4.7 Review

Conceptual analysis of health systems resilience: A scoping review

期刊

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE
卷 232, 期 -, 页码 168-180

出版社

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.04.020

关键词

Resilience; Health systems; Health systems resilience; Conceptual analysis; Scoping review

资金

  1. Inserm, public research institute

向作者/读者索取更多资源

System resilience has long been an area of study, and the term has become increasingly used across different sectors. Studies on resilience in health systems are more recent, multiplying particularly since the 2014 Ebola epidemic in West Africa. The World Health Organization (WHO) is calling for national governments to increase the resilience of their health systems. Concepts help define research objects and guide the analysis. Yet, to be useful, concepts need to be clear and precise. We aimed to improve the conceptual understanding of health systems resilience by conducting a scoping review to describe the state of knowledge in this area. We searched for literature in 10 databases, and analyzed data using a list of themes. We evaluated the clarity and the precision of the concept of health systems resilience using Daigneault & Jacob's three dimensions of a concept: term, sense, and referent. Of the 1091 documents initially identified, 45 met the inclusion criteria. Term: multiple terms are used, switching from one to the other to speak about the same subject. Sense: there is no consensus yet on a unique definition. Referent the magnitude and nature of events that resilient health systems face differ with context, covering a broad range of situations from sudden crisis to everyday challenges. The lack of clarity in this conceptualization hinders the expansion of knowledge, the creation of reliable analytical tools, and the effectiveness of communication. The current conceptualization of health systems resilience is too scattered to enable the enhancement of this concept with great potential, opening a large avenue for future research.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Analyzing implementation of public health interventions: A need for rigor, and the challenges of stakeholder involvement

V. Ridde, S. Carillon, A. Desgrees du Lou, I. Sombie

Summary: This article demonstrates the role of conceptual models in the development and evaluation of public health interventions and discusses the challenges of stakeholder involvement. The analysis is based on the authors' participation in two public health intervention research projects. The findings emphasize the value of process evaluations and the need for a rigorous approach, highlighting the importance of stakeholder involvement and interdisciplinary evaluative approaches.

REVUE D EPIDEMIOLOGIE ET DE SANTE PUBLIQUE (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Considering social inequalities in health in COVID-19 response: insights from a French case study

Zoe Richard, Fanny Chabrol, Lara Gautier, Kate Zinszer, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study analyzed the consideration of social inequalities in health (SIH) in the design of two COVID-19 prevention and control interventions in France. The findings revealed that despite a shared concern for SIH, an epidemiological frame of reference dominated the intervention design, with consideration for SIH appearing as a complement. This highlights that the COVID-19 health crisis did not provide an opportunity to further address social inequalities in health.

HEALTH PROMOTION INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Innovations in mutuality: challenges and learnings for the Universal Health Insurance Plan in Mali

Laurence Toure, Pauline Boivin, Yacouba Diarra, Seydou Diabate, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study focuses on the innovation and scalability conditions for universal health coverage (UHC) in Mali. It reveals that the procrastination and scepticism at the government and international level, as well as the reluctance to renew the old mutualist proposal, have hindered the experiment. Therefore, future support and amplification of the reform are needed to expect a cheaper, technically and institutionally more efficient system.

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Evolution of assisted deliveries at primary healthcare centres in an unstable security context in Mali

Emmanuel Bonnet, Thomas Lerosier, Laurence Toure, Yacouba Diarra, Seydou Diabate, Dansine Diarra, Valery Ridde

Summary: In Mali, the conflict has severely affected the healthcare system, particularly in maternal healthcare. This study aims to understand how assisted deliveries are being organized at health centers and how they are adapting to the security crisis.

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Minimal resilience and insurgent conflict: qualitative analysis of the resilience process in six primary health centres in central Mali

Thomas Lerosier, Laurence Toure, Seydou Diabate, Yacouba Diarra, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study examines the challenges of implementing primary health centers in the context of insurgency conflicts in central Mali, within the framework of universal health coverage in the Sahel. It found that the resilience strategies deployed by health professionals were relatively basic and uncoordinated, and that individuals showed absorption but had limited room for maneuver. In the most isolated health centers, resilience relied on subordinate, poorly trained staff, and degraded working conditions and fear led to resignation among health workers.

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2023)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Use of interviewer-administered telephone surveys during infectious disease outbreaks, epidemics and pandemics: a scoping review

Sayaka Arita, Mouhamadou Faly Ba, Zoumana Traore, Emmanuel Bonnet, Adama Faye, Valery Ridde

Summary: During the COVID-19 crisis, researchers had to collect data remotely using telephone surveys and interviews. This scoping review identified 70 IATS conducted during infectious disease outbreaks, with a majority taking place during the COVID-19 pandemic. The use of qualitative studies and mobile phones for IATS increased during the pandemic.

