Approximately Quantized Thermal Hall Effect of Chiral Liquids Coupled to Phonons

The recent observation of a half-integer quantized thermal Hall effect in alpha-RuCl 3 is interpreted as a unique signature of a chiral spin liquid with a Majorana edge mode. A similar quantized thermal Hall effect is expected in chiral topological superconductors. The unavoidable presence of gapless acoustic phonons, however, implies that, in contrast to the quantized electrical conductivity, the thermal Hall conductivity kappa(xy) is never exactly quantized in real materials. Here, we investigate how phonons affect the quantization of the thermal conductivity, focusing on the edge theory. As an example, we consider a Kitaev spin liquid gapped by an external magnetic field coupled to acoustic phonons. The coupling to phonons destroys the ballistic thermal transport of the edge mode completely, as energy can leak into the bulk, thus drastically modifying the edge picture of the thermal Hall effect. Nevertheless, the thermal Hall conductivity remains approximately quantized, and we argue that the coupling to phonons to the edge mode is a necessary condition for the observation of the quantized thermal Hall effect. The strength of this edge coupling does, however, not affect the conductivity. We argue that for sufficiently clean systems the leading correction to the quantized thermal Hall effect,Delta kappa(xy)/T similar to sign(B) T-2, arises from an intrinsic anomalous Hall effect of the acoustic phonons due to Berry phases imprinted by the chiral (spin) liquid in the bulk. This correction depends on the sign but not the amplitude of the external magnetic field.