4.5 Article

Improved training of football referees and the decline in home advantage post-WW2

期刊

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE
卷 14, 期 2, 页码 220-227

出版社

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.psychsport.2012.11.001

关键词

Home advantage; Referees' decision making; Soccer; Association; Football; Crowd effects

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Objectives: Research has identified a decline in home advantage (HA) in a number of professional leagues since World War 2 (WW2). The purpose of the current study was to identify whether the decline in HA in English and Scottish Professional Football Leagues is mirrored by the radical transformation in the training of referees post-WW2, thus providing a new insight into the cause of HA. Design: A longitudinal quasi-experimental design. Methods: HA was calculated for each team at the end of every season for the four English and the Scottish Premier League post-WW2. We also compiled a list of events, statements and quotations to illustrate the dramatic change in the way referees have been trained (physically and psychologically), and assessed over the same period. Results: We observed a systematic decline in HA in professional English and Scottish leagues post-WW2, but with the steepest decline observed in lower divisions with smaller crowds. Of the factors thought to influence HA, crowd support appears the most consistent with these observations. Crowds are known to influence referees' decisions to favour the home side. However we argue that improved training of referees since WW2 has contributed to an improved ability to make objective decisions and a greater resilience to crowd influence, which explains the decline in HA but also accounts for the steeper decline observed with smaller crowds. Conclusions: The continued existence of HA, and the less steep decline observed in top leagues suggests that referees' judgements are still not immune to the influence of larger crowds. (c) 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.5
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Sport Sciences

Key Anthropometric Variables Associated With Front-Crawl Swimming Performance in Youth Swimmers: An Allometric Approach

Senda Sammoud, Yassine Negra, Helmi Chaabene, Raja Bouguezzi, Ahmed Attia, Urs Granacher, Hachana Younes, Alan M. Nevill

Summary: This study aimed to identify key anthropometric characteristics associated with 100-m front-crawl swimming performance in young swimmers. The results showed that length ratio, foot length and ankle girth, biacromial breadth, and % of body fat were associated with the swimming performance. These findings emphasize the importance of assessing anthropometric characteristics for talent identification in young front-crawl swimmers.

JOURNAL OF STRENGTH AND CONDITIONING RESEARCH (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

The association between training load indices and upper respiratory tract infections (URTIs) in elite soccer players

Caoimhe Tiernan, Thomas Comyns, Mark Lyons, Alan M. Nevill, Giles Warrington

Summary: The study revealed a significant association between the accumulation of training load in soccer players and the increased risk of Upper Respiratory Tract Infection (URTI), particularly with 2-week and 3-week cumulative loads. This highlights the potential impact of training loads on players' susceptibility to illnesses such as URTIs.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS SCIENCE & COACHING (2022)

Article Management

How job crafting builds organizational agility in a government-dependent NSO: the mediating role of organizational climate

Mohsen Loghmani, Tom Webb, Graham Cuskelly, Seyed Hossein Alavi

Summary: The present study examines the mediating role of organizational climate in the relationship between job crafting and organizational agility in a government-dependent NSOs. The study finds a positive relationship between job crafting and organizational outcomes, suggesting a practical strategy for selecting employees for NSOs.

MANAGING SPORT AND LEISURE (2023)

Article Sport Sciences

Examining the mental health status of referees in the turkish professional football league

Yavuz Lima, Sergen Devran, Nazli Deniz Oz, Tom Webb, Bulent Bayraktar

Summary: This study evaluated the mental health status of referees in the Turkish professional football leagues. Younger age, being single, lower-level refereeing, performance concerns, and inadequate social support were associated with higher levels of depression, anxiety, and stress in referees. MH assessments should be conducted to identify referees at higher risk of MH problems and provide appropriate interventions.

SCIENCE AND MEDICINE IN FOOTBALL (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Analysis of the physiological response in junior tennis players during short-term recovery: Understanding the magnitude of recovery until and after the 25 seconds rule

Jorge E. Morais, Jose A. Bragada, Rui Silva, Alan M. Nevill, Fabio Y. Nakamura, Daniel A. Marinho

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the physiological recovery of tennis players between points, and test the best curve fitting model. The results showed that tennis players had significant heart rate and oxygen uptake recovery within 25 seconds after the end of a drill, and the recovery magnitude decreased gradually after 65 seconds.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS SCIENCE & COACHING (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Association of air pollution with dementia: a systematic review with meta-analysis including new cohort data from China

Jie Tang, Anthony Chen, Fan He, Martin Shipley, Alan Nevill, Hugh Coe, Zhi Hu, Tao Zhang, Haidong Kan, Eric Brunner, Xuguang Tao, Ruoling Chen

Summary: Two cohort studies in China found a significant association between air pollution and increased risk of dementia, which is supported by a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of 15 population-based cohort studies worldwide. Controlling air pollution and targeting specific pollutants would help reduce dementia globally.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

No Crowds, No Home Advantage in Football during the COVID-19 Season: Are Crowds Able to Manipulate All but the Best Referees' Behaviour?

