4.5 Review

Diagnostic errors in the intensive care unit: a systematic review of autopsy studies

期刊

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY
卷 21, 期 11, 页码 894-902

出版社

BMJ PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1136/bmjqs-2012-000803

关键词

-

资金

  1. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality [HS017755-01]
  2. NIH

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Context: Misdiagnoses may be an under appreciated cause of preventable morbidity and mortality in the intensive care unit (ICU). Their prevalence, nature, and impact remain largely unknown. Objectives: To determine whether potentially fatal ICU misdiagnoses would be more common than in the general inpatient population (similar to 5%), and would involve more infections or vascular events. Data sources: Systematic review of studies identified by electronic (MEDLINE, etc.) and manual searches (references in eligible articles) without language restriction (1966 through 2011). Study selection and data abstraction: Observational studies examining autopsy-confirmed diagnostic errors in the adult ICU were included. Studies analysing misdiagnosis of one specific disease were excluded. Study results (autopsy rate, misdiagnosis prevalence, Goldman error class, diseases misdiagnosed) were abstracted and descriptive statistics calculated. We modelled the prevalence of Class I (potentially lethal) misdiagnoses as a non-linear function of the autopsy rate. Results: Of 276 screened abstracts, 31 studies describing 5863 autopsies (median rate 43%) were analysed. The prevalence of misdiagnoses ranged from 5.5%-100% with 28% of autopsies reporting at least one misdiagnosis and 8% identifying a Class I diagnostic error. The projected prevalence of Class I misdiagnoses for a hypothetical autopsy rate of 100% was 6.3% (95% CI 4.0% to 7.5%). Vascular events and infections were the leading lethal misdiagnoses (41% each). The most common individual Class I misdiagnoses were PE, MI, pneumonia, and aspergillosis. Conclusions: Our data suggest that as many as 40 500 adult patients in an ICU in USA may die with an ICU misdiagnoses annually. Despite this, diagnostic errors receive relatively little attention and research funding. Future studies should seek to prospectively measure the prevalence and impact of diagnostic errors and potential strategies to reduce them.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.5
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Behavioral Sciences

Crossing Academic Boundaries for Diagnostic Safety: 10 Complex Challenges and Potential Solutions From Clinical Perspectives and High-Reliability Organizing Principles

Elham A. Yousef, Kathleen M. Sutcliffe, Kathryn M. McDonald, David E. Newman-Toker

Summary: This study applies the high-reliability organization (HRO) paradigm to the diagnostic process, outlining challenges and solutions. Multiple challenges are identified, but it is pointed out that these challenges are not insurmountable. The conclusion suggests that the HRO perspective can improve the safety of the diagnostic process, and the proposed ideas can be implemented by both individual clinicians and healthcare leaders for systematic progress in enhancing diagnostic performance.

HUMAN FACTORS (2022)

Article Emergency Medicine

Cerebrovascular disease hospitalizations following emergency department headache visits: A nested case-control study

Ava L. Liberman, Ahmed Hassoon, Mehdi Fanai, Shervin Badihian, Hetal Rupani, Susan M. Peterson, Krisztian Sebestyen, Zheyu Wang, Yuxin Zhu, Richard B. Lipton, David E. Newman-Toker

Summary: This study found that 0.6% of patients with emergency department visits for headaches were subsequently hospitalized for cerebrovascular disease, often at a different medical center. Patients with a history of stroke or neurosurgery prior to the visit may represent important opportunities for cerebrovascular disease prevention. Poor documentation of neurological examinations among cases suggests a potential need for improvement in emergency department processes.

ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE (2022)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

A descriptive evaluation of causes of death in venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

Sagar B. Dave, Kristopher B. Deatrick, Samuel M. Galvagno, Michael A. Mazzeffi, David J. Kaczorowski, Ronson J. Madathil, Raymond Rector, Ali Tabatabai, Daniel J. Haase, Daniel Herr, Thomas M. Scalea, Jay Menaker

Summary: This study investigated the causes and timing of in-hospital mortality in patients supported with VV ECMO. It found that most deaths occurred prior to lung recovery and decannulation, with the most common cause being removal of life sustaining therapy in the setting of multisystem organ failure. Older age and worse predictive mortality scores were associated with non-survival.

PERFUSION-UK (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Stroke hospitalization after misdiagnosis of benign dizziness is lower in specialty care than general practice: a population-based cohort analysis of missed stroke using SPADE methods

Tzu-Pu Chang, Anand K. Bery, Zheyu Wang, Krisztian Sebestyen, Yu-Hung Ko, Ava L. Liberman, David E. Newman-Toker

Summary: This study compared stroke hospitalizations in general care vs. specialty care settings for patients with purportedly benign dizziness, finding a higher short-term stroke risk in general care and no significant difference in long-term risk, indicating higher misdiagnosis-related harms in general care.

DIAGNOSIS (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Characterizing the relationship between diagnostic intensity and quality of care

Michael Ellenbogen, Laura Prichett, David E. Newman-Toker, Daniel J. Brotman

Summary: By analyzing the hospital-level diagnostic overuse index and quality metrics, no significant relationship between diagnostic intensity and quality of care was found. This suggests that targeted efforts to reduce diagnostic overuse in hospitals may not adversely impact the quality of care.

DIAGNOSIS (2022)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

COVID-19 outcomes of venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for acute respiratory failure vs historical cohort of non-COVID-19 viral infections

Sagar B. Dave, Ronald Rabinowitz, Aakash Shah, Ali Tabatabai, Samuel M. Galvagno, Michael A. Mazzeffi, Raymond Rector, David J. Kaczorowski, Thomas M. Scalea, Jay Menaker

Summary: This study compares the outcomes of VV ECMO treatment in COVID-19 patients and non-COVID-19 viral infection patients. The results show that COVID-19 patients have a higher mortality rate, but survivors have longer duration of VV ECMO use and similar hospital length of stay.

PERFUSION-UK (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Short-term stroke risk after emergency department treat-and-release headache visit

Ava L. Liberman, Cenai Zhang, Richard B. Lipton, Hooman Kamel, Neal S. Parikh, Babak B. Navi, Alan Z. Segal, Junaid Razzak, David E. Newman-Toker, Alexander E. Merkler

Summary: Patients discharged to home after an emergency department visit for headache face a heightened risk of stroke, three to four times higher than the risk associated with renal colic or back pain.

HEADACHE (2022)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Decreased PRESET-Score corresponds with improved survival in COVID-19 veno-venous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

Elizabeth K. Powell, Allison S. Lankford, Mira Ghneim, Joseph Rabin, Daniel J. Haase, Siamak Dahi, Kristopher B. Deatrick, Eric Krause, Gregory Bittle, Samuel M. Galvagno, Thomas Scalea, Ali Tabatabai

Summary: Lower PRESET scores are associated with improved survival in COVID-19 VV ECMO patients. The incorporation of PRESET-Score into institutional ECMO candidacy guidelines may help ensure access to this limited healthcare resource for all critically ill patients.

PERFUSION-UK (2023)

Correction Emergency Medicine

The HINTS exam is a skill emergency physicians need to learn, apply and master (vol 24, pg 379, 2022)

Jeffrey J. Perry, David E. Newman-Toker, Robert Ohle

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Impact of Clinician Training Background and Stroke Location on Bedside Diagnostic Accuracy in the Acute Vestibular Syndrome - A Meta-Analysis

Alexander A. Tarnutzer, Daniel Gold, Zheyu Wang, Karen A. Robinson, Jorge C. Kattah, Georgios Mantokoudis, Ali S. Saber Tehrani, David S. Zee, Jonathan A. Edlow, David E. Newman-Toker

Summary: This study assessed the accuracy of bedside findings in differentiating peripheral vestibular from central neurologic causes. The HINTS eye movement battery had high sensitivity and specificity for stroke diagnosis. These findings suggest that HINTS examination should be disseminated to all clinicians evaluating dizziness/vertigo.

ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

The Maryland (USA) Critical Care Coordination Center (C4): From Pandemic to Permanence

Melissa A. Kelly, Luis M. Pinet-Peralta, Tara M. Roque, Thomas M. Scalea, Theodore R. Delbridge, Samuel M. Galvagno

Summary: This article describes the implementation of a state-wide Critical Care Coordination Center (C4) in Maryland, USA, which ensures timely and equitable access to critical care. The C4 played an integral role during the COVID-19 pandemic and can serve as a model for other regions to adopt.

PREHOSPITAL AND DISASTER MEDICINE (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Optimizing measurement of misdiagnosis-related harms using symptom-disease pair analysis of diagnostic error (SPADE): comparison groups to maximize SPADE validity

Ava L. Liberman, Zheyu Wang, Yuxin Zhu, Ahmed Hassoon, Justin Choi, J. Matthew Austin, Michelle C. Johansen, David E. Newman-Toker

Summary: This study aims to clarify the use of the Symptom-Disease Pair Analysis of Diagnostic Error (SPADE) method to ensure valid results. The study discusses four different types of comparators and the logic behind choosing one over the other, as well as the inferences that can be drawn from comparative analysis. The aim is to improve the validity of SPADE and related approaches to quantifying diagnostic errors in medicine.

DIAGNOSIS (2023)

Review Emergency Medicine

Survival Benefit of Helicopter Scene Response for Patients with an Injury Severity Score of at Least Nine: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Christie L. Fritz, Sarah Alice Thomas, Samuel M. Galvagno, Stephen H. Thomas

Summary: Helicopter EMS (HEMS) is considered appropriate for severely injured patients with ISS >15, but this study aimed to evaluate the mortality benefit of HEMS for patients with ISS >8. The results showed a significant survival benefit for patients with ISS >8 when HEMS was used over traditional ambulance transportation.

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Burden of serious harms from diagnostic error in the USA

David E. Newman-Toker, Najlla Nassery, Adam C. Schaffer, Chihwen Winnie Yu-Moe, Gwendolyn D. Clemens, Zheyu Wang, Yuxin Zhu, Ali S. Saber Tehrani, Mehdi Fanai, Ahmed Hassoon, Dana Siegal

Summary: By combining prior results and rigorous estimates of disease incidence, we estimated that 795,000 Americans become permanently disabled or die annually due to misdiagnosis of dangerous diseases. Just 15 diseases account for about half of all serious harms, suggesting that the problem may be more tractable than previously thought.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2023)

Meeting Abstract Clinical Neurology

Remote Expert Diagnosis by Video-Oculography is More Accurate Than In-Person ED Diagnosis in Acute Vertigo and Dizziness-Preliminary Results of the AVERT Trial

Shervin Badihian, David S. Zee, John P. Carey, Ari M. Blitz, Jonathan A. Edlow, Daniel R. Gold, Joshua N. Goldstein, Joanna C. Jen, Jorge C. Kattah, Kevin A. Kerber, Amir Kheradmand, Doris D. M. Lin, William J. Meurer, Rodney Omron, Susan M. Peterson, Richard E. Rothman, Ali S. Tehrani, Adriana Batazzi, Tzu-Pu Chang, Tracey Economas, Vahid Eslami, Vahid Eslami, Joshua Gruber, Meghan Hildreth, Michael Iacobelli, Karen Lane, Nichol Mcbee, Noeleen Ostapkovich, Nana Tevzadze, Ying Wang, Zheyu Wang, Yuxin Zhu, Daniel F. Hanley, David E. Newman-Toker

ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY (2022)

暂无数据