Implementing a patient decision aid, a process evaluation of a large-scale pre- and post-implementation trial

Purpose Patient decision aids (PtDAs) have been reported to have a positive influence on patients making a health care decision in trials. Nevertheless, post-trial implementation is poor. The aim of this study is to explore patient, clinician, and organizational success factors for implementing a PtDA designed for breast cancer patients, facing a decision on their radiation treatment. Methods We performed a process evaluation within a multi-center pre- and post-implementation trial. The PtDA was incorporated as much as possible in the logistics of 13 participating centers. Tracking data were collected on PtDA use. Process characteristics were recorded by both clinicians and patients. A logistic regression method was applied to investigate which process characteristics were significantly related to the probability that patients logged in to the PtDA. Results 189 patients received the PtDA of whom140 (77%) used the PtDA. If patients received the link via the surgery department they were more likely to use the PtDA (OR 9.77 (1.28-74.51)), compared to patients that received the link via the radiation oncology department. If the report of the multidisciplinary team stated that radiation treatment had to be discussed with the patient, patients were more likely to use the PtDA (OR 2.29 (1.12-4.71)). Educational level was not related to the probability of PtDA use. Conclusions We accomplished a high level of PtDA use. Patients were more likely to use the PtDA if they received the link via the surgery department and if to be discussed with the patient was written in the multidisciplinary team report.

Automated summary

This study aimed to explore the success factors for implementing a PtDA for breast cancer patients facing radiation treatment decisions. Patients were more likely to use the PtDA when they received the link via the surgery department and when the multidisciplinary team report mentioned the need to discuss radiation treatment with the patient.