4.7 Article

A critical perspective on interpreting amplicon sequencing data in soil ecological research

期刊

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY
卷 160, 期 -, 页码 -

出版社

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.soilbio.2021.108357

关键词

Amplicon sequencing; Soil metabarcoding; Soil microorganisms; Soil microbial diversity; Soil complexity; Compositional data

资金

  1. Austrian Science Fund (FWF) DK+ program 'Microbial Nitrogen Cycling' [W1257B20]
  2. Czech Science Foun-dation [19-24309Y]
  3. MEYS [EF16_013/0001782SoWa]
  4. Czech Science Foundation [21-07275 S]
  5. European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union [819446]
  6. European Research Council (ERC) [819446] Funding Source: European Research Council (ERC)

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Marker gene amplicon sequencing is a common method in soil research, but there are technical challenges and limitations that need to be addressed with statistical and experimental approaches. Consideration of compositionality and sample replication affects the interpretation of data and statistical power in soil community analysis. Increased study reproducibility, data availability, and complementary techniques are suggested for deeper insights into microbial roles in soil ecosystems.
Microbial community analysis via marker gene amplicon sequencing has become a routine method in the field of soil research. In this perspective, we discuss technical challenges and limitations of amplicon sequencing and present statistical and experimental approaches that can help addressing the spatio-temporal complexity of soil and the high diversity of organisms therein. We illustrate the impact of compositionality on the interpretation of relative abundance data and discuss effects of sample replication on the statistical power in soil community analysis. Additionally, we argue for the need of increased study reproducibility and data availability, as well as complementary techniques for generating deeper ecological insights into microbial roles and our understanding thereof in soil ecosystems. At this stage, we call upon researchers and specialized soil journals to consider the current state of data analysis, interpretation, and availability to improve the rigor of future studies.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Agronomy

Infectivity and symbiotic efficiency of native arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi from high-input arable soils

Paula A. Buil, Jan Jansa, Alena Blazkova, Ondrej Holubik, Renata Duffkova, Martin Rozmos, David Puschel, Michala Kotianova, Martina Janouskova

Summary: This study examined the effects of native arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungal communities from conventionally managed arable soils on plant growth and nutrient uptake. The results showed that arbuscular mycorrhiza had a negative correlation with P availability, and the positive effects of mycorrhiza were more pronounced in a small subset of soils.

PLANT AND SOIL (2023)

Review Soil Science

Hyphosphere microbiome of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi: a realm of unknowns

Maede Faghihinia, Jan Jansa, Larry J. Halverson, Philip L. Staddon

Summary: The hyphosphere microbiome associated with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) plays a crucial role in soil carbon and nutrient cycling, soil food web dynamics, and plant nutrition and health. However, there is still incomplete understanding of the identities, roles, and mechanisms of interaction in the AMF hyphosphere. Innovative approaches and tools are needed to address the knowledge gaps and unresolved questions in this field.

BIOLOGY AND FERTILITY OF SOILS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Microbial responses to soil cooling might explain increases in microbial biomass in winter

Joerg Schnecker, Felix Spiegel, Yue Li, Andreas Richter, Taru Sanden, Heide Spiegel, Sophie Zechmeister-Boltenstern, Lucia Fuchslueger

Summary: In temperate, boreal and arctic soil systems, microbial biomass increases during winter and decreases in spring, potentially stabilizing soil carbon during winter. The causes of this increase, whether it is due to changes in microbial physiology or community composition, remain unclear. In a laboratory study, soil microbial communities responded strongly to cooling, with reduced growth and cell division but unchanged glucose uptake and respiration. Microbes invested glucose-derived carbon in unsaturated fatty acids at colder temperatures, potentially as a precaution to reduced temperatures. This immediate response of soil microorganisms to soil cooling could help explain the high microbial biomass carbon observed in temperate soils in winter.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Ecology

Taurine as a key intermediate for host-symbiont interaction in the tropical sponge Ianthella basta

Florian U. U. Moeller, Craig W. W. Herbold, Arno Schintlmeister, Maria Mooshammer, Cherie Motti, Bettina Glasl, Katharina Kitzinger, Faris Behnam, Margarete Watzka, Thomas Schweder, Mads Albertsen, Andreas Richter, Nicole S. S. Webster, Michael Wagner

Summary: Marine sponges play a critical role in marine ecosystems as filter-feeders and reef-builders, and they harbor dense communities of microbes. These microbes contribute to the processing of dissolved organic matter (DOM). A study using metaproteogenomics and laboratory incubations found that a dominant gammaproteobacterial symbiont in a marine sponge expressed a pathway for the import and dissimilation of taurine, a common metabolite in marine sponges. The symbiont also imported and used DMSP as a carbon and sulfur source. These findings highlight the importance of biogenic sulfur compounds in the interaction between marine sponges and their microbial symbionts.

