3.9 Review

Evaluating the Reliability of the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System

期刊

AEROSPACE MEDICINE AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE
卷 86, 期 8, 页码 728-735

出版社

AEROSPACE MEDICAL ASSOC
DOI: 10.3357/AMHP.4218.2015

关键词

HFACS; human error; error analysis

向作者/读者索取更多资源

INTRODUCTION: This paper examines the reliability of the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (HFACS) as tool for coding human error and contributing factors associated with accidents and incidents. METHODS: A systematic review of articles published across a 13-yr period between 2001 and 2014 revealed a total of 14 peerreviewed manuscripts that reported data concerning the reliability of HFACS. RESULTS: Results revealed that the majority of these papers reported acceptable levels of interrater and intrarater reliability. CONCLUSION: Reliability levels were higher with increased training and sample sizes. Likewise, when deviations from the original framework were minimized, reliability levels increased. Future applications of the framework should consider these factors to ensure the reliability and utility of HFACS as an accident analysis and classification tool.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

3.9
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Understanding the Swiss Cheese Model and Its Application to Patient Safety

Douglas A. Wiegmann, Laura J. Wood, Tara N. Cohen, Scott A. Shappell

Summary: This article reviews the Theory of Active and Latent Failures, also known as the Swiss cheese model, and aims to provide a better understanding of its underlying theory. The goal is to help patient safety professionals leverage the model and its tools for root cause analysis and other patient safety activities.

JOURNAL OF PATIENT SAFETY (2022)

Review Engineering, Industrial

Using flow disruptions to understand healthcare system safety: A systematic review of observational studies

Tara N. Cohen, Douglas A. Wiegmann, Falisha F. Kanji, Myrtede Alfred, Jennifer T. Anger, Ken R. Catchpole

Summary: This systematic review provides information on methodologies, measurements and classification systems used in observational studies of flow disruptions in clinical environments, analyzing 30 studies and synthesizing the findings into a framework for conducting rigorous methodological studies aimed at understanding clinical systems.

APPLIED ERGONOMICS (2022)

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

A Human Factors Approach to Vaginal Retained Foreign Objects

Tara N. Cohen, Falisha F. Kanji, Colby Souders, Alexandra Dubinskaya, Karyn S. Eilber, Harry Sax, Jennifer T. Anger

Summary: This study applied a structured human factors analysis to identify conditions contributing to vaginal retained foreign objects (RFOs). The most common items were vaginal packing and vaginal sponges. The main contributing factors were skill-based errors and communication breakdowns. Human factors interventions, such as simulation, teamwork training, and streamlining workflow, can address and improve these errors.

JOURNAL OF MINIMALLY INVASIVE GYNECOLOGY (2022)

Letter Surgery

Addressing misconceptions of flow disruption studies in Is non-stop always better? Examining assumptions behind the concept of flow disruptions in studies of robot-assisted surgery

Ken Catchpole, Connor Lusk, Matthias Weigl, Jennifer Anger, Tara Cohen

Summary: This letter to the editor responds to the concept of flow disruptions in robot-assisted surgery studies, clarifying misconceptions and emphasizing the importance of understanding the clinical process from a systems perspective.

JOURNAL OF ROBOTIC SURGERY (2022)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Human Factors Integration in Robotic Surgery

Ken Catchpole, Tara Cohen, Myrtede Alfred, Sam Lawton, Falisha Kanji, Daniel Shouhed, Lynne Nemeth, Jennifer Anger

Summary: Using the example of robotic-assisted surgery, this study explores the challenges of technology integration in surgery and emphasizes the importance of systems engineering and clinical human factors research. Human factors studies of robotic surgery have provided insights into hidden complexities and suggested methods for improvement. There is a growing need for human-systems integration to enhance safety and quality in healthcare.

HUMAN FACTORS (2022)

Article Surgery

The Application of Human Factors Engineering to Reduce Operating Room Turnover in Robotic Surgery

Tara N. Cohen, Jennifer T. Anger, Kevin Shamash, Kenneth R. Catchpole, Raymund Avenido, Eric J. Ley, Bruce L. Gewertz, Daniel Shouhed

Summary: This study applied a human factors approach to reduce turnover time in robotic surgery. Through observation and analysis of 40 robotic surgery turnovers, researchers developed targeted interventions. Post-intervention, turnover time was significantly reduced by 26 minutes and major delays decreased by over 50%.

WORLD JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

A Novel Approach for Engagement in Team Training in High-Technology Surgery: The Robotic-Assisted Surgery Olympics

Tara N. Cohen, Jennifer T. Anger, Falisha F. Kanji, Jennifer Zamudio, Elise DeForest, Connor Lusk, Ray Avenido, Christine Yoshizawa, Stephanie Bartkowicz, Lynne S. Nemeth, Ken Catchpole

Summary: The RAS Olympics was successfully implemented as a game-based educational competition to improve skills in robotic-assisted surgery. Participants positively responded to the activity, finding it relevant to their work and effective in learning new techniques to enhance their practice. The interactive learning environment of the RAS Olympics was preferred over traditional training methods.

