4.6 Article

Quantifying the Impact and Relevance of Scientific Research

期刊

PLOS ONE
卷 6, 期 11, 页码 -

出版社

PUBLIC LIBRARY SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0027537

关键词

-

资金

  1. Arcadia and the United Kingdom Research Council [RES-240-25-006]
  2. Economic and Social Research Council
  3. Natural Environment Research Council
  4. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council
  5. Scottish Government
  6. European Commission [244090-STEP-CP-FP]
  7. Economic and Social Research Council [ES/H037055/1] Funding Source: researchfish
  8. ESRC [ES/H037055/1] Funding Source: UKRI

向作者/读者索取更多资源

Qualitative and quantitative methods are being developed to measure the impacts of research on society, but they suffer from serious drawbacks associated with linking a piece of research to its subsequent impacts. We have developed a method to derive impact scores for individual research publications according to their contribution to answering questions of quantified importance to end users of research. To demonstrate the approach, here we evaluate the impacts of research into means of conserving wild bee populations in the UK. For published papers, there is a weak positive correlation between our impact score and the impact factor of the journal. The process identifies publications that provide high quality evidence relating to issues of strong concern. It can also be used to set future research agendas.

作者

我是这篇论文的作者
点击您的名字以认领此论文并将其添加到您的个人资料中。

评论

主要评分

4.6
评分不足

次要评分

新颖性
-
重要性
-
科学严谨性
-
评价这篇论文

推荐

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Linking climate change vulnerability research and evidence on conservation action effectiveness to safeguard European seabird populations

Henry Hakkinen, Silviu O. Petrovan, William J. Sutherland, Maria P. Dias, Eric I. Ameca, Steffen Oppel, Ivan Ramirez, Becki Lawson, Aleksi Lehikoinen, Katharine M. Bowgen, Nigel G. Taylor, Nathalie Pettorelli

Summary: The increasing threat of climate change to species' long-term survival requires the integration of scientific knowledge and conservation actions. However, the lack of strategic collection and collation of information on species' climate change vulnerability and the effectiveness of conservation actions hinders decision-making and conservation outcomes. By utilizing a pressure-state-response framework, existing knowledge can be effectively utilized to identify missing information and improve conservation outcomes.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Sown mini-meadows increase pollinator diversity in gardens

Janine Griffiths-Lee, Elizabeth Nicholls, Dave Goulson

Summary: Habitat loss and fragmentation are severe threats to pollinator decline, with 97% of wildflower meadows lost in England and Wales. Creating flower-rich margins in agricultural environments is effective, and there is growing potential to support pollinators in urban landscapes.

JOURNAL OF INSECT CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Entomology

The effects of non-crop habitat on spotted wing drosophila (Drosophila suzukii) abundance in fruit systems: A meta-analysis

Nicolas Buck, Michelle T. Fountain, Simon G. Potts, Jacob Bishop, Michael P. D. Garratt

Summary: Drosophila suzukii (SWD) poses a threat to fruit crops worldwide. Non-crop habitats, particularly woodland and field margins with host plants, have a greater impact on SWD population than cropped areas. The difference in SWD abundance between crop and non-crop habitats is influenced by winter months and conventional farming methods.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST ENTOMOLOGY (2023)

Article Entomology

Sown wildflowers between vines increase beneficial insect abundance and richness in a British vineyard

Janine Griffiths-Lee, Balin Davenport, Bradley Foster, Elizabeth Nicholls, Dave Goulson

Summary: Planting perennial wildflowers or allowing natural regeneration in vineyards can increase floral abundance and diversity, supporting beneficial insects and their pollination activities. This simple and effective approach can be widely adopted in British viticulture to enhance biodiversity in vineyards.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST ENTOMOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Which interventions contribute most to the net effect of England's agri-environment schemes on pollination services?

Mike Image, Emma Gardner, Yann Clough, William E. Kunin, Simon G. Potts, Henrik G. Smith, Graham N. Stone, Duncan B. Westbury, Tom D. Breeze

Summary: This study investigates the impact of the English agri-environment scheme on pollination services and identifies hedge/woodland edge management and fallow areas as the main drivers. Floral margins have limited benefits, and interventions are more effective in areas with fewer semi-natural habitats.

LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Characterization Factors to Assess Land Use Impacts on Pollinator Abundance in Life Cycle Assessment

Elizabeth M. Alejandre, Laura Scherer, Jeroen B. Guinee, Marcelo A. Aizen, Matthias Albrecht, Mario V. Balzan, Ignasi Bartomeus, Danilo Bevk, Laura A. Burkle, Yann Clough, Lorna J. Cole, Casey M. Delphia, Lynn V. Dicks, Michael P. D. Garratt, David Kleijn, Aniko Kovacs-Hostyanszki, Yael Mandelik, Robert J. Paxton, Theodora Petanidou, Simon Potts, Miklos Sarospataki, Catharina J. E. Schulp, Menelaos Stavrinides, Katharina Stein, Jane C. Stout, Hajnalka Szentgyorgyi, Androulla I. Varnava, Ben A. Woodcock, Peter M. van Bodegom

Summary: While wild pollinators are crucial for global food production, they are currently not included in the commonly used environmental impact assessment method, Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), due to data limitations and compatibility issues. To address this gap, a Delphi assessment was conducted to obtain relative pollinator abundance estimates from 25 experts covering 16 nationalities and 45 countries. Based on the estimates, globally generic characterization factors (CFs) were developed to assess the impact of land use on wild pollinator abundance in LCA studies.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Co-developing guidance for conservation: An example for seabirds in the North-East Atlantic in the face of climate change impacts

Henry Hakkinen, Nigel G. Taylor, Nathalie Pettorelli, William J. Sutherland, Jon Aldara, Tycho Anker-Nilssen, Christophe Aulert, Rob S. A. van Bemmelen, Daisy Burnell, Bernard Cadiou, Letizia Campioni, Bethany L. Clark, Nina Dehnhard, Maria P. Dias, Leonie Enners, Robert W. Furness, Gunnar thorn or Hallgrimsson, Sjurour Hammer, Erpur Snaer Hansen, Martti Hario, Stephen Hurling, Mark Jessopp, Birgit Kleinschmidt, Meelis Leivits, Klaudyna Maniszewska, Steffen Oppel, Ana Payo-Payo, Daniel Piec, Jaime A. Ramos, Frederic Robin, Iben Hove Sorensen, Antra Stipniece, Danielle L. Thompson, Antonio Vulcano, Silviu Petrovan

Summary: Conservation guidance is an important tool to communicate evidence-based advice to conservation actors, especially in the face of rapidly increasing pressure from climate change. However, the process of developing guidance documents with input from stakeholders can be complicated and costly. There is currently little direct evidence and guidance specifically targeting climate change. This study introduces a process for co-developing guidance for species conservation in the context of a changing climate, using seabirds in the North-East Atlantic as a case study.

CONSERVATION SCIENCE AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Business

Principles for using evidence to improve biodiversity impact mitigation by business

T. B. White, S. O. Petrovan, L. A. Bennun, T. Butterworth, A. P. Christie, H. Downey, S. B. Hunter, B. R. Jobson, S. O. S. E. Zu Ermgassen, W. J. Sutherland

Summary: Currently, there is an increasing expectation for the private sector to address biodiversity impacts and contribute to global conservation goals. Appropriate evidence use can help businesses minimize biodiversity losses, reduce ineffective actions, and secure opportunities from engaging with biodiversity. This study reviews the status of evidence-based action in the private sector, identifies concerning trends, and proposes principles for evidence-based biodiversity impact mitigation. Meeting these principles would improve biodiversity outcomes, but broader political and socio-economic issues also need to be addressed for business action to fully contribute to global conservation goals.

BUSINESS STRATEGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Ecology

A systematic map of cassava farming practices and their agricultural and environmental impacts using new ontologies: Agri-ontologies 1.0

Amelia S. C. Hood, Gorm E. Shackelford, Alec P. Christie, Hope O. Usieta, Philip A. Martin, William J. Sutherland

Summary: This article presents a systematic map of scientific studies on cassava farming practices, aiming to identify knowledge gaps and clusters. The study found regional knowledge clusters and gaps, as well as issues with study design and reporting standards. The map can guide researchers and funders in addressing knowledge gaps, and the ontologies developed can facilitate more efficient synthesis.

ECOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS AND EVIDENCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Crop-pollinator interactions in urban and peri-urban farms in the United Kingdom

Elizabeth Nicholls, Janine Griffiths-Lee, Parthiba Basu, Soumik Chatterjee, Dave Goulson

Summary: Urban food production can contribute to sustainable food provision and the health of urban residents, as well as benefit biodiversity. However, there is limited research on urban pollinator populations. This study found a diverse range of insects visiting urban allotments and pollinating crops, with certain crops attracting more visitors. Natural pollination of strawberries resulted in lower quality fruit compared to hand-pollination, highlighting the need to improve urban crop pollination through habitat provision for insects.

PLANTS PEOPLE PLANET (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Sustaining insect biodiversity through Action Competence-An educational framework for transformational change

Peter Lampert, Dave Goulson, Daniel Olsson, John Piccolo, Niklas Gericke

Summary: In this paper, the Action Competence for Insect Conservation (ACIC) framework is developed as a tool for improving education and citizen action for insect biodiversity conservation. The ACIC aims to bridge the gap between knowledge and action implementation by fostering peoples' action-oriented knowledge, confidence, and willingness to take action. It covers not only actions in private greenspaces but also emphasizes the importance of actions that involve others in the community and relevant stakeholders.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Emerging threats and opportunities to managed bee species in European agricultural systems: a horizon scan

Bryony K. Willcox, Simon G. Potts, Mark J. F. Brown, Anne Alix, Yahya Al Naggar, Marie-Pierre Chauzat, Cecilia Costa, Antoine Gekiere, Chris Hartfield, Fani Hatjina, Jessica L. Knapp, Vicente Martinez-Lopez, Christian Maus, Teodor Metodiev, Francesco Nazzi, Julia Osterman, Risto Raimets, Verena Strobl, Annette Van Oystaeyen, Dimitry Wintermantel, Nikol Yovcheva, Deepa Senapathi

Summary: Managed bees play a vital role in global food security through their pollination services. However, they face various threats and it is important to anticipate and reduce risks for sustainable management. In a horizon scanning exercise conducted in Europe, experts identified emerging threats and opportunities for managed bees in agricultural systems, calling for renewed research and policy focus to maintain sustainable and healthy managed bee pollinators.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Neither sulfoxaflor, Crithidia bombi, nor their combination impact bumble bee colony development or field bean pollination

Edward A. Straw, Elena Cini, Harriet Gold, Alberto Linguadoca, Chloe Mayne, Joris Rockx, Mark J. F. Brown, Michael P. D. Garratt, Simon G. Potts, Deepa Senapathi

Summary: Many pollinators, including bumble bees, are declining due to various factors. This study tested the effects of an insecticide and a common bumble bee parasite on bumble bee colonies and found that they did not have an impact on foraging performance or fruit set. These results suggest that the insecticide tested may be less harmful to bee health compared to other commonly used insecticides.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Ecology

Climate-driven phenological shifts in emergence dates of British bees

Chris Wyver, Simon G. Potts, Mike Edwards, Rowan Edwards, Stuart Roberts, Deepa Senapathi

Summary: Climate change has a diverse range of impacts on wild bees, including their phenology. This study analyzes the shifts in emergence dates of British wild bees over 40 years, showing widespread advances. Temperature is the key driver of this shift, with an average advance of 6.5 days per 1 degree Celsius warming. Species-specific variation is observed, highlighting the possible impact on the temporal structure of bee communities and pollination networks.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Ecology

Spatio-temporal shifts in British wild bees in response to changing climate

Chris Wyver, Simon G. Potts, Mike Edwards, Rowan Edwards, Deepa Senapathi

Summary: Climate plays a significant role in species distribution and activity timing. With changing climate, many species are shifting their ranges and emergence phenology. This study examined the impact of climate on bee emergence dates and predicted future trends. The results suggest that wild bees in Great Britain are susceptible to climate changes and are likely to shift their ranges northward in the future. Species distribution models were used to predict suitable climate envelopes, showing an increase in suitable habitats for most species.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

暂无数据