4.7 Article

Assessment and inter-comparison of recently developed/reprocessed microwave satellite soil moisture products using ISMN ground-based measurements

期刊

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT
卷 224, 期 -, 页码 289-303

出版社

ELSEVIER SCIENCE INC
DOI: 10.1016/j.rse.2019.02.008

关键词

Soil moisture; International soil moisture network; Passive microwave remote sensing; Active microwave remote sensing; Evaluation; Review

资金

  1. CNES, France (Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales) through the TOSCA (Terre Ocean Surfaces Continentales et Atmosphere) program
  2. European Space Agency (ESA
  3. SMOS Expert Support Laboratory)

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Soil moisture (SM) is a key state variable in understanding the climate system through its control on the land surface energy, water budget partitioning, and the carbon cycle. Monitoring SM at regional scale has become possible thanks to microwave remote sensing. In the past two decades, several satellites were launched carrying on board either radiometer (passive) or radar (active) or both sensors in different frequency bands with various spatial and temporal resolutions. Soil moisture algorithms are in rapid development and their improvements/revisions are ongoing. The latest SM retrieval products and versions of products that have been recently released are not yet, to our knowledge, comprehensively evaluated and inter-compared over different ecoregions and climate conditions. The aim of this paper is to comprehensively evaluate the most recent microwave-based SM retrieval products available from NASA's (National Aeronautics and Space Administration) SMAP (Soil Moisture Active Passive) satellite, ESA's led mission (European Space Agency) SMOS (Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity) satellite, ASCAT (Advanced Scatterometer) sensor on board the meteorological operational (Metop) platforms Metop-A and Metop-B, and the ESA Climate Change Initiative (CCI) blended long-term SM time series. More specifically, in this study we compared SMAPL3 V4, SMOSL3 V300, SMOSL2 V650, ASCAT H111, and CCI V04.2 and the new SMOS-IC (V105) SM product. This evaluation was achieved using four statistical scores: Pearson correlation (considering both original observations and anomalies), RMSE, unbiased RMSE, and Bias between remotely-sensed SM retrievals and ground-based measurements from > 1000 stations from 17 monitoring networks, spread over the globe, disseminated through the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN). The analysis reveals that the performance of the remotely-sensed SM retrievals generally varies depending on ecoregions, land cover types, climate conditions, and between the monitoring networks. It also reveals that temporal sampling of the data, the frequency of data in time and the spatial coverage, affect the performance metrics. Overall, the performance of SMAP and SMOS-IC products compared slightly better with respect to the ISMN in situ observations than the other remotely-sensed products.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Siberian carbon sink reduced by forest disturbances

Lei Fan, Jean-Pierre Wigneron, Philippe Ciais, Jerome Chave, Martin Brandt, Stephen Sitch, Chao Yue, Ana Bastos, Xin Li, Yuanwei Qin, Wenping Yuan, Dmitry Schepaschenko, Liudmila Mukhortova, Xiaojun Li, Xiangzhuo Liu, Mengjia Wang, Frederic Frappart, Xiangming Xiao, Jingming Chen, Mingguo Ma, Jianguang Wen, Xiuzhi Chen, Hui Yang, Dave van Wees, Rasmus Fensholt

Summary: Siberian forests have been considered an important carbon sink, but severe droughts and fire disturbances may have affected their carbon dynamics. Limited forest inventories have led to uncertainties in the carbon balance. This study analyzed microwave observations from 2010 to 2019 and found that the carbon balance of Siberian forests was close to neutral, with a small carbon sink. Fire and drought caused significant losses of live above-ground carbon, contrasting with the greening trends in leaf area index. This highlights the vulnerability of large forest carbon stores in Siberia to climate-induced disturbances.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2023)

Article Agronomy

Asymmetric response of primary productivity to precipitation anomalies in Southwest China

Guanyu Dong, Lei Fan, Rasmus Fensholt, Frederic Frappart, Philippe Ciais, Xiangming Xiao, Stephen Sitch, Zanpin Xing, Ling Yu, Zhilan Zhou, Mingguo Ma, Xiaowei Tong, Qing Xiao, Jean-Pierre Wigneron

