Molecular Evidence for a Deep Clade of Dunnarts (Marsupialia: Dasyuridae: Sminthopsis)

Sminthopsis is the most speciose genus of living dasyurid marsupials and, along with its close relatives Antechinomys and Ningaui, constitutes the clade Sminthopsini. Phylogenetic relationships among the 23 species in this clade have been the subject of much morphological and molecular investigation, including a recent integration of penis morphology (in Sminthopsis) with molecular systematics. Several phylogenetic issues remain open, however, including the monophyly of Sminthopsis and branching order among early sminthopsin lineages. In this study, we revisit sminthopsin systematics with an expanded molecular data set, including new DNA sequences from mitochondrial (valine transfer-RNA and 16S ribosomal RNA) and nuclear (interphotoreceptor retinoid binding protein and beta-fibrinogen) loci, along with previously published sequences of cytochrome b, 12S ribosomal RNA, control region, and protamine P1. Our results again fail to establish the monophyly of Sminthopsis, but do provide a clearer resolution of early sminthopsin branching. Specifically, our phylogeny suggests three major groups of Sminthopsis species: S. longicaudata (perhaps the sister of Antechinomys); the Macroura species group of previous authors (S. crassicaudata, S. macroura, S. virginiae, S. douglasi, and S. bindi); and the remaining 13 species allied with the Murina species group. Our results depart from previous molecular findings by reuniting S. ooldea with the Murina group, while resolving S. psammophila as sister to the hairy-footed dunnarts (S. hirtipes and S. youngsoni). We suggest that this conflict traces to anomalous phylogenetic signal in previously published cytochrome b sequences. Penis morphology maps reasonably well onto our phylogeny, requiring parallel origination of only one of the ten morphotypes described for Sminthopsis.