of incentives limit contributions to the ClinVar database. Payers can play a crucial role in expanding knowledge and effectiveness of genetic testing but current policies create challenges. Mandating data sharing and incentivizing quality in payment contracts can help close knowledge gaps and improve patient outcomes.

JOURNAL OF LAW AND THE BIOSCIENCES (2023)

暂无数据