Summary: Southwest China has been the largest terrestrial carbon sink in China, but recent droughts caused by high precipitation variability have posed a threat to vegetation productivity. The impact of precipitation anomalies on vegetation primary productivity is still poorly understood.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST METEOROLOGY (2023)

Article Meteorology & Atmospheric Sciences

Impact of Design Factors for ESA CCI Satellite Soil Moisture Data Assimilation over Europe

Zdenko Heyvaert, Samuel Scherrer, Michel Bechtold, Alexander Gruber, Wouter Dorigo, Sujay Kumar, Gabrielle De Lannoy

Summary: In this study, the combination of active-passive ESA Climate Change Initiative soil moisture product with the Noah-MP land surface model is evaluated over Europe. The impact of different design choices on the performance of the data assimilation system is explored. The choice of observation errors, observation bias correction method, and atmospheric reanalysis dataset all affect the skill improvements.

JOURNAL OF HYDROMETEOROLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Uncertainty Quantification of Satellite Soil Moisture Retrieved Precipitation in the Central Tibetan Plateau

Ke Zhang, Long Zhao, Kun Yang, Lisheng Song, Xiang Ni, Xujun Han, Mingguo Ma, Lei Fan

Summary: This study quantifies the uncertainties in SM2RAIN-estimated precipitation using SMAP soil moisture data in the Tibetan Plateau. The original SM2RAIN algorithm underestimates precipitation, and the descending SMAP product performs better than the ascending one. The combination of both orbits improves the overall estimation accuracy.

REMOTE SENSING (2023)

Article Ecology

Effect of Socioeconomic Variables in Predicting Global Fire Ignition Occurrence

Tichaona Mukunga, Matthias Forkel, Matthew Forrest, Ruxandra-Maria Zotta, Nirlipta Pande, Stefan Schlaffer, Wouter Dorigo

Summary: Fires are common on land and contribute to carbon emissions. Humans are responsible for most fire ignitions. Models are used to estimate fire effects, but there is no agreement on how to represent human-caused fire ignitions. This study examined globally available predictors of human activity to explain fire ignitions.

FIRE-SWITZERLAND (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Drought and Waterlogging Stress Regimes in Northern Peatlands Detected Through Satellite Retrieved Solar-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence

Bram Valkenborg, Gabrielle J. M. De Lannoy, Alexander Gruber, Diego G. Miralles, Philipp Koehler, Christian Frankenberg, Ankur R. Desai, Elyn Humphreys, Janina Klatt, Annalea Lohila, Mats B. Nilsson, Eeva-Stiina Tuittila, Michel Bechtold

Summary: This study investigates water-related vegetation stress in northern peatlands using satellite-observed Solar-Induced chlorophyll Fluorescence (SIF). The results show that most locations experience both drought and waterlogging stress, while some regions only experience waterlogging or drought stress. The study finds that the minimal water-related vegetation stress occurs at a water table depth of -0.22 m (short-term) and -0.20 m (long-term).

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Global increase in biomass carbon stock dominated by growth of northern young forests over past decade

Hui Yang, Philippe Ciais, Frederic Frappart, Xiaojun Li, Martin Brandt, Rasmus Fensholt, Lei Fan, Sassan Saatchi, Simon Besnard, Zhu Deng, Simon Bowring, Jean-Pierre Wigneron

Summary: Changes in terrestrial carbon storage under environmental and land-use changes are crucial for regional and global carbon budgets. This study used L-band microwave vegetation optical depth to generate global maps of annual live vegetation biomass, and found that boreal and temperate forests contribute the most to the global carbon sink, while wet tropical forests serve as small carbon sources. Additionally, the study revealed that tropical deforested and degraded old-growth forests are nearly carbon neutral, while young and middle-aged forests in temperate and boreal regions are the largest sinks.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Hidden becomes clear: Optical remote sensing of vegetation reveals water table dynamics in northern peatlands

