4.7 Article

Unstructured citizen science data fail to detect long-term population declines of common birds in Denmark

期刊

DIVERSITY AND DISTRIBUTIONS
卷 22, 期 10, 页码 1024-1035

出版社

WILEY-BLACKWELL
DOI: 10.1111/ddi.12463

关键词

citizen science; common bird monitoring; JAGS; occupancy model; population trend; volunteer

资金

  1. European Commission [226487]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Aim Long-term monitoring of biodiversity is necessary to identify population declines and to develop conservation management. Because long-term monitoring is labour-intensive, resources to implement robust monitoring programmes are lacking in many countries. The increasing availability of citizen science data in online public databases can potentially fill gaps in structured monitoring programmes, but only if trends estimated from unstructured citizen science data match those estimated from structured monitoring programmes. We therefore aimed to assess the correlation between trends estimated from structured and unstructured data. Location Denmark. Methods We compared population trends for 103 bird species estimated over 28 years from a structured monitoring programme and from unstructured citizen science data to assess whether trends estimated from the two data sources were correlated. Results Trends estimated from the two data sources were generally positively correlated, but less than half the population declines identified from the structured monitoring data were recovered from the unstructured citizen science data. The mismatch persisted when we reduced the structured monitoring data from count data to occurrence data to mimic the information content of unstructured citizen science data and when we filtered the unstructured data to reduce the number of incomplete lists reported. Mismatching trends were especially prevalent for the most common species. Worryingly, more than half the species showing significant declines in the structured monitoring showed significant positive trends in the citizen science data. Main conclusions We caution that unstructured citizen science databases cannot replace structured monitoring data because the former are less sensitive to population changes. Thus, unstructured data may not fulfil one of the most critical functions of structured monitoring programmes, namely to act as an early warning system that detects population declines.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Connectivity between countries established by landbirds and raptors migrating along the African-Eurasian flyway

Joao L. Guilherme, Victoria R. Jones, Ines Catry, Martin Beal, Maria P. Dias, Steffen Oppel, Juliet A. Vickery, Chris M. Hewson, Stuart H. M. Butchart, Ana S. L. Rodrigues

Summary: The conservation of long-distance migratory birds requires coordination between countries connected by their movements. Tracking studies have provided new information on these movements, but it is often inaccessible to conservation practitioners and policy makers. This study synthesized current knowledge on migratory connectivity between European breeding countries and sub-Saharan African nonbreeding countries. The number of available tracking studies has increased, but the coverage of data is incomplete and biased towards certain species and regions. Despite limitations, the results can inform policy discussions and help prioritize future tracking studies.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Quantifying annual spatial consistency in chick-rearing seabirds to inform important site identification

Martin Beal, Paulo Catry, Richard A. Phillips, Steffen Oppel, John P. Y. Arnould, Maria I. Bogdanova, Mark Bolton, Ana P. B. Carneiro, Corey Clatterbuck, Melinda Conners, Francis Daunt, Karine Delord, Kyle Elliott, Aymeric Fromant, Jose Pedro Granadeiro, Jonathan A. Green, Lewis Halsey, Keith C. Hamer, Motohiro Ito, Ruth Jeavons, Jeong-Hoon Kim, Nobuo Kokubun, Shiho Koyama, Jude V. Lane, Won Young Lee, Sakiko Matsumoto, Rachael A. Orben, Ellie Owen, Vitor H. Paiva, Allison Patterson, Christopher Pollock, Jaime A. Ramos, Paul Sagar, Katsufumi Sato, Scott A. Shaffer, Louise Soanes, Akinori Takahashi, David R. Thompson, Lesley Thorne, Leigh Torres, Yutaka Watanuki, Susan M. Waugh, Henri Weimerskirch, Shannon Whelan, Ken Yoda, Jose C. Xavier, Maria P. Dias

Summary: Animal tracking studies provide insights into space use patterns and inform conservation planning. This study used GPS-tracking data from 23 seabird species to assess the importance of multi-year sampling for identifying important conservation sites. The results showed a high degree of spatial overlap among distribution patterns from different years, suggesting that tracking animals in multiple years may not be necessary. However, it is crucial to track enough individuals to provide a representative estimate of the population distribution during the sampling period.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Correction Biodiversity Conservation

Quantifying annual spatial consistency in chick-rearing seabirds to inform important site identification (vol 281, 109994, 2023)

Martin Beal, Paulo Catry, Richard A. Phillips, Steffen Oppel, John P. Y. Arnould, Maria I. Bogdanova, Mark Bolton, Ana P. B. Carneiro, Corey Clatterbuck, Melinda Conners, Francis Daunt, Karine Delord, Kyle Elliott, Aymeric Fromant, Jose Pedro Granadeiro, Jonathan A. Green, Lewis G. Halsey, Keith C. Hamer, Motohiro Ito, Ruth Jeavons, Jeong-Hoon Kim, Nobuo Kokubun, Shiho Koyama, Jude V. Lane, Won Young, Sakiko Matsumoto, Rachael A. Orben, Ellie Owen, Vitor H. Paiva, Allison Patterson, Christopher J. Pollock, Jaime A. Ramos, Paul Sagar, Katsufumi Sato, Scott A. Shaffer, Louise Soanes, Akinori Takahashi, David R. Thompson, Lesley Thorne, Leigh Torres, Yutaka Watanuki, Susan M. Waugh, Henri Weimerskirch, Shannon Whelan, Ken Yoda, Jose C. Xavier, Maria P. Dias