ISME JOURNAL (2023)

Article Agronomy

Tree stem and soil methane and nitrous oxide fluxes, but not carbon dioxide fluxes, switch sign along a topographic gradient in a tropical forest

Warren Daniel, Clement Stahl, Benoit Burban, Jean-Yves Goret, Jocelyn Cazal, Andreas A. Richter, Ivan Janssens, Laetitia M. Brechet

Summary: The purpose of this study was to investigate the variation of stem and soil greenhouse gas fluxes along a topographic gradient in a tropical forest. The results showed that both wetland and slope soils and tree stems were sources of CO2, while fluxes of CH4 and N2O were more variable and influenced by temperature and soil water content.

PLANT AND SOIL (2023)

Article Microbiology

Facilitative interaction networks in experimental microbial community dynamics

Hiroaki Fujita, Masayuki Ushio, Kenta Suzuki, Masato S. Abe, Masato Yamamichi, Yusuke Okazaki, Alberto Canarini, Ibuki Hayashi, Keitaro Fukushima, Shinji Fukuda, E. Toby Kiers, Hirokazu Toju

Summary: By analyzing the shotgun metagenomic sequencing data of an experimental microbial community, we discovered that the network structure of facilitative interactions in microbial ecosystems can change over time. By using metabolic modeling, we inferred the potential facilitative interaction networks at 13 time points during the 110-day monitoring of the microbiomes. We found that positive feedback loops, which can lead to ecological cascade breakdown, existed in the metabolic interaction networks before the drastic community compositional shift.

FRONTIERS IN MICROBIOLOGY (2023)

Article Microbiology

Alternative stable states, nonlinear behavior, and predictability of microbiome dynamics

Hiroaki Fujita, Masayuki Ushio, Kenta Suzuki, Masato S. Abe, Masato Yamamichi, Koji Iwayama, Alberto Canarini, Ibuki Hayashi, Keitaro Fukushima, Shinji Fukuda, E. Toby Kiers, Hirokazu Toju

Summary: Researchers combined theoretical frameworks and empirical analyses to predict microbiome dynamics. They found that abrupt changes in microbial communities could be forecasted by analyzing time-series data based on statistical physics and non-linear mechanics.

MICROBIOME (2023)

Review Plant Sciences

The role of arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis in improving plant water status under drought

Mohanned Abdalla, Michael Bitterlich, Jan Jansa, David Pueschel, Mutez A. Ahmed

Summary: This article reviews the role of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) in improving crop drought tolerance, highlighting their effects on water supply and the biophysical mechanisms involved. Using a soil-plant hydraulic model, the authors demonstrate how AMF can enhance water transport in the soil and extend root length to mitigate the impact of soil drying on plant water potential. The synthesis of evidence and simulations suggest that AMF symbiosis postpones the onset of stress by regulating transpiration rates and leaf water potentials during drought, thus promoting crop survival under limited water availability. The article also calls for future research to integrate soil and root hydraulic dynamics in order to better understand the role of AMF in plant-water relations under changing climate conditions.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Can cardiolipins be used as a biomarker for arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi?

Tomas Rezanka, Hana Hrselova, Lucie Kyselova, Jan Jansa

Summary: This study focused on the use of complex polar lipids as biomarkers to detect and quantify arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi in plant and soil samples. The analysis revealed specific molecular species in mycorrhizal roots, suggesting the possibility of using these biomarkers for quantification of AM fungi.