Iuliia Burdun, Michel Bechtold, Mika Aurela, Gabrielle De Lannoy, Ankur R. Desai, Elyn Humphreys, Santtu Kareksela, Viacheslav Komisarenko, Maarit Liimatainen, Hannu Marttila, Kari Minkkinen, Mats B. Nilsson, Paavo Ojanen, Sini-Selina Salko, Eeva-Stiina Tuittila, Evelyn Uuemaa, Miina Rautiainen

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Heatwave Characteristics in the Recent Climate and at Different Global Warming Levels: A Multimodel Analysis at the Global Scale

A. Al-Yaari, Y. Zhao, F. Cheruy, W. Thiery

Summary: This study analyzes the representation of heatwaves in CMIP6 models and evaluates their performance against global reanalysis and observations. It investigates how heatwaves are projected to change at different global warming levels. The results show that the models perform reasonably well in representing time-related criteria but have larger uncertainty in capturing the magnitude of heatwaves. The projections indicate that heatwave occurrence, spatial extension, and duration will increase globally at different global warming levels, but with strong regional variability and model dependency.

EARTHS FUTURE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate Variability and Glacier Evolution at Selected Sites Across the World: Past Trends and Future Projections

Amen Al-Yaari, Thomas Condom, Clementine Junquas, Antoine Rabatel, Victor Ramseyer, Jean-Emmanuel Sicart, Mariano Masiokas, Sophie Cauvy-Fraunie, Olivier Dangles

Summary: This study focuses on 25 glaciers in different climates and latitudes and investigates their recent and projected trends in precipitation, temperatures, ice mass loss, and their relationships with cloud properties. The findings show that almost half of the studied glaciers are likely to vanish by 2050, with widespread warming and drying trends. These results highlight the serious consequences for future water availability.

EARTHS FUTURE (2023)

Article Remote Sensing

Carbon dynamics of Western North American boreal forests in response to stand-replacing disturbances

Ling Yu, Lei Fan, Philippe Ciais, Stephen Sitch, Rasmus Fensholt, Xiangming Xiao, Wenping Yuan, Jingming Chen, Yingtong Zhang, Xiaocui Wu, Yuanwei Qin, Mingguo Ma, Zhongbing Chang, Mengjia Wang, Kai Yan, Lisheng Song, Jean-Pierre Wigneron

Summary: North American boreal forests have suffered extensive tree mortality and carbon loss due to stand-replacing disturbances, but the impacts on forest dynamics are still unknown. This study used remote sensing data and biomass datasets to estimate the effects of fires, logging, and insect outbreaks on the carbon balance of western North American boreal forests. The results showed significant losses in aboveground biomass for all three disturbances, with fire being the dominant factor for forest recovery. Environmental factors also played a role in forest recovery. These findings have important implications for effective forest management after disturbances.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATION AND GEOINFORMATION (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Soil moisture estimates at 1 km resolution making a synergistic use of Sentinel data

Remi Madelon, Nemesio J. Rodriguez-Fernandez, Hassan Bazzi, Nicolas Baghdadi, Clement Albergel, Wouter Dorigo, Mehrez Zribi

Summary: High-resolution (around 10-100m) surface soil moisture observations are important for various applications. This study adapted the (SMP)-M-2 algorithm to work at 1 km resolution and extended its application to herbaceous vegetation types. The algorithm combines Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data and shows good agreement and accuracy compared to other datasets.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Ecology

Assessing the sensitivity of multi-frequency passive microwave vegetationoptical depth to vegetation properties

Luisa Schmidt, Matthias Forkel, Ruxandra-Maria Zotta, Samuel Scherrer, Wouter A. Dorigo, Alexander Kuhn-Regnier, Robin van der Schalie, Marta Yebra

Summary: Vegetation attenuates microwave emission from the land surface. This attenuation is quantified by vegetation optical depth (VOD) and can be used to estimate above-ground biomass, monitor phenology, and model wildfires at large scales. Different VOD products exist, but the relationships with vegetation variables are non-monotonic and complex, indicating the need for more sophisticated estimation methods.

