4.6 Article

Empirical Evidence for Species-Specific Export of Fish Naivete from a No-Take Marine Protected Area in a Coastal Recreational Hook and Line Fishery

期刊

PLOS ONE
卷 10, 期 8, 页码 -

出版社

PUBLIC LIBRARY SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0135348

关键词

-

资金

  1. Marie Curie Post-Doc grant (Project Fish&Fishers, FP7-PEOPLE-IEF) [327160]
  2. B-Types project through Leibniz Competition [SAW-2013-IGB-2]
  3. FPI-INIA grant
  4. REC2 [CTM2011-23835]

向作者/读者索取更多资源

No-take marine protected areas (MPAs) are assumed to enhance fisheries catch via the spillover effect, where biomass is exported to adjacent exploited areas. Recent studies in spearfishing fisheries suggest that the spillover of gear-naive individuals from protected to unprotected sites increases catch rates outside the boundaries of MPAs. Whether this is a widespread phenomenon that also holds for other gear types and species is unknown. In this study, we tested if the distance to a Mediterranean MPA predicted the degree of vulnerability to hook and line in four small-bodied coastal fish species. With the assistance of underwater video recording, we investigated the interaction effect of the distance to the boundary of an MPA and species type relative to the latency time to ingest a natural bait, which was considered as a surrogate of fish naivete or vulnerability to fishing. Vulnerability to angling increased (i.e., latency time decreased) within and near the boundary of an MPA for an intrinsically highly catchable species (Serranus scriba), while it remained constant for an intrinsically uncatchable control species (Chromis chromis). While all of the individuals of S. scriba observed within the MPA and surrounding areas were in essence captured by angling gear, only one fifth of individuals in the far locations were captured. This supports the potential for the spillover of gear-naive and consequently more vulnerable fish from no-take MPAs. Two other species initially characterized as intermediately catchable (Coris julis and Diplodus annularis) also had a shorter latency time in the vicinity of an MPA, but for these two cases the trend was not statistically significant. Overall, our results suggest that an MPA-induced naivete effect may not be universal and may be confined to only intrinsically highly catchable fish species. This fact emphasizes the importance of considering the behavioural dimension when predicting the outcomes of MPAs, otherwise the effective contribution may be smaller than predicted for certain highly catchable species such as S. scriba.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.6
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Fisheries

Reviving the unique potential of recreational fishers as environmental stewards of aquatic ecosystems

Samuel Shephard, Charles J. List, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Recreational anglers play a crucial role in aquatic conservation, but their importance is often overlooked. Recreational fishing not only involves environmental and moral implications, but also requires skills and ethical imperatives associated with sustainable and responsible use of fish populations. Marginalizing anglers could undermine aquatic biodiversity conservation, as they have a unique ability to develop care and responsibility for aquatic systems and bridge the gap between values and actions through local capacities.

FISH AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Change points in marine recreational fisheries-The impact of stock status and fisheries regulations: A case from the western Baltic Sea

Wolf-Christian Lewin, Marc Simon Weltersbach, Kevin Haase, Robert Arlinghaus, Harry V. Strehlow

Summary: This study found that the western Baltic cod population collapsed in 2016/17, which led to the introduction of a bag limit in recreational fishing. However, the number of anglers and catch rates showed weak correlation with cod stock biomass, indicating that this fishery-related indicator was more responsive to the bag limit than stock status. The study highlights the importance of long-term monitoring programs for identifying change points in recreational fisheries and improving fisheries management in the future.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Size-selective harvesting impacts learning and decision-making in zebrafish, Danio rerio

Tamal Roy, Tabea Rohr, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Selective harvesting in fisheries can evolutionarily alter the life history and behavior of exploited fish populations. Our study on zebrafish showed that size-selective harvesting led to slower associative learning but faster decision-making in the large-harvested line. These results suggest that size-selective fishing can affect the cognitive abilities of exploited fish stocks, potentially impacting resource acquisition and survival.

BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Patterns of genetic variation in native and non-native populations of European catfish Silurus glanis across Europe

Paul Castagne, Ivan Paz-Vinas, Stephanie Bouletreau, Jessica Ferriol, Geraldine Loot, Charlotte Veyssiere, Robert Arlinghaus, Robert Britton, Marlene Chiarello, Emili Garcia-Berthou, Pavel Horky, Delphine Nicolas, Annamaria Nocita, Oscar Nordahl, Michaël Ovidio, Filipe Ribeiro, Ondrej Slavik, Chloe Vagnon, Simon Blanchet, Frederic Santoul

Summary: Biological invasions are a significant component of global change, but they can also have negative impacts on native populations. Efficient management policies are needed to prevent the spread of invasive species in non-native areas while protecting native populations. Genetic variation analysis can help assess the genetic state, identify invasion pathways, determine management strategies, and identify populations requiring conservation measures.