MYCORRHIZA (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Fiber consumption stimulates the activity of microbial bile salt hydrolases

Andras Gregor, Sandra Auernigg-Haselmaier, Manuel Malleier, Stefan Bruckberger, Joana Seneca, Petra Pjevac, Marc Pignitter, Kalina Duszka

Summary: Previously, we found that caloric restriction (CR) led to increased levels of taurine and taurine-conjugated bile acids (BA) in the gut. In this study, we discovered that restrictive diets, such as intermittent fasting and fasting-mimicking diet, had a similar effect as CR. The type of cage bedding affected the levels of BAs and taurine, and removal of cage bedding reversed the CR phenotype. Microbiota transplant from CR mice increased BAs deconjugation. Inhibition of bile salt hydrolase (BSH) prevented the increase in free taurine while increasing taurine-conjugated BA levels. Consuming high fiber diets increased taurine conjugates without elevating BAs levels.

JOURNAL OF FUNCTIONAL FOODS (2023)

Article Microbiology

Plant-symbiotic fungal diversity tracks variation in vegetation and the abiotic environment along an extended elevational gradient in the Himalayas

Inga Hiiesalu, Johannes Schweichhart, Roey Angel, John Davison, Jiri Dolezal, Martin Kopecky, Martin Macek, Klara Rehakova

Summary: This study investigated the ecology of AM fungi in alpine environments using DNA metabarcoding. The results showed that the alpha diversity of AM fungal communities declined linearly with elevation, while the within-site taxon turnover was unimodally related to elevation. The composition of AM fungal communities was influenced by vegetation types, elevation, temperature, and precipitation.

FEMS MICROBIOLOGY ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Only a minority of bacteria grow after wetting in both natural andpost-mining biocrusts in a hyperarid phosphate mine

Talia Gabay, Eva Petrova, Osnat Gillor, Yaron Ziv, Roey Angel

Summary: Biological soil crusts (biocrusts) are crucial for desert ecosystem functions. In the Negev Desert, phosphate mining has destroyed soil habitats and fragmented the landscape. This study used DNA stable isotope probing to examine bacterial growth in post-mining and adjacent natural biocrusts. The results showed minimal bacterial growth in hyperarid biocrusts after wetting, likely due to harsh climatic conditions. These findings emphasize the importance of active restoration practices following mining.
Article Soil Science

Benefits in plant N uptake via the mycorrhizal pathway in ample soil moisture persist under severe drought

David Pueschel, Michael Bitterlich, Jana Rydlova, Petra Bukovsk, Radka Sudova, Jan Jansa

Summary: Drought under global change poses a threat to plant growth and nutrition. This study investigated the role of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus in plant uptake of nitrogen from different sources along a soil moisture gradient. The results showed that mycorrhizal plants had a higher uptake of nitrogen compared to nonmycorrhizal plants, and this advantage was observed across different moisture levels.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Reevaluation and novel insights into amino sugar and neutral sugar necromass biomarkers in archaea, bacteria, fungi, and plants

Erika Salas, Markus Gorfer, Dragana Bandian, Stephanie A. Eichorst, Hannes Schmidt, Julia Horak, Simon K. -M. R. Rittmann, Christa Schleper, Barbara Reischl, Thomas Pribasnig, Jan Jansa, Christina Kaiser, Wolfgang Wanek

Summary: This study analyzed the AS and NS compounds in the biomass of different taxa and found GlcN to be the most common AS and glucose to be the most common NS. A potential biomarker specific to Euryarchaeota was identified. Multivariate statistical methods were used to compare the variability of these compounds between taxonomic groups and evaluate their potential as necromass residue biomarkers. Conversion factors were proposed to estimate the fungal and bacterial carbon content, as well as the archaeal or all-microbial necromass residue carbon content.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Soil Science

Biological denitrification inhibition (BDI) on nine contrasting soils: An unexpected link with the initial soil denitrifying community

C. Beraud, F. Piola, J. Gervaix, G. Meiffren, C. Creuze des Chatelliers, A. Delort, C. Boisselet, S. Poussineau, E. Lacroix, A. A. M. Cantarel

Summary: This study investigated the soil factors influencing the development of biological denitrification inhibition (BDI) and found that initial soil moisture, ammonium concentration, and the initial abundance of certain microbial genes play significant roles in BDI development. Additionally, the research highlighted the relevance of biotic factors in explaining BDI and proposed the use of procyanidin concentration from plant belowground system as a new proxy for measuring BDI intensity.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Core species impact plant health by enhancing soil microbial cooperation and network complexity during community coalescence

Yizhu Qiao, Tingting Wang, Qiwei Huang, Hanyue Guo, He Zhang, Qicheng Xu, Qirong Shen, Ning Ling