Alan Nevill, Alastair Pearson, Tom Webb

Summary: This study confirmed that there was no home advantage in association football during the COVID-19 2020-21 season without crowds. Referees did not show bias towards the home team in awarding red and yellow cards in both home and away games. However, referees tended to award more cards to away players when there were crowds present.

JOURNAL OF GLOBAL SPORT MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Referee Abuse, Intention to Quit, and Well-Being

Paul Downward, Tom Webb, Peter Dawson

Summary: There is a growing problem of abuse towards match officials in sports, which also impacts their recruitment and retention. This study examines the impact of physical and nonphysical abuse on association football referees' intention to quit and their personal well-being. The findings indicate that both physical and nonphysical abuse have a negative effect on referees' intention to quit and well-being. The research recommends adopting a zero-tolerance approach towards abuse of officials in sports and emphasizes the responsibility of organizations for the well-being of their officials.

RESEARCH QUARTERLY FOR EXERCISE AND SPORT (2023)

Review Sport Sciences

The Effect of Different Strength Training Modalities on Sprint Performance in Female Team-Sport Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

William Hughes, Robin Healy, Mark Lyons, Alan Nevill, Clement Higginbotham, Aoife Lane, Kris Beattie

Summary: In recent years, female sports have seen increased participation, professionalism, and profile. Sprinting ability is important for successful performance in many female team sports. However, most studies on improving sprint performance in team sports have been conducted with male participants, which may be problematic for programming training for female athletes. This systematic review aimed to investigate the effects of lower body strength training on sprint performance in female team-sport athletes, as well as the effects of specific strength training modalities.

SPORTS MEDICINE (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

The Impact of Kiwifruit Consumption on the Sleep and Recovery of Elite Athletes

Ronan Doherty, Sharon Madigan, Alan Nevill, Giles Warrington, Jason Gordon Ellis

Summary: This study investigates the impact of kiwifruit consumption on sleep and recovery in elite athletes. The results show that kiwifruit intake has positive effects on sleep quality and quantity, as well as on recovery stress balance.

NUTRIENTS (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Elite athletes' and support staffs' experiences and perceptions of long-haul travel, and the self-management strategies they use

Antonia Rossiter, Thomas M. M. Comyns, Ian Sherwin, Alan M. M. Nevill, Giles D. D. Warrington

Summary: This study aimed to explore the perception of elite athletes and support staff on long-haul travel and its impact on performance. It was found that long-haul travel is perceived as disruptive to physical and mental performance, and increases the risk of illness and injury. However, participants implemented self-management strategies to mitigate these effects.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS SCIENCE & COACHING (2023)

Article Sport Sciences

Secular trends in the physical fitness of Brazilian youth: Evidence that fitness is declining for the majority but not for a fit minority

Alan M. Nevill, Michael J. Duncan, Adroaldo Gaya, Julio B. Mello

Summary: There has been a decline in children's physical fitness in recent decades, based on evidence from North America, Europe, and Asia. This study examines the trend and variation in physical fitness scores of young Brazilians from 2005 to 2022. The results indicate a decline in physical fitness over time in 5 out of 6 fitness variables, with increasing variances/standard deviations.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE & SCIENCE IN SPORTS (2023)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

The use of video feedback as a facet of performance analysis: an integrative review

Alastair Pearson, Tom Webb, Gemma Milligan, Matt Miller-Dicks

Summary: This integrative review examined the impact of video feedback on athlete learning. The findings indicate that instructional delivery, classroom-style training, and timing of feedback all influence learning outcomes. Collaborative practices between coach and athlete can enhance engagement in the learning process. Future research should employ a wider range of experimental methods and develop frameworks for effective performance analysis delivery.

INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF SPORT AND EXERCISE PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Pediatrics

Change of Direction Speed in Youth Male Soccer Players: The Predictive Value of Anthropometrics and Biological Maturity

Yassine Negra, Senda Sammoud, Alan M. Nevill, Helmi Chaabene

Summary: The study aimed to develop a model that predicts the change of direction (CoD) mean speed performance in youth male soccer players based on body size/shape and biological maturity. A total of 115 youth soccer players (age: 12.4 [1.3] y) participated in the study. Anthropometric measurements and maturity status were assessed to identify the characteristics associated with CoD speed performance. The findings suggest that fat mass, sitting height, and maturity offset are key predictors of CoD mean speed performance in youth soccer players.

PEDIATRIC EXERCISE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Striving for excellence: talent identification and development in English football refereeing

Tom Webb, Jimmy O'Gorman, Lee Markham

Summary: This study examines the talent identification and development experiences of referees in England. It found three overarching themes: recruitment processes, talent identification and development, and support mechanisms. Opportunities for referee progression are affected by age, training provision and quality, knowledge of progression pathways, regional and national differences in information dissemination, and variability in support networks.

EUROPEAN SPORT MANAGEMENT QUARTERLY (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Defining the scope and content of mental health guidelines for community sport in Australia: A Delphi study

Caitlin Liddelow, Matthew J. Schweickle, Jordan T. Sutcliffe, Christian Swann, Richard Keegan, Simon Rice, Anthony Okely, Stewart A. Vella

Summary: Regular sport participation has physical and psychological health benefits, but some sport environments may contribute to the development of mental health disorders. To ensure psychologically safe sport environments for all participants, mental health guidelines for recreational sport are needed, and collaboration with experts is crucial.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Does messaging matter? A registered report on appearance-versus health-based message framing in exercise appeals targeted towards women

Kimberly R. More, Curt More, Kayla A. Burd, Aikaterini Mentzou, L. Alison Phillips

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the prediction of psychological reactance through the matching of message framing and health message outcomes, and its impact on cognitive and behavioral outcomes related to exercise.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Perfectionism and performance in sport: Exploring non-linear relationships with track and field athletes

Sanna M. Nordin-Bates, Daniel J. Madigan, Andrew P. Hill, Luke F. Olsson

Summary: This study explored the relationship between perfectionism and athletic performance and found a nonlinear relationship. In some cases, perfectionistic strivings may have both positive and negative effects on sport performance.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

A psychosocial investigation of exercise preferences in real and virtual environments

Robyn L. Moffitt

Summary: These three studies examined exercise preferences in real-world and virtual environments and their relationship with social physique anxiety, social comparison, and self-presentational efficacy. The results showed that individuals who preferred exercising at home tended to have lower exercise behavior and more negative fitness-related social comparisons. Those with lower exercise behavior, negative social comparisons, lower self-presentational efficacy, or higher social physique anxiety were more likely to choose virtual reality exercise over real-world exercise. In a virtual reality exercise setting, individuals with higher social physique anxiety and more negative social comparisons preferred embodying a nonhuman and fantasy avatar. The findings suggest that individuals who value self-presentation and have low belief in their competence to project a positive image are more likely to prefer exercise contexts that minimize physique and fitness evaluations. Additionally, virtual reality may offer a less threatening environment for individuals who feel self-conscious or inferior during exercise.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Golf skill learning: An external focus of attention enhances performance and motivation

Jongseong An, Gabriele Wulf

Summary: The study demonstrates that an external focus improves performance and learning of motor skills compared to an internal focus. Through a golf pitch shot experiment, it is found that external focus instructions enhance skill learning, increase positive affect, reduce negative affect, and improve self-efficacy. These findings support assumptions of the OPTIMAL theory and emphasize the attentional and motivational benefits of an external focus.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Improving physical activity using a single personalized consequence-based approach-avoidance training: Effects on self-reported behaviors, attitudes, and choices

Silvio Maltagliati, Philippe Sarrazin, Dominique Muller, Layan Fessler, Thibaud Ferry, Reinout W. Wiers, Boris Cheval

Summary: This study examined the effects of a personalized consequence-based approach-avoidance training (ABC training) on physical activity (PA). The results showed that although the ABC training did not significantly improve PA, it had positive effects on choices and automatic attitudes, suggesting that this intervention still has potential. Further research with intensive training and device-based measures of PA is needed.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Dual career (DC) experiences of Korean elite judokas before and at university

Hee Jung Hong, Seung Han Hong

Summary: The present study explores the experiences of Korean elite judokas in managing dual career during their pre-university years, at university, and in preparation for the transition to post-university life. The study focuses on a particular case, utilizing interviews and thematic analysis to identify key themes. It discusses the unique challenges and barriers faced by Korean judokas in their career development and highlights the importance of sociocultural context in their experiences.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