JOURNAL OF PATIENT SAFETY (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

A better way: training for direct observations in healthcare

Myrtede Alfred, John Del Gaizo, Falisha Kanji, Samuel Lawton, Ashley Caron, Lynne S. Nemeth, A. Alekseyenko, Daniel Shouhed, Stephen Savage, Jennifer T. Anger, Ken Catchpole, Tara Cohen

Summary: Direct observation is valuable for identifying latent threats and system complexity in clinical environments. Effective and comprehensive observer training is critical for ensuring reliability and reproducibility of data collection. However, ensuring methodological rigour remains a challenge in direct observation research in healthcare.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Planning an Escape: Considerations for the Development of Applied Escape Rooms

Shawn M. Doherty, Andrew C. Griggs, Elizabeth H. Lazzara, Joseph R. Keebler, Bruce L. Gewertz, Tara N. Cohen

Summary: The purpose of this article is to provide seven considerations that are relevant to the development, implementation, and effectiveness of an escape room. These considerations include determining the objectives, identifying a theme, assigning the roles, establishing participant interdependence, selecting a venue, designing the puzzles, and creating the assessments. These considerations can advance the science underlying the use of escape rooms and preclude difficulties associated with their use.

SIMULATION & GAMING (2023)

Review Surgery

Understanding ultrarare adverse events - Lessons learned from a twelve-year review of intraoperative deaths at an academic medical center

Tara N. Cohen, Falisha F. Kanji, Andrew S. Wang, Edward G. Seferian, Harry C. Sax, Bruce L. Gewertz

Summary: This study reviewed the demographics of intraoperative deaths (ID) and found that most deaths occurred during emergency procedures. However, the incident reports provided little actionable information on ergonomic factors.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

Article Surgery

Demands of surgical teams in robotic-assisted surgery: An assessment of intraoperative workload within different surgical specialties

Jennifer Zamudio, Jeffrey Woodward, Falisha F. Kanji, Jennifer T. Anger, Ken Catchpole, Tara N. Cohen

Summary: This study assessed workload in robotic-assisted surgery by administering SURG-TLX surveys to surgical staff at three sites. The results showed significantly higher workload during urology and gynecology procedures, and significant differences in domain workload by role and specialty, highlighting the need for tailored workload interventions.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

Article Surgery

Identifying Workflow Disruptions in Robotic-Assisted Bariatric Surgery: Elucidating Challenges Experienced by Surgical Teams

Jennifer Zamudio, Falisha F. Kanji, Connor Lusk, Daniel Shouhed, Barry R. Sanchez, Ken Catchpole, Jennifer T. Anger, Tara N. Cohen

Summary: Robotic bariatric surgery is an effective treatment for extreme obesity, but it presents challenges for OR teams and the clinical system. This study found that flow disruptions were most frequent during patient transfer and robot docking phases of RBS, with coordination issues being the main contributing factor.

OBESITY SURGERY (2023)

Review Urology & Nephrology

Female sexual health digital resources: women and health care providers need more options

Alexandra Dubinskaya, John R. Heard, Eunice Choi, Tara Cohen, Jennifer Anger, Karyn Eilber, Victoria Scott

Summary: This study aimed to evaluate the educational content and services of existing applications on female sexual health. A total of 17 apps were identified and reviewed, covering different themes such as education, emotions and communication, relaxation and meditation, general sexual health, and social and fun. The study demonstrated the need for more accessible educational resources addressing female sexual health and dysfunction.

SEXUAL MEDICINE REVIEWS (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Comparing the Safety Action Feedback and Engagement (SAFE) Loop with an established incident reporting system: Study protocol for a pragmatic cluster randomized controlled trial

Carl T. Berdahl, Andrew J. Henreid, Tara N. Cohen, Bernice L. Coleman, Edward G. Seferian, Donna Leang, Sungjin Kim, Marcio A. Diniz, Matthew Grissinger, Karen Kaiser, Sara McCleskey, Xi Zhu, Teryl K. Nuckols

Summary: This study aims to improve hospital incident reporting systems and enhance patient safety by implementing the Safety Action Feedback and Engagement (SAFE) Loop. The SAFE Loop incorporates various strategies such as prioritizing safety issues, training nurses to write informative reports, and providing feedback to nurses. The study will be conducted in 20 nursing units at a hospital in Los Angeles, and outcomes will include incident reporting practices, nurses' attitudes, and rates of high-priority events.

CONTEMPORARY CLINICAL TRIALS COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Meeting Abstract Medicine, Research & Experimental

Pathology for Surgeons: The Development of an Innovative Curriculum Using a Needs Assessment Approach

Kenechukwu Ojukwu, Michael Kozak, Chau Bui, Tiffany Lee, Stephanie Dreikorn, David Afework, Bonnie Balzer, Farin Amersi, Tara Cohen, Monica Jain, Kevin Waters

LABORATORY INVESTIGATION (2023)

暂无数据