BIOGEOSCIENCES (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Reliability of resilience estimation based on multi-instrument time series

Taylor Smith, Ruxandra-Maria Zotta, Chris A. Boulton, Timothy M. Lenton, Wouter Dorigo, Niklas Boers

Summary: Many widely used observational data sets consist of overlapping instrument records. A growing body of work explores using metrics such as variance and autocorrelation to quantify the stability or resilience of a system and detect critical transitions. This study examines how changes in noise structure of a data set affect resilience metrics, using both synthetic and empirical data from remote sensing vegetation indicators.

EARTH SYSTEM DYNAMICS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Estimating leaf moisture content at global scale from passive microwave satellite observations of vegetation optical depth

Matthias Forkel, Luisa Schmidt, Ruxandra-Maria Zotta, Wouter Dorigo, Marta Yebra

Summary: The moisture content of vegetation canopies plays a crucial role in various ecosystem processes. Leaf moisture content, or live-fuel moisture content, is frequently used to estimate flammability and fire danger. This study aims to estimate leaf moisture content from microwave satellite observations at large scales and over decadal time series. The results show a strong correlation between microwave observations and leaf moisture content in grasslands, croplands, and shrublands.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Improving estimates of sub-daily gross primary production from solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence by accounting for light distribution within canopy

Ruonan Chen, Liangyun Liu, Xinjie Liu, Zhunqiao Liu, Lianhong Gu, Uwe Rascher

Summary: This study presents methods to accurately estimate sub-daily GPP from SIF in evergreen needleleaf forests and demonstrates that the interactions among light, canopy structure, and leaf physiology regulate the SIF-GPP relationship at the canopy scale.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Evaluating the spatial patterns of US urban NOx emissions using TROPOMI NO2

Daniel L. Goldberg, Madankui Tao, Gaige Hunter Kerr, Siqi Ma, Daniel Q. Tong, Arlene M. Fiore, Angela F. Dickens, Zachariah E. Adelman, Susan C. Anenberg

Summary: A novel method is applied in this study to directly use satellite data to evaluate the spatial patterns of urban NOx emissions inventories. The results show that the 108 spatial surrogates used by NEMO are generally appropriate, but there may be underestimation in areas with dense intermodal facilities and overestimation in wealthy communities.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Wide-swath and high-resolution whisk-broom imaging and on-orbit performance of SDGSAT-1 thermal infrared spectrometer

Zhuoyue Hu, Xiaoyan Li, Liyuan Li, Xiaofeng Su, Lin Yang, Yong Zhang, Xingjian Hu, Chun Lin, Yujun Tang, Jian Hao, Xiaojin Sun, Fansheng Chen

Summary: This paper proposes a whisk-broom imaging method using a long-linear-array detector and high-precision scanning mirror to achieve high-resolution and wide-swath thermal infrared data. The method has been implemented in the SDGs satellite and has shown promising test results.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Simulation of urban thermal anisotropy at remote sensing pixel scales: Evaluating three schemes using GUTA-T over Toulouse city

Dandan Wang, Leiqiu Hu, James A. Voogt, Yunhao Chen, Ji Zhou, Gaijing Chang, Jinling Quan, Wenfeng Zhan, Zhizhong Kang

Summary: This study evaluates different schemes for determining model coefficients to quantify and correct the anisotropic impact from remote sensing LST for urban applications. The schemes have consistent results and accurately estimate parameter values, facilitating the broadening of parametric models.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Very high resolution canopy height maps from RGB imagery using self-supervised vision transformer and convolutional decoder trained on aerial lidar

Jamie Tolan, Hung - Yang, Benjamin Nosarzewski, Guillaume Couairon, Huy V. Vo, John Brandt, Justine Spore, Sayantan Majumdar, Daniel Haziza, Janaki Vamaraju, Theo Moutakanni, Piotr Bojanowski, Tracy Johns, Brian White, Tobias Tiecke, Camille Couprie

Summary: Vegetation structure mapping is crucial for understanding the global carbon cycle and monitoring nature-based approaches to climate adaptation and mitigation. This study presents the first high-resolution canopy height maps for California and Sao Paulo, achieved through the use of very high resolution satellite imagery and aerial lidar data. The maps provide valuable tools for forest structure assessment and land use monitoring.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatially constrained atmosphere and surface retrieval for imaging spectroscopy

Regina Eckert, Steffen Mauceri, David R. Thompson, Jay E. Fahlen, Philip G. Brodrick

Summary: In this paper, a mathematical framework is proposed to improve the retrieval of surface reflectance and atmospheric parameters by leveraging the expected spatial smoothness of the atmosphere. Experimental results show that this framework can reduce the surface reflectance retrieval error and surface-related biases.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

A vehicle imaging approach to acquire ground truth data for upscaling to satellite data: A case study for estimating harvesting dates

Chongya Jiang, Kaiyu Guan, Yizhi Huang, Maxwell Jong

Summary: This study presents the Field Rover method, which uses vehicle-mounted cameras to collect ground truth data on crop harvesting status. The machine learning approach and remote sensing technology are employed to upscale the results to a regional scale. The accuracy of the remote sensing method in predicting crop harvesting dates is validated through comparison with satellite data.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Low-amplitude brittle deformations revealed by UAV surveys in alluvial fans along the northwest coast of Lake Baikal: Neotectonic significance and geological hazards

Oksana V. Lunina, Anton A. Gladkov, Alexey V. Bochalgin

Summary: In this study, an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) was used to detect and map surface discontinuities with displacements of a few centimeters, indicating the presence of initial geological deformations. The study found that sediments of alluvial fans are susceptible to various tectonic and exogenous deformational processes, and the interpretation of ultra-high resolution UAV images can help recognize low-amplitude brittle deformations at an early stage. UAV surveys are critical for discerning neotectonic activity and its related hazards over short observation periods.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Global retrieval of the spectrum of terrestrial chlorophyll fluorescence: First results with TROPOMI

Feng Zhao, Weiwei Ma, Jun Zhao, Yiqing Guo, Mateen Tariq, Juan Li

Summary: This study presents a data-driven approach to reconstruct the terrestrial SIF spectrum using measurements from the TROPOMI instrument on Sentinel-5 precursor mission. The reconstructed SIF spectrum shows improved spatiotemporal distributions and demonstrates consistency with other datasets, indicating its potential for better understanding of the ecosystem function.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Choosing a sample size allocation to strata based on trade-offs in precision when estimating accuracy and area of a rare class from a stratified sample

Stephen Stehman, John E. Wagner

Summary: This article investigates optimal sample allocation in stratified random sampling for estimation of accuracy and proportion of area in applications where the target class is rare. The study finds that precision of estimated accuracy has a stronger impact on sample allocation than estimation of proportion of area, and the trade-offs among these estimates become more pronounced as the target class becomes rarer. The results provide quantitative evidence to guide sample allocation decisions in specific applications.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Use of a new Tibetan Plateau network for permafrost to characterize satellite-based products errors: An application to soil moisture and freeze/ thaw

Jingyao Zheng, Tianjie Zhao, Haishen Lu, Defu Zou, Nemesio Rodriguez-Fernandez, Arnaud Mialon, Philippe Richaume, Jianshe Xiao, Jun Ma, Lei Fan, Peilin Song, Yonghua Zhu, Rui Li, Panpan Yao, Qingqing Yang, Shaojie Du, Zhen Wang, Zhiqing Peng, Yuyang Xiong, Zanpin Xing, Lin Zhao, Yann Kerr, Jiancheng Shi

Summary: Soil moisture and freeze/thaw (F/T) play a crucial role in water and heat exchanges at the land-atmosphere interface. This study reports the establishment of a wireless sensor network for soil moisture and temperature over the permafrost region of Tibetan Plateau. Satellite-based surface soil moisture (SSM) and F/T products were evaluated using ground-based measurements. The results show the reliability of L-band passive microwave SSM and F/T products, while existing F/T products display earlier freezing and later thawing, leading to unsatisfactory accuracy.

REMOTE SENSING OF ENVIRONMENT (2024)