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Learning from intersectoral initiatives to respond to the needs of refugees, asylum seekers, and migrants without status in the context of COVID-19 in Quebec and Ontario: a qualitative multiple case study protocol

Lara Gautier, Erica Di Ruggiero, Carly Jackson, Naima Bentayeb, Marie-Jeanne Blain, Fariha Chowdhury, Serigne Touba Mbacke Gueye, Muzhgan Haydary, Lara Maillet, Laila Mahmoudi, Shinjini Mondal, Armel Ouffouet Bessiranthy, Pierre Pluye, Saliha Ziam, Nassera Touati

Summary: This research project examines how community and public sectors collaborated on intersectoral initiatives during the COVID-19 pandemic to support refugees, asylum seekers, and migrants without status in Canadian cities. It aims to generate lessons for a sustainable response to the diverse needs of these migrants.

HEALTH RESEARCH POLICY AND SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Hospital Governance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Multiple-Country Case Study

Lara Gautier, Shinichiro Noda, Fanny Chabrol, Pierre-Marie David, Arnaud Duhoux, Renyou Hou, Sydia Rosana de Araujo Oliveira, Lola Traverson, Kate Zinszer, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study compares the governance strategies of six hospitals from Brazil, Canada, France, and Japan in response to COVID-19. It finds that hospitals' governance played a crucial role in reorganizing and responding to the needs of their staff. The study identifies significant variations across hospitals in terms of clear and timely COVID-19 response strategies, effective coordination within and across decision-making levels, and clear and transparent communication with diverse stakeholders.

HEALTH SYSTEMS & REFORM (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

How Did an Integrated Health and Social Services Center in the Quebec Province Respond to the COVID-19 Pandemic? A Qualitative Case Study

Morgane Gabet, Arnaud Duhoux, Valery Ridde, Kate Zinszer, Lara Gautier, Pierre-Marie David

Summary: In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, an integrated health and social services center in Quebec, Canada, developed resilience strategies including reorganizing services, managing contamination risks, and handling personal protective equipment and supplies. These strategies were influenced by Quebec's health care system reforms in 2015 and were constrained by organizational challenges such as centralized governance, budget cuts to long-term care facilities, and a lack of human resources.

HEALTH SYSTEMS & REFORM (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Did the design and planning of testing and contact tracing interventions for COVID-19 consider social inequalities in health? A multiple case study from Brazil, Canada, France & Mali

Marie-Catherine Gagnon-Dufresne, Lara Gautier, Camille Beaujoin, Pauline Boivin, Abdourahmane Coulibaly, Zoe Richard, Stephanie Gomes de Medeiros, Raylson Emanuel Dutra Da Nobrega, Sydia Rosana de Araujo Oliveira, Patrick Cloos, Fanny Chabrol, Valery Ridde, Kate Zinszer

Summary: This study analyzed the consideration of social inequalities in health (SIH) in the design and planning of public health responses to COVID-19 in Brazil, Canada, France, and Mali. The findings suggest that SIH was not prioritized in the initial responses, and decision-making power was unequal between different actors in each jurisdiction. Adaptations to interventions were made to improve accessibility, availability, and acceptability. The study highlights the importance of considering SIH in public health interventions and provides recommendations for collaboration, resources, and flexibility.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Financial issues in times of a COVID-19 pandemic in a tertiary hospital in Mali

Valery Ridde, Abdourahmane Coulibaly, Laurence Toure, Mouhamadou Faly Ba, Kate Zinszer, Emmanuel Bonnet, Ayako Honda

Summary: This study examines the impact of government financing response on healthcare providers' functioning during the COVID-19 pandemic, shaped by existing healthcare financing systems. Through in-depth interviews, observation, and reviewing records, the study found that complex public financing management procedures resulted in delays in fund transfers and decreased revenue for hospitals. These challenges led to delays in staff payments and potential unfair treatment of patients. The pre-existent issues in healthcare financing and governance constrained the effective management of COVID-19-related services and created confusion at the frontline of healthcare service delivery.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HEALTH PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Nursing

Supporting Reassigned Hospital Staff During the COVID-19 Pandemic in the Montreal Region: What Does it say About Leadership Styles?

Lara Gautier, Morgane Gabet, Arnaud Duhoux, Lola Traverson, Valery Ridde, Kate Zinszer, Pierre-Marie David

Summary: The study conducted a qualitative comparative analysis of two hospitals in Quebec to explore the experiences of hospital staff reassigned to COVID-affected facilities. It found major differences in leadership styles, with one hospital exhibiting leader-centered styles and the other expressing follower-centered leadership styles. These leadership styles were largely influenced by recent policies, and the study suggests that leadership styles that support the recovery of health human resources are crucial for successful crisis response.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF NURSING RESEARCH (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Hospital Resilience in Three COVID-19 Referral Hospitals in Brazil

Karla Myrelle Paz de Sousa, Sydia Rosana de Araujo Oliveira, Betise Mery Alencar Sousa Macau Furtado, Ana Lucia Ribeiro de Vasconcelos, Stephanie Gomes de Medeiros, Gisele Cazarin, Aletheia Soares Sampaio, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study evaluated the resilience of three hospitals in Recife, Brazil during the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings showed that all three hospitals demonstrated adaptive capacity but not transformative capacity.