Summary: Soil microbial community coalescence, the mixing and interaction of microbial communities, has been found to enhance the stability and complexity of rhizobacterial networks, leading to improved plant health and biomass. This study investigated the effects of different degrees of bacterial community coalescence on plant disease resistance by mixing soils from healthy and diseased habitats for watermelon planting. The results showed that mixing in more healthy soil reduced the plant disease index and increased biomass by improving the stability and complexity of the rhizobacterial network. Core taxa Nitrospirillum and Singulisphaera were enriched in the rhizosphere from healthy soils and played important roles in disease suppression and regulating the positive cohesion and modularity of the networks. Overall, these findings provide insights into the potential mechanism of microbial community coalescence for improving plant microbial community function and suggest new tools for enhancing plant fitness via soil microbiota mixing.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Maize genotypes regulate the feedbacks between maize nitrogen uptake and soil nitrogen transformations

Mengqiu He, Shending Chen, Lei Meng, Xiaoqian Dan, Wenjie Wang, Qinying Zhu, Zucong Cai, Jinbo Zhang, Pierfrancesco Nardi, Christoph Mueller

Summary: Maize genotypes directly affect gene expression and nitrogen uptake capacity. The feedback between maize genotypes and soil nitrogen transformations, as well as their regulations on nitrogen uptake capacity, have been studied. The findings suggest that maize genotypes play a central role in regulating these feedbacks, which are important for maize breeding and enhancing maize production.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Accumulation of soil microbial extracellular and cellular residues during forest rewilding: Implications for soil carbon stabilization in older plantations

Ke Shi, Jiahui Liao, Xiaoming Zou, Han Y. H. Chen, Manuel Delgado-Baquerizo, Zhengming Yan, Tingting Ren, Honghua Ruan

Summary: Through rewilding, microbial extracellular and cellular residues can continuously accumulate in soils and significantly contribute to soil organic carbon sequestration. Extracellular residues are mainly driven by fine root biomass, while cellular residues are mainly driven by soil nitrogen and organic carbon content.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Threats to the soil microbiome from nanomaterials: A global meta and machine-learning analysis

Sensen Chen, Ying Teng, Yongming Luo, Eiko Kuramae, Wenjie Ren

Summary: This study comprehensively assesses the effects of NMs on the soil microbiome through a global meta-analysis. The results reveal significant negative impacts of NMs on soil microbial diversity, biomass, activity, and function. Metal NMs, especially Ag NMs, have the most pronounced negative effects on various soil microbial community metrics.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

How will climate change affect the feeding biology of Collembola?

Shareen K. D. Sanders, Gerard Martinez-De Leon, Ludovico Formenti, Madhav P. Thakur

Summary: Collembolans, the diverse group of soil invertebrates, are affected by anthropogenic climate warming, which alters their diversity and density. In addition to abiotic stressors, changes in food availability, specifically the abundance of saprotrophic and mycorrhizal fungi, influence Collembola responses to climate warming. Collembolans prefer saprotrophic fungi but rely on mycorrhizal fungi when food sources are scarce. Understanding the mechanisms behind these dietary shifts in warm-dry and warm-wet soil conditions is crucial for predicting the impact of climate change on Collembola-fungal interactions.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Mixing plant residues of different quality reduces priming effect and contributes to soil carbon retention

Wimonsiri Pingthaisong, Sergey Blagodatsky, Patma Vityakon, Georg Cadisch

Summary: A study found that mixing high-C/N ratio rice straw with low-C/N ratio groundnut stover can improve the chemical composition of the input, stimulate microbial growth, decrease the loss of residue-derived carbon in the soil, and reduce native soil carbon and nitrogen consumption.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Soil Science

Interplanting leguminous shrubs boosts the trophic interactions of soil micro-food web in a karst grassland

Jiachen Wang, Jie Zhao, Rong Yang, Xin Liu, Xuyuan Zhang, Wei Zhang, Xiaoyong Chen, Wende Yan, Kelin Wang

Summary: Nitrogen is vital for ecosystem productivity, restoration, and succession processes. This study found that legume intercropping was more effective than chemical nitrogen fertilizers in promoting the complexity and stability of the soil micro-food web, as it increased microbial and nematode communities and enhanced energy flow patterns.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2024)