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

The lure of the big city: smaller Danish rookeries are increasingly associated with urban land cover

Henning Heldbjerg, Claus Lunde Pedersen, Ole R. Therkildsen, Thomas Bregnballe, Henning Ettrup, Johnny Kahlert, Thomas Vikstrom, Anthony D. Fox

Summary: Rooks in Denmark are commonly found in urban and agricultural habitats. The number of rookeries has increased by 40% from 1991 to 2021, but the nest abundance only increased by 6% due to smaller rookeries associated with urban sites. The proportion of urban area around rookeries has increased while agricultural land cover has decreased, indicating a preference for smaller urban rookeries over agricultural landscapes.

URBAN ECOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Ornithology

The effects of temporally distinct light pollution from ships on nocturnal colony attendance in a threatened seabird

Martin Austad, Steffen Oppel, James Crymble, Hannah R. Greetham, Dilek Sahin, Paulo Lago, Benjamin J. Metzger, Petra Quillfeldt

Summary: Artificial light can have complex ecological effects, and ships, which are often brightly lit, can temporarily increase light levels in otherwise dark areas. In this study, we found that the presence of ships in front of coastal cliffs significantly reduced colony attendance of Yelkouan Shearwaters.

JOURNAL OF ORNITHOLOGY (2023)

Article Ornithology

Assessing genetic diversity patterns at neutral and adaptive loci to inform population reinforcement of an endangered migratory vulture

Anastasios Bounas, Victoria Saravia-Mullin, Maria Mendez, Volen Arkumarev, Lusine Aghajanyan, Korsh Ararat, Evan Buechley, Vladimir Dobrev, Dobromir Dobrev, Ron Efrat, Ivaylo Klisurov, Elzbieta Kret, Theodora Skartsi, Steffen Oppel, Rusko Petrov, Cagan H. Sekercioglu, Anton Vaidl, Jose A. Donazar, Stoyan C. Nikolov, Konstantinos Sotiropoulos

Summary: This study provides genetic management recommendations for the conservation translocation program of the declining Egyptian Vulture population in the Balkans. The results show that the current population management scheme and source populations do not have a significant impact on genetic diversity. However, releasing individuals of different origin would be appropriate to prevent further population contraction and loss of adaptive alleles.

JOURNAL OF ORNITHOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Co-developing guidance for conservation: An example for seabirds in the North-East Atlantic in the face of climate change impacts

Henry Hakkinen, Nigel G. Taylor, Nathalie Pettorelli, William J. Sutherland, Jon Aldara, Tycho Anker-Nilssen, Christophe Aulert, Rob S. A. van Bemmelen, Daisy Burnell, Bernard Cadiou, Letizia Campioni, Bethany L. Clark, Nina Dehnhard, Maria P. Dias, Leonie Enners, Robert W. Furness, Gunnar thorn or Hallgrimsson, Sjurour Hammer, Erpur Snaer Hansen, Martti Hario, Stephen Hurling, Mark Jessopp, Birgit Kleinschmidt, Meelis Leivits, Klaudyna Maniszewska, Steffen Oppel, Ana Payo-Payo, Daniel Piec, Jaime A. Ramos, Frederic Robin, Iben Hove Sorensen, Antra Stipniece, Danielle L. Thompson, Antonio Vulcano, Silviu Petrovan

Summary: Conservation guidance is an important tool to communicate evidence-based advice to conservation actors, especially in the face of rapidly increasing pressure from climate change. However, the process of developing guidance documents with input from stakeholders can be complicated and costly. There is currently little direct evidence and guidance specifically targeting climate change. This study introduces a process for co-developing guidance for species conservation in the context of a changing climate, using seabirds in the North-East Atlantic as a case study.

CONSERVATION SCIENCE AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

First evidence of mouse predation killing adult great albatrosses

Maelle Connan, Christopher W. Jones, Michelle M. Risi, Lucy K. Smyth, Steffen Oppel, Vonica Perold, Kim L. Stevens, Roelf Daling, Peter G. Ryan

Summary: Invasive mice pose a threat to native species, particularly seabirds, on sub-Antarctic Gough and Marion Islands. This study reports the first deaths of adult great albatrosses attributed to mouse attacks. The breeding adults of these long-lived species are critically impacted, highlighting the urgent need for eradication of mice on these islands.