HEALTH SYSTEMS & REFORM (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Exploring how social inequalities in health have influenced the design of Mali's SARS-CoV-2 testing policy: a qualitative study

Pauline Boivin, Lara Gautier, Abdourahmane Coulibaly, Kate Zinszer, Valery Ridde

Summary: This study examines whether and how social inequalities in health were addressed in the design and planning of the national COVID-19 testing policy in Mali. The results show that the concept of social inequalities in health was unclear to the participants and was not a priority for the authorities. Efforts to reduce inequalities across geographical territories were mentioned, but the reflection and consideration of social inequalities in health within COVID-19 interventions were difficult due to the governance approach and the urgency of the situation.

HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Using curiosity to counter health information avoidance

Samantha Horn, Yana Litovsky, George Loewenstein

Summary: This study suggests that curiosity can be a useful tool in increasing demand for and engagement with aversive health information. By manipulating curiosity through various methods, researchers found that participants were more likely to view and engage with information about their drinking habits, cancer risk, and the sugar content in drinks. Overall, curiosity prompts provide a simple and effective way to increase engagement with aversive health information.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

We're implementing AI now, so why not ask us what to do? - How AI providers perceive and navigate the spread of diagnostic AI in complex healthcare systems

Sandra Gillner

Summary: Despite high expectations, the extensive and rapid adoption of AI in medical diagnostics has not been realized. This study investigates the perception and navigation of AI providers in complex healthcare systems, revealing their self-organization to increase adaptability and the practices utilized to mitigate tensions within the healthcare subsystems.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring the impact of social protest on mental health: A study of the 2019 Social Uprising in Chile

Fabian Duartea, Alvaro Jimenez-Molina

Summary: This study found that violence related to social protest has a significant impact on depressive symptoms, leading to an increase in depression among the population in Chile. The effect varies by gender and age, with a stronger influence on men and young adults.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The impacts of rent burden and eviction on mortality in the United States, 2000-2019

Nick Graetz, Carl Gershenson, Sonya R. Porter, Danielle H. Sandler, Emily Lemmerman, Matthew Desmond

Summary: Investments in stable, affordable housing may be an important tool for improving population health. This study, using administrative data, found that high rent burden, increases in rent burden during midlife, and evictions were associated with increased mortality.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Beyond the patient-doctor dyad: Examining other patient engagement in Traditional Chinese Medicine consultations

Wan Wei

Summary: This study explores the phenomenon of other patient participation in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), uncovering the various roles that third parties can assume during medical interactions. The findings contribute to existing research on patient resistance and triadic medical interactions, providing insights into the dynamics and implications of third-party involvement in medical consultations.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Mobilizing pilot-based evidence for the spread and sustainability of innovations in healthcare: The role of innovation intermediaries

Harry Scarbrough, Katie Rose M. Sanfilippo, Alexandra Ziemann, Charitini Stavropoulou

Summary: This paper examines the contribution of pilot implementation studies to the wider spread and sustainability of innovation in healthcare systems. Through an empirical examination of an innovation intermediary organization in the English NHS, the study finds that their work in mobilizing pilot-based evidence involves configuring to context, transitioning evidence, and managing the transition. The findings contribute to theory by showing how intermediary roles can support the effective transitioning of pilot-based evidence, leading to more widespread adoption and sustainability of innovation.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Perinatal health in Spain during and after the Great Recession: Educational selection into fertility as a protective factor in high unemployment contexts

Marta Seiz, Leire Salazar, Tatiana Eremenko

Summary: This study examines the impact of maternal educational selection on birth outcomes during an economic recession, and finds that more educated mothers are more likely to give birth during high unemployment periods. Additionally, maternal education mitigates the adverse effects of unemployment on birth outcomes and is consistently associated with better perinatal health.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Cultural tightness-looseness and normative social influence in eight Asian countries: Associations of individual and collective norms with vaccination intentions

Jingyuan Shi, Hye Kyung Kim, Charles T. Salmon, Edson C. Tandoc Jr, Zhang Hao Goh

Summary: This study examines the influence of individual and collective norms on COVID-19 vaccination intention across eight Asian countries. The findings reveal nuanced patterns of how individual and collective social norms influence health behavioral decisions, depending on the degree of cultural tightness-looseness.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Social connectedness, functional capacity, and longevity: A focus on positive relations with others

Elliot Friedman, Melissa Franks, Elizabeth Teas, Patricia A. Thomas

Summary: This study found that positive relations with others have a significant impact on functional limitations and longevity in aging adults, independent of social integration and social support.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Age-friendly neighbourhood environment, functional abilities and life satisfaction: A longitudinal analysis of older adults in urban China

Zhuolin Pan, Yuqi Liu, Ye Liu, Ziwen Huo, Wenchao Han

Summary: This study examines the effects of age-friendly neighbourhood environment and functional abilities on life satisfaction among older adults in urban China. The findings highlight the importance of transportation, housing, and social and physical environment factors in influencing functional abilities and life satisfaction. The study provides valuable insights for policymakers in enhancing older adults' life satisfaction in the Chinese urban context.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)