BIODIVERSITY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Review Fisheries

Global responses to the COVID-19 pandemic by recreational anglers: considerations for developing more resilient and sustainable fisheries

J. Robert Britton, Adrian C. Pinder, Josep Alos, Robert Arlinghaus, Andy J. Danylchuk, Wendy Edwards, Katia M. F. Freire, Casper Gundelund, Kieran Hyder, Ivan Jaric, Robert Lennox, Wolf-Christian Lewin, Abigail J. Lynch, Stephen R. Midway, Warren M. Potts, Karina L. Ryan, Christian Skov, Harry V. Strehlow, Sean R. Tracey, Jun-ichi Tsuboi, Paul A. Venturelli, Jessica L. Weir, Marc Simon Weltersbach, Steven J. Cooke

Summary: The global COVID-19 pandemic led to restrictions on people's movements in many jurisdictions, affecting recreational angling. After the restrictions were lifted, initial surveys suggested increased participation and altered angler demographics, but evidence remained limited. This study examines changes in angling interest, licence sales, and angling effort in different regions during the 'pre-pandemic,' 'acute pandemic,' and 'COVID-acclimated' periods. It suggests that efforts to retain younger anglers and provide more urban angling opportunities could increase overall participation levels and enhance resilience in recreational fisheries.

REVIEWS IN FISH BIOLOGY AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ecosystem-based management outperforms species-focused stocking for enhancing fish populations

Johannes Radinger, Sven Matern, Thomas Klefoth, Christian Wolter, Fritz Feldhege, Christopher T. Monk, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Ecosystem-based management is costly, but its effectiveness compared to traditional species-focused alternatives in conservation is uncertain. This study conducted large-scale experiments in fish conservation, finding that adding coarse woody habitats did not enhance fish abundance, while creating shallow water habitat consistently improved the abundance of juvenile fish. Species-focused fish stocking as an alternative approach completely failed. The findings question the efficacy of species-focused conservation actions in aquatic ecosystems, and recommend ecosystem-based habitat management.

SCIENCE (2023)

Article Fisheries

Economic impact of resident and nonresident marine anglers to the local economy in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, Germany

Harry V. Strehlow, Artem Korzhenevych, Jorrit Lucas, Wolf-Christian Lewin, Marc Simon Weltersbach, Carsten Riepe, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: This study estimated the number and expenditures of German marine recreational anglers, and compared the economic impacts of resident and nonresident anglers in coastal and transitional brackish waters in northeastern Germany. The results showed that recreational fishing has a significant contribution to the local and regional economies, with nonresident anglers having a greater economic impact.

FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AND ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Corroborating otolith age using oxygen isotopes and comparing outcomes to scale age: Consequences for estimation of growth and reference points in northern pike (Esox lucius)

Timo D. Rittweg, Clive Trueman, Elias Ehrlich, Michael Wiedenbeck, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Accurate age estimates are crucial for assessing fish life histories and providing management advice. This study validated age estimates for northern pike using oxygen isotopes and found that estimates from scales significantly underestimated the age of older fish. This underestimation has implications for population models and management regulations, leading to conservative management and lost yield.

FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AND ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Explaining attitudes to management actions and beliefs about other user groups and conservation with angler characteristics: A case study in a coastal pike (Esox lucius) fishery in the southern Baltic Sea, Germany

Catherine Slaton, Dieter Koemle, Max Birdsong, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Understanding the attitudes of recreational anglers is crucial for fisheries management. In this study, we examined the relationship between angler characteristics (specialization, catch orientation, place attachment, and demographics) and attitudes towards conservation and management of northern pike in Germany. Our results showed that angler specialization, catch orientations, place attachment, and demographics were consistent predictors of attitudes towards management and conservation. Addressing conflicts in the pike fishery can be achieved by targeting specialized and release-oriented anglers who have higher conflict sensitivity and are more willing to accept regulations.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

A synthesis of a coastal northern pike (Esox lucius) fishery and its social-ecological environment in the southern Baltic Sea: Implications for the management of mixed commercial-recreational fisheries

