4.7 Article

A new approach to the problem of overlapping values: A case study in Australia's Great Barrier Reef

期刊

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES
卷 10, 期 -, 页码 61-78

出版社

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.ecoser.2014.09.005

关键词

Great Barrier Reef; Ecosystem services; Economic valuation; Total economic value

资金

  1. Australian Government's National Environmental Research Program TROPICAL Ecosystems Hub [10.2]
  2. James Cook University
  3. Australian National University
  4. Charles Darwin University

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Estimating the value of entire ecosystems in monetary units is difficult because they are complex systems composed of non-linear, interdependent components and the value of the services they produce are interdependent and overlapping. Using the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) as a case study, this paper explores a new 'whole ecosystem' approach to assessing both the importance (to overall quality of life) and the monetary value of various community-defined benefits, some of which align with various ecosystem services. We find that provisioning services are considered, by residents, to be less important to their overall quality of life than other ecosystem services. But our analysis suggests that many community-defined benefits are overlapping. Using statistical techniques to identify and control for these overlapping benefits, we estimate that the collective monetary value of a broad range of services provided by the GBR is likely to be between $15 billion and $20 billion AL'S per annum. We acknowledge the limitations of our methods and estimates but show how they highlight the importance of the problem, and open up promising avenues for further research. With further refinement and development, radically different 'whole ecosystem' valuation approaches like these may eventually become viable alternatives to the more common additive approaches. (C) 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved,

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.7
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Pandemic refuges: Lessons from 2 years of COVID-19

Seth D. Baum, Vanessa M. Adams

Summary: This paper relates the COVID-19 pandemic to the concept of pandemic refuges, proving through case studies that jurisdictions other than island nations can successfully function as refuges, providing important insights for future pandemics.

RISK ANALYSIS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Piecemeal stewardship activities miss numerous social and environmental benefits associated with culturally appropriate ways of caring for country

Silva Larson, Diane Jarvis, Natalie Stoeckl, Ryan Barrowei, Bessie Coleman, David Groves, Joshua Hunter, Maria Lee, Michael Markham, Anna Larson, Glenn Finau, Michael Douglas

Summary: Prior research has identified the contributions of people and nature to each other, but lacks guidance on operationalizing these ideas for environmental managers. This paper fills that knowledge gap by learning from Australia's First Nations People and improving accounting frameworks, providing practical insights for decision makers.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Ecology

Changes in authorship, networks, and research topics in ecosystem services

Ida Kubiszewski, Luke Concollato, Robert Costanza, David I. Stern

Summary: A large network of researchers and practitioners have been studying ecosystem services (ES) for a long time. This research analyzes the authorship structure, citations, topics, and journals publishing on ES, and compares the results with a previous analysis. The study also examines the influence of the journal Ecosystem Services on these variables. The findings show significant growth in the number of authors and published articles on ES, expansion of authorship networks, and changes in co-authorship patterns.

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2023)

Review Environmental Studies

Review of the approaches for assessing protected areas? effectiveness

Haojie Chen, Tong Zhang, Robert Costanza, Ida Kubiszewski

Summary: This paper reviews the various approaches to assessing the effectiveness of protected areas (PAs) and provides guidance on their use. It also suggests areas for future research and highlights the importance of these assessments in promoting sustainable development of PAs.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Australian agricultural resources: A national scale land capability map

Vanessa M. Adams, Jayden E. Engert

Summary: Ongoing land clearing is driving biodiversity loss and climate change. This article presents a national agricultural land capability map for Australia, based on state datasets and modeled pastoral capability. The dataset fills a knowledge gap and can be utilized for retrospective analysis of land use policies and prospective regional planning initiatives.

DATA IN BRIEF (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A Conceptual Framework for Biodiversity Monitoring Programs in Conservation Areas

Daniel T. Dalton, Vanessa Berger, Vanessa Adams, Judith Botha, Stephan Halloy, Hanns Kirchmeir, Andrej Sovinc, Klaus Steinbauer, Vid Svara, Michael Jungmeier

Summary: Maintaining and improving the state of biodiversity is crucial in conservation areas. Robust monitoring programs are necessary to evaluate the species and habitats, but challenges such as limited resources and poor data management practices must be addressed. We propose a framework of seven basic questions to guide conservation area managers in implementing effective biodiversity monitoring techniques.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Ecology

The monetary value of 16 services protected by the Australian National Biosecurity System: Spatially explicit estimates and vulnerability to incursions

Natalie Stoeckl, Aaron Dodd, Tom Kompas

Summary: This study generates spatially explicit estimates of the value of services provided by biosecurity systems in Australia's natural resource management regions. The estimated aggregate value is approximately $250 billion per year, with ecosystem services accounting for nearly 90% of the total. The study also assesses the vulnerabilities of different regions to weed and invertebrate infestations, finding that urban areas are generally more vulnerable and weed vulnerabilities dominate in certain remote regions.

