4.4 Article

Physical literacy: a concept analysis

期刊

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY
卷 25, 期 8, 页码 946-959

出版社

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/13573322.2019.1677586

关键词

Physical literacy; concept analysis; physical education; definitions; interpretations

资金

  1. Australian Government Research Training Program (RTP)
  2. RTP Fees Offset Scholarship through Monash University Australia

向作者/读者索取更多资源

This paper presents an evolutionary concept analysis of Physical Literacy (PL) in order to shed some clarity within the uncertainty surrounding this highly adopted yet widely adapted concept. Inevitably, concepts like PL become re-interpreted as they gain popularity and get redeployed to serve an increasingly diverse range of purposes in varied contexts. The inevitability of an ?evolution? of concepts has not bypassed PL. With implications for research and theory formation, this paper takes stock of the concept of PL and presents findings that form a conceptual understanding of the concept as it has appeared within the scholarly literature over time. 103 papers from the peer-reviewed literature between 1993 and 2019 were analysed according to Rodgers? (2000. Concept analysis: An evolutionary view. In B. L. Rodgers & K. A. Knafl (Eds.), Concept development in nursing: Foundations, techniques, and applications (pp. 77?102). Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders) six-step method of concept analysis. Thematic coding involved extracting and analysing the surrogate terms and related concepts for, and the attributes, antecedents, consequences, and references of PL. Findings map the evolution of the concept, its subsequent splintering into a range of variable interpretations and an obscurification of foundational ideas. Rather than present a single, universal or ?correct? version of PL from a synthesis of the literature, we draw upon Sartori?s (1970. Concept misformation in comparative politics. The American Political Science Review, 64(4), 1033?1053) ?ladder of abstraction? to present a pluralistic approach to the concept for researchers and practitioners to adopt. Using this approach, PL can be defined against its level of abstraction (low, medium or high) and by moving between thicker and thinner interpretations of the concept, some clarity about ?what version? of PL is being used can be obtained. This research should enable PL to be used in future theory development and empirical research with greater confidence and clarity.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.4
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Education & Educational Research

Challenging ableism and the 'disability as problem' discourse: how initial teacher education can support the inclusion of students with a disability in physical education

Laura Alfrey, Ruth Jeanes

Summary: This research emphasizes the importance of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) in promoting inclusion of students with disabilities in Physical Education (PE). It suggests a specific combination of elements that can be enacted within a Bachelor of Education program to support pre-service teachers (PSTs) in becoming more inclusive teachers. These elements include pedagogization of theory, creating a sense of safety, establishing partnerships for authentic learning, and promoting student voice and co-design.

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The problematization of the (im)possible subject: an analysis of Health and Physical Education policy from Australia, USA and Wales

Laura Alfrey, Karen Lambert, David Aldous, Risto Marttinen

Summary: This paper analyzes policy documents from Australia, the United States, and Wales in the context of Health and Physical Education (HPE). The analysis focuses on how learners are represented in the policies and applies Bacchi's approach to guide the analysis. The findings reveal common discourses of idealism, neoliberalism, healthism, and individualism across the policies, reinforcing deficit language and a focus on what learners lack. The paper emphasizes the importance of examining discourses and voices within curriculum policy documents, making educational and health politics visible, and encouraging critical consciousness related to policy.

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Mapping the physical literacy controversy: an analysis of key actors within scholarly literature

Lisa Young, Justen O'Connor, Laura Alfrey

Summary: Physical Literacy (PL) is a concept enduring controversy, as multiple actors disagree on its definition and there is shared uncertainty around it. This paper maps the controversial state of PL as presented by different actors on the scholarly web, analyzing 77 scholarly articles to observe and describe the network of actors involved in the PL controversy. The findings reveal four clusters of actors invested in different ideologies of what PL should be, leading to overlapping yet contested framings of PL on the scholarly web. The implication is that PL flows in many directions and is understood/utilized differently across clusters of actors.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Transforming physical education: an analysis of context and resources that support curriculum transformation and enactment

Laura Alfrey, J. O'Connor

Summary: This paper presents a counter-narrative to the belief that Physical Education (PE) is resistant to change. The purpose of this research is to examine the resources that enable curriculum transformation and enactment in one school. The findings suggest that teachers were supported by resources across different contextual dimensions and activity layers, with the most valued resources being structural and networked support, sustained leadership, a clear vision for PE, professional learning, and time.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

When teachers Google physical literacy: A cartography of controversies analysis

Lisa Young, Laura Alfrey, Justen O'Connor

Summary: Research indicates that how physical literacy is presented on the web is influenced by various viewpoints and ideologies from the education, sport, and health domains, with Google's algorithms favoring specific viewpoints and ideologies. There may be differences in understanding and practices between educators and coaches who only focus on the first page of Google results and those who engage with a broader range of sources.

