4.7 Review

Adaptive approaches in metamodel-based reliability analysis: A review

期刊

STRUCTURAL SAFETY
卷 89, 期 -, 页码 -

出版社

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.strusafe.2020.102019

关键词

Adaptive metamodeling; Reliability analysis; Response surfaces; Polynomial chaos expansion; Support vector machines; Kriging

向作者/读者索取更多资源

This work reviews the implementation of adaptive metamodeling for reliability analysis, with emphasis on four main types of metamodels and a comparative discussion of their conceptual problems, theoretical descriptions, and applications. The efficiency of adaptive metamodeling is influenced by various considerations, and new areas of research interest such as cross application of methodologies and ensembles are identified.
The present work reviews the implementation of adaptive metamodeling for reliability analysis with emphasis in four main types of metamodels: response surfaces, polynomial chaos expansions, support vector machines, and Kriging models. The discussion presented is motivated by the identified spread and little interaction between metamodeling techniques in reliability, which makes it challenging for practitioners to decide which one to consider in a context of implementation. The conceptual problem of reliability analysis and the theoretical description of the four models is presented, and complemented by a comparative discussion of applications with identification of new areas of interest. The different considerations that influence the efficiency of adaptive metamodeling are reviewed, with extension to applicability discussions for the four models researched. Despite all adaptive techniques contributing to achieve significant gains in the amount of effort required for reliability analysis, and with minimal trade-off in accuracy, they should not be expected to perform equally in regard to the dependence on the reliability problem being addressed. Cross application of methodologies, bridging the gap between methodology and application, and ensembles are some of new areas of research interest identified. One of the major critical considerations for adaptive metamodeling, and that has been target of limited research, is the need for comprehensive techniques that allow a blind selection of the most adequate model with relation to the problem in-hand. To conclude, the extensive and comprehensive discussion presented aims to be a first step for the unification of the field of adaptive metamodeling in reliability; so that future implementations do not exclusively follow individual lines of research that progressively become more narrow in scope, but also seek transversal developments in the field of adaptive metamodeling for reliability analysis.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Engineering, Industrial

Reliability analysis using a multi-metamodel complement-basis approach

Rui Teixeira, Beatriz Martinez-Pastor, Maria Nogal, Alan O'Connor

Summary: This study discusses an innovative approach to metamodeling in reliability by using a field-transversal rationale. The proposed complement-basis method of using multiple metamodels or techniques for reliability analysis shows potential in improving efficiency. Further transversal research may enhance metamodeling in reliability analysis.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2021)

Article Energy & Fuels

The Role of Simulation and Serious Games in Teaching Concepts on Circular Economy and Sustainable Energy

Rocio de la Torre, Bhakti S. Onggo, Canan G. Corlu, Maria Nogal, Angel A. Juan

Summary: Efforts are being made to instill key concepts such as circular economy and sustainable energy in higher education institutions to raise awareness among future professionals and managers about the importance of energy optimization. Despite successful implementation in favoring active student learning, there is still a need for more widespread use, particularly in serious games, to incorporate circular economy concepts into higher education degrees. Currently, there are challenges in integrating these concepts at the university management level.

ENERGIES (2021)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Role of Sensors in Error Propagation with the Dynamic Constrained Observability Method

Tian Peng, Maria Nogal, Joan R. Casas, Jose Turmo

Summary: The inverse problem of structural system identification is prone to ill-conditioning issues, and uncertainty quantification analysis is necessary to evaluate its impact on estimated parameters. The dynamic constrained observability method can compensate for the shortcomings of existing methods, and its correct performance and applicability are demonstrated through the analysis of a real bridge. The optimal sensor placement should consider not only the accuracy of sensors, but also the unknown structural part as epistemic uncertainty is removed with increasing knowledge of the structure.

SENSORS (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Multi-system intervention optimization for interdependent infrastructure

Omar Kammouh, Maria Nogal, Ruud Binnekamp, A. R. M. Rogier Wolfert

Summary: The paper introduces the 3C concept for managing infrastructure interventions, which optimizes activities and leads to cost savings. The approach formalizes a mathematical model to account for interactions between infrastructure networks and stakeholders, accommodating different types of interventions.