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

The complex relationships between economic inequality and biodiversity: A scoping review

Ida Kubiszewski, Caroline Ward, Kate E. Pickett, Robert Costanza

Summary: Biodiversity change and increasing within-country economic inequalities are two major global challenges. The most marginalized in society are vulnerable to biodiversity change, but the relationship between biodiversity change and economic inequalities is not clear. A systematic scoping review found 27 studies that examined the relationships between economic inequality and biodiversity. Most studies found that more unequal regions had lower biodiversity levels, while wealthier areas had higher biodiversity levels. However, causal mechanisms and metrics used varied, and more research is needed to understand the interaction between economic inequality and biodiversity.

ANTHROPOCENE REVIEW (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Benefits and risks of incremental protected area planning in the Southern Ocean

Anne Boothroyd, Vanessa Adams, Karen Alexander, Nicole Hill

Summary: Establishing representative Marine Protected Area networks is crucial for conserving marine biodiversity. This study shows that a bioregional planning approach can protect representative environments in the Southern Ocean, but it requires political will to adapt existing protected areas.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Assessing prioritization measures for a private land conservation program in the US Prairie Pothole Region

Kaylan M. Kemink, Robert. L. Pressey, Vanessa M. Adams, Christoph Nolte, Sarah K. Olimb, Aidan M. Healey, Boyan Liu, Todd Frerichs, Randy Renner

Summary: Private land conservation has become an important tool for protecting biodiversity and habitat, but there is a need for further development in methods for prioritizing and scheduling conservation on private land. In this study, the authors investigated different approaches within a return on investment framework for breeding waterfowl and broods in the Prairie Pothole Region. Their results suggested that the MinLoss approach was the most efficient for both breeding waterfowl and broods, and incorporating probability of wetland drainage into decision-making improved the overall return on investment. They recommend the inclusion of a return on investment or cost-effective analysis in future conservation scheduling for private land conservation.

CONSERVATION SCIENCE AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Quantifying population-level conservation impacts for a perpetual conservation program on private land

Kaylan M. Kemink, Robert L. Pressey, Vanessa M. Adams, Sarah K. Olimb, Aidan M. Healey, Boyan Liu, Todd Frerichs, Randy Renner

Summary: Area-based targets for nature protection are commonly used, but they may not effectively measure the success of conservation interventions. Most impact evaluations focus on the effect of protected areas on deforestation, while evaluations on dynamic systems or different outcomes are less common due to data availability. Simulations offer a valuable tool to estimate the potential impact of conservation programs, as shown by a simulation of wetland drainage in North Dakota, South Dakota, and Montana. The results suggest a low programmatic impact, but the long-term governance of the program holds promise for cumulative conservation impact if future wetland drainage occurs.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Biographical-Item Ecology

Robert L. Pressey (1953-2023)

Vanessa M. Adams, Jorge G. Alvarez-Romero, Natalie C. Ban, Morena Mills, Piero Visconti

Summary: This sentence describes a person who is a leading conservation planner and advocate for biodiversity.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2023)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Multiple-use protected areas are critical to equitable and effective conservation

Vanessa M. Adams, Alienor L. M. Chauvenet, Natasha Stoudmann, Georgina G. Gurney, Dan Brockington, Caitlin D. Kuempel

Summary: Multiple-use protected areas are effective in conserving biodiversity and are more likely to operate under equitable governance arrangements, playing a crucial role in achieving the 2030 conservation targets.

ONE EARTH (2023)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Defining biodiverse reforestation: Why it matters for climate change mitigation and biodiversity

Samantha E. Andres, Rachel J. Standish, Paige E. Lieurance, Charlotte H. Mills, Richard J. Harper, Don W. Butler, Vanessa M. Adams, Caroline Lehmann, Sasha G. Tetu, Peter Cuneo, Catherine A. Offord, Rachael V. Gallagher

Summary: Reforestation for carbon sequestration is gaining attention as a climate change mitigation policy, but there are differences in the definition and application of biodiversity. Stakeholders in reforestation projects often have a vague understanding of diversity, resulting in inadequate levels of restored biodiversity to support functional ecosystems and desired ecosystem services. Integrating biodiversity objectives and setting specific restoration goals with transparent reporting outcomes are important for meaningful outcomes for biodiversity and incentivizing payments.

PLANTS PEOPLE PLANET (2023)

暂无数据