Robert Arlinghaus, Timo Rittweg, Felicie Dhellemmes, Dieter Koemle, Rob van Gemert, Hendrik Schubert, Dominique Niessner, Soren Moeller, Jan Droll, Rene Friedland, Wolf-Christian Lewin, Malte Dorow, Linda Westphal, Elias Ehrlich, Harry V. Strehlow, Marc Simon Weltersbach, Phillip Roser, Marlon Braun, Fritz Feldhege, Helmut Winkler

Summary: We conducted a comprehensive review of literature on the small-scale northern pike fishery in lagoon ecosystems in the southern Baltic Sea, including peer-reviewed work, grey literature, and novel data analyses. Our findings have important implications for the management of mixed commercial-recreational fisheries in coastal areas. The decline of the pike stock in these lagoons is attributed to multiple pressures such as overharvest, loss of stock structure, eutrophication, predation mortality, availability of prey, and climate change.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

Length-based assessment of an exploited coastal pike (Esox lucius) stock (R?gen, southern Baltic Sea) underscores the crucial relevance of growth and natural mortality for assessment outcomes

Colm J. Fitzgerald, Jan S. Droll, Samuel Shephard, Christopher T. Monk, Timo Rittweg, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: The objective of this study was to assess the exploitation status of the northern pike fishery in brackish lagoons in the southern Baltic Sea of Germany. Length structure data and empirical estimates of growth, maturation, and fecundity were used to fit the Length-Based Spawning Potential Ratio (LB-SPR) model. The study emphasizes the importance of unbiased growth and natural mortality estimates when using length-based methods for stock assessment.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Limnology

Environmental determinants of coarse woody habitat in gravel pit lakes

S. Matern, C. Robichon, R. Nikolaus, C. T. Monk, R. Arlinghaus

Summary: This study investigates the density of coarse woody habitat (CWH) in 26 gravel pit lakes in Lower Saxony, Germany. The study finds that CWH density is lower in German gravel pit lakes compared to North American natural lakes. The presence of large trees on the shore and wind direction have a positive impact on CWH density in lakes managed for recreational fisheries, while lake age and density of large trees on the shore and wind from land positively affect the density of large CWH. Recreational fisheries managers and individual anglers are recommended to maintain CWH in shallow littoral zones to promote fish habitats in generally low-structured gravel pit lakes.

LAKE AND RESERVOIR MANAGEMENT (2023)

Review Ecology

Positioning aquatic animals with acoustic transmitters

Robert J. Lennox, Kim Aarestrup, Josep Alos, Robert Arlinghaus, Eneko Aspillaga, Michael G. Bertram, Kim Birnie-Gauvin, Tomas Brodin, Steven J. Cooke, Lotte S. Dahlmo, Felicie Dhellemmes, Karl o. Gjelland, Gustav Hellstrom, Henry Hershey, Christopher Holbrook, Thomas Klefoth, Susan Lowerre-Barbieri, Christopher T. Monk, Cecilie Iden Nilsen, Ine Pauwels, Renanel Pickholtz, Marie Prchalova, Jan Reubens, Milan Riha, David Villegas-Rios, Knut Wiik Vollset, Samuel Westrelin, Henrik Baktoft

Summary: This paper provides an overview of the method of geolocating aquatic animals with acoustic tags, including considerations for designing receiver arrays, testing performance, synchronizing receiver clocks, and calculating positions from detection data. Common positioning algorithms, including open-source solvers and manufacturer-provided "black-box" methods, are also introduced. It is the first comprehensive overview of methods and considerations for designing and implementing better positioning studies in aquatic systems, aiming to support users and encourage further advances in knowledge.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Editorial Material Ecology

The power and promise of interdisciplinary international research networks to advance movement ecology

Ivan Jaric, Robert J. Lennox, Marie Prchalova, Christopher T. Monk, Milan Riha, Ran Nathan, Robert Arlinghaus

MOVEMENT ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

How involvement drives decision rules behind stated preferences for recreational-fisheries management

Dieter Koemle, Birgit Gassler, Gerard Kyle, Juergen Meyerhoff, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: This paper examines the relationship between involvement in recreational fishing and decision rules, specifically regret-minimizing versus utility-maximizing behavior. The study finds that individuals who are more involved in fishing are more likely to exhibit regret-minimizing behavior. Factors such as behavioral commitment and psychological involvement are significantly related to the decision rule, while skills, attitudes, and place attachment do not impact the decision rules followed. The study also demonstrates that welfare estimates of policy changes are influenced by the decision rule, and assuming regret-minimizing behavior results in lower estimates compared to assuming utility maximization behavior.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

暂无数据