Evaluation of Extracellular Matrix Composition to Improve Breast Cancer Modeling

The development of resistance to therapy is a significant obstacle to effective therapeutic regimens. Evaluating the effects of oncology drugs in the laboratory setting is limited by the lack of translational models that accurately recapitulate cell-microenvironment interactions present in tumors. Acquisition of resistance to therapy is facilitated, in part, by the composition of the tumor extracellular matrix (ECM), with the primary current in vitro model using collagen I (COL I). Here we seek to identify the prevalence of COL I-enhanced expression in the triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) subtype. Furthermore, we identify if methods of response to therapy are altered depending on matrix composition. We demonstrated that collagen content varies in patient tumor samples across subtypes, with COL I expression dramatically increased in typically less aggressive estrogen receptor (ER)-positive(ER+)/progesterone receptor (PGR)-positive (PGR(+)) cancers irrespective of patient age or race. These findings are of significance considering how frequently COL I is implicated in tumor progression. In vitro analyses of ER+ and ER-negative (ER-) cell lines were used to determine the effects of ECM content (collagen I, collagen IV, fibronectin, and laminin) on proliferation, cellular phenotype, and survival. Neither ER+ nor ER- cells demonstrated significant increases in proliferation when cultured on these ECM substrates. ER- cells cultured on these substrates were sensitized to both chemotherapy and targeted therapy. In addition, MDA-MB-231 cells expressed different morphologies, binding affinities, and stiffness across these substrates. We also demonstrated that ECM composition significantly alters transcription of senescence-associated pathways across ER+ and ER- cell lines. Together, these results suggest that complex matrix composites should be incorporated into in vitro tumor models, especially for the drug-resistant TNBC subtype. Impact statement The importance of tumor extracellular matrix (ECM) in disease progression is often inadequately represented in models of breast cancer that rely heavily on collagen I and Matrigel. Through immunohistochemistry analysis of patient breast tumors, we show a wide variation in collagen content based on subtype, specifically a repression of fibril collagens in the receptor negative subtype, irrespective of age and race. We also demonstrated that tumor ECM composition alters cellular elasticity and oncogenic pathway activation demonstrating that physiologically relevant three-dimensional models of breast cancer should include an ECM that is subtype specific.

Automated summary

This study identified an increased prevalence of COL I expression in the triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) subtype and variations in collagen content among patient tumor samples across subtypes. In vitro cell line analyses demonstrated that ECM composition affects cellular elasticity, proliferation, and sensitivity to therapy.