EUROPEAN PHYSICAL EDUCATION REVIEW (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Moving from physical literacy to co-existing physical literacies: What is the problem?

Lisa Young, Laura Alfrey, Justen O'Connor

Summary: This paper explores the different ideological positions associated with physical literacy (PL) and presents PL as a multiplicity of physical literacies. Through analyzing scholarly articles and non-scholarly texts, the study identifies three waves of PL cosmoses, each with its own objectives, actors, and obligations. The paper advocates for understanding PL as a multiverse, allowing individuals to become aware of and comprehend the distinct PL cosmoses and their differences for effective implementation.

EUROPEAN PHYSICAL EDUCATION REVIEW (2023)

Article Demography

Informal sport and (non)belonging among Hazara migrants in Australia

Ramon Spaaij, Jonathan Magee, Ruth Jeanes, Dawn Penney, Justen O'Connor

Summary: This article, based on qualitative fieldwork, examines how the involvement of Hazara men in the ethno-specific informal sport of sangarag influences their (non)belonging experiences in Australia. The findings highlight the role of sangarag as a response to challenging settlement journeys and the reinforcement of intra-group differentiations. The marginal status of sangarag within the Australian sports system leads to feelings of unsupported and misrecognition among participants. Policy implications include the recognition and support of informal sports for migrants' sense of belonging and well-being.

JOURNAL OF ETHNIC AND MIGRATION STUDIES (2023)

Article Art

Conceptualising Intergenerational Lived Experience: Integrating Art- Moving-Well-Being across Disciplines, Communities and Cultures

Megan Adams, Geraldine Burke, Nikki Browne, Karan Kent, Kylie Colemane, Laura Alfrey, Aislinn Lalor, Keith Hill

Summary: This paper proposes a cross-disciplinary framework to reduce feelings of loneliness and improve social connections across generations. It brings together Aboriginal Artists, Teacher Educators, and Physical and Occupational Therapists to explore the impact of art and movement on the health and well-being of different age groups.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ART & DESIGN EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

An expansive learning approach to transforming traditional fitness testing in health and physical education: student voice, feelings and hopes

Laura Alfrey

Summary: This paper examines Australian secondary students' feelings towards current fitness testing practices and explores their suggestions for changing these practices. The research findings indicate that fitness testing can cause anxiety and overwhelm for some students, but also highlight the students' capacity to propose alternative approaches that are more suitable for their school.

CURRICULUM STUDIES IN HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

The enactment of leisure-time physical activity policy for older adults in community leisure settings

Michael Butson, Ruth Jeanes, Justen O'Connor

Summary: This paper examines the enactment of local government leisure policies in community leisure facilities and finds that leisure facility managers lack engagement with policies, particularly those targeting older adults. To improve participation rates and justify public investments in leisure facilities, the study recommends establishing a negotiation process and reinterpreting policies.

JOURNAL OF POLICY RESEARCH IN TOURISM LEISURE AND EVENTS (2023)

Editorial Material Management

Promoting physical activity participation to older adults: a critical analysis of leisure facility advertising

Michael Butson, Ruth Jeanes, Justen O'Connor

Summary: This study examines the visibility and representation of older adults across Victorian, Australian aquatic and leisure facility websites. The findings show that older adults are visually underrepresented on these websites, and when they are represented, it often includes language and content that can be seen as stereotyping and ageist. This ageism and stereotyping can limit older adults' engagement with these facilities and their potential for health promotion. The research suggests strategies to eliminate visual ageism in advertising, such as designing for dynamic diversity and involving older adults in the design process.

MANAGING SPORT AND LEISURE (2023)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Identifying Ageism Within Australian Local Government Physical Activity Policy: A Critical Discourse Analysis

Michael Butson, Ruth Jeanes, Justen O'Connor

Summary: This research aims to identify ageist content in local government physical activity policies concerning older adults. Utilizing a critical discourse analysis approach, the study examined physical activity policy documents from 16 local government areas in Victoria, Australia, and conducted interviews with local government employees responsible for developing these policies. The findings suggest that ageism is prevalent in local government policies, leading to the perpetuation of stereotypes about older adults. However, it was also found that older adults make significant contributions to the community through paid employment, caregiving roles, and volunteering.

JOURNAL OF AGING AND PHYSICAL ACTIVITY (2023)

暂无数据