A moderated mediation analysis on the influence of social support and cognitive flexibility in predicting mental wellbeing in elite sport

R. M. Davies, M. A. Knoll, M. N. Kyranides

Summary: This study aimed to examine the mechanism by which social support influences mental wellbeing, using cognitive flexibility as a mediator, and analyzing the consistency of this pathway between elite athletes, retired athletes, and non-athletes. The results showed a significant indirect effect from social support to mental wellbeing through cognitive flexibility, but the effectiveness of cognitive flexibility interventions may be less significant for elite athletes compared to other groups.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Wellbeing in high-performance swimming: A grounded theory study

Katie S. Uzzell, Camilla. J. Knight, Kurtis Pankow, Denise M. Hill

Summary: The demands of elite sport have the potential to negatively impact athletes' wellbeing. However, not all athletes are affected in the same way. This study used grounded theory methodology to examine the processes of change in high-performance swimmers' wellbeing. The findings illustrate how a dominant performance narrative influences the development and maintenance of an exclusive swimmer identity tied to performance. Transitions were identified as critical points where wellbeing is likely to be affected, but proactive coping strategies and appropriate support can help minimize the impact.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Peer and parent influences on youth skateboarding and factors that affect their decision to return to the sport after injury

Barbara A. Morrongiello, Mackenzie Seasons, Emillie Erum, Emilie Arbour

Summary: Despite the high risk of injuries, skateboarding is increasingly popular among youth. The study found that youth value the psychological well-being, companionship, and sense of community that comes from sharing this activity with peers. They are motivated to return to the sport even after serious injury.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Martial arts, combat sports, and mental health in adults: A systematic review

Simone Ciaccioni, Oscar Castro, Fatimah Bahrami, Phillip D. Tomporowski, Laura Capranica, Stuart J. H. Biddle, Ineke Vergeer, Caterina Pesce

Summary: This systematic review examined the relationship between martial arts and combat sports training and the mental health of adult practitioners. The findings suggest inconclusive associations between martial arts and combat sports practice and self-related constructs, limited evidence of significant associations with sub-domains of ill-being and well-being, and consistent evidence of positive association with perceptual and inhibition abilities. However, the evidence on attention, memory, and the negative associations of boxing with changes in brain structure integrity was limited and inconclusive. The multifaceted nature of martial arts and combat sports may produce different outcomes on mental health, and factors such as activity exposure, expertise, level of competitive engagement, sex, and type of practice may moderate these effects. Further research is needed to enhance theoretical and practical approaches in this field.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Professional development of sport psychology practitioners: From systematic review to a model of development

Janaina Lima Fogaca, Alessandro Quartiroli, Christopher R. D. Wagstaff

Summary: This article systematically reviews the professional development of sport psychology practitioners (SPPs) and creates a process model of professional development. Through reflexive thematic analysis, the researchers identify four developmental phases, four facilitating processes, and nine developmental elements. This model has potential contributions to future research, supervision, and training programs.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Automatic processes moderate the association between reflective processes and movement behavior: A cross-sectional study

Andressa de Oliveira Araujo, Gledson Tavares Amorim Oliveira, Felipe de Oliveira Matos, Fivia de Araujo Lopes, Rodrigo Alberto Vieira Browne, Hassan Mohamed Elsangedy

Summary: This study investigated the influence of reflective and automatic processes on physical activity and sedentary behavior, and found direct associations and moderating effects between the two. The findings underline the importance of considering the interplay between reflective and automatic processes in shaping movement behavior.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Investigating the day-level associations between affective variability and physical activity using ecological momentary assessment

Bridgette Do, Donald Hedeker, Wei-Lin Wang, Tyler B. Mason, Britni R. Belcher, Kimberly A. Miller, Alexander J. Rothman, Stephen S. Intille, Genevieve F. Dunton

Summary: There is an association between affective variability and daily physical activity levels, with individuals experiencing greater fluctuations in affect engaging in more physical activity on the same day.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Effects of task difficulty on performance and event-related bradycardia during preparation for action

Jennifer Henderson, Maria Kavussanu, Germano Gallicchio, Christopher Ring

Summary: This study examines the relationship between heart rate changes and golf putting performance, finding that task difficulty affects heart rate deceleration characteristics and correlates with task performance.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)