BIOLOGICAL INVASIONS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Conserving the evolutionary history of birds

Christopher J. W. McClure, Igor Berkunsky, Evan R. Buechley, Leah Dunn, Jeff Johnson, Jennifer McCabe, Steffen Oppel, Brian W. Rolek, Luke J. Sutton, Rikki Gumbs

Summary: Amidst the ongoing sixth mass extinction, conservationists are faced with limited resources and the need to prioritize species and areas for conservation action. This study emphasizes the importance of evolutionary distinctiveness in determining the conservation priority of bird species. By combining evolutionary distinctiveness with a species' global endangered status, an EDGE (Evolutionary Distinct and Globally Endangered) score is obtained. The researchers analyzed all bird species and bird conservation areas globally, with a focus on parrots, raptors, and seabirds due to their high threat levels and species richness. The results showed that these three groups had a significant median threatened evolutionary history, indicating their importance in preserving bird evolutionary history. The countries of Australia, Brazil, Indonesia, Madagascar, New Zealand, and the Philippines were identified as particularly critical for bird conservation, as they had a high concentration of threatened evolutionary history for endemic birds and were important for the focal groups mentioned above. The study highlights the need for increased enforcement of international agreements to protect parrots, raptors, and seabirds, as they safeguard millions of years of threatened bird evolutionary history. Urgent action is required to conserve the evolutionary history of birds in the Anthropocene.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Zoology

Integrative taxonomy reveals unrecognised species diversity in African Corypha larks (Aves: Alaudidae)

Per Alstroem, Zeinolabedin Mohammadi, Paul F. Donald, Marianne Nymark, Erik D. Enbody, Martin Irestedt, Emmanuel Barde Elisha, Henry K. Ndithia, B. Irene Tieleman, Derek Engelbrecht, Urban Olsson, Lois Rancilhac, Martin Stervander

Summary: Comprehensive taxonomic analysis of the rufous-naped lark complex in sub-Saharan Africa reveals the need for reclassification, proposing the recognition of nine species instead of five.

ZOOLOGICAL JOURNAL OF THE LINNEAN SOCIETY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Looming-eyes buoys fail to reduce seabird bycatch in the Icelandic lumpfish fishery: depth-based fishing restrictions are an alternative

Yann Rouxel, Holmfriour Arnardottir, Steffen Oppel

Summary: Bycatch of seabirds in gillnets is a significant conservation issue in the north Atlantic. This study tested the effectiveness of a floating device called 'looming-eyes buoy' (LEB) in reducing seabird bycatch in the Icelandic lumpfish fishery. The study found no direct effect of LEBs on target lumpfish catch and bycatch, but indicated that fishing depth-based restrictions could effectively eliminate seabird bycatch. The study estimated that limiting fishing to waters deeper than 50 meters could save between 5000 and 9300 seabirds annually, without significant impact on fish catch.

ROYAL SOCIETY OPEN SCIENCE (2023)

Article Ecology

Co-designing a toolkit for evidence-based decision making in conservation: Processes and lessons

Rebecca K. Smith, William H. Morgan, Nida Al-Fulaij, Tatsuya Amano, Andrew E. Bowkett, Alec Christie, Harriet Downey, Winifred F. Frick, David O'Brien, Nancy Ockendon, Steffen Oppel, Silviu O. Petrovan, David Righton, Paul Tinsley-Marshall, Thomas A. Worthington, William J. Sutherland

Summary: Researchers collaborated with practitioners, policymakers, and academics to develop tools and resources for improving conservation practice. The Conservation Evidence Programme emphasized the importance of engagement, role consensus, and flexibility in achieving effective conservation practices.

ECOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS AND EVIDENCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

A novel, post-Soviet fire disturbance regime drives bird diversity and abundance on the Eurasian steppe

Tejas Bhagwat, Tobias Kuemmerle, Mahmood Soofi, Paul F. Donald, Norbert Hoelzel, Albert Salemgareev, Ingrid Stirnemann, Ruslan Urazaliyev, Matthias Baumann, Johannes Kamp

Summary: The increase in fire disturbance in post-Soviet Eurasian steppe has resulted in significant declines in bird abundance and changes in community assembly. Restoring wild herbivore populations and traditional domestic ungulate grazing systems are crucial for controlling wildfires and preventing further biodiversity loss.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Detections of house mice on Gough Island approach zero within days of aerial baiting

Araceli Samaniego, Kim L. L. Stevens, Vonica Perold, Steffen Oppel, Pete McClelland

Summary: This study utilized an actual mouse eradication operation to document the rapid decline in mouse activity after the application of rodent bait. The results showed that most mice consumed the bait as soon as it became available, which was faster than what laboratory trials suggest. These findings are important for improving eradication guidelines and future mouse eradication projects.

WILDLIFE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Seabird bycatch in a Baltic coastal gillnet fishery is orders of magnitude larger than official reports

Julius Morkunas, Steffen Oppel, Modestas Bruzas, Yann Rouxel, Rasa Morkune, Daniel Mitchell

Summary: Bycatch, particularly in small-scale fisheries using gillnets, poses a significant threat to seabird populations worldwide. This study presents data on seabird bycatch in the small-scale coastal fishery in Lithuania during the 2015-2020 winter period, revealing deficiencies in the country's current reporting system.

AVIAN CONSERVATION AND ECOLOGY (2022)

暂无数据