4.3 Editorial Material

Critical Comment on the Article by R. Rek The Maunder Minimum and the Sun as the Possible Source of Particles Creating Increased Abundance of the 14C Carbon Isotope

期刊

SOLAR PHYSICS
卷 261, 期 2, 页码 353-359

出版社

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11207-009-9497-4

关键词

Sun: activity

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Several strong but erroneous statements were made by R. Rek in an article published in this volume of Solar Physics. Here we show that these misleading statements are caused by neglecting the known effects of the carbon cycle and misinterpretation of the data. In particular we show that the claim of the Maunder minimum being the period without a significant cessation of activity contradicts the bulk of observational evidence and is caused by the misinterpretation of proxy data.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.3
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

The first ground-level enhancement of solar cycle 25 on 28 October 2021&x22c6;

A. Papaioannou, A. Kouloumvakos, A. Mishev, R. Vainio, I Usoskin, K. Herbst, A. P. Rouillard, A. Anastasiadis, J. Gieseler, R. Wimmer-Schweingruber, P. Kuehl

Summary: This study reports the first relativistic solar proton event of solar cycle 25, identifies the solar origin of the event through various observational methods, and demonstrates different time profiles with anisotropic characteristics. Notably, the event exhibits a moderately hard rigidity spectrum at high energies.

ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

DENDROCHRONOLOGY AND RADIOCARBON DATING

Charlotte L. Pearson, Steven W. Leavitt, Bernd Kromer, Sami K. Solanki, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: Dendrochronology and radiocarbon (C-14) dating have been intertwined since the 1950s, with tree-ring date samples playing a crucial role in calibrating the C-14 timescale. These methods continue to shape and improve chronological frameworks worldwide, answering questions across various scientific fields.

RADIOCARBON (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Estimation of Cosmic-Ray-Induced Atmospheric Ionization and Radiation at Commercial Aviation Flight Altitudes

Panagiota Makrantoni, Anastasia Tezari, Argyris N. Stassinakis, Pavlos Paschalis, Maria Gerontidou, Pantelis Karaiskos, Alexandros G. Georgakilas, Helen Mavromichalaki, Ilya G. Usoskin, Norma Crosby, Mark Dierckxsens

Summary: The ionization of the Earth's atmosphere induced by cosmic radiation during recent solar cycles was globally studied using the CRAC:CRII model. The study found that galactic cosmic rays constitute the main source of ionization in the Earth's atmosphere and significantly contribute to radiation exposure inside the atmosphere. Specific altitudes of interest, such as those commonly used by commercial aviation, were also focused on.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Annual integral solar proton fluences for 1984-2019

O. Raukunen, I Usoskin, S. Koldobskiy, G. Kovaltsov, R. Vainio

Summary: This study revisits the derivation of annual integral solar energetic particle (SEP) fluxes using in situ measurements from 1984 to 2019. The results show that solar cycle 24 had significantly weaker SEP fluence compared to cycles 22 and 23. The cumulative occurrence probability of SEP fluence above a certain value is perfectly described by the Weibull distribution, providing a projection for the occurrence of solar extreme eruptive events on longer timescales.

ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS (2022)

Article Meteorology & Atmospheric Sciences

Zonal Mean Distribution of Cosmogenic Isotope (7Be, 10Be, 14C, and 36Cl) Production in Stratosphere and Troposphere

K. Golubenko, E. Rozanov, G. Kovaltsov, I Usoskin

Summary: This study computed the production of cosmogenic isotopes in the Earth's atmosphere using the CRAC model, providing zonal mean production rates for different latitudinal zones in the stratosphere and troposphere. The results indicate that isotope production by solar energetic particles in the tropical zone is small and can be neglected.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Long-term forcing of the Sun's coronal field, open flux, and cosmic ray modulation potential during grand minima, maxima, and regular activity phases by the solar dynamo mechanism

Soumyaranjan Dash, Dibyendu Nandy, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: This study utilizes simulations and observational data to reveal the impact of magnetic fields generated by the Sun's internal dynamo mechanism on the variations of the solar corona and the state of the heliosphere, establishing causality between solar internal variations and the state of the heliosphere.

MONTHLY NOTICES OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY (2023)

Review Astronomy & Astrophysics

Long-Term Modulation of Solar Cycles

Akash Biswas, Bidya Binay Karak, Ilya Usoskin, Eckhard Weisshaar

Summary: Solar activity has a cyclic nature, with the 11-year Schwabe cycle dominating its variability on the interannual timescale. However, solar cycles can vary significantly in length, shape, and magnitude, from grand minima to grand maxima. The limited length and inhomogeneous quality of direct sunspot-number series necessitates the use of cosmogenic-isotope proxy to study long-term solar variability. This article provides a brief overview of the long-term variability of solar activity at centennial - millennial timescales, discussing the occurrence of grand minima and maxima, as well as quasi-periodicities such as the Gleissberg, Suess/de Vries, and Hallstatt cycles. It also reviews theoretical perspectives on the observed features in the context of dynamo models, highlighting the importance of nonlinearities and stochastic fluctuations.

SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS (2023)

Review Astronomy & Astrophysics

A history of solar activity over millennia

Ilya G. Usoskin

Summary: In this article, the authors review the current understanding of long-term solar activity on a multi-millennial timescale through indirect proxy methods. The concept of solar activity is explained, along with an overview of indices used to quantify different aspects of variable solar activity, with a focus on sunspot numbers. The historical development and modern state of proxy-based reconstructions of past solar activity are discussed, emphasizing the use of cosmogenic isotopes C-14 and Be-10. The article concludes with the main features of long-term solar magnetic activity and their implications for solar/stellar dynamo theory.

LIVING REVIEWS IN SOLAR PHYSICS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

A New Open-Source Geomagnetosphere Propagation Tool (OTSO) and Its Applications

Nicholas Larsen, Alexander Mishev, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: We introduce a new open-source tool OTSO for modeling cosmic ray propagation in the Earth's geomagnetosphere and demonstrate its application in several events. Comparison with widely used tools and validation show good agreement. The tool is also used to provide necessary background for analyzing two notable ground-level enhancements.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SPACE PHYSICS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Multiproxy Reconstructions of Integral Energy Spectra for Extreme Solar Particle Events of 7176 BCE, 660 BCE, 775 CE, and 994 CE

Sergey Koldobskiy, Florian Mekhaldi, Gennady Kovaltsov, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: Extreme solar particle events (ESPEs) are rare and powerful processes of solar eruptive activity. This study presents a new method to reconstruct ESPE fluence based on advanced modeling techniques, combining different cosmogenic isotope (CI) data. The reconstructed ESPE fluences have a smoother spectral shape and significantly higher estimates of low-energy fluence, making ESPEs even more dangerous for modern technological systems than previously believed. The fitted modified Band function allows for the application of the obtained results in different fields.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SPACE PHYSICS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Revised Reconstruction of the Heliospheric Modulation Potential for 1964-2022

Pauli Vaisanen, Ilya Usoskin, Riikka Kahkonen, Sergey Koldobskiy, Kalevi Mursula

Summary: Galactic cosmic rays (GCRs) collide with atmospheric constituents, generating showers of secondary particles in the Earth's atmosphere. The flux of GCRs near Earth is influenced by solar magnetic activity and geomagnetic shielding. A global network of ground-based neutron monitors (NMs) has continuously monitored the variability of GCR flux since the 1950s. This study provides an updated and extended reconstruction of the heliospheric modulation potential using a new method and measurements from high-latitude NMs.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SPACE PHYSICS (2023)

Review Astronomy & Astrophysics

Solar Cycle Observations

Aimee Norton, Rachel Howe, Lisa Upton, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: This article describes the defining observations of the solar cycle and their constraints on the dynamo processes within the Sun. It covers topics such as sunspot numbers, active region flux ranges and lifetimes, bipolar magnetic region tilt angles, Hale and Joy's law, and various other aspects.

SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Effects of Global Geomagnetic Field Variations Over the Past 100,000 Years on Cosmogenic Radionuclide Production Rates in the Earth's Atmosphere

Sanja Panovska, Stepan Poluianov, Jiawei Gao, Monika Korte, Alexander Mishev, Yuri Y. Shprits, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: The production rates of cosmogenic radionuclides in the Earth's atmosphere vary with the Earth's geomagnetic field and solar activity. This study estimated the production rates of several cosmogenic nuclides for the past 100,000 years based on global, time-dependent geomagnetic field models and moderate solar activity. The results showed that the production rates were high during the Laschamps geomagnetic excursion, with no notable latitudinal dependence. Hemispheric asymmetry and persistent overall time ranges were observed in the production rates predicted by the geomagnetic field models.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SPACE PHYSICS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

The impact of an extreme solar event on the middle atmosphere: a case study

Thomas Reddmann, Miriam Sinnhuber, Jan Maik Wissing, Olesya Yakovchuk, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: A possible impact of an extreme solar particle event (ESPE) on the middle atmosphere has been studied, considering present-day climate and geomagnetic conditions. The study reveals that the impact of ESPE on the atmosphere is greater compared to an extreme geomagnetic storm (GMS). This research is important in revealing the potential hazards of solar particle events on the atmosphere.

ATMOSPHERIC CHEMISTRY AND PHYSICS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

A Comparative Study of Ground-level Enhancement Events of Solar Energetic Particles

Leon Kocharov, Alexander Mishev, Esa Riihonen, Rami Vainio, Ilya Usoskin

Summary: Major solar eruptions can generate solar particle events that can be detected by neutron monitors worldwide. This study analyzes the similarities between two events with similar time profiles and explores the relationship between the events and their progenitor solar flares and coronal mass ejections. The results suggest that a single solar eruption can contribute to multiple components of solar energetic particles.

ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL (2023)

暂无数据