4.6 Article

Outcomes of 92 patient-driven family studies for reclassification of variants of uncertain significance

期刊

GENETICS IN MEDICINE
卷 21, 期 6, 页码 1435-1442

出版社

SPRINGERNATURE
DOI: 10.1038/s41436-018-0335-7

关键词

variant of uncertain significance; family study; patient-driven; variant classification; VOUS

资金

  1. Damon Runyon Cancer Research Foundation [DRR-33-15]
  2. National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) [R21HG008513]
  3. Fred Hutch/University of Washington Cancer Consortium [NCI 5P30 CA015704-39]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Purpose: Family studies are an important but underreported source of information for reclassification of variants of uncertain significance (VUS). We evaluated outcomes of a patient-driven framework that offered familial VUS reclassification analysis to any adult with any clinically ascertained VUS from any laboratory in the United States. Methods: With guidance from FindMyVariant. org, participants recruited their own relatives for study participation. We genotyped relatives, calculated quantitative cosegregation likelihood ratios, and evaluated variant classifications using Tavtigian's unified framework for Bayesian analysis with American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology (ACMG/AMP) criteria. We report participation and VUS reclassification rates from the 50 families enrolled for at least one year and reclassification results for 112 variants from the larger 92-family cohort. Results: For the 50-family cohort, 6.7 relatives per family were invited to participate and 67% of relatives returned samples for genotyping. Sixty-one percent of VUS were reclassified, 84% of which were classified as benign or likely benign. Genotyping relatives identified a de novo variant, phase variants, and relatives with phenotypes highly specific for or incompatible with specific classifications. Conclusions: Motivated families can contribute to successful VUS reclassification at substantially higher rates than those previously published. Clinical laboratories could consider offering family studies to all patients with VUS.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.6
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Relationship between genetic knowledge and familial communication of CRC risk and intent to communicate CRCP genetic information: insights from FamilyTalk eMERGE III

Sukh Makhnoon, Deborah J. Bowen, Brian H. Shirts, Stephanie M. Fullerton, Hendrika W. Meischke, Eric B. Larson, James D. Ralston, Kathleen Leppig, David R. Crosslin, David Veenstra, Gail P. Jarvik

Summary: This study found that patients' genetic knowledge was associated with their future intended familial communication of genetic information, but not with current communication of colorectal cancer risk. Better family functioning was associated with more frequent current communication of CRC risk.

TRANSLATIONAL BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

What improves the likelihood of people receiving genetic test results communicating to their families about genetic risk?

Deborah J. Bowen, Sukh Makhnoon, Brian H. Shirts, Stephanie M. Fullerton, Eric Larson, James D. Ralston, Kathleen Leppig, David R. Crosslin, David Veenstra, Gail P. Jarvik

Summary: The study found infrequent communication of cancer risk among family members, with a low overall impact of communication within the family. Age and education were associated with the frequency of familial communication, but not with the cancer-related impact of familial communication.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2021)

Article Oncology

The FamilyTalk randomized controlled trial: patient-reported outcomes in clinical genetic sequencing for colorectal cancer

Sukh Makhnoon, Deborah J. Bowen, Brian H. Shirts, Stephanie M. Fullerton, Eric B. Larson, James D. Ralston, Kathleen A. Leppig, David R. Crosslin, David Veenstra, Gail P. Jarvik

Summary: Genetic information plays a role in family communication about colorectal cancer risk and screening, but the study found that tools like FamilyTalk did not significantly impact patient-reported outcomes in terms of privacy concerns, reactions to test results, and lifestyle changes. The limited sample size of participants with specific genetic results and the short follow-up period could have influenced the lack of significant findings.

CANCER CAUSES & CONTROL (2021)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Design of a study to implement population-based risk assessment for hereditary cancer genetic testing in primary care

Deborah J. Bowen, Catharine Wang, Allison M. Cole, Barbara M. Norquist, Sarah Knerr, Beth Devine, Brian Shirts, Kevin Cain, Heather M. Harris, Helen G. Haile, Elizabeth M. Swisher

Summary: This study aims to compare and evaluate two population-wide engagement strategies for identifying members of a primary care clinic's population with a family or personal history of cancer and offering high-risk individuals genetic testing for cancer susceptibility mutations. The study will evaluate the effects of the two engagement strategies on patient, provider, and clinic leader outcomes, including perceptions of benefits, harms, and satisfaction with the engagement strategy and process of cancer risk assessment and genetic testing. Additionally, the study will assess the cost-effectiveness and budget impact of each engagement strategy.