AUTOMATION IN CONSTRUCTION (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Planning low-error SHM strategy by constrained observability method

Tian Peng, Maria Nogal, Joan R. Casas, Jose Turmo

Summary: This paper highlights the importance of reducing estimation errors in Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) strategy and Structural System Identification (SSI) analysis, introducing a new method based on the constrained observability method and decision trees. The effectiveness of this method is validated using numerical models and a real bridge case, indicating the significant insights it provides for decision-making in optimal SHM + SSI strategy.

AUTOMATION IN CONSTRUCTION (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Mitigation Controller: Adaptive Simulation Approach for Planning Control Measures in Large Construction Projects

Omar Kammouh, Maria Nogal, Ruud Binnekamp, A. R. M. (Rogier) Wolfert

Summary: Probabilistic Monte Carlo simulations are commonly used to determine project completion times at specific probability levels. However, schedule changes can negatively impact the probability of timely completion, necessitating a manual trial and error approach to find effective mitigation measures.

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT (2021)

Review Engineering, Civil

Systems thinking approach for improving maintenance management of discrete rail assets: a review and future perspectives

Yue Shang, Maria Nogal, Haoyu Wang, A. R. M. (Rogier) Wolfert

Summary: Performance evaluation and maintenance planning are becoming increasingly important for ageing rail infrastructure and increasing demand for track safety and continuous availability. Discrete railway assets, such as bridges and level crossings, along with extended track sections, comprise the main railway network infrastructure. These assets have significant implications for train safety, riding comfort, operating expenditures, and effective network capacity. The heterogeneity of asset features and operating environments also presents challenges for efficient maintenance planning. This review focuses on level crossings and synthesizes different perspectives on their maintenance management. The integration of a systems thinking approach and two levels of asset management (micro- and macro-level) provide a structured synthesis that is interdependent and synergistic. The review also compares mechanistic and data-driven modeling approaches and identifies limitations in existing studies, with directions for future research aimed at improving the inspection and diagnosis process and moving towards a system-level maintenance approach for multiple level crossings.

STRUCTURE AND INFRASTRUCTURE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Flow Cytometry and Fecal Indicator Bacteria Analyses for Fingerprinting Microbial Pollution in Karst Aquifer Systems

Luka Vucinic, David O'Connell, Rui Teixeira, Catherine Coxon, Laurence Gill

Summary: Microbial pollution of aquifers is a global water quality problem that poses significant risks to public health. This study utilized flow cytometric analysis and fecal indicator bacteria to assess the potential of providing faster and more descriptive information on microbial pollution in karst aquifers. The study also evaluated the use of turbidity as a proxy indicator for fecal groundwater contamination. The findings suggest that flow cytometry can provide additional insights into fecal pollution sources and its fate and transport in karst catchments.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Metamodel-based metaheuristics in optimal responsive adaptation and recovery of traffic networks

Rui Teixeira, Beatriz Martinez-Pastor, Maria Nogal, Alan O'Connor

Summary: This study explores the application of metamodels in recovery and adaptation modeling and proposes a sequential global metamodeling technique. The results show that metamodeling-based metaheuristics enable fast engineering analysis of traffic recovery and adaptation, which may change the way decisions are made.

SUSTAINABLE AND RESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Toward Interpretability in Fault Diagnosis for Autonomous Vehicles: Interpretation of Sensor Data Anomalies

Yukun Fang, Haigen Min, Xia Wu, Xiaoping Lei, Shixiang Chen, Rui Teixeira, Xiangmo Zhao

Summary: In order to ensure the safety and reliability of autonomous driving applications, a fault diagnosis framework tailored to autonomous vehicles is essential. This study discusses the interpretability issue in fault diagnosis for autonomous vehicles from the perspective of sensor data analytics. The impact of the environment on sensor data is evaluated using noise energy as a measure. A signal quality indicator and online denoising techniques are proposed to mitigate the impact and enhance data quality. An adversarial learning neural network, ALDSAE, is constructed for sensor data anomaly detection. An explanation model specific to ALDSAE is employed to interpret the anomaly detection results. Experiments with real test field data show that ALDSAE has higher performance than traditional anomaly detectors in terms of area under the ROC curve (AUC_ROC), and the explanation accuracy of the residual explainer is comparable to the widely used kernel Shapley additive explanation (SHAP) with significantly reduced response time.

IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Flood adaptation decision-making for vulnerable locations using expectation-quantile-investment analysis

Rui Teixeira, Beatriz Martinez-Pastor, Luka Vucinic, Alan O'Connor

Summary: Floods are a major challenge for human societies, and effective flood adaptation decision-making is crucial. The study proposes a new approach, called expectation-quantile-investment (EQI) evaluation, that considers expectations, probability quantiles, and investments to assess robust adaptation decisions. The results show that EQI-informed decisions can determine optimality in seemingly competitive measures.

JOURNAL OF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

A fault diagnosis framework for autonomous vehicles with sensor self-diagnosis

Haigen Min, Yukun Fang, Xia Wu, Xiaoping Lei, Shixiang Chen, Rui Teixeira, Bing Zhu, Xiangmo Zhao, Zhigang Xu

Summary: Fault diagnosis for autonomous vehicles is important to provide information about the vehicle's operation status and avoid potential risks. This study proposes a fault diagnosis framework with sensor self-diagnosis, using a residual consistency checking algorithm and a denoising shrinkage autoencoder (DSAE) for anomaly detection. Experimental results show that the proposed algorithm effectively detects and isolates failed sensors, and the DSAE achieves the best anomaly detection performance compared to other machine learning methods.

EXPERT SYSTEMS WITH APPLICATIONS (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Stochastic analysis and reliability assessment of critical RC structural components considering material properties uncertainty

A. R. Ibrahim, D. A. Makhloof

Summary: The unavoidable heterogeneity in the mechanical characteristics of concrete is crucial to consider in the design of high-rise buildings. This study investigates the spatial variability of material properties and proposes a framework to capture the stochastic response and assess the reliability of structural components. The results demonstrate the importance of accounting for material uncertainty in ensuring the safety of high-rise buildings.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Global sensitivity evolution equation of the Fréchet-derivative-based global sensitivity analysis

Zhiqiang Wan

Summary: This paper emphasizes the importance of global sensitivity analysis for stochastic dynamical systems with multiple uncertain parameters and proposes a global sensitivity index suitable for this purpose. The research findings demonstrate that the proposed approach exhibits high efficiency and accuracy.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Variance-based reliability sensitivity with dependent inputs using failure samples

Max Ehre, Iason Papaioannou, Daniel Straub

Summary: Reliability sensitivity analysis is a method to measure the influence of uncertain input parameters on the probability of failure in a system. Statistically dependent inputs pose challenges in computing and interpreting sensitivity indices. This study introduces a separation of effects between the probabilistic model and computational model to compute the independent and full contributions of all inputs. By using hierarchically structured isoprobabilistic transformations, the full set of variance-based sensitivity indices can be computed with a single set of failure samples obtained from a rare event estimation method.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Measurement plan targeting the accuracy of calibrated chloride ingress model for concrete structures in marine environment

Ze Yuan, Quanwang Li, Kefei Li

Summary: This paper proposes a method to determine a measurement plan for durability assessment of concrete structures, by calibrating the models using Bayesian updating and linear fitting in order to achieve the required accuracy. The paper establishes probabilistic time-dependent models for surface chloride concentration and chloride diffusion coefficient, and discusses the key factors affecting the accuracy of the models.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Optimized equivalent linearization for random vibration

Ziqi Wang

Summary: This study addresses the fundamental limitation of equivalent linearization methods in nonlinear random vibration analysis, proposing a method to construct an estimator that converges on the nonlinear system solution using a limited number of nonlinear system simulations and optimizing the equivalent linear system to approach the nonlinear system solution quickly, especially for rare event probabilities.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

A multi-fidelity stochastic simulation scheme for estimation of small failure probabilities

Min Li, Srinivasan Arunachalam, Seymour M. J. Spence

Summary: This paper presents a multi-fidelity approach for computing small failure probabilities in engineering systems. By integrating information from different levels of model fidelity, the required number of high-fidelity model runs is reduced while maintaining accuracy in estimating failure probabilities.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Towards system reliability targeted design for flange-angle partially restrained steel moment connections

Aritra Chatterjee, Trisha Chakravorty, Baidurya Bhattacharya

Summary: This paper presents a methodology to determine the system reliability of commonly used steel moment connections that have been designed according to current element based procedures. A general expression is derived to modify element resistance factors and meet specified system reliability targets.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Variance reduction function for a potential inclined slip line in a spatially variable soil

Yuanqin Tao, Kok-Kwang Phoon, Honglei Sun, Jianye Ching

Summary: This study derives theoretical and approximate variance reduction functions (VRFs) for a potential inclined slip line in a spatially variable soil. The study investigates one-dimensional (1D) VRFs and proposes approximate VRFs for the one-dimensional Whittle-Mate 'rn (WM) model and the one-dimensional cosine Whittle-Mate 'rn (CosWM) model. The paper also derives theoretical scales of fluctuation and VRFs for commonly used two-dimensional autocorrelation models and proposes general approximations for the VRF over an inclined line.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Solution of FPK equation for stochastic dynamics subjected to additive Gaussian noise via deep learning approach

Amir H. Khodabakhsh, Seid H. Pourtakdoust

Summary: The Fokker-Plank-Kolmogorov (FPK) equation is a crucial model for understanding and improving the performance of engineering systems. However, its solution is challenging due to its high dimensionality. This study introduces FPK-DP Net, a physics-informed network that can effectively solve high-dimensional FPK equations and demonstrates its applicability and accuracy through numerical implementations on benchmark problems.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Risk-based maintenance and inspection of riverine flood defence systems

Wouter Jan Klerk, Vera van Bergeijk, Wim Kanning, Rogier Wolfert, Matthijs Kok

Summary: This paper examines the reliability of flood defence systems under shock-based degradation and compares different maintenance concepts. The results show that the current maintenance concept fails to meet the reliability requirements for revetment failure. Additional inspections and targeted interventions can significantly reduce total cost and improve the robustness of flood defence systems.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Probabilistic model of traffic scenarios for extreme load effects in long-span bridges

Xuejing Wang, Xin Ruan, Joan R. Casas, Mingyang Zhang

Summary: This paper proposes a probabilistic Gaussian mixture model for simulating heavy vehicle scenarios on long-span bridges under free-flow conditions. The study utilizes a non-stationary Poisson process to simulate the uneven occurrence of heavy vehicles in different lanes, considering the correlation of gross vehicle weights within close range. The results show that the correlation and stationarity of vehicle distribution location significantly affect the structural responses.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Relaxation-based importance sampling for structural reliability analysis

Jianhua Xian, Ziqi Wang

Summary: This study presents an importance sampling formulation based on adaptively relaxing parameters, providing a unified framework for various existing variance reduction techniques and laying the foundation for creating new importance sampling strategies. It proposes two importance sampling strategies for low-dimensional and high-dimensional problems, which are crucial for fragility analysis in performance-based engineering.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Numerical algorithm for determining serviceability live loads and its applications

Chi Xu, Jun Chen, Jie Li

Summary: This study proposes a new algorithm to determine the probability distributions of the live load duration and compares the results with Monte Carlo simulation. The algorithm allows the exact determination of design live loads based on a predefined exceeding probability, providing guidance for engineering design.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Mixed Bayesian Network for reliability assessment of RC structures subjected to environmental actions

Hongyuan Guo, You Dong, Emilio Bastidas-Arteaga

Summary: This paper presents a general reliability assessment framework for RC structures based on a Mixed Bayesian network, taking into account environmental parameters, chloride transport, and concrete crack inspection. The case study reveals that early detection of large cracks may lead to an overestimation of failure probability by about 500%.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

AK-SEUR: An adaptive Kriging-based learning function for structural reliability analysis through sample-based expected uncertainty reduction

Changle Peng, Cheng Chen, Tong Guo, Weijie Xu

Summary: Reliability Analysis (RA) is critical in structural design and performance evaluation. This study proposes a novel learning function, SEUR, for surrogate model-assisted RA to improve efficiency and accuracy. The SEUR function is demonstrated to be more effective and efficient in dealing with nonlinear problems, small probabilities, and complex limit states.

STRUCTURAL SAFETY (2024)