CONTEMPORARY CLINICAL TRIALS (2021)

Article Genetics & Heredity

One in seven pathogenic variants can be challenging to detect by NGS: an analysis of 450,000 patients with implications for clinical sensitivity and genetic test implementation

Stephen E. Lincoln, Tina Hambuch, Justin M. Zook, Sara L. Bristow, Kathryn Hatchell, Rebecca Truty, Michael Kennemer, Brian H. Shirts, Andrew Fellowes, Shimul Chowdhury, Eric W. Klee, Shazia Mahamdallie, Megan H. Cleveland, Peter M. Vallone, Yan Ding, Sheila Seal, Wasanthi DeSilva, Farol L. Tomson, Catherine Huang, Russell K. Garlick, Nazneen Rahman, Marc Salit, Stephen F. Kingsmore, Matthew J. Ferber, Swaroop Aradhya, Robert L. Nussbaum

Summary: The study evaluated the impact of technically challenging variants on clinical genetic tests, finding considerable variability in the analytic and clinical sensitivity of NGS workflows. Some challenging variants were not detected by all workflows, highlighting the importance of test design, validation, and selection for clinicians.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2021)

Article Allergy

Molecular diagnosis of childhood immune dysregulation, polyendocrinopathy, and enteropathy, and implications for clinical management

Sarah K. Baxter, Tom Walsh, Silvia Casadei, Mary M. Eckert, Eric J. Allenspach, David Hagin, Gesmar Segundo, Ming K. Lee, Suleyman Gulsuner, Brian H. Shirts, Kathleen E. Sullivan, Michael D. Keller, Troy R. Torgerson, Mary-Claire King

Summary: This study identified damaging germline mutations in 27 genes in about 39% of patients with childhood-onset immune dysregulation, polyendocrinopathy, and enteropathy. Many of these genes had not been previously associated with the disease. Genetic diagnoses of these patients have clinical implications and can potentially alter therapeutic management, providing targeted treatments and recommendations for hematopoietic cell transplantation.

JOURNAL OF ALLERGY AND CLINICAL IMMUNOLOGY (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Closing the gap: Systematic integration of multiplexed functional data resolves variants of uncertain significance in BRCA1, TPS3, and PTEN

Shawn Fayer, Carrie Horton, Jennifer N. Dines, Alan F. Rubin, Marcy E. Richardson, Kelly McGoldrick, Felicia Hernandez, Tina Pesaran, Rachid Karam, Brian H. Shirts, Douglas M. Fowler, Lea M. Starita

Summary: The combination of multiplexed functional data with clinical data can effectively drive the reclassification of missense variants, reducing the number of variants of uncertain significance and having a major impact on clinical variant interpretation.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2021)

Article Urology & Nephrology

Inherited TP53 Variants and Risk of Prostate Cancer

Kara N. Maxwell, Heather H. Cheng, Jacquelyn Powers, Roman Gulati, Elisa M. Ledet, Casey Morrison, Anh Le, Ryan Hausler, Jill Stopfer, Sophie Hyman, Wendy Kohlmann, Anne Naumer, Jennie Vagher, Samantha E. Greenberg, Lorraine Naylor, Mercy Laurino, Eric Q. Konnick, Brian H. Shirts, Saud H. AlDubayan, Eliezer M. Van Allen, Bastien Nguyen, Joseph Vijai, Wassim Abida, Maria Carlo, Marianne Dubard-Gault, Daniel J. Lee, Luke D. Maese, Diana Mandelker, Bruce Montgomery, Michael J. Morris, Piper Nicolosi, Robert L. Nussbaum, Lauren E. Schwartz, Zsofia Stadler, Judy E. Garber, Kenneth Offit, Joshua D. Schiffman, Peter S. Nelson, Oliver Sartor, Michael F. Walsh, Colin C. Pritchard

Summary: Complementary analysis of prostate cancer incidence in LFS males and gTP53 prevalence in prostate cancer cohorts suggests that gTP53 predisposes to aggressive prostate cancer. Prostate cancer should be considered as part of LFS screening protocols and TP53 should be considered in germline prostate cancer susceptibility testing.

EUROPEAN UROLOGY (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Harmonizing variant classification for return of results in the All of Us Research Program

Steven M. Harrison, Christina A. Austin-Tse, Serra Kim, Matthew Lebo, Annette Leon, David Murdock, Aparna Radhakrishnan, Brian H. Shirts, Marcie Steeves, Eric Venner, Richard A. Gibbs, Gail P. Jarvik, Heidi L. Rehm

Summary: The All of Us Research Program aims to accelerate research and improve healthcare by collecting data from one million people in the United States. Participants can choose to receive genome analysis results, including actionable findings for certain gene-disorder pairs. Four participating clinical laboratories conducted a prelaunch study to ensure consistent reporting of variant classifications, with 99.1% concordance and resolution of all reportability differences through reassessment and discussion. This approach will be maintained for continuous classification harmonization and consistent reporting within the program.

HUMAN MUTATION (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Laboratory-related outcomes from integrating an accessible delivery model for hereditary cancer risk assessment and genetic testing in populations with barriers to access

Laura M. Amendola, Elizabeth Shuster, Michael C. Leo, Michael O. Dorschner, Bradley A. Rolf, Brian H. Shirts, Marian J. Gilmore, Sonia Okuyama, Jamilyn M. Zepp, Tia L. Kauffman, Kathleen F. Mittendorf, Cecilia Bellcross, Charisma L. Jenkins, Galen Joseph, Leslie Riddle, Sapna Syngal, Chinedu Ukaegbu, Katrina A. B. Goddard, Benjamin S. Wilfond, Gail P. Jarvik

Summary: This study aims to evaluate the laboratory-related outcomes of participants offered genomic testing based on cancer family history risk assessment tools. The study found that 5% of participants had a pathogenic/likely pathogenic cancer risk variant and 1% had a secondary finding. Participant personal history and PREMM5 score were associated with the category of findings.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

An algorithm for optimal testing in co-segregation analysis

Ronald W. Buie, John Michael O. Ranola, Annie T. Chen, Brian H. Shirts

Summary: This paper proposes an algorithm to evaluate the variant information gain in familial cosegregation analysis, and validates its performance by comparing actual recruitment strategies with optimized testing strategies. The results show that the testing strategy indicated by the algorithm can achieve maximal information gain more rapidly.

HUMAN MUTATION (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Implementation of pharmacogenomic clinical decision support for health systems: a cost-utility analysis

Shangqing Jiang, Patrick C. Mathias, Nathaniel Hendrix, Brian H. Shirts, Peter Tarczy-Hornoch, David Veenstra, Daniel Malone, Beth Devine

Summary: A cost-effectiveness model was constructed to evaluate the clinical and economic value of a CDS alert program providing PGx testing results in ACS and AF. The program was found to significantly reduce major clinical events and deaths in ACS and AF, and was cost-effective with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of $39,477/QALY compared to no alert program, under a willingness-to-pay threshold of $100,000/QALY gained.

PHARMACOGENOMICS JOURNAL (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Socioeconomic Status and Interest in Genetic Testing in a US-Based Sample

E. J. Dusic, Deborah J. Bowen, Robin Bennett, Kevin C. Cain, Tesla Theoryn, Mariebeth Velasquez, Elizabeth Swisher, Jeannine M. Brant, Brian Shirts, Catharine Wang

Summary: This study found that socioeconomic status affects individuals' interest in pursuing hereditary cancer genetic testing, with factors such as education and household income being related to the level of interest.

HEALTHCARE (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

The utility of cerebrospinal fluid-derived cell-free DNA in molecular diagnostics for the PIK3CA-related megalencephaly-capillary malformation (MCAP) syndrome: a case report

Wei-Liang Chen, Emily Pao, James Owens, Ian Glass, Colin Pritchard, Brain H. Shirts, Christina Lockwood, Ghayda M. Mirzaa

Summary: The megalencephaly-capillary malformation (MCAP) syndrome is an overgrowth disorder caused by mosaic gain-of-function variants in PIK3CA. This study reports the utility of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF)-derived cfDNA for the molecular diagnosis of MCAP syndrome and highlights the importance of minimally invasive approaches using cfDNA for accurate diagnosis and potential therapeutic implications for individuals with refractory epilepsy.

COLD SPRING HARBOR MOLECULAR CASE STUDIES (2022)

Article Oncology

Prospective Statewide Study of Universal Screening for Hereditary Colorectal Cancer: The Ohio Colorectal Cancer Prevention Initiative

Rachel Pearlman, Wendy L. Frankel, Benjamin J. Swanson, Dan Jones, Weiqiang Zhao, Ahmet Yilmaz, Kristin Miller, Jason Bacher, Christopher Bigley, Lori Nelsen, Paul J. Goodfellow, Richard M. Goldberg, Electra Paskett, Peter G. Shields, Jo L. Freudenheim, Peter P. Stanich, Ilene Lattimer, Mark Arnold, Thomas W. Prior, Mitchell Haut, Matthew F. Kalady, Brandie Heald, Ian Paquette, David J. Draper, Joanna M. Brell, Sameer Mahesh, Kisa Weeman, Shyamal Bastola, Jeffrey Zangmeister, Aruna Gowda, Filix Kencana, Albert Malcolm, Yinong Liu, Sharon Cole, Charles Bane, Chaoyang Li, Esther Rehmus, Colin C. Pritchard, Brian H. Shirts, Angela Jacobson, Shelly A. Cummings, Albert de la Chapelle, Heather Hampel

Summary: The study found that 7.1% of individuals with CRC have PGVs, and UTS alone is insufficient for identifying a large proportion of CRC patients with hereditary syndromes, including some with LS. Pan-cancer MGPT for all patients with CRC may be a better screening method.

JCO PRECISION ONCOLOGY (2021)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Two years of newborn screening for Duchenne muscular dystrophy as a part of the statewide Early Check research program in North Carolina

Katerina S. Kucera, Beth Lincoln Boyea, Brooke Migliore, Sarah Nelson Potter, Veronica R. Robles, Oksana Kutsa, Heidi Cope, Katherine C. Okoniewski, Anne Wheeler, Catherine W. Rehder, Edward C. Smith, Holly L. Peay

Summary: Screening for elevated CK-MM levels in dried blood spots is a feasible method to identify newborns with DMD. Including specific cutoffs, repeat testing, and genetic sequencing can improve the accuracy and sensitivity of screening.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Preparing for the unexpected: Recommendations for returning secondary findings in late-stage cancer care

Madeline Currey, Ilana Solomon, Sarah Mcgraw, Jenny Shen, Francisco Munoz, Ernesto Sosa, Vanessa Puello-Lozano, Sam Wing, Lisa Lopez, Michelle Afkhami, Janine Lobello, Szabolcs Szelinger, Stacy W. Gray

Summary: This study conducted qualitative interviews with cancer patients and providers to identify gaps in clinical care and propose care delivery solutions for the return of secondary germline findings. The responses of patients varied depending on the amount of pre-test counseling they received, and providers identified insufficient clinic time as a major barrier to pretest education. Online support tools and standardized pre-test education models were favored by providers. There were differing perspectives on how pre-test education should be integrated into clinical workflows, but agreement on the inclusion of differences between somatic and germline testing, likelihood of medically actionable findings, and the possibility of being referred to a genetics provider.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Genome sequencing detects a wide range of clinically relevant copy-number variants and other genomic alterations

Kiely N. James, Shimul Chowdhury, Yan Ding, Sergey Batalov, Kelly Watkins, Yong Hyun Kwon, Lucitia Van Der Kraan, Katarzyna Ellsworth, Stephen F. Kingsmore, Lucia Guidugli

Summary: This study used genome sequencing to detect a wide range of copy-number variants (CNVs) and other non-single nucleotide variant/indel variant types. These genetic alterations accounted for 15.8% of reported variants, with deletions being the most common type. The study also found that additional genetic tests were ordered in some cases, but failed to report the variants detected by genome sequencing.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Physician services and costs after disclosure of diagnostic sequencing results in the NYCKidSeq program

Asem Berkalieva, Nicole R. Kelly, Ashley Fisher, Samuel F. Hohmann, Monisha Sebastin, Miranda Di Biase, Katherine E. Bonini, Priya Marathe, Jacqueline A. Odgis, Sabrina A. Suckiel, Michelle A. Ramos, Rosamond Rhodes, Noura S. Abul-Husn, John M. Greally, Carol R. Horowitz, Melissa P. Wasserstein, Eimear E. Kenny, Bruce D. Gelb, Bart S. Ferket

Summary: The study aims to understand the effects of returning diagnostic sequencing results on clinical actions and economic outcomes for pediatric patients with suspected genetic disorders. The results showed that patients with positive findings were more likely to receive specialist consultation, but there were no significant increases in overall physician services and costs. More large-scale studies are needed to confirm these findings.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Incidence, prevalence, age at diagnosis, and mortality in individuals with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism: A population-based registry study

Kirstine Stochholm, Camilla Holmgard, Shanlee M. Davis, Claus H. Gravholt, Agnethe Berglund

Summary: This study assessed the incidence, prevalence, and age at diagnosis of individuals with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism and described the associated mortality pattern. The study found an increasing incidence of 45,X/46,XY mosaicism in males and a stable incidence in females. Males were diagnosed at an older age than females. Additionally, 45,X/46,XY mosaicism was associated with increased all-cause mortality.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)

Article Genetics & Heredity

DLG2 intragenic exonic deletions reinforce the link to neurodevelopmental disorders and suggest a potential association with congenital anomalies and dysmorphism

Yunjia Chen, Ender Karaca, Nathaniel H. Robin, Dana Goodloe, Ali Al-Beshri, S. Joy Dean, Anna C. E. Hurst, Andrew J. Carroll, Fady M. Mikhail

Summary: This study confirms the association between DLG2 intragenic deletions and neurodevelopmental disorders, supports the haploinsufficiency of the DLG2 gene, and suggests a potential association between these deletions and congenital anomalies and dysmorphism.

GENETICS IN